5 Things You Can Learn about India from Their Action Movies
Part of being a decent human is attempting to understand and empathize with the many different cultures and societies that surround us. And what better way to accomplish that than by watching their most hilariously confusing movies and extrapolating out a set of unfair, ridiculous stereotypes from them? I've already done it once, and I learned a very important lesson: Never go up against a Christian when death is on the line. Now I'm going to apply the same absurdly faulty logic to understanding another huge portion of the world around me: the Indian subcontinent. Sure, it's an impenetrably dense network comprised of a billion people and untold thousands of heterogeneous subcultures, but I figure we can probably get the gist of it from this fucked-up musical about killer robots.
#5. Physics Need Not Apply

First of all, I should clarify that this movie, Enthiran -- a three-hour musical epic halfway between Bicentennial Man and RoboCop -- is a Tamil film. That's a region in Southern India with many of their own unique beliefs and styles, and it's a very different thing than Bollywood. For example, while both Bollywood and Tamil place a lot of filmic importance on music and dance, the latter places equal importance on the kick-to-flight ratio of dudes with shitty mustaches. Seriously, you can't pass the salt in a Tamil movie without accidentally sending somebody's creepy uncle hurtling through a window.
For example, here's one of the disposable slapstick comedy characters getting fist-catapulted across the room in the very first scene:

That's how the movie introduces itself: by launching a series of screaming tech support missiles across the room. And you'd better suspend that disbelief from the ceiling, friend, because Enthiran is going to spend the rest of its run time taking wild, blind swings at it with a bat. Tamil cinema in general thinks that the laws of physics are for frail, weak men who lack enough cushioning bloat to take a good beating, and Enthiran is their God-king. It makes sense: You work as a dishwasher in a busy restaurant all day, you sure as shit don't want to do the dishes when you come home. Well, the hard sciences are a booming industry in India, so when they head out to the movies, the last thing they want to do is understand some bullshit kinetics.
Think I'm exaggerating? Here's the main character being Frisbee'd into the roof by a malignant android that looks like a cross between Wayne Newton and Pepe Le Pew:

You know how you can always tell when a tech manual has been outsourced to India because, while it's obvious that they have a firm grasp on the English language, there's some bizarre flourish hidden in every other sentence that simply defies understanding? Well, Enthiran has taught me that the same thing applies to physics: In India, slapping isn't just an insult, but an economic method of travel, probably because somebody fucked up the translation on Newton's Laws of Motion.
#4. Time Holds No Meaning

Enthiran is a hell of a long movie. Like I said, it's a three-hour musical epic, and as we all know, adding the term "musical" to anything makes it at least four relative hours longer. But even the term "epic" is not doing this monumental bastard any sort of justice, because in addition to the unwieldy run time, there isn't a single slack nanosecond in Enthiran. Characters move fast, talk fast and walk fast, and if you want crap like atmosphere or time to process, then you're a disappointment to your grandparents; why can't you be more like Ishwar? He has two doctorates, three jobs and four ulcers, and he just turned 12.
Every shot in Enthiran watches like a blind editor came in and chopped the first and last third off of the scene, regardless of consequence. The movie switches locations before you realized the conversation ended, and new characters pop in for lines, even though you had no idea they were in the room in the first place, or else they leave the scene entirely and the film doesn't bother to show you. The end result is the implication that this entire society has mastered the art of teleportation, but mostly just use it to nag each other across a span of continents.
"W-wait ... what? I was just on a beach. Where the fuck did you come from? WHERE AM I RIGHT NOW!?"
So when I say it's a three-hour epic, you need to understand that means three Tamil hours, which translate to American chronology in roughly the same ratio as dog years. This is 20 hours of movie shoved into 168 frantic minutes. Watching Enthiran is like learning kung fu in The Matrix; there's just no way this much information should be delivered to your brain that quickly. It's unnatural, and there are sure to be repercussions. So if you make it all the way to the end and you find yourself hemorrhaging cerebrally, or that some of your loved ones have long since died, try to take some solace in the knowledge that there was truly no more efficient delivery system for bloated Indian men getting kicked in the groin by the Terminator.
#3. Love Like You've Never Been Hurt, Rape Like Nobody's Watching

There's only one main female character in Enthiran, Sana, and she has two jobs: to be compared (not always favorably) to foodstuffs via song, and to almost get raped. Seriously, every musical number insists she's an overripe kumquat or mayonnaise in chocolate, and for every single one of her actions there is an equal but opposite attempted gangbang. She's nearly assaulted by the Indian Backstreet Boys, a cult that worships boomboxes, a mildly retarded farmer -- even the titular robot character gets in on the action, and the movie makes it explicitly, repeatedly clear that he was not built with a penis. At that point, he's just raping her on principle.
Please don't mistake me here: I am absolutely not saying that rape is anything less than a direly serious matter, I'm just saying that nobody told this movie that. If Enthiran is to be believed, then Indian life is like a perverse Harlan Ellison story:
I have no dick, and I must ...
But it's the scene with the dimwitted farmer that really hammers home how casually rape is doled out in the universe of Enthiran. That guy is on screen for two minutes, tops, and roughly a minute and a half of that time is him being adorably dumb and bashful:

The other 30 seconds is him trying to molest the main character. There's literally no segue there -- the transformation from harmless comic relief to sexual criminal was apparently in one of those scenes the blind editor lopped off, because this character flips from Barney Fife to Nils Bjurman in the nanoseconds between manic jump cuts. Luckily, Sana escapes unscathed with the male lead, and they both enjoy an uproarious laugh about the sexual assault, not 15 seconds after they've escaped it.
"Hahaha, you should've seen the look on your face when he tried to forcibly penetrate you!"









Insanely funny, this one. The article that is. The movie on the other hand, defies description.
Replythat fight scene goes so well with heavy techno music it hurts my insides.
ReplyEndhiran is worst movie ever made on this planet. Shankar is indeed worst director, who has no brain. He randomly copies from various Hollywood movies and paste it in his silly script. The most pathetic thing is he has been compared with Spielberg. That's cockamamie nonsense.
ReplyI dunno, man... Calling Spielberg "the most pathetic thing" is a bit of a stretch, but I don't think he's ever stretched the limits of bat-shit insanity like Shankar has...
Yep thats India movie industry, so bad its good, and always colorfull and BIG, thats why I love them
ReplyI saw this directly after watching Rubber and Hobo with a Shotgun. We had Little Caesar's. It was a good night.
ReplyAlso, it's a shame the video of the song didn't have subtitles because that was the best one. So much special in that song...
Dude ,If you want to give a review i suggest you learn tamil a little bit and then watch the film!!!the translations are very bad and they don't make any sense at all!!!And for an industry in which cashflow is nowhere near as Hollywood i think they have made a good film!!!Give the kind of money with which "I robot "or "Avatar" was made to shankar then i assure you he will make films like Steven Spielberg with ease.
ReplyLOL lacking the money that Hollywood has is not why Indian movies are like this lol. It's cultural difference. Give them more money and the movies will be the same just better effects.
Hmmm..
This movie is the most expensive movie in asia or smth
There was no lack of budget for the production of this movie
Well, Shankar ( director of this movie) can be described as michael bay of India.
ReplyWhile he does diret mindless fantasy movies, he also has produced very realistic movie that depicts small town life almost comparable to celebrated ahghanistan movies ( Veyil), A love story brought to tragic end because of deep segregation in indain society ( kadhal) and almost only tamil parody of current events (Imsai Arasan 23am Pulikesi).
Most of the tamil directors has burning ambition to make a decent movie that can be called as art, but have to compromise a lot due to commercial obligations ( sound familiar?)
Shankar has recently parodied himself, in his new movie ( Nanban, a remake of Hindi Three Idiots) in very post modern style. thats when he really became likable.
Well, brokaway watched a tamil movie, and so many fellow tamilians read cracked, wow!
i'm the 666th comment.I feel special
ReplyI am mad they pulled out cellphones(hoping for a rape I might add). Man this movie is wild as hell and I will be peeping this out lol. Excellent article. Them skates lol.
ReplyCrappy article to entertain some white skinned asses.. Enthiran was way better than most useless shits made in hollywood ..
ReplyThat... Isn't that what the article said?
Yes. Mr. Too Many Vowels just doesn't speak the white skinned asses' language and missed that point.
Thalaviar Valga India Valga ...
ReplyI think you meant: "5 Things You Can Learn about India from Their Action MOVIE" -- as it seems you've only seen the one.
ReplyThere was a whole article some time ago about Tamil films, one of the clips had the same actor (Rajinikanth) 'kicking the gravity out of someone'.
I've seen clips of other action movies from India...they are just like this one lol. they love the crazy action.
If Robert Brockway chooses to write only on tamil movies, he will have enough material for ages.
ReplyI own this movie.
ReplyJust because somebody has to say it.... Still a better love story than Twilight. There. It's said. I need to take a brillo pad with me into the shower and scrub away the shame.
ReplyI want to see this, why aren't epic movies like this in American theaters? Instead we just get crappy movies recycled in 3d(star wars ep.1 in 3d)-seriously? It was terrible enough without jar-jar's retarded face popping out at me. f**k you George Lucas, just die of a cocaine overdose already and stop giving movies in general a bad name.
Replyif you ever go to india, you'll find that the vast majority of the extremely hot women are somehow missing and that, in fact, the hotness of the average female is woefully low. i'm indian, have been there more than 6 or 7 times for 3 months at a time, and can vouch for this.
ReplyThank you for your insightful analysis of how useless women in India are, seeing as they're all not attractive enough for you to gaze at. I will steer clear of India so I won't waste time on crappy viewings and sightseeings...
Maybe all the "hot" women stay home because Indian men are a bunch of groping sexual harassers. They call it "eve-teasing"; in reality it's sexual assault.
★★★★★ My friends told me about---onenightcupid.c/0/m---. She told me it is the best
Replyplace to seek casual fun and short-term relationship. I have tried. It is fantastic! Tens of thousands cute guys and pretty girls are active there. You wanna get laid tonight? Come in and give it a shot, you will find someone you like there. Have fun! Q_Q
WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH YOUR SMILEYS O_O
Highest mountain in Africa? You mean Machu Picchu in SOUTH AMERICA?
Reply Hide All See All 4 RepliesWhat?
That's why the caption contains "- this isn't even f***ing Africa!". The MOVIE is referencing Africa and umm, did I hear CLICKING as song "lyrics"? Yikes.
You should listen to some African music, clicking actually does happen in some of it.
@Veccon
Around 0.01% of African languages have clicking and it sounds nothing like whatever the hell that was in the film.
Indian movies are like Indian people,overblown and dumb.
Reply Hide All See All 4 Repliesyes all 1.2 billion of them are the same , idiot
grange..that awkward moment when you say something sarcastic and people think you're an ignorant fool
kayana punda
Dumb, that must be why they graduate more scientist than us.