The 10 Most Disastrous Saturday Morning Cartoon Adaptations
In the '80s and '90s, it seemed like every cultural phenomenon was turned into a Saturday morning cartoon. It was a simpler time when kids still wanted to be like their parents and older siblings, and these shows gave them time-traveling, crime-fighting versions of the stuff old people talked about (when they weren't singing Huey Lewis songs or doing blow off the kitchen table).
But, not all fads translated well to Saturday mornings. Below, the 10 worst Saturday morning cartoon translations, complete with symptomatic title sequences and probably too in-depth analysis of why they sucked.
Based On:
The novel First Blood, as well as its film adaptation and its sequel Rambo: First Blood Part II.
Sucked Because:
Rambo was an expert in guerrilla warfare--a man who was the best with guns, with knives and with his bare hands. He was a man who had been trained to ignore pain, to ignore weather, to live off the land and to eat things that would make a billy goat puke. In Vietnam, his job was to dispose of enemy personnel. To kill! Period! Except in cartoon form, where Rambo was the leader of a multicultural, G.I. Joe-like squad of do-gooders, each with their own special backgrounds and talents.
Cartoon Rambo was a well-adjusted man, who never talked about his experiences in Vietnam as a prisoner of war or his lingering case of post-traumatic stress disorder. A man who was nonviolent and overcame his enemies through clever thinking rather than an explosive arrow tip to the chest. He was a man who could sustain a poorly-thought-out animated adaptation of source material wildly inappropriate for children for only one season before cancellation.
Evidence from the Title Sequence:
Here we have Rambo skiing down a snowy mountain and dodging flamethrowers, all in the name of protecting the innocent:
Nothing too outrageous there, right? Now check out the trailer for the upcoming John Rambo. Go ahead and skip right to 1:13 where Rambo starts decapitating people and turning entire human bodies into hamburger meat.
Coming out in January, just in time for those of us who grew up on the cartoons!
Based On:
Not the 1984 film Ghostbusters, but the 1975—76 live-action TV show The Ghost Busters
Sucked Because:
After Columbia Pictures licensed the name Ghostbusters from Filmation for what turned out to be a surprise hit film, Filmation rushed to cash in with an animated revival of its live-action children' series about a pair of bumbling paranormal investigators. It's impossible to enjoy Filmation' Ghostbusters on its own terms. Many was the child who tuned in excitedly to watch the adventures of Venkman,Spengler, Stantz and Zeddemore, only to be crushed with disappointment at having to settle for the antics of Jake Kong, Eddie Spencer and Tracy the Gorilla (Why the gorilla isn't the one named Kong defies explanation).
Viewers used to the portable nuclear accelerators employed by the cinematic Ghostbusters may also be dismayed at the low-tech means used to capture phantasms here, which include trapping them in bubble gum and soap bubbles and throwing rope lassos around them.
Evidence from the Title Sequence:
It starts out as you'd expect: the busters are called to a scene that needs some ghost busting. When they arrive, the ghost in question inexplicably transforms into a random assortment of popular fictional characters including C-3PO, Skeletor and Pres. Teddy Roosevelt. Also, Tracy the Gorilla stands around and looks scared. Hopefully Shaggy gets him some Tracy-snacks from the van.
The first viewing of that opening sequence was a landmark event for many a young Ghostbusters fan, as it resulted in their very first utterance of the phrase, "What the fuck?!?" I mean, if only they'd made a cartoon based on the movie! That couldn't fail to be cool!
Based On:
The 1984 film Ghostbusters
Sucked Because:
They proved us wrong. Issues with the film' stars over likeness rights forced a redesign of the characters, leading to such oddities as the bizarre, peroxide pompadour sported by Dr. Egon Spengler above.
Bill Murray then asked producers why Dr. Peter Venkman sounded like Garfield rather than himself, which led to voice actor Lorenzo Music being sacked and Full House irritant Dave Coulier getting a steady gig voicing Venkman for the rest of the show' run (perversely, Murray took Lorenzo Music' job voicing Garfield in the 2004 feature film; if Lorenzo Music hadn't died in 2001, you'd think Murray really had it in for the guy).
Basically, Bill Murray did his best to wreck The Real Ghostbusters. But, even he can't be blamed for the elevation of Slimer from a small appearance in the original film to a full-fledged member and official mascot of the team, a move that made the cartoon somewhat more kid-friendly and exponentially more irritating.
Evidence from the Title Sequence:
The creators of the show were criminally out of touch with the liakbility of their ghosts. In the intro, the one from the logo has been turned into a hip cat jiving down the street like he' Michael Jackson in the "Billie Jean" video.
If ever there were a ghost you could get behind, it' this guy. He appears to be minding his own business and even avoids knocking over a couple of trash cans, when the circle with the bar across it swings down and hits him in the face. On the other end of the spectrum, the ghost they've taken as their mascot appears to be mentally retarded and commits an act of sexual aggression just moments after being introduced.
Based On:
The Rubik' Cube, the fad toy of the early 1980s
Sucked Because:
How can you really make a television about an inanimate, plastic polyhedron interesting? They made the titular cube sentient and gave it a variety of magical powers, which might not have been necessary if he'd had any arms.
Being essentially a double amputee, Rubik was dependent on three Hispanic children who discovered him after he fell out of an evil wizard' stagecoach. Also boasting a theme song performed by a pre-Ricky Martin Menudo, Rubik was surprisingly Hispanic-friendly (Or maybe it wasn't--each episode revolves around the efforts of a trio of young Hispanic thieves to keep the cube' rightful owner from recovering his property, evil wizard or not).
Also, while Rubik could come alive when his puzzle was solved, he was easily scrambled from being merely dropped or touched. As dubious as this is, it' even more of a stretch that his first orders upon being descrambled weren't for the children to glue or tape his blocks permanently in place.
Evidence from the Title Sequence:
Not content with cynically exploiting just one popular '80s fad, the intro tells the story of kids on bikes in the woods finding an alien creature who enables them to fly away from a pursuer. But where do they fly to? Why to a picturesque shot of the children and the alien silhouetted against the moon, of course!
Based On:
The She-Ra series of Mattel toys, a spinoff of the more popular He-Man line.
Sucked Because:
It was essentially a gender-flipped version of He-Man and the Masters of the Universe meant to appeal to girls. But, the girls who wanted a He-Man-style series were just fine with watching He-Man. Meanwhile, boys who weren't turned off by She-Ra or by the character of Madame Razz (basically a drag king impersonating He-Man' Orko) found it hard to accept the token-male character, a bard named Bow. Bow essentially filled the same ecological niche as Eric Erlandson, the guy who played guitar in Hole; no matter how hard you rock, it' still totally emasculating to be the token dude in a chick band.
Compounding the problem, his appearance couldn't possibly have been gayer. Not only did he sing and play harp, but he sported a thick mustache and a heart on the chest of his uniform.
Evidence from the Title Sequence:
While most intros choose to dramatize the origin story, She-Ra directly addresses the camera and explains she' He-Man' twin sister, the producers figuring little girls' smaller brains couldn't be trusted to pick up on image cues. The end result is an intro that comes off feeling like a PSA about magical swords.








ok, i'll let you by with the ghostbusters thiing, even though egon spengler was the onject of my early sex-fantasies (yes, i was attracted to a strangely-drawn, skinny whiteboy of a cartoon character with the worlds most impossible elvis 'do and big red glasses, but dammit, nerds are just plain sexy).
Replybut NOBODY criticizes she-ra!!!!! (alright, cat-ra was my early lesbian fantasy, ok? don't judge me.)
Eh, I liked Ghostbusters, the Real Ghostbusters, and She-Ra... Oh, well.
Reply...Oh, and where is the Pac-Man cartoon or the New Kids on the Block cartoon? Seriously, now those sucked!
Actually, Johnny wasn't available because he'd been licensed for something else. Rambo, like the Zelda toon and the D&D toon, fell victim to censorship that prevented actual sword or arrow violence.
ReplyShe-Ra was awesome, AND I had all the dolls. It's "emasculating" to be the only dude with a bunch of women? But I guess it's totally NORMAL for most cartoons/ action films whatever to be all dude with just one or two chicks prancing around in sexed-up leotards. You think Teela liked being the one chick at the sausage party? Prolly not.
ReplyI can't imagine the guys were too happy about it either. Then again, judging by their outfits maybe they were...
I watched and loved The Real Ghostbusters and She-Ra. I was too young for me to remember She-Ra much but Ghostbusters was a great cartoon. Maurice Lamarche (The Brain) was in it for crying out loud. It made both IGN's top 100 cartoons (22) and was 11 on Nostalgia Critic's top 11 Nostalgic Cartoons
ReplyWaitwaitwait... With so many disasterous choices to pick from, you put Real Ghostbusters on this list?! Real Ghostbusters, that ran for five years? That had several comic spin-offs and one sequel animated series (which, admittedly, was pretty bad)? That had a toyline that lasted longer than the series itself? That outlasted the actual Ghostbusters film franchise? That WAS Ghostbusters for a lot kids, even moreso than the films? That screwed up a whole generation's idea of what Samhain was?
ReplySir I beg to differ!
I can't belive this , cracked writers, you left out(probably the worst adaptation)...Chuck Norris: Karate Komandos
ReplyHe heard you...
I liked some of this cartoons ;)
ReplyI am She-Ra, why do I exist?
Replyi dont know if anyone else noticed but the part where jordan turns on the rocket shoes he sticks his tongue out like a dog or crazy person
ReplyI think that was his patented "slam dunk face"
I don't really know much about them, but here's how i would have setup the sports superheros if given a generic trio with the sports from ProStars:
ReplyBasketball guy: Can create temporary invisible "steps" in the air to climb higher on jumps, is great with throwing things with precise aim and complex rebound patterns (like those trick beerpong shots), he's also good with slight of hand managing to swipe things from the adversary's hands with ease. He also has the power of altering the bounciness of things he touches temporarily, he can dribble a rock, a ball of mud, an egg etc just as easy as a well pressured basketball, or turn a patch of asphalt into a trampoline for example.
American Football/Baseball guy: Way strong, kinda indesctructible. Unmovable when still, unstoppable while moving. He can throw things really hard, and can grab anything at reach (trashcan, lightpole, parked schoolbus etc) and use as a bat to hit an incoming projectile away with absurd precision; also great at catching things without dropping.
Hockey guy: Very fast, legs bellow the knees replaced with laser skates (that he can switch between a few different wheel modes, like, inline, old disco skates, and perhaps monstertruck skates, all with "solid light" wheels, and also to blade mode, the blade can cut just about anything, besides working like a perfect skate blade for any surface; perhaps also add a tank thread mode as well to make it cooler, also made of "solid light"), he can use any rock, coin, drink can or just about anything not much bigger than a shoe as a projectile, hitting with his twin telescopic sticks (when they are not in use he keeps then on his back in a X mount, like ninja swords), with surprising strength and precision, oh and he can skate on walls and ceilings, and for a limited time over water (if he stays over water for too long water starts turning into steam and he starts sinking)
New Kids on the Block Cartoon doesn't even get an honourable mention for being awful?
ReplyTo be a DISASTROUS adaptation, the original thing it was adapted from would have to have some redeeming quality of its own. So no, it doesn't belong on this list.
I've been watching all the episodes of She-Ra on Netflix lately with my kids and I've gotta be honest with you, She-Ra is a BAMF, I swear I get an adrenaline rush every time she changes. I love He-Man and She-Ra forever.
ReplyI never actually watched the Hulk Hogan one, but I absolutely detested it for the fact that the baddie is a Scotsman and his car appears to have giant bagpipes on the back. Why? What did Scotland ever do to him?
ReplyIt's so bad that I watch bloody TNA every week hoping that Sting will smash Hogan's face in.
At the time, Hogan was feuding with Rowdy Roddy Piper, who's gimmick was his strong Scottish heritage. The man came down to the ring playing the bagpipes and wearing a kilt. Ironically, Piper wasn't actually Scottish at all (he was Canadian).
until you have seen "Siegfried and Roy: Masters of the Impossible" you do not know just how good bad awesome horrible animated adaption of something that did not need an adaption of any kind, anywhere, can truly be.
ReplyI totally would have watched She-Ra.
ReplyBut then, I watched the Real Ghostbusters for years, oblivious to how much of a terrible adaptation it was. I'd seen the film, I just didn't understand it well enough to realize that Slimer wasn't one of the good guys.
Wait......Slimer wasn't one of the good guys?
Dude.... you just killed a tiny part of my childhood.
I guess- for a lot of kids - the cartoons were canon (rather than the movies) . It was a pretty cool show, if you were seven.
Also, Peroxide Egon was totally my first fictional crush. The original Egon arouses my nerd boner, as well, but he didn't used have a poster of Socrates ( or was it Plato) on his bedroom wall:D.
Wait.... do girls get boners? Perhaps I should have spent my childhood paying attention to something other than all these terrible cartoons.
Hey man! Every 26th century person knew that Cupcake from 'Fonz & The Gang' was 83!
ReplyWhy is Ernest Hemingway an evil wizard/rubik's cube inventor?
ReplyBecause f**k it. That's why.
god forgive me for ever liking prostars
ReplyI loved Cracked until they ragged on She-Ra!!! Who cares if it was a 30 minute commercial based on a chessy line of toys ripped off from He-Man? I LOVED SHE-RA!!! I owned all the toys! I had a Crystal Castle!! f**k CRACKED!!!
Reply