5 Bizarre Mashups that Shouldn't Work This Well

Mashups are all the rage online these days. It's to the point where artists can build huge careers out of nothing more than mixing and mashing other people's songs. Like Girl Talk, for example.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

That "band" is actually just one dude named Greg Gillis, and he absolutely shreds on a laptop. So much so that he tours the world and releases entire albums and makes loads of money, all while skirting copyright law on the grounds that he produces transformative works that fall under the doctrine of fair use. He's obviously not the only person making mashups in the world, though. We talk about some of the more surprising song combos from recent memory on this week's Unpopular Opinion podcast ...

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

... where I'm joined by comics Jeff May, Quincy Johnson, and Vanessa Gritton. That's also what I'm going to talk about in this column today. Imagine that! Here are five mashups that make terrible songs great.

Advertisement

5
Justin Bieber vs. Slipknot -- "Psychosocial Baby"

YouTube

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Aside from the fact that they both make music I don't listen to, Justin Bieber and Slipknot don't have much in common. One of them is best known for putting on disgusting, vile live shows that test the limits of what an audience can comfortably stand to look at for an extended period of time. The other is a rock band that wears scary clown masks and s**t. Clearly, they occupy opposite ends of the modern music landscape.

For the record, it's not that I dislike the music of Slipknot. I suppose they're fine, but I honestly just don't know if I've ever been angry enough about anything to really want to listen to a song like "Psychosocial."

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

I'm just not that f*****g mad about things, you know?

As for Justin Bieber, I don't know what kind of mood you have to be in to willingly seek out his music as an adult, but it's one I've never been in. I mean, I saw the Biebs in concert once, but it was just for work. Beyond that, his songs have never interested me much. It's probably because I'm not a child.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

So even in terms of why I don't count myself a fan, both acts are miles away from each other. Somehow, though, when they come together, they produce something beautiful.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

That miracle of modern music machinery is called "Psychosocial Baby," and it is goddamn magic. It takes the overly aggressive lyrics of Slipknot and combines them with the bullshit pop music of Justin Bieber, and just like that, everything that's wrong is right. The inherent flaws of each act wash away in a sea of grown men screaming about their feelings while some faceless Swedish pop producers wail on a synthesizer version of every instrument. It's kind of like a McDonald's cheeseburger. The individual parts aren't that great, but when you get them all in one place, it's completely and totally good enough.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Standout Moment:

Jump in at around the 2:12 mark, when the guest verse from Ludacris starts, and you'll spend that entire section of the video wholly unaware that it's anything other than the Justin Bieber song he originally appeared on.

YouTube


You know the one!
Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

It's like one of those prank videos that come out every year around Halloween, where you get tricked into staring at it for a long time and then there's a high-pitched screaming noise ...

YouTube


If he starts soloing, this is legitimately my nightmare.

... then that picture pops up and you get the s**t scared out of you. That's how every Slipknot video should work.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

4
The DMX Remix of the "Reading Rainbow" Theme

YouTube

Whether you want to admit it or not, sometimes a gritty reboot is a good thing. Case in point: Remember the Reading Rainbow theme song? For as long as you've been alive, it's sounded the exact same way. Sure, it will never stop being as catchy as all get out, but it definitely hasn't aged and matured the same way you have. It's from a show for kids, after all -- it's not a huge deal. Unless, of course, you want to indulge in the breezy melodies of that childhood classic without looking like a total weirdo to the people around you.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

In moments like this, that aforementioned reboot is exactly what you need. Enter rap legend and all-around crazy person DMX.

Mike Lawrie/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement


"Dog noises!"

With nothing more than a few well-placed grunts, growls, swear words, and requests for oral sex, DMX turns a childhood classic into something you'd be proud to listen to at your next adult gathering.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

"Proud" might be a bit too strong of a word. "Comfortable" might even be pushing it, depending on a variety of factors. It's definitely a conversation starter, if nothing else.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Standout Moment:

Look, this is 56 seconds long. Every one of those seconds is a delight. Listen to it twice.

3
Nine Inch Nails vs. Carly Rae Jepsen -- "Call Me a Hole"

YouTube

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

The title of this column, at least as I'm writing it, mentions that there will be at least one terrible song in the mix at each stop along the way. If nothing else, there will be something you wouldn't listen to on its own. So with that in mind, I think it should be pretty obvious which of the two songs referenced here earns the honor of "worst of the bunch." That, of course ...

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

... is neither of them. Sorry, that's just how this entry has to work. That's also what's so wonderful about this mashup of seemingly disparate musical worlds. Instead of masking each other's faults, they just bring out the best in each other. Is that hard to read for Nine Inch Nails fans? I'd ask the same thing of Carly Rae Jepsen fans, but let's not s**t ourselves, she doesn't have fans. That one song she did had fans. If you've already forgotten the name, just as a reminder, the song in question is "Call Me Maybe."

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

You could be forgiven for misplacing the name of the star behind this song, because the real star here is the music. It's the only star, actually. Carly Rae Jepsen sounds like any other software-corrected pop singer who came before her.

YouTube


Actually, "Carly Rae Jepsen" is just their band name.

You could put just about any configuration of lyrics over music like that and it would sound right at home. The mashup at the heart of this entry demonstrates that perfectly.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

It also highlights one of the things that was so great about Trent Reznor, back when him being great was a thing. He was a master at pairing pop melodies with gloomy industrial rock that turned into chart-topping hits, even when he still looked like this ...

YouTube

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement


Yeah, of course those are dreadlocks!

That's no minor feat, and it happened in large part because he knew how to craft a catchy melody, enough so that he sounds right at home alongside the song that so very recently wrecked your summer.

Standout Moment:

As with so many other Trent Reznor productions, skip directly to the chorus, which starts right around the 25-second mark. A grown man complaining loudly will never sound so joyous again.

2
Lady Gaga vs. Judas Priest -- "Lady Judas"

YouTube

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

We have a societal obligation to take any song with the word "Judas" in the title and find an appropriate Judas Priest song for it to marry. So when Lady Gaga released a song by that very name, search parties were immediately dispatched, and they returned with a song called "Painkiller."

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

If you listened, you'll note that nothing you saw or heard implies that a union with Lady Gaga is anywhere in the near future. Well, all the dudes are wearing leather ...

YouTube


Naturally.

... but that's where the similarities to a Lady Gaga performance seemingly end. "Painkiller" is '80s thrash metal chaos. Lady Gaga is a radio-friendly pop artist. On paper, there's no reason for these songs to work together at all.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

As you'll hear in that video, though, they totally do. Not only do they sound like they belong together, but Rob Halford's screeches don't sound any less insane alongside a Lady Gaga instrumental. If this mashup revealed anything, it's that "Judas" was metal as f**k (so to speak).

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Unlike most everything else on this list, the verses switch off between both artists, which seems surprising on the surface, but come on, we're talking about Rob Halford and Lady Gaga. It's a pairing that at least makes some sense, if you catch my drift.

YouTube

Leather. I just mean they both wear a lot of leather.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Standout Moment:

Every time Lady Gaga says "I'm in love with Judas," a heavy metal chorus of dudes shouting "Priest!" is tacked on to the end, and not once is not funny. Also, any time Rob Halford is singing.

1
System of a Down vs. Elton John -- "Crocodile Chop"

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Can either of the two songs that have been joined at the hip here be classified as truly "terrible?" Yeah, sure: "Chop Suey" by System of a Down. What's that? You're a System of a Down fan? Neat! That's probably why we don't know each other. Anyway, don't let me tell you how awful System of a Down was as a band. Instead, let Oasis songwriter and lead guitarist Noel Gallagher do it for you. Here's a quote from an interview that happened around the time SoaD was active:

"Do you ever look at the sky and think, I'm glad I'm alive? After I heard System of a Down, I thought, I'm actually alive to hear the shittiest band of all time. Which is quite something when you think about it. Of all the bands that have gone before and all the bands that'll be in the future, I was around when the worst was around."

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Amen to that, Noel Gallagher! Still, there has to be something that can be done to make the music of System of a Down more tolerable, right? Right! And that thing is mixing it with the Elton John classic "Crocodile Rock."

Listen, I don't love "Crocodile Rock" any more than you do. Among his BIG hits, that's probably my least favorite song of his that isn't "I'm Still Standing."

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

But see, as much as I moderately hate this one Elton John song, I extremely hate this System of a Down song. I mean, I'm an adult who (occasionally) pays bills and does grownup things. What does this band hold for me in terms of appeal? The answer is "almost nothing," in case you're wondering. Why? Because again, the music of System of a Down just isn't some s**t I'm interested in. But when you couple it with one of Elton John's most enduring (and coke-fueled) songs of all time, something that seems to be approaching magic happens.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

See, what I initially hated about that System of a Down song was everything. Now that it's been sexed with an Elton John song, I'm fully aware that, at the end of the day, the music was really the problem. Is that band singing about something that would bother me? Nah, I barely know they exist. Still, why is System of a Down music even happening?

Standout Moment:

Again, almost every single minute of this is pretty great, but if you really want to focus on one great moment, make it that point when the dude from System of a Down and Elton John hit the high harmonies. I didn't link to it. Just give it a listen. You'll find it.

For more from Adam, follow him on Twitter @adamtodbrown.

For more from ATB, check out 5 Tribute Albums that Don't Realize How Insulting They Are and 4 Difficult Jobs Everyone Secretly Thinks They'd Be Good At.

Are you on reddit? Check it: We are too! Click on over to our best of Cracked subreddit.

To turn on reply notifications, click here

581 Comments

Load Comments

More Blogs

4 Crazy Ways The Human Body's Changing In Our Own Lifetimes

Our bodies are changing.

127

5 Celebrities With Arguably More Interesting Parents

Many of today's celebrities have some real surprises in their family trees.

81

5 Meltdowns That Went Viral Before The Internet Existed

Everybody loves a good old-fashioned meltdown.

86

5 Iconic Movies Saved By Last-Minute Changes

Some of your favorite movie moments were added months after everyone went home.

109

5 'Romantic Triangle' Characters We Just Feel Sorry For

Fictional love triangles are always a rigged game.

150