6 Studies That Prove Reality TV Is Causing the Apocalypse
Lots of people joke about reality TV being the end of civilization, and many of them are us, but we weren't really worried. Until we found out what scientists were saying. Hard data and scientific papers spell out exactly how reality television is undoing civilized society, aka "the thing that keeps us from killing and eating each other for fun."

"Why People Watch Reality TV"
Professor Steven Reiss, Dr. James Wiltz
Ohio State University
Media Psychology, 6, 363-378 (2004)
For years, scientists have been trying to answer the question, "Why do people watch reality TV?" -- a question that was revised to "WHYYYYY? Oh my God, why are they doing this?" sometime around the premiere ofA Shot at Love With Tila Tequila.

There had better be a damn good reason for this.
The early money in academic circles was on voyeurism. Watching strangers interact with one another on TV seemed to appeal to humanity's inner Peeping Tom. However, voyeurism implies that the people you're watching don't know they're being watched. Reality TV stars were only getting more self-aware, and the ratings were only growing.
Deciding it was time to go back to the drawing board, two idealistic Ohio State researchers decided to compare viewing behaviors and personality profiles using Aristotle's model of the human soul. It was at this point that they discovered, to their horror, that the voyeur theory wasn't too cynical. In fact, when it comes to why we watch reality TV, the theory equating a large swath of humanity with lonely men masturbating in trees wasn't cynical enough.

Way to make humanity look like complete assholes, SCIENCE.
The adult fans of reality TV whose personalities they mapped ended up having pretty much all the worst traits possible. Professor Reiss himself writes that "the people who watched reality television had above-average trait motivation to feel self-important and, to a lesser extent, vindicated, friendly [and] free of morality." If each personality profile was a different Christian Bale character, Patrick Bateman would be the model reality TV viewer.
Their theory was that reality TV was essentially the antidote to self-improvement: Instead of feeling better about yourself by achieving anything, you can just watch the worst possible humans fawn over Flava Flav for half an hour! It's like a Hot Pocket for your self-esteem -- quick, easy and overall bad for you.

In an objective, scientific sense, listening to this man talk erodes your soul.
The study also found that those who watched reality TV were far more concerned with social status and vengeance, and significantly less motivated by idealism, morality or honor. In other words, asking people whether they watch My Big Fat Obnoxious Fiance is a great way to discover who'll be wearing the leather after Mad Max happens.

His Reiss Profile "social status" score is Humongous.

"The reality of reality television: Does reality TV influence local crime rates?"
Professor Lesley Chiou, Professor Mary Lopez
Department of Economics, Occidental College, Los Angeles, CA, United States
Economics Letters 108 (2010), 330-333
The problem with academia is that it tends to lag behind the latest trends by a few years. For instance, we couldn't find any scientists who had undertaken research on Jersey Shore, or at least none who hadn't immediately switched to researching interplanetary travel. The closest we came was an expert on viral weaponry who disappeared while researching Snooki, leaving behind only a voice mail message that said, "Call me when she decides she can sing. I'll be ready."

Her YouTube page may be the most convincing argument against the existence of a loving god.
Unfortunately, that lag might mean it may already be too late. While we're not saying reality TV causes an immediate decay in any societies it directly impacts, that's exactly what two Occidental College professors found last year with their statistical analysis of the reality show Laguna Beach. One part of their analysis compared the titular setting of the reality show with the statistically similar, but relatively untelevised, town of Dana Point.

While Dana Point's crime rate continued to drop along with the rest of America's throughout the 2000s, being the setting of a reality show acted as a spring board for crimes like "burglary, robbery, rape, auto theft, and larceny" in Laguna Beach. One theory is that the region was flooded with people who wanted to either be like the rich idiots on the show or take advantage of them. Another posited that the criminal underground has no respect for life, law or property but has a well-developed sense of justice against that bitch Alex.
Of course, one graph doesn't imply causality. Still, it's worth noting that the professors applied more statistical analysis to Laguna Beach than early scientists did to powered flight. For instance:

The existence of a mathematical equation involving Laguna Beach just lowered IQ.
Not anybody's in particular; the idea of IQ itself was lowered by this equation.
Their conclusion? "We find suggestive evidence that non-residential burglaries, auto thefts, and rapes increased during the period following the show's debut." TV doesn't just appeal to Mad Max types -- it's actually causing them.

A future gated community.
Of course, that's only the specific location where the show was filmed. As long as we're not watching Jersey Shore while sitting on the Jersey Shore, it's safe to sit back and watch it from a distance, right?

"The Influence of Plastic Surgery 'Reality TV' on Cosmetic Surgery Patient Expectations and Decision Making"
Richard J. Crockett, M.D.,Thomas Pruzinsky, Ph.D.,John A. Persing, M.D.
"A correlational and experimental examination of reality television viewing and interest in cosmetic surgery"
Charlotte N. Markey, Patrick M. Markey
People watch these shows and talk about them -- that just means they're both bored and boring, right? Surely they don't take them seriously? On a scale of seriousness, from "1" to "Getting themselves cut open with knives," two studies show that fans of reality TV take what they're watching extremely seriously.
A survey of first-time plastic surgery patients found that 78 percent were influenced by reality television, and 57 percent of all first-time patients were "high-intensity" viewers of cosmetic surgery reality TV.

The fact that that's even a genre will cost us dearly when the transmissions reach more advanced alien species.
The paper discussed "widespread unease" the how many people were getting plastic surgery because of these programs. Worth noting: This paper appeared in a journal by, for and dedicated to people who make their living performing plastic surgery. They routinely patch up victims of motorbike crashes and industrial machinery, and the reason for getting plastic surgery they're most scared of is reality TV. Probably because using artificial means to become more like reality TV contestants is the exact opposite of evolution.

Above: The fittest?
This isn't just normal vanity, or an obvious correlation like how people interested in surgery would watch the shows. Another study, this one involving 189 people, found that those merely "exposed" to Extreme Makeover (note that the scientists referred to the show the same way they'd refer to nuclear waste) were more likely to want surgery. After only 20 minutes, a group watching Extreme Makeover was measurably more interested in surgery compared with a control group watching Sell This House. Unfortunately, no data were collected on the frivolous purchases of unused power tools by the second group.
Terrifyingly, the study showed that the people's self-esteem, gender or happiness with their looks didn't affect how much the show influenced them. The only thing that mattered was whether they'd watched the show.

"Boy, having someone slice off sections of my face sure seems more bearable than watching this show."








I actually wrote a term paper on Reality TV, and god forgive me, I actually listed some of the virtues of that medium. Then no matter how many showers I took I just couldn't wash the filth off. Damn I hate Reality TV.
ReplyI think you have to be somewhat dumb to begin with if you choose to watch RTV (and like it). No one truly intelligent would watch it.
ReplyP.S. "The existence of a mathematical equation involving Laguna Beach just lowered IQ.
Not anybody's in particular; the idea of IQ itself was lowered by this equation." LOL
There are only two channels I now watch since there is so much reality TV now: Teletoon Retro and The Sports Network. I highly recommend either of them. The shows I used to watch as a kid just seem to get better and better (No Digimon yet though, which is a shame.)
ReplyI don't want to watch reality TV anymore. During the period that I did, I was so deeply affected with the program (and one annoying person) and pretty much spread the hate everywhere. No positive energy at all >_
ReplyWell I do feel better by watching other people living their life worst than mine :)
ReplyReality TV is the main reason i don't watch TV anymore. Thank God for torrents!
ReplyAnd the internet in general.
I've always felt like reality TV, the vew times I was unfortunate to watch them), were like somebody has pulled a plug on the bathtub containing the liquid of my soul. This article confirms my suspicions.
ReplyThe green gal on the #2 item, why is she holding one whole Imax theater on her lap?
ReplyStructural equation models still don't imply causality.
ReplyBecause you're a statistical analyst and you didn't just look up the definition of causality because it's your job to know what causality is.
This is why I'm glad I don't watch RTV, ever.
ReplyI don't feel better about my self when I'm watching reality TV...on the contrary, when I watch something (forced by friends who find it amusing to watch people humiliate themselves) I have a sudden and strong urge to improve myself, especially if any person on the show has any similarities in their behaviour to mine. RTV makes me wash the dishes, be nice to strangers and tell my boyfriend how great he is cooking even if I start twitching when I see him put the hot frying pan on the wooden table.Just because I just watched some wife screaming and spitting at her husband for forgetting the peanut butter. I always want to go to those people and tell them how they could have a better life if they were nicer to each other. They make me feel like I'm not good enough as long as we have the least bit in common.RTV is bad for my self esteem. And I don't understand how anyone would feel better when they get to watch how much worse it could get. Maybe german RTV is not artificial enough...
ReplyYou are awesome. RTV is bad, and like anyone DECENT who sees a mess, you want to clean it up as soon as possible. May you find a billion dollars and keys to a transforming tank-jet.
God! I found out recently that my 14 year old brother watches Jersey Shore. When I asked him why he watch that crap he told me to mind my own damn business and not tell him what to do, then my folks came in to tell me to stop trying to be a parent. I went back in my room like I always do, so they could complain more that I never come out and interact with them.
ReplyNow that I think about I my parents watch a lot of reality shows like the Bachelor, trading spaces, and a lot of other stuff like those pawn shows and other things that don't even have like game show challenges look make them even a little interesting. And that used to be the best part of a reality show that I would actually pay attention to.
so i'm curious...does these horrible things apply JUST to the type of dramafied reality tv that puts terrible behavior under the microscope (jersey shore, the bachelor, flavor of love, et al)? or does it apply to ALL reality tv, including what might be considered somewhat educational as well as voyeuristic (surgeries come to mind!)
ReplyI'm not gonna HUCK my TV out the window yet. I watch sitcoms and cartoons and doc*mentaries; I think I'm good for now.
ReplyThere's an article somewhere on this site that says we as a society aren't actually getting dumber, but we're getting smarter. (There was a mention about how having an IQ of 100 is pretty below average by now.)
ReplyBut honestly I just have a hard time believing that. Everything in this article says otherwise. Reality TV and its fans contribute to absolute mindless entertainment. That caption underneath the picture of Snooki's YouTube page is 100% correct. My tolerance for humanity is nearing empty here.
Most people actually are above an I.Q. of 100, but the problem is that I.Q. changes. They make the average 100, so even though we're getting smarter, for the most part the average stays at 100. If the average score became 120, they would just mess around the grading system so that 120=100 the next time they updated the test.
Ever heard of "correlation vs causation" or "the narrative fallacy"?
ReplyKudos on the Bill Hicks though ;)
The worst part about the reality TV epidemic are all the unwitting people caught in the crossfire. People who have a couple hours of downtime and get sucked into a terrible show because it gives them a quick fix of self-importance, like some low-grade ocular cocaine. They proceed to watch the shows more frequently, all the while spouting the mantra of the RTV addict: "I'm watching this crap IRONICALLY! I don't actually LIKE it." At that point they're totally absorbed. People like that seem to be oblivious that TV execs don't care what your attitude is toward the show as long as you're watching. Beating yourself in the face with a rotten salmon is a stupid thing to do, whether you're doing it "ironically" or not.
ReplyPlain and simple: If it's poison, DON'T INGEST IT.
God, so true. Years ago my friend's then-wife would put on something like a marathon of America's Next Top Model for "background noise" and I would get totally drawn in to the point of caring who won a certain challenge. It sucked! :(
Sport is the definition of reality TV, no scripts, no actors and completly unpredictable. Everybody needs to watch some form of sports and have something to cheer for. It makes TV so much enjoyable, but i guess that's what some of the above shows do for some ppl. It seems like ppl watch shows like Survivor, Apprentice, Idol because they have thier favorite character and they watch the show to cheer for them, and i can accept that. But shows like Jersey shore, Simple Life, etc are just useless works of crap. I don't understand how they are succesful, i guess ppl enjoy watching idiots since it makes them feel better about themselves or something. But yah, Sport is the best form of Television. Ever.
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesWell, it's completely unpredictable unless you're watching a Patriots games circa 2005-2008.
I don't watch sports or reality TV.
"Everybody needs to watch some form of sports and have something to cheer for."
My city is way better than your city. Our jerseys are a better color and feature a symbol much more badass than that of your city. Since the roster is ever-changing, I assume this is what I'm cheering for.
Oh, and MTV is to blame for all this.
ReplyYet another reason to hate it. MTV should have died and dignified death in 1990.
A lot of things should kelgo, a lot of things should.
Am I the only one who feels physically ill and nauseous, just by reading Tila Taquila's name?
ReplyI can't sta....[barf]