The 5 Most Ridiculous Lies Ever Published as Non-Fiction
So you've got an idea for a novel. Big deal, right? Thousands of those are published every year and most collect dust on the shelves. How can you call attention to yours?
Hey, why not claim all the stuff in the book actually happened to you? Instead of a ridiculous product of your deranged imagination, it's an inspiring true story!
Be careful, though, because apparently that plan can blow up in your face.

The Book:
In 2003, author James Frey published a "memoir" about his life as a total unrepentant addict, alcoholic, criminal and all-around bad-ass motherfucker. So bad-ass, in fact, he has a tattoo on his forearm that says "FTBSITTTD," which allegedly stands for "Fuck The Bullshit, It's Time To Throw Down."
His book describes one fucked up incident after another. How he'd been arrested 11 times before he reached the age of 19. How he was investigated by the FBI for his massive drug-running empire but was never caught. How, drunk and high on crack, he nearly ran down a cop in Ohio. Then he took on said cop's backup, almost won and, instead, wound up in the slammer.

The Bullshit:
In reality, of course, Jimmy Frey never did any of those things. Oh, there's a microscopic grain of truth to some of it. He did not run down a cop, but he did blatantly park illegally near one, was busted for driving under the influence and having an open beer in the car with him, and spent about five whole hours in jail before a buddy ponied up a few hundred dollars in bail.
The cop he "almost ran down" did call for back up, but that was because he was a foot patrolman and didn't have a car to transport the reportedly "polite and cooperative" Mr. Frey to the Big House. You can guess how much truth there was in his claim to being a Tony Montana-esque drug kingpin.

Now, normally, this level of horseshit is reserved for the dumb fucker you meet in a bar who turns his routine traffic stop into the finale of Bonnie and Clyde. You know it's crap, but you play along because either A) The story is at least entertaining; B) The guy's so hammered you're bound to get into a "Oh yeah? YOU CALLIN' ME A LIAR, MOTHERFUCKER?" confrontation; or C) You just don't care enough to call the dude on his bullshit.
But what makes Mr. Frey's deceit so monumental is that he spun it into a best-selling novel and managed to con the famously gullible Oprah Winfrey. When Oprah slapped her "Book Club" sticker on this pile of bullshit wrapped in a hardcover and dustjacket, it spent weeks and weeks on The New York Times bestseller list.
The Crash:
The Smoking Gun found that not only were his stories of drug running and cop smooshing bullshit, but that he had inexplicably written himself into the tragic auto vs. locomotive death of three teens in his hometown of St. Joseph, Michigan.

Oprah, Valkyrie of wounded dignity that she was, brought Frey and his publisher back onto her show. She reduced Frey to a stammering six-year-old caught with his hand in the cookie jar and forced his publisher to admit that she never really got around to checking the veracity of Frey's claims 'cause, you know, he seemed so trustworthy. For an admitted drunk, junkie and criminal, that is.

The Book:
Our second entry in the "lame-ass white kid wants to be a stone-cold criminal" category is Love and Consequences penned under the nom de bullshit "Margaret B. Jones."
In this fauxmoir, "Jones" claims she is a half American Indian/half white foster kid growing up in the baddest parts of South Central Los Angeles, a world renowned war zone. She details her life with her foster mother, "Big Mom," her various foster brothers and sisters (many of whom die in violent and tragic ways), her experiences as a drug runner for the infamous Bloods gang at the age of 13 and cooking up some crack cocaine to pay the water bill at the age of 16.

The Bullshit:
"Jones" is actually Margaret Seltzer: an all white, upper-middle class girl who grew up in the oh-so-dangerous, predominantly white, San Fernando Valley suburb of Sherman Oaks. That's right kids, the killer drug running chick is actually a true-bred "Valley Girl."
How did Seltzer manage to get away with this crap before her own family sold her down the river? Through the totally convincing use of street slang, yo. For instance, she would spell words with a "k" instead of a "c". What, you didn't know gang folk did that? In her own words:
"... I want people to understand how deep-seated the hatred really is between CRIPs and Bloods. CRIPs celebrate C-days rather than B-days (birthdays) and Bloods smoke bigarettes not cigarettes. The hate is so deep that, as a Blood, you automatically change the spelling in words with a c in them."

That's... plausible. Right?
The Crash:
Poor Seltzer didn't get the chances that Frey did, such as scamming Oprah on national television. No, before her book tour got started Seltzer was ratted out... by her own sister. So that probably made for an awkward Thanksgiving.
Seltzer got the idea, she claimed, by hanging out very briefly at Grant High School in a less affluent area of the San Fernando Valley. These were the stories, she claimed, of friends and acquaintances she had made during that time and she felt their stories should be heard.

The Grant High School Marching Bloods.
As to why she chose to tell those stories as though they had happened to her, we're not entirely certain. Perhaps she thought it might give her some of the "street cred" that is so desperately necessary when attempting to "represent" to the "homies" at Trader Joe's.

The Book:
In 1956, a publishing sensation swept through England. Finally, finally, someone had written a true-life story about being a Tibetan lama... and there was magic and ninjas and stuff in it! Just what the country ordered!
The Third Eye, authored by a man with the improbably hilarious name of Tuesday Lobsang Rampa, told the true story of a young Tibetan boy (the author) who became a lama (religious teacher) at a young age. Over the next few years he flies, meets yetis and has a hole drilled in his forehead to open his "third eye." Why does he do this last thing? Because the Dalai Lama has foreseen the Chinese re-taking of Tibet, and Lobsang's third eye will give him super-powers for reading minds.

Having lived through far too much awesomeness for one book, he continued it in sequels in which Lobsang flies airplanes for the Chinese in WW II, gets captured and spends time in a P.O.W. camp, survives Hiroshima, goes to England, is tortured, escapes his torturers in a luxury car and finally...
The Bullshit:
... he dies. Yes, he wrote his own death into his autobiography. While he was walking around alive.
To be fair to his publishers, he didn't work the whole "And then I totally died!" part in until his third book. And it was probably a James Frey situation, where the guy really was a lama but had to spice things up a little. Or a lot.

The Crash:
The famous Tibetologist and adventurer Heinrich Harrer (played by dream-boat Brad Pitt in Seven Years in Tibet) became suspicious of Lobsang and hired a private detective to track the elusive lama down. And that detective did find his man... namely, Cyril Henry Hoskins, an Irish plumber's son who knew no Tibetan, had never been to Tibet and in fact did not even have a passport.
When all the academics cried in unison "Shenanigans, sir!" Cyril waved it off and told them the real story: That he was Tuesday Lobsang Rampa's spirit, and he was inhabiting the body of Cyril Hoskins. Undeterred, the man went on to write 24 books total, including tale about his real trip to Venus in a spaceship.









Shinnecock Indians.
ReplyI'm very shocked, indeed. Did you know that I was enlisted in the Red Army at the age of 10 and was send to infiltrate the French Legion later? Oh, wait, I have to write the book first... If you have ideas for a plot, just send them to me.
ReplyI have to give Frey some credit, in that FTBSITTTD is pretty much the exact noise I made when I snorted coffee up my nose reading about his tattoo
ReplyAs amusing as the Shinnecock picture was, the joke kind of falls flat for those of us who grew up in that area and know it's not pronounced shiny-cock, but shin-ah-cock.
ReplyI think shine-ah-cock is even funnier personally
Not that it would have made for good reading, but you forgot numerous Holy Books (heck, they're presented as a step above non-fiction: textbooks), especially the Worldwide #1 Best Seller.
Replyif i was james frey i would have stood on oprahs couch pointed in her bloody fat face and said "thanks to you...." *raises arms above head closes eyes* "IM RICH BIITTCHHHH"
ReplyRoflmao! Don't forget to deepen your voice a little to make it boom impressively as you yell at the ignorant broad!
so oprah tore frey's publisher a new one for not checking her facts? i wonder if when oprah introduced herself, the conversation went something like, "hi pot, my name's kettle"
ReplyIm glad to see the Protocols of the learned elders of Zion is not included in this...Cracked knows whats up haha
Reply Hide All See All 3 Replies'Coz the ZOG mindwash is already set in.
Bringing up the Protocols and discussing them to further "De-Bunk" them gets people to READ them.
And F*ck if they aren't true. Oh, I won't Deny the Holocaust or say the Protocols are real... Yeah, prolly a Tzarist forgery. BUT, it's more or less what any such group trying to take over the world WOULD do.
Sounds crazy and I use to think there was no truth to the insane claims but I can't help but find it odd and even frightening that journalists and public figures that make even the lightest mention of bankers, the media, and generally the rich and powerful running the world they are immediately accused (usually by several sources simultaneously) of being anti Semitic Holocaust deniers, even when they make no mention of the holocaust or Hebrews.
And I would like to point out to people (including a few cracked writers and countless cementers) that disliking or even hating Zionism is not antisemitism any more than hating Nazis makes you prejiduce towards Germans.
I know I'm ranting now but it pisses me off when people attack these figures by asking "Well if it's true, why isn't this powerful secret society having you killed or shut down?" but then they don't find it even a little interesting or suspicious when those very people are killed or when they are attacked by several (sometimes all) major news networks at the same time.
Yeah yeah, nothing going on there, I guess they all hate Jewish people and think history never happened. That's way more comforting than the thought that they may be right about an organized powerful force suppressing information and manipulating the masses.
wait..I, whay?! hahahahaha. These are the craziest ass replies to a comment ever! Zionist conspiracies? you guys are f*****g nuts.
Now they are saying Sybil is a big lie too.
ReplyIndeed. I hear at least seven of her personalities have turned against her and are claiming she's just a nice, sane Lutheran girl from Milwaukee and made the whole thing up.
You forgot Dave Pelzer, the guy who wrote "A Child Called It". He has written two other books about his child abuse at the hands of his alcoholic mother, but most of his family has refuted his claims.
ReplyI just read The Smoking Gun article on "A Million Little Pieces" and looked up James Frey. I can't believe this untalented f***face is still writing and still successful. He hasn't apologized for or acknowledged his bulls**t; Oprah apparently even apologized to him for calling him out. He never would have been published in the first place if he hadn't presented the story as nonfiction. The moral of this story, kids: bullshit your way to success and fame, and when confronted with your lies, never, ever back down.
ReplyThat's how it's done son...
Re: Love and Consequence...I graduated from Grant High School in Van Nuys...Oops, Valley Glen, in the San Fernando Valley...13000 Oxnard...ugly orange and brown colors....yep, that's the place *LOL*...I kid you not...Grant has produced some of the best minds in music, acting, and creative writing in the country....look it up, you'll be amazed at the listing...but that was back in the 1960's and early 1970's. In the late 1970's demographics started to change and the school began to loose its luster, following a downward spiral into a Title I school.
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesEven so, even during its glory days, it was a financially segregated institution, (I was fortunate and got to go there on an in-district transfer) and although the demographics have changed since my days, and I've heard the violence has quelled, it remains a severely financially segregated institution (a wide gap between the "haves" and "have-nots"), due to its location.
This leads the affleunt to "adopt" or become very familiar with the less than affluent people's culture. So, they pretend they are "down" when in reality, they wouldn't be caught dead into the neighborhoods north and northeast of the school. It was true in the 1970's and it is true today....all this young lady did was take what she learned in her Creative Writing class, what she experienced in "the quad" (a place where students congregate during class breaks and lunch), and put what she heard/observed on paper, getting it published for all to see. Isn't that the American Way?
I give her an "A" for the semester in Creative Writing and advise her to stay in Sherman Oaks, Encino, Tarzana, Toluca Lake or some other 'near Ventura' neighborhood. Faking it is fun...the reality of it is not.
I "looset" interest after the first paragraph. You're old.
for a writing teacher, you're pretty s****y at writing and spelling. isn't our education system here in america wonderful?
Fellow Angelino here. Grant is located in a neighborhood that's far from s****y as well. Maybe she did it fur the lulz?
In all fairness, I thought "A Million Little Pieces" had a great cover! But I still didn't read it.
ReplyNothing is more fraudulent than profiting off of vast human tragedies like the Holocaust.
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesWell, one of them is a real survivor...I'm not sure if it makes it a little better or a whole lot worse he made stuff up.
It makes it worse. It reduces the impact of the stories from all the survivors who didn't make things up, makes people wonder about their accuracy. The most moving thing I recently read about the Holocaust was Art Spiegelaman's Maus, incidentally. It made it all feel very real to me, and before it was just too much to imagine. Worth reading.
I blame the Jews.
What about the memoirs of John Smith? While stories of his later life had some truth to them, seems to have made from whole cloth the entirety of his early life, complete with pirates, duels, knighthoods, damsels slavery, and of course how much of a badass fighter and Casanova he was. He was an Internet commentator before his time.
ReplyI don't see how anyone could fall for the James Frey book. I am pretty sure if the FBI was investigating you for a crime they might just arrest you when you admit to that crime in a memior. Kinda like a confession really, no smart criminial would do that unless double jeopardy was invovled. Seriously Oprah you are overrated and you make me get migraines. Now excuse me as I go cry for the future of America.
ReplyThe Book of Mormon should be on this list.
Reply Hide All See All 4 RepliesThat would go better with the admitted hoaxes I think.
and the bible
And anything by Godek.
Anything relating to organized religion.
I remember seeing A Million Little Pieces in the bookstore all the time, but it always seemed to be the escapades of a man made of candy and covered in those colourful sprinkles that you put on cookies, judging the book by its cover.
ReplyHungry now.
Now I want to read a book called 'A Million Reese's Pieces.'
No mention of Papillon? Half of that was a story he heard in prison and the rest was pure male fantasy. The stuff about all the hot chicks he got, that was the male fantasy part.
ReplyThe 'Shinnecock Indian' was a work of genius, utterly lost my s**t at that.
Reply