The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

When people vanish, it usually turns out they were killed or kidnapped, or at least they were very likely to have been. Usually we have some kind of an answer. Usually -- but not always.
The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

Back in the Dark Ages, people disappeared all the time. Crusades, disease and nearly nonexistent bookkeeping made it easy to slip through the cracks without so much as a footprint left behind. Luckily, the modern world makes such disappearances damn near impossible -- when people vanish, it usually turns out they were killed or kidnapped, or at least they were very likely to have been. The point is, usually we have some kind of an answer.

Which makes it all the more mind-boggling when people actually do vanish into thin air, under very weird circumstances. Like ...

Ray Gricar

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

For 20 years, Ray Gricar was the district attorney of Centre County, Pennsylvania. He was a solid man with a tough reputation. On April 15, 2005, Gricar phoned his girlfriend and told her he was driving in the countryside and would be back soon.

He never returned.

But hey, mystery schmystery, right? Dude was a hardass DA, he was bound to make enemies. He was probably making that call under duress from some gang member or something.


"Tell her I send my love. No, I couldn't do it myself, it's embarrassing."

That's pretty much what the cops must have figured when Gricar's car was found outside an antiques store. Pretty much everything but his cellphone was missing. There were no signs of a struggle, but it must be noted that DAs seldom put up a fight at gunpoint unless they're played by Aaron Eckhart.

A search ensued. Gricar's credit cards and accounts were monitored, with no signs of activity. His laptop was retrieved from a nearby river, too damaged to recover any files.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

Although thankfully not too damaged to run Windows ME.

So what makes Gricar's disappearance any different from those of countless other guys who could have been killed, or killed themselves? Well ...

It Gets Weirder:

Want to guess what case he was working at the time he disappeared? Here's a hint: It's Pennsylvania, home of Penn State University.

CSAILT T ABUSE 57 STEP D2i 0 Canpe 14 FAETS! 6

Hey, what a coincidence! Something big happened there just the other ... year ... oh.

Yep. Investigators found that at the time of his disappearance in 2005, Gricar was working on what would be known as the Penn State sex abuse scandal, which may or may not end up revealing an assistant football coach as a horrible dickbag who deserves all the prison. You know, that scandal that just broke last year. Gricar was working on it six years earlier.

Then he vanished.

Furthermore, investigators found out Gricar had in 1998 mysteriously refused to press charges against the coach despite having more than enough evidence. In 2005, same thing. It was almost like he was stacking evidence for the mother of all judicial beatdowns.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

"You're about to be as screwed as those k-- oh, shit. I probably shouldn't say that."

Many officials have since said that Gricar's disappearance must have something to do with the Penn State scandal, goddamnit. And true enough, even without the whole case-building thing, Gricar had a history of animosity with the university. But here's yet another curve:

Remember that laptop we mentioned, the one that was found in the river? You know, implying that the killer dumped it there? In 2009, someone got around to searching Gricar's home computer. Its search history showed that Gricar had made a whole lot of Web searches for things such as "how to wreck a hard drive," "how to fry a hard drive" and "water damage to a notebook computer." It's as if he was planning to destroy the computer himself, in a way that would make its contents unrecoverable.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

"Haha! Now no one will discover all that incriminating evidence! Wait, shit."

So that would mean he dumped the computer, and then vanished. Why?

It's looking like we'll never know.

Louis Le Prince

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

Louis Le Prince was a 19th century inventor who specialized in cameras and was so far ahead of his time that he actually created the world's first true moving picture. With such pioneering technology at his disposal and loads more up his sleeve, Le Prince was well on his way to becoming the most influential Frenchman since Napoleon. So ... why haven't we ever heard of him before?

Because he vanished. From a train.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

"That's odd. Coal almost never screams when you burn it."

In 1890, Le Prince was traveling to America to get new patents and show off his newest wonderful toys. In Dijon, France, he checked his baggage, boarded a train bound for Paris, retired to his cabin and ... that was the last time anyone saw him.

It Gets Weirder:

No passengers saw anything suspicious. There were no noises from Le Prince's cabin. All windows were tightly closed. Yet when the train pulled into Paris, not only was Le Prince not on the train, but his baggage -- kept in a separate compartment -- was missing as well. Both the train and the railroad were searched in their entirety, but neither the man nor the luggage was ever found.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

Which is a shame, as his luggage held the upgrade for this ... trouser press?

Some were certain that Le Prince had performed an elaborate suicide by essentially vanishing into thin air, despite being in the middle of a trip to go show off the work he was so proud of. Others claimed his family had ordered him to disappear due to financial problems, and he took it a bit literally. Others still stretched the family theory even further, claiming his brother had murdered him and somehow managed to magic the corpse-luggage combo away because screw you, logic, we're conspiracy theorizin' here.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

Occam's razor clearly points toward weaponized spontaneous human combustion.

Of course, there is also that other theory.

Le Prince was in heavy competition with an American film pioneer. Said American actively blocked the Frenchman's U.S. patents, while Le Prince returned the favor by having the American's camera designs bleed out to French cameramen before he could get European patents for them.

So, a slightly dickish, insanely competitive American inventor who was keen on cinematography? Hi, Thomas Edison! We've been missing you.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

What's that, Edison? A "murdering train-bound Frenchmen" potion? You scamp!

In a sweet (for Edison) twist of fate, Le Prince's disappearance meant there was no one to hold Tommy back from hogging all the credit for discovering motion pictures. Many investigators noticed this, but there was absolutely no way to connect Edison to the case. And even if he was behind Le Prince's disappearance somehow, that would take us no closer to the grand question: How?

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

We actually have film footage, but people are waiting for the 3-D rerelease.

Still, we can't help thinking that if you wanted to come up with someone who could make a dude just flat out disappear, the guy whose actual nickname had the word "Wizard" in it might warrant more than a passing glance.

Jean Spangler

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

Jean Spangler was one of the many denizens of the shadowy underbelly of Los Angeles -- a gorgeous actress who didn't let her limited success stop her from leading as sparkling a life as she could manage. She had just finished filming a bit part in the movie Young Man With a Horn (tee hee!), among numerous other small roles, and it might just have been a matter of time before she'd make it big. Or not. We'll never know, as fate had other plans for her. One October day in 1949, she set off to meet her ex-husband about child support and was never seen again.

Admiral Blandy Sees Russ War Danger 10S Angeles Examiner Black Dahlia Parallel: GLAMOUR GIRL'S BODY HUNTED Alasbe Delense ALL S Biad The 3ee ibaes A a

And the creepy headline floodgates opened.

Her purse appeared two days later, untouched and exactly as cashless as it had been (she didn't carry money -- the investigation ruled out robbery). The only thing inside was a cryptic note:

"Kirk, Can't wait any longer. Going to see Dr. Scott. It will work best this way while mother is away."

mnr A oar thes ak: tet l A 4 hat Mene d S ade

"Cont. in next tweet."

Nobody knew who "Kirk" was. But there was one Kirk she knew that made the case all the more curious ...

It Gets Weirder:

And when we say curious, we mean the case was intriguing enough to become a nationwide sensation. Publicity brought plenty of new tips and leads, each turning out to be completely useless. All clues pointed in different directions, and each path was a dead end. Yes, even the ex-husband she was on her way to see.

And then we have that "Kirk" she had worked with. Specifically, actor Kirk Douglas of Spartacus and Being Michael Douglas' Dad fame.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

Winner of Cracked's "Holy Crap Is That Dude Still Alive?" award 2012.

Douglas managed to become entangled in the case by going out of his way to tell everyone that the "Kirk" in the note totally wasn't him, honestly, guys, he barely knew her. Curiously, up until then the police hadn't even really thought of him as a suspect, despite at the time checking out pretty much every Kirk and Scott within their jurisdiction, just in case.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

"To prove it, here's a creepy photo of me in my new film The Champion, out this year."

Douglas could, of course, just have been covering his back, as he'd recently starred in a film Spangler also had a role in. And his involvement was just one of many odd little facts that kept popping up. For instance, three weeks before Spangler's disappearance, a shady abortion doctor named, yes, Dr. Kirk had been threatening all his former patients over the phone, and a close associate of his actually disappeared without a trace. But no evidence ever turned up connecting him with Spangler's disappearance.

In yet another lead, two mobsters who had been partying with Spangler had also vanished at around the same time. Any evidence they were involved with her disappearance? Of course not!

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

We suspect this child. Because just look at that ghoulish little face.

In fact, no definitive theory or suspect was ever named, as every day it seemed more like Spangler had just flat out walked right off the earth. Lacking gruesome details, the case slipped through the cracks of public consciousness within months. Soon, it was little more than a shrug and a bucketload of half-assed assumptions of botched abortions and various fatal encounters. Thus faded the memory of Jean Spangler.

You know, except for that one time when a mysterious woman who looked exactly like her was spotted in Texas the following year. However, police never pursued the lead.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

"Oh yeah, faces like hers are 10 a penny."

Jim Thompson

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

During World War II, Jim Thompson was an agent for OSS, the predecessor of the CIA. After his service ended, he decided to retire in his mission country of Thailand and enter the strangest possible profession for a former spy: Thompson became a fashion big shot who single-handedly rebuilt the Thai silk industry. Thompson's efforts to improve the economy won him the respect of both the public and the government, not to mention making him ridiculously rich.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

Tours of his house Cribs-style rich.

On March 26, 1967, while vacationing in a highlands cottage with some friends, he never returned from his solitary afternoon walk. His popularity and power immediately led to the largest search in Thai history. Alas, Thompson was never found.

It Gets Weirder:

We know for a fact that Thompson wasn't planning on a long walk, because he didn't take his jacket, medication or -- a telltale sign, as he was a heavy smoker -- his cigarettes.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

"Machetes are a better secondhand killer."

It also seems unlikely that he accidentally got lost or fell. He was a retired military officer/spy with extensive survival experience. The terrain was relatively easy, and he was an experienced hiker who liked to engage in solo jungle walkabouts that would pass for a training montage in a Tarzan movie.

So, maybe he had a stroke or something? But that huge search operation wasn't just a bunch of guys lazily wandering around the area -- it was a battalion of experienced trackers, combing the land. Dead or alive, if Thompson were there he would've been found (or at least you'd think).

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

"I'm gonna go test this invisibility cloak and experiment with mixing hard drugs. Be back in an hour."

Rumor soon had it that Thompson, being a wealthy American expatriate, had been kidnapped. If so, they weren't doing it for the money -- no ransom demand appeared, and no evidence ever turned up of such an operation.

Despite rewards and multiple search and re-search parties, no credible evidence of Thompson's fate has ever surfaced. The most generally accepted theory claims he was abducted by communists -- and that one is based on testimony by a freaking psychic.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

An all-American, capitalist hero psychic.

Since we are already at the "psychics get a say in this" stage, let's run this thing through the Cracked Speculation Machine (patent pending): Thompson was a revered member of the U.S. Intelligence community, and not necessarily a former one at that. Longstanding rumors maintained that he never quite let go of the whole spying thing, and the fact that he disappeared during a time when Southeast Asia was quickly becoming extremely hostile for Americans -- mere months before the Tet Offensive -- seems awfully convenient.

We're not explicitly saying he might have been called back from retirement for one last spy mission, the enthralling details of which we can never be allowed to know. We're just heavily implying.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

Just like this spy's about to heavily imply a bunch of lead into some commie faces.

The Crew of the MV Joyita

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

In October 1955, a merchant vessel named MV Joyita set sail from Samoa for a two-day voyage to Tokelau Islands, carrying 25 people and a cargo of timber and empty oil drums. Four days later, its destination port sent out a message that the ship had never arrived. No distress signals had been received -- the Joyita had just vanished.

Everyone flipped out and a huge search mission was organized. Still, the vessel wasn't found until over a month later, floating aimlessly a good 600 miles away from Samoa ... with nobody on board.

The Joyita was flooded and tilting to the point of being partially submerged.

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

The band stayed on until the end, despite ample lifeboat space and them being an a cappella ensemble.

And no, it wasn't a case where everybody was standing on one rail and when the boat tipped it dumped them all into the water. The boat's logbook and navigational equipment were missing, as were the dinghy, all three lifeboats and all the food. The radio of the ship was found to be in perfect working order and set to the emergency frequency. However, it only had a range of about 2 miles due to messed-up wiring that had gone unnoticed.

Well ... that's eerie, granted, but pretty straightforward. The ship started leaking and they had to abandon it, because they were unable to signal for help, right?

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

"We signaled to the dolphins to save us, but they just ate Claude and laughed."

It Gets Weirder:

That would be a nice theory, except for the fact that the ship was completely seaworthy. It had a large hole in its superstructure, indicating a collision with something -- but as the actual hull had not been breached, that was nowhere near enough to cause much harm. There was a little water inside the ship, but that was mainly due to it bobbing in the waves like a cork for weeks.

If the crew and passengers loaded up in lifeboats and pissed off toward familiar waters, why weren't any of them spotted by air rescue? Lifeboats tend to be designed for good visibility, and even if they keel over they don't sink easily. And we're not talking about one lifeboat here, but three.


Lifeboat tastes better when sandwiched between people steaks.

Wait, it gets better! Most of the windows of the ship were smashed. The main engine was covered in mattresses for no apparent reason, and only one of the other engines was working. One of the passengers was a doctor, and his bag was found on the deck -- with several tools removed and replaced with bloody rags. To cap off the scene, the failing generator had stopped each of the ship's clocks at 10:25 p.m., presumably to indicate what we'll just go ahead and call "Cthulhu Time."

Unsurprisingly, most everyone started pushing their pet theory on what had happened. Even less surprisingly, said theories range from the usual pirate and mutiny stories to the obligatory "aliens did it" one, to a particularly creative one about Japanese holdouts from WWII having attacked the boat.

And who knows, maybe one of those batshit insane proposals is correct. MV Joyita isn't telling. She is too busy enjoying the deserved reputation of the "Mary Celeste of the Pacific."

The 5 Creepiest Disappearances That Nobody Can Explain

The MV Joyita would run aground three more times in the following years. Because the first thing you do with a demon boat is keep it fed.

For more disturbing unanswered questions, check out The 5 Creepiest Unsolved Crimes Nobody Can Explain and 6 Insane Discoveries That Science Can't Explain.

And stop by LinkSTORM to discover what really happened to Ross.

And don't forget to follow us on Facebook and Twitter to get sexy, sexy jokes sent straight to your news feed.

Do you have an idea in mind that would make a great article? Then sign up for our writers workshop! Do you possess expert skills in image creation and manipulation? Mediocre? Even rudimentary? Are you frightened by MS Paint and simply have a funny idea? You can create an infographic and you could be on the front page of tomorrow!

Scroll down for the next article
Forgot Password?