The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

At one time, every major rap album had to contain at least one track in which the rapper recounted, in extreme detail and in first person, a boastful yet grossly implausible tale involving himself and perhaps his crew. Many believe the mid-'80s to the mid-'90s marked the golden era of rap storytelling. Sadly, it all came crashing down.
The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

At one time, every major rap album had to contain at least one track in which the rapper recounted, in extreme detail and in first person, a boastful yet grossly implausible tale involving himself and perhaps his crew. Many believe the mid-'80s to the mid-'90s marked the golden era of rap storytelling. This era ended in 1994, with Nate Dogg and Warren G's "Regulate," a song which details, among other events, Warren G looking so handsome that a group of women crash their car from staring at him so hard. The genre's credibility was never regained, causing many of us to cast a skeptical eye on tales such as ...

"Parents Just Don't Understand" -- Will Smith

The very first time mainstream America heard from future worldwide superstar Will Smith was the 1988 single "Parents Just Don't Understand," back when Smith was going by The Fresh Prince. It's a bouncy, radio-friendly, lighthearted tale told from the point of view of a teenager, which partway through takes a turn for the nightmarish.

The second verse, which depicts at least one felony that Smith was apparently never indicted for, begins with him "borrowing" his parents' car while they're away. Then he finds a girl:

That's when I saw this beautiful girlie girl walking

I picked up my car phone to perpetrate like I was talking

You should've seen this girl's bodily dimensions

I honked my horn just to get her attention


Above: what all women want. Forever.

She likes the Porsche and climbs in, then immediately starts desperately trying to seduce him:

She kicked her shoes off onto the floor

She said, "Drive fast, speed turns me on"

She put her hand on my knee, I put my foot on the gas


This girl's hand was steadily moving up my thigh

She had opened up three buttons on her shirt so far


At best, his eyes are on the road a third of the time.

At this point, he's going so fast that he attracts the attention of the police. Which is a problem, since he 1) stole a car, 2) doesn't have license, and 3) ...

I almost had a heart attack that day

Come to find out the girl was a 12-year-old runaway

What. The. Fucking. Fuck. Motherfucker.


Wait, she's 12?

Let's review. Will Smith, future international superstar and Oscar nominee, says "You should've seen this girl's bodily dimensions" about a middle-school child. A child who says "Drive fast, speed turns me on" before moving her hand toward his dick. Finally, she seduces him by unbuttoning the top three buttons on her shirt to reveal her cleavage. Her 12-year-old cleavage.

I was arrested, the car was impounded, there was no way for me to avoid being grounded

During this whole sequence, a confused Smith seems to think the problem is that he doesn't have a license. No, Will, the problem is that you abducted a child off the street with the intention of molesting her. "Accidental" or not, that's the case you're getting.

"Funky Cold Medina" -- Tone Loc

If you traveled in a time machine back to 1989 and turned on MTV, you'd see a Tone Loc video. He had two hits, both of which were about his dysfunctional and at times clearly illegal sexual habits. The first was "Wild Thing" and the second was "Funky Cold Medina," after which humanity politely asked him to stop making music.

The story begins in a bar, where Tone is frustrated that he's not having any success trying to dig up a one-night stand:

Cold coolin' at a bar, and I'm lookin' for some action

But like Mick Jagger said, I can't get no satisfaction

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

Ladies, help us out here. What about this is off-putting to you? The glasses?

First of all, when Jagger said he couldn't get satisfaction, we're pretty sure he was also having lots and lots of sex. No, Tone, your problems are not similar to Mick's. And let's face it, Tone wasn't the most attractive guy. He was a little overweight, wore ratty T-shirts and jeans, and sounded like Wolfman Jack. So right away, we see that perhaps Tone doesn't have the firmest grip on reality.

But on the other side of the bar, some normal-looking jackoff is surrounded by women. So Tone walks over and asks him how.

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

It can't be the sunglasses.

So I got up and strolled over to the other side of the cantina

I asked the guy, 'Why you so fly?' He said, 'Funky Cold Medina

It's better than any alcohol or aphrodisiac

A couple of sips of this love potion, and she'll be on your lap'

Yes, the stranger introduces him to a mind-controlling date rape drug, which Tone doesn't even hesitate to accept. Now, clearly it would be irresponsible to immediately start drugging human women with this concoction. So Tone tests it on his dog, which becomes so aroused that it tries to mate with Tone Loc himself:

So I gave some to my dog when he began to beg

Then he licked his bowl and he looked at me and did the wild thing on my leg

He used to scratch and bite me, before he was much much meaner

But now all the poodles run to my house for the Funky Cold Medina

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

His home now a writhing, yelping canine orgy, Mr. Loc considers this a successful test and immediately proceeds to drug a girl without her knowledge:

She said, 'I'd like a drink,' I said, 'Ehm -- OK, I'll go get it'

Then a couple sips she cold-licked her lips, and I knew that she was with it

What Tone did there now carries a 20-year minimum prison sentence, thanks to the Drug Induced Rape Prevention and Punishment Act of 1996.

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

Look everyone, a felony! In the wild!

But this was 1989, which was still the '80s, as Tone is about to remind us. So chemically enhanced sexual encounters with unwilling partners were still in a legal gray area. Because of shit like this, "It was a different time" is possibly the most frightening phrase to ever come from any past generation.

Tone soon gets his comeuppance, however:

So I took her to my crib, and everything went well as planned

But when she got undressed, it was a big old mess, Sheena was a man


This is the '80s, and I'm down with the ladies

This suggests that Tone alternates his sexual orientation by decade, which means that as of 2010, he's gay again. We're also going to find out later that apparently, almost having sex with someone who has a penis was a nearly universal phobia back in the day. But we'll come back to that.

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

"Clearly, trans people exist only to tempt me!"

Back in the saddle, lookin' for a little affection

I took a shot as a contestant on The Love Connection

The audience voted, and you know they picked a winner

I took my date to the Hilton for Medina and some dinner

Tone, undaunted and unable to find rest in his home due to the mass of humping dogs that are presumably still in his living room, decides to try his luck on a popular game show from the '80s called The Love Connection. This is where we have a problem. We've seen, recorded, and memorized every episode of that show, and we don't recall Tone Loc ever being on it. However, he claims that he not only participated, but also won.

We would suggest that he put Love Connection in there because it was the only thing he could think of that rhymed with "affection." But that seems unlikely, considering that "erection" is out there.

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

We would also suggest that this guy win every major music award.

She had a few drinks, I'm thinkin' soon what I'll be getting

Instead she started talkin' 'bout plans for our wedding

So here Tone claims that even though he had a date that was guaranteed by contract, he still used the rape drug. But instead of the girl having sex with him, she wanted to get married, as the chemical has the remarkable ability to not only lower a woman's inhibitions and increase her sex drive, but to also create the kind of illusions of compatibility and long-term attraction that would induce her to propose marriage after a few hours.

This scares Tone, who warns listeners off of using Funky Cold Medina at all, despite the fact that it seemed to work just fine for the stranger at the bar and his dog. At no point does Tone realize that perhaps he is the problem.

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs


"Black Steel In The Hour Of Chaos" -- Public Enemy

The tragedy of Public Enemy is that there are fans reading this who are young enough that they know Flavor Flav only as a goofy reality show star. And still a younger generation which will never know him at all.

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

"Tragedy" is such a small word.

Back in the day, he and Chuck D changed rap music forever. Their first hit album was the bombastically titled It Takes A Nation Of Millions To Hold Us Back in 1988. They rapped about racism and the tragic state of black America, and about their persecution at the hands of a white-dominated government. In the middle of it all was the prison break tale "Black Steel In The Hour Of Chaos".

Subtlety really wasn't their thing.

So first, the arrest:

I got a letter from the government

The other day

I opened and read it

It said they were suckas

They wanted me for their army or whatever

Picture me givin' a damn, I said never


Cold sweatin' as I dwell in my cell

How long has it been?

They got me sittin' in the state pen

So if you're to believe Mr. D, he was arrested for dodging the draft ... in 1988. He evidently got a letter from "the government," which called themselves "suckas" and then had him thrown in prison and scheduled for execution (he says later in the song that he is on "death row"). Once in prison, Chuck devises a plan to break out. The first step is to call Flavor Flav, resulting in this exchange:

Flavor Flav: Yo Chuck, you serious, you in the justice man?

Chuck: Word 'em up. I'm lookin' for that steel.

Flavor Flav: Yo, man, we gonna break you outta there, man we ain't goin' out like that man.

One thing we learn from that exchange that Chuck D is in fact a man, at least in the mind of Flav. After this, we find out that Chuck's intricate escape plan consists of waiting for the guard on death row to fall asleep while leaning against his cell:

You know I caught a C-O

Fallin' asleep on death row

I grabbed his gun -- then he did what I said so

Alright, so Chuck was fortunate enough to wind up in the most escapable prison since that one with the magnet boots in Face/Off. Now with hostages, it's time to make demands:

To understand my demands

I gave a warnin' -- I wanted the governor, y'all

And plus the warden to know

That I was innocent -

Because I'm militant

Posing a threat, you bet it's fuckin' up the government

Wait, are you innocent, or are you militant? You can't advocate overthrowing the government and then complain that you're falsely accused.

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

Nothing shady goin' on here.

Maybe part of the story is missing? Let's see if we can find a clue in here:

Got a woman C-O to call me a copter

She tried to get away, and I popped her

Twice, right, now who wanna get nice?

I had six C-Os, now it's five to go

See, it's going to be awfully hard to get the governor to accept your innocence when you just killed a prison guard. And not for attacking you or trying to get the gun away, but for trying to leave. We're starting to think you're the bad guy, Chuck D.

But then he makes his move, and the story strains our suspension of disbelief one step too far. He and his fellow escapees make a run for it, venturing into the courtyard past the guard towers:

... from the tower shots rang out

A high number of dose -- yes, and some came close

Figure I trigger my steel, stand and hold my post


And then I threw up my steel bullets flew up

And to my surprise the guard tower blew up

What? Who? The bazooka was who?

And to my rescue, it was the S1Ws

Yes, Flavor Flav has shown up with the "S1W's" (Public Enemy's hype men / backup dancers).

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

Their half of the escape plan was to launch shoulder-fired rockets at the guard tower and presumably the fence.

Now, obviously this is where rappers' tendency to tell these stories first-person muddles things. Clearly Chuck D never murdered multiple prison guards and/or destroyed a prison with rockets. That would have made the news. It's a cathartic revenge fantasy about a very real, often corrupt system. But that fantasy still reveals something deeply disturbing about his personality: In the event of a life-or-death emergency, he somehow thinks it would be a good idea to call Flavor Flav for help.

"Boyz-N-The Hood" And "Nobody Move" -- Eazy-E

Before Ice Cube was starring in family comedies and Dr. Dre was doing Dr. Pepper commercials, they were in a rap group called NWA with a tiny man named Eazy-E. And before Boyz N The Hood was a critically acclaimed 1991 gangster movie starring Ice Cube, it was a 1987 song by Eazy-E.

Boyz-N-The Hood Dopeman NIWU.A MAXI-12SINGLE

Eazy sadly passed away in 1995, but in his prime, he went on an imaginary crime spree that shocked the nation.

On an encounter with a friend who tried to steal his stereo:

Chased him up the street to call a truce

The silly motherfucker pull out a deuce-deuce

Little did he know I had a loaded 12-gauge

One sucker dead, LA Times first page

It seems unlikely that the shooting of a single man over a stereo would make the front page of a newspaper in a city that averaged two or three homicides a day at the time. But who knows, maybe the guy stealing his stereo was the mayor or something. Then Eazy meets his girlfriend:

Went to her house to get her out of the pad

Dumb ho says something stupid that made me mad

She started talkin' shit, wouldn't you know?

Reached back like a pimp and slapped the ho

Here we're introduced to a theme that is going to be repeated throughout nearly all of Eazy-E's tales: his penchant for solving problems by slapping people. Which brings us to our second example from his catalog: "Nobody Move," which details an armed robbery by Eazy and his crew.

This is a stick-up, everybody get face-down

Ren, gag their mouths so they can't make a sound


Take out the security guard with a slap of my hand

Yeah, he's wearin' a badge, but he's a old-ass man

Here Eazy takes out the guard with his superhuman slapping abilities. Again, in real life, Eazy-E was about the size of a middle school cheerleader.

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

Now it's time to deal with the closed-circuit security system:

Cover the lens on the TV screen, you know, so me and my gang just can't be seen

Eazy covers "the lens on the TV screen." Now, we're not the most tech-savvy people in the world, but even we know that that's not the way security cameras work. The "TV screen" part is what displays what's on the camera. The actual camera is somewhere else. Covering the screen will prevent Eazy and his gang from seeing themselves on the security system, but the cameras will continue to record. Nearly all problems in human society can be traced back to this "If we can't see it, it is no longer a problem" fallacy.

So the guys are robbing the bank and slapping random people when Eazy notices a woman he'd like to rape. During the robbery.

Peepin' at a bitch cause my dick's on hard


and then untie the ho, so I can start creepin'

I said: "Lay down, and unbutton your bra!"

She had the biggest titties that a n***a ever saw

But then the plan runs into a complication:

The suspense was makin' me sick

She took her panties down and the bitch had a dick!

I said 'Damn,' dropped the gat from my hand

What I thought was a bitch, ain't nothing but a man

Yes, the exact same scenario as played itself out in "Funky Cold Medina." Now, to be fair, this scenario didn't just turn up in a startling number of old-school rap songs -- virtually every transgender person in pop culture back then was presented as a sly deceiver out to trick manly dudes into having sex with them. People do, in fact, get beaten and murdered for that assumed scenario all the time in real life -- it's just that Eazy-E considered himself a hero for doing it in his fake story. There's so much to unpack there, we could probably turn it into a very large book. Instead, let's press on.

Eventually the police surround the bank, and Eazy demands a helicopter "so we can get away clean, and take some pussy along, if you know what I mean." It doesn't work. Police shoot tear gas into the bank and the guys get arrested, but only because Eazy's gun jams. We're not sure why he didn't just slap his way out.

"Paul Revere" -- Beastie Boys


Just like Will Smith, the Beastie Boys were in their 20s when their first hit album, License to Ill, came out in 1987, but they played the part of teenagers in some of their songs. But then you have the Beastie Boys origin story, "Paul Revere," which is not in fact about Paul Revere, but instead tells of how the group became friends over the course of a crime spree:

The song begins with Ad-Rock (Adam Horovitz) riding through the desert on his horse:

Had a little horsey named Paul Revere, just me and my horsey and a quart of beer

Riding across the land, kicking up sand, sheriff's posse on my tail cause I'm in demand

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

Sure you are.

Why is he on a horse? Wait, is this an Old West tale? That would at least make it transparently fictional, and thus more honest than the other examples on this list.

The sun is beating down on my baseball hat, the air is gettin' hot, the beer is getting flat

I was lookin' for a girl

Hmmm ... no, he's wearing a "baseball hat." So that eliminates two explanations as to why he's on a horse -- he's neither a cowboy nor Amish.

So he's clopping through the desert, drinking a beer and looking for a girl to party with. Now, it's suspect enough that he should be looking for someone to have sex with in the middle of the desert, but he also has the cops on his tail. They couldn't catch him on horseback? Are the cops on foot?

The horse seems important to the story, since the song is named after him, but they never mention him again. Already this raises doubts in our mind.

ohn ACA o t A

The Beastie Boys and their "horse."

Out of the blue, MCA (Adam Yauch) appears. MCA asks for a drink of Ad-Rock's beer, which Ad-Rock denies him. MCA replies by pulling his gun, introducing himself, and demanding -- at gunpoint -- that Ad-Rock become his friend and get drunk with him:

He put the gun to my head and this is what he said,


Now, 'I got the gun, you got the brew

You got two choices of what you can do

It's not a tough decision as you can see

I can blow you away or you can ride with me.'


Pictured: cowboy.

Ad-Rock agrees, and we learn why he came to be riding through the desert on horseback:

I'll ride with you if you can get me to the border

The Sheriff's after me for what I did to his daughter

I did it like this, I did it like that

I did it with a wiffleball bat

Ah, there's the sexual assault. Though we guess there could have been consent there? It's at least questionable that there's no "we" when describing the sex acts. Anyway, Ad-Rock tells MCA he knows of a club that serves champagne, which will satisfy MCA's need for something to drink and will get Ad-Rock across "the border" and out of the sheriff's jurisdiction.

We rode for six hours then we hit the spot

To you aspiring criminals, this is why horses do not make good getaway vehicles. To get out of a sheriff's jurisdiction in America, you only need to get out of the county -- an area just 20 or 30 miles wide at most. This trip takes them six hours. Then again, the sheriff is still not able to catch them. Maybe the deputies are all confined to wheelchairs?

They reach the bar, and once inside, they see a guy who apparently knows MCA. They sit next to him, and he immediately stands up, announces that he's robbing the place, and shoots two random customers:

The kid said, 'Get ready cause this ain't funny, my name's Mike D. and I'm about to get money.'

Pulled out the jammy, aimed it at the sky, he yelled, 'Stick 'em up!' and let two fly

Hands went up and people hit the floor, he wasted two kids that ran for the door


Yeah, that we can believe.

Then he does something that really makes us doubt that he or any member of this group has ever successfully committed a crime: He tells everyone in the bar his name.

'I'm Mike D. and I get respect

Your cash and your jewelry is what I expect'

Then we are introduced to the unsung hero of this story:

... I grabbed the piano player and I punched him in the face

The piano player's out, the music stopped

We're talking about the club's piano player. Apparently, the pianist is so dedicated that during the entire robbery, multiple gunshots, and two murders, he just kept on playing. The music didn't stop until Ad-Rock punched him in the face.

The 5 Most Implausible Old-School Rap Songs

"He's deaf and blind! This guy is Ray Charles squared."

At this point, the three gather up all of their loot, Ad-Rock abducts two women, and they leave (if you're keeping count, that's five people who had to pile onto the back of poor Paul Revere).

Presumably they chose to form a rap group shortly thereafter.

If you don't remember or weren't around, read more about Eazy-E and how N.W.A was one of the country's most iconic groups of their time.

If you loved this article and want more content like this, support our site with a visit to our Contribution Page. Or sign up for our Subscription Service for exclusive content, an ad-free experience, and more.

For more check out The 15 Most Baffling Boasts in the History of Rap and The 5 Worst Attempts to Start a Catchphrase in Rap History.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel and check out The One Skill Rappers Haven't Bragged About Yet, and watch other videos you won't see on the site!

Also follow us on Facebook. You won't regret it.

What the Hell Did I Just Read: A Novel of Cosmic Horror, the third book in David Wong's John Dies at the End series, is available now!

Scroll down for the next article
Forgot Password?