The 9 Most Offensive 9/11 References in Pop Culture
Sept. 11, 2001 scarred our national psyche. Even today, it provokes impassioned responses across the political spectrum. It's important to treat this sensitive subject with delicacy and restraint, and we promise to do so, just as soon as we get finished showing you all these people who most certainly did not.

This is an ad for a French newsmagazine. The tagline is "Learn to anticipate."
The visual seems to suggest that the easiest way to prevent 9/11 would have been to construct the WTC towers shorter. We shouldn't have increased airport security, or paid more attention to our foreign intelligence, or maybe not trained and funded Osama bin Laden in the late 1970s; it all could have been avoided if we'd just quit at the 80th story.
What possible defense is there for this? "We, the French, were simply unaware that the planes were piloted by terrorists! We thought your planes just could not fly high enough to overcome your mighty buildings!"

"This is why we build plane-holes into our towers."
This ad is clearly implying that, had the buildings been shorter, the terrorists would have simply continued their flights unabated, like they stole the planes in the first place only to fulfill their long-held dreams of attending flight school. We don't want to make fun of all French people here, because this is just an isolated incident by a really stupid company, and also because we actually have a lot of respect for their military prowess and innovative whoremongering.
But this ad demonstrates a very shaky grasp of aeronautics, engineering, tact and even the loosest definition of sanity. Or maybe it's simply suggesting that we should have had the foresight to build magical squishy buildings -- ones that could comically shrink to duck under missiles. You know, looking back now, it's easy to come up with a solution like that, France. Everything seems clearer in hindsight. But the world was a much simpler place back then; we didn't know how bad we needed the squishiness. We just ... we didn't know.

If only we'd invested more money in Gak development.

The WWF (the World Wildlife Fund, though we will never read that and not think of wrestling) likes to point out that the 2004 Asian tsunami killed 100 times as many people as 9/11 did. And apparently it likes to do so with all the tact and dignity of a professional wrestler whose entire gimmick was eating children. The WWF suggests that we should respect nature more, which we guess seems reasonable. But it concludes that, in this particular case, the best way to respect nature is by donating money to save panda bears from extinction -- despite the fact that nature has expressed in no uncertain terms that it wants pandas dead like yesterday.
And at no point does th WWF's panda-saving initiative connect the tsunami to 9/11, planes, cities or indeed, any single aspect of this ad. It's like somebody built a dartboard with all the major tragedies of the past couple centuries written on it, closed his eyes, threw the darts and then built a Photoshop image out of whatever terms he hit. We're just lucky we didn't end up with a poster of Princess Di's corpse starting the Great Chicago Fire while they canceled Arrested Development in the background.

"Ooh! Let's also have vampire-JFK nailing zombie-Di from behind. That'll save a shit-stack of pandas."
Obviously, the ad caused considerable controversy when it leaked. The WWF admitted it commissioned the ads, but insisted it would never have approved it to run, even though it was later discovered that the ad had actually been printed, once, in a small Sao Paulo paper so the advertising firm responsible for it could submit it to advertising competitions. That's right -- someone published this image not in a crass attempt to catch the eye of the average consumer ... but because he thought it was so damn good he wanted critical acclaim for it.
The only way they could have been more aggressively misguided is if they'd made a live action version and screened it at the most prestigious film festival in the world. Which they totally did, screening the following ad at the Cannes film festival.
"Sacre Bleu! There are not enough awards in existence, to give us all we should win for this!"

If you don't immediately register a pop-up 9/11 collector's coin as tasteless and insulting, then you're probably only skimming this article in an Internet Explorer window crowded by tabs featuring Juice Tigers, chemtrail conspiracy forums and half a dozen TMZ stories. But somehow, it actually gets worse: The whole thing is also a massive scam. The coin makers even received an official censure from the U.S. mint after it came out, because they were charging $30 for about 25 cents worth of metal, and they donated absolutely none of their profits to relief or reconstruction efforts. The advertisements also claim that the coin is legal tender, endorsed by the government, which is true ... in Liberia.

And what is more American than Liberia?

A Saskatchewan politician wanted to hold a fundraising pig roast. But not just any pig roast! This would be a classy affair, one you'd be proud to take your morbidly obese mother to on her Formal Rascal.

We're just kidding. Canada doesn't allow fat people -- the Mounties have orders to harpoon on sight.
The man had everything planned out: the food, the entertainment -- he'd even arranged for an actual 9/11 firefighter to speak at the dinner. Now, after going to all this work, he understandably wanted to advertise the event. It also seemed appropriate to somehow mention the presence of the heroic firefighter and the tragedy he'd survived. While separately, these both seem like reasonable enough desires, the way he combined them wound up raising a few eyebrows:

Please notice two things: One, that this is the second annual 9/11 pig roast, and two, that the words "pig roast" are tactfully placed just above the flames that would eventually kill several heroic firefighters ... and policemen.

Pokemon Black and White introduces a new game environment, a bustling metropolis based on New York City. That's not just us saying that: "[D]irector Junichi Masuda revealed that Unova (Isshu) was modeled after New York City; the games' Castelia City takes the place of Lower Manhattan and the Sky Arrow Bridge serves as a stand in for the Brooklyn Bridge."
Neat, huh? Let's take a look at the map! So there's the Brooklyn Bridge, and there's Central Park, and there's Manhattan, and right below is ...

Oh.
So, how does Pokemon choose to depict the sensitive, emotionally charged setting of Ground Zero, a literal scar on our greatest city, left by our nation's most profound contemporary tragedy?

This is still closer to a tasteful memorial than every Toby Keith song combined.
Obviously, they can't say the devastation was caused by terrorists. So they concocted a story about a falling meteor -- an object of unspeakable power that was quarantined by the government and is now being coveted by Team Plasma. Even weirder, another meteor dropped this Pokemon near the city.

Why do we bring him up? Take a look at his Wiki article. His official height is given as 9 feet 11 inches.
...
So, hey kids, gotta catch 'em all! Especially that new, super-rare Pokemon that is both the very embodiment of and directly responsible for 9/11.








the multiple inclusions of "a 9/11" cracked me up so hard. too soon?
ReplyI just want to point out that the commenters with the avatars with the hoodies and the dark sunglasses kinda look like the Unabomber. . . just an observation.
ReplyWow, alot of these are fucked up.
ReplyAnd whats up with everyone saying "x kills more and is more tragic"
well, im sure it is, but those tragedies werent because some nut jobs decided to ram planes into the towers which led to a major war which is claiming alot of lives regardless.
But yeah...really offensive, especially the french and the anti smokeing and wwf ones.
wtf?
That's one of my biggest pet peeves: the logical fallacy that because something else is worse, that makes the thing in question not bad. Yes, the tsunami and smoking kill more people than the events of 9/11, but that doesn't make the events of 9/11 not bad.
ReplyThe thing america did in response were worse. But of course that doesn't mean 9/11 wasn't bad.
the fact that anyone has defended the cancer one (even tacitly by saying "well cancer does kill more people and is still ongoing") is completely ridiculous. Cancer is tragic; smoking causes cancer; smoking is bad. BUT, people who die from smoking related cancer chose to smoke. The people who died in 9/11 made no choice to lead to their deaths. I, myself, smoke and if I don't quit, there's a good chance it'll kill me one day. And if I do, it will have been my own fault. My choice to start and my choice not to quit will have led to my death. Only an idiot would equate people making personal choices that are detrimental to their health and people enforcing death upon thousands. And only an idiot would respond to that comparison with the word "well,".
ReplySmoking doesn't cause cancer, cancer cells cause cancer.
And smoking causes cancer in cells.
I don't really understand how featuring the 9/11 incident as a tragic plot twist is offensive. That's a bit far-fetched. Usually I would expect sarcasm and humor associated with logical reasons of why something is or isn't, but it fell flat for me at that part.
ReplyYeah that didn't really hit me as offensive (Beyond having to watch that twilight guy) It seemed like a surprisingly well executed and empathic use of 9/11 as a plot device. a far cry from the other examples here
Is this...righteous indignation? From a Cracked article??
ReplyDayum I am surprised at how pissed off non-Americans are about the exposure level 9-11 gets. Honestly the only time I ever hear about it is the week surrounding its anniversary date or by some random happenstance like reading this article.
ReplyAddressing the issue of it being a small tragedy in comparison to other events: I agree that there have been much worse tragedies before and after 9-11, but man did 9-11 have an impact on me as an American. I was young, only 12 or so, but it really did change everything in a single day. I went from a care free 12 year old, to a 12 year old who was worrying about things like losing his mom who travels between major cities like NYC and Chicago each week to another attack, of having the country go to war and losing family members in the military, of having a group of people out there who hate us so much they have no problem literally killing themselves just to kill us.
Looking back I am surprised my 12 year old brain handled it as well as it did.
Kyuurem isn't even caught near that desert,he's way northeast of it. You hit the desert at level 20 or so, you can't get kyuurem until around level 60 or so. The writer didn't do his research on this very well
ReplyOK, let's see......F**k you France, F**ck you Pokemon (that one is just for being completely absurd in the first place, nvm 9/11 references, F**k you France again, a pat on the head and a diaper change for Canada, because they simply know not what they do, a public hanging for the Twilight dude, followed by a stuffing of his corpse with Lisy Corp's 9/11 candy and the ashes of its board of directors, at which time there would be the world's first internationally televised pinata party. Then F**k France again, just for the hell of it.
ReplyI love the b@llz of the coin hucksters' promotion of the fact that "these will never be circulated". Yeah, they will never be circulated (in the numismatic definition) because THEY AREN'T REAL COINS. Very clever how they turned fakery into a selling point.
ReplyI I gust cant believe how dis respectfull pepul can be! f**k all the makers of this suff!!!
ReplyI just can't believe how someone obviously not old enough to be alive on 9/11 (based on your horrible spelling and grammar) can be so obnoxious.
Errrr... No, Cancer is far more tragic than 9\11.
ReplyFuck! You!
Cancer does kill significantly more people then 9/11 did, and while 9/11 was most certainly a tragedy, you do have a point. the one thing about 9/11 is just the amount of people killed in a single bloody moment, being a stepping stone to war. While I might not be the best person to talk about 9/11 (I believe I was only 5 at the time), you certainly do have a point with cancer being more tragic then 9/11. Plus, cancer is still ongoing, and while the effects of what happened that terrible day are still felt, at best barely to the same degree as cancer.
Im guessing if it was the other way around and america launched a plane into another countries skyscrapers no one would give half a s**t but OH IM SORRY i forgot america is better than every other f*****g person who has suffered even worse tragedies
Reply Hide All See All 3 Repliesjust let it go, you wont get anywhere if you cling to this forever, you cant change the past, and dragging freaking POKEMON of all things into this for another reason to declare butthurt, jesus christ
kyurem has no connection to castelia whatsoever and lives on the otherside of the goddamned map. But seriously america needs to release its grip on 9/11 im sure the victims wouldnt want people shoving it down their throats year after year and then making money off of their suffering.
I'm not sure why they dragged pokemon into this either, I mean Kyurem lives in a magic cave in a magic forest surrounded by a cave near a beach and though I don't profess to be an expert on New York, I'm pretty sure the WTF was located anywhere near a forest cave beach place. Nine foot eleven? There are like 600 pokemon now of all sorts of heights, I don't think that was symbolic of anything especially considering half the legendaries' backstories are "fuck it, go with a meteor" and as for the desert thing that's hardly a new addition. I mean most of this was great because it was funny and true but that last bit just seemed lazy.
Rambling by a guy with a marshmallow for a brain. Do we bother counting the logical fallacies and flawed unstated premises? Nah, just roast him.
I hate to agree with such a hateful-sounding comment, but if I were related to or knew a victim of 9/11, I don't think I would appreciate being reminded of it every year any more than any of the things in this article. What's the point of making a day of it? Very few people think about the intended message on Columbus day, Veteren's day, etc, and this one will soon be the same.
Also, definitely agree with Lionhart on the Pokemon thing.
I am in awe of theese comments.
Reply"9-11 was a decade ago get over it" then in the same sentence "what about when america bombed japan? (70 f*****g years ago)" "the fact that it was a carefully planned and hateful religiously based attack during peace time makes no difference, its the same as a natural disaster"
I have run out of dislikes, the world does not contain enough dislikes for such a vast collection of callous loudmouth self righteous douchebags. I hope to christ i am just underestimating the amount of trolls.
Die and go to hell
I'm sure the victims of the atom bomb, the war in Iraq, and the Shoah appreciate everyone dragging their suffering into a "my tragedy is better than your tragedy" pissing contest.
ReplyI'm sure many people in the comments have already said it, but I'll say it again: The pokemon section is false.
ReplyI'm something of a pokemaniac, and I can testify that no in-game origin is given to the desert north of Castelia City (Based on NYC). It doesn't make much sense for a desert to be that close to a prosperous city and an ocean, but you shouldn't play a pokemon game looking for sense.
Team Plasma never search for a meteor in the entire game. Their primary goal is to [SPOILER ALERT] use the power of the legendary dragon with the same color as your game (Reshiram for white, Zekrom for black) to free all pokemon.
While it is true that Kyurem arrived from a meteor, he is as far away from Castelia as possible while still remaining in the region (He lives in the dot at the very top right corner). His height was probably determined in metric first, then converted to feet, because the Japanese use metric. Most sources list his height as 9'10''
There is little evidence that there is any reference to 9/11 in Pokemon Black or White. But the rest of the article was pretty good. Also, sorry for the walls of text.
I agree but I didn't want to say in the articles defense that bulbapedia does point out Kyurem's similiarity to a half crashed plane
Actually it is Reshiram for black and Zekrom for white
Foreigners are assholes...
ReplyOK slick, to me you are a foreigner.
Pokémon, Remember Me, The Anti-Smoking ads, and the pig roast I don't think were that offensive. Remember Me was suppost to drum up sympathy for the victims, and the attacks came out of nowhere in the movie, just like in real life. Pokémon's was meant to show that it was being rebuilt, due to construction materials, and the nation had started getting back on its feet, while it chose a desert to show the tragedy that took place there. (Due to deserts being seen as places of death, and despair.) Kyurem was also officially 9'10, and I don't think that the game makes any reference to a meteorite destroying route 4.The anti-smoking ads were showing that smoking is a tragedy in itself due to the amount of people it kills each year. Finally, the pig roast's flyer: how do you think they put pig roast above the flames on purpose to spite the police? I don't think that makes any sense.
Replybecause a less than flattering term for police officers is "Pig"
and no, trying to tie smoking into a terrorist attack is just fucked up, no matter who you are
I never got the pig roast thing but then I'm not American and so was never able to read into its supposed hidden meaning. So on the whole I could personally think it was just coincidence rather than intentional. It seems to have to take much under assumption for it to be plausible. They intentionally made it a pig roast in order to trample on policemen and not because that just happened to be the viand they preferred? They intentionally put pig roast over the flames to symbolize that hatred rather than it simply being a matter of placing the event in the heading where it would normally go and it simply coincided with the flames? Maybe they were even secretly in league with the terrorists and they planned it all along that the flames should be high up in the building so that this poster could be made in this specific manner? No mention of policemen because they hated police or simply because their guest speaker was a fireman and so mentioning all other manner of involved rescue personnel and authorities would have thus been unrelated?
As for the anti-smoking and WWF ads I kind of get what you're saying, RC. Yeah, at first it would seem somewhat ok since they are supposed to be giving a positive public awareness message. What is insensitive about it though is that it is using an unrelated tragedy, then seemingly trivializing it in order to draw attention to its own cause. It's like saying, "Oh yeah, sure your father may have died due to that drunk driver but it's nothing compared to how many that smoking kills." You don't just downplay a personal tragedy that way and use it as a stepping stone so that the feelings of survivors and relatives of those killed in the attack are likewise trivialized in order to glorify your cause.
I can see Bin Laden's face in those orange crayon scribbles.
Reply