6 Baffling Mistakes Every Movie Criminal Makes
According to the movies, those who choose a career in organized crime are genuine mental enigmas so puzzling they make John Nash look like Kevin Federline. These people have made a career out of evading law enforcement and bypassing high-level security systems, yet when it comes down to making some common sense decisions, they are utter morons.
If you are looking for a life of crime, here's a Hollywood guide on what not to do:

As Seen In:
Pulp Fiction, Thief, Heat, American Gangster, Goodfellas
In Hollywood productions, criminals do not mess around. If they're willing to steal, they're usually also willing to murder, torture, and blow up anything that can possibly be blown up (and probably some things that quite honestly can't be blown up). Most of civilized society, however, tends to frown upon such behavior, and as such it's really not prudent to discuss those plans in public. Doing so may lead to death at the hands of a wisecracking, world-weary cop.
So, when one is planning heists, murders, and mind-blowingly awesome explosions, it might be smart to do so in a secure, isolated location where other people are unlikely to be found.
Just a suggestion.
What you would not do is hold your conferences in, say, a diner, with a couple dozen potential eavesdroppers in the vicinity.
It isn't like they don't have a choice in the matter. Most movie criminals have access to everything from military grade machine guns and vault-cutting lasers to Joe freakin' Pesci. We're expected to believe that they can't find a private room somewhere to act as a hide-out? Why can't they just meet in the same old "Desolate Woods on the Outskirts of the City" where they are always dumping bodies? Surely the corpse of Billy Bats is unlikely to snitch on them.

This sort of thing happens so often that we're surprised anyone living in the Crime Thriller universe still eats out, for fear they'll get caught in a crossfire at some point.
Worst Offender:
We could have gone with Heat, where Robert Deniro nearly murders a man in the crowded parking lot of a diner (foiled only because the guy pretty much vanishes into thin air like David freaking Copperfield) or American Gangster, where Denzel Washington's character actually gets up, walks down the sidewalk, and blows a dude's head off before walking calmly back into the diner to finish his meal.

But no, the prize has to go to Pulp Fiction, where a couple of robbers discuss robbing while sitting a diner, before robbing the same diner. At which point the robbery is thwarted because a couple of hitmen happened to be a few tables over, openly discussing the business of being hitmen.

As Seen In:
Heat, Reservoir Dogs, Goodfellas, Casino, Panic Room
When accepting new members into their gang, Hollywood criminals definitely need to work on their screening process. Joining a "crew", as it turns out, is even easier than winning a Grammy. You don't really need to possess a single useful skill at all, because there's this role that always needs to be filled: that of the terrifying madman who no one in their right mind would ever associate with.
While most movie bank robbers and stick-up men will only kill when it's necessary to get the job done, it's the job of the sociopath to kill people, who like, "didn't need to die man", all the while giggling like a little kid at Build-A-Bear workshop.
The other characters in the movie get pretty angry about such things, but really, it's their own fault. Who on earth plans a perfect crime and then decides it'd be a good idea to bring along their insane friend? There's some serious stuff at stake here. Despite what you may have come to believe after hours of playing Grand Theft Auto, the consequences of a botched crime job are often quite a bit worse than waking up in a hospital with a little less money than you used to have.
Collective IQ=7
Worst Offender:
Goodfellas. In other crime films, the madman is usually used for one job. After making the mistake of inviting the crazy kid to the party once, the characters learn the lesson and the psychopath winds up dead (or everyone else does).

In this film, however, Joe Pesci's sociopath remains close friends with the main characters for decades, even though he uses every second of screen time to prove that he is the most violently impulsive human being on the planet. In real life, the mob would never ...
Wait, that was based on a true story?
Holy shit. Once again, it turns out real life is more retarded than fiction.

As Seen In:
Oceans 11, 12, 13. The Departed, Panic Room, Bonnie & Clyde
You know those girls on Myspace who have 23,138 friends? It doesn't matter to them that no human being needs that many friends, or that no person could maintain a reasonable level of sanity with that many people bugging them to hang out. The large number makes them feel popular and validated. Well, Hollywood thinks that criminals are pretty much the same.
Sure, they might not need a lot of people to pull off a job, but won't the innocent bystanders be impressed to see a dozen dudes strolling into the bank in ski masks?
"Shit, there's an old lady. I knew we shoulda brought four guys."
Wrong. Absolutely freaking wrong. First of all, let's think of the motive that drives these characters. Greed. For them, it is indeed all about the Benjamins, and the fact of the matter is, the more people involved in the crime, the smaller the shares, and therefore less cash for everyone.
Second of all, with so many people in on the plan, the odds of getting caught rise exponentially. Hell, how many people would you trust with a secret that could send you to jail?
Worst Offender:

The Oceans 11 series. This only gets worse as the series goes on, and they have to keep inflating the roster and the size of the heist. By the fifth or sixth movie they'll have enough guys to rob an armored car by just gathering around it and carrying it way.








Mentioned a few times before, but what the heck...
ReplyIn the book Donnie Brasco(written by Joe Pistone) it shows just how long it took him to get cozy with the mob, and also the close calls caused by him being the new guy.
On the other hand, his intelligence, education, training, experience and lack of the usual wiseguy self-destructive behavior certainly helped speed him along on his new "career".
On number 2, I'm surprised Usual Suspects wasn't cited. If you've seen it, you know what I mean!! If you haven't, WATCH IT!!! It is the most masterful tale of $#!T (once you hit the end) Then again, the sociopath one might also apply.
ReplyNumber Two has been around forever. White Heat is a good example: somehow G-Man Edmond O'Brien convinces psycho gangster James Cagney that he's a valuable member of the team *and* his best bud. Border Incident does this too with an INS agent joining an immigrant smuggling gang. Even in Serpico (though nominally a cop movie and based on a true story) it takes years for the crooked cops to figure out who's selling them out.
Replyand, in the departed, the reason why the police got much more successful was not attributed to dicaprio because matt damon's character had also infiltrated the police and was involved in the chase for nicholson; and nicholson had given damon the go ahead to let the cops get close, but not too close. in nicholson's view, the heat would have been somewhat expected; and the only time dicaprio really got close to exposing himself was the shootout, in which a member of nicholson's crew was fatally shot- after revealing to dicaprio that he caught dicaprio's mistake but didn't tell on him for a reason, he died; and is shortly after reported to be a snitch- so there was reason to believe that, even if the heat wasn't coming from matt damon dangling nicholson under their nose, the undercover in the crew was dead.
Replygoodfellas was based on a true story but pesci's character is not a real person. he was a composite of several people, namely two brothers henry was friends with, neither of whom was quite as scarily sociopathic as tommy. their mother was actually pretty pissed at how they were handled.
Replysame goes for donnie brasco- the relationship he has in the film with ruggerio was actually more like the relationship he had with sonny black. it was changed to hieghten the drama of the film- this comes from pistone himself in a few interviews after the film.
Well Donnie brasco was based on a true story with much of the plot and dialogue being almost verbatim. So I guess real life criminals are just as dumb as hollywood ones
ReplyI think the worst offender in #4 (too many criminals) is The Sting. I still don't know how,after renting buildings and buying equipment, they were going to split the take 73 ways and make any money. I know you could buy a 3 bedroom home for $1.50 back then, but still.
Replyi dont believe there was any time where 1.50 could get you a 3 bed home where we still used dollars and cents. In like 40s, itd still take about $700.
In offense #1 you mentioned the shootout in "Heat",and that the shootout would result in worse consequences then the actual bank robbery.
ReplyBank robbery is a federal crime punishable by 20 years,especially if you have a record like all these guys did.
Add in the "armed" part and the fact that there is no parole in the federal prison system,and your easily looking at spending the rest of your life in a federal PMITA prison.
Given the choice between surrendering after getting caught red handed in a crime like this and dying in prison, or fighting it out and possibly escaping,its really a no-brainier.
Whats more of a no-brainier is that risking your life and the lives of innocent people is a stupid idea over the fiat money in American banks.
Bank Robbery: 20 years
Shootout involving many casualties: over 9000
does this article have a MySpace reference? irrelevant. i will read no further.
ReplyDid you notice when this was written?
They missed one. How about the villian catching the good guy, then having a long conversation explaining in great detail every facet of his criminal enterprise before leaving the good guy in an elaborate and complicated situation that is designed to kill him...somehow. Of course, he escapes to set up the Final Encounter. So...why doesn't the villian just catch him and shoot him in the head? Immediately. Like right then. Game over. Of course, so is the movie.
ReplyIn Die Hard, Gruber's plan was to lure the FBI into it because their MO in dealing with terrorist threats was the key to opening the vault. If he had gotten away with it, the Feds would've discovered his terrorist front was a fake. Besides, it wasn't affiliated with any government in the first place.
ReplyThe reason to discuss your plans at an eatery, is because it's really difficult to successfully record a conversation with loads of ambient noise. Although of course the movies have to downplay that issue because they are in fact recording a conversation.
Replyim surprised that telling your kidnapped hero about your entire plan soon before they escaped isnt on there
ReplyBecause not all of them do it.
you can be a successful criminal AND think with your dick, its called RAPE ;)
ReplyThat's not being a criminal. That's being a scummy douchebag.
That's not being a criminal. That's being a scummy douchebag.
Alan Rickman's voice is sexy. That is all.
ReplyYeah, Dignum told him they were the only people who knew he was a cop. Also remember Billy was the one being approached. He never asked to join the club. Billy actually uses the tenure of the other guys against them, pointing out one day they'd like to take over. Then the part about him committing no crimes after prison time and the coke deals once released? Sorry, I'm not with any of that. Totally agree that Mr. Orange was allowed into the gang rather generously, and would be the much better example.
ReplyAgreeing with TheThird: billy costigan (dicaprio) was put in jail for over a year to build his cover story, and had his police academy records deleted in case the mobsters did background checks (which they did). add that to the fact that costigan's biological dad was part of costello's (nicholson) crew before he was killed on a job. tim roth in reservoir dogs is a better example (he convinces them he is not a cop with a memorized "amusing anecdote").
Replydismounting my high horse, i enjoyed the article
This article ha me laughing out loud. Well written.
ReplyIt bothers me that you said that in The Departed the cops became more efficient as soon as Costigan joined the gang. I seem to remember he spent years in the gang as a really low level member. I remember a scene that wasn't very far into the movie, in which Costigan says he's been "doing this for a year" and want to know when they're gonna pull the trigger on Costello.
ReplySecondly, the cops became less efficient once Costigan joined the gang. This is due mainly to the efforts of Sullivan, who started his career as a crooked cop pretty much the same day as Costigan gets recruited as an undercover, but still, Costello saw a lot of success while Costigan was a member of his gang.
Thirdly, Costigan and the undercover unit do a very good job of thwarting the disinformation that Costello threw their way.
Maybe I'm over-thinking this, but The Departed is one of my favorite movies, so I felt the need to defend it, ha ha. Great article, by the way.
I don't Believe that The Departed deserves to be on this list for the under cover cop thing. The cops made a very convincing show to prove that Leo was out of the police academy. Leo already had connections and ties to the mob through his father. The cops also freakin sent him to prison to drive home the point. You will notice that on his way out another prisoner asks him is he was related to someone else. So I think the movie did a terrific job in explaining this plot point. This isn't me trolling. I just really love the Departed and saw it was being done injustice here. Other than that, this list was great! I love this website!
Reply