5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars Forever

Imagine for a moment that George Lucas didn't sell the Star Wars franchise to Disney in 2012. Instead of The Force Awakens, Rogue One, and the avalanche of other Star Wars movies about to get crammed down our throats, what would the franchise look like? What would the Star Wars fan experience be like now?

Would you believe it'd be a lot worse? Probably, yes. That sounds extremely plausible. Let's examine how.

Advertisement

5
Star Wars: Detours Would Have Plumbed New Depths Of Self-Mockery

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasFilm Animation

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

There have been a lot of ridiculous parodies of Star Wars over the years, from Saturday Night Live sketches to Spaceballs to the time Donny and Marie fought disco-dancing stormtroopers with the power of song. But, with the possible exception of every home video re-release since 1997, George Lucas never tried to make fun of Star Wars himself.

But he was about to.

In 2012, months before the sale to Disney, Lucas announced a new Star Wars TV show called Star Wars: Detours. Not content with having some of the characters in Star Wars be ridiculous CG caricatures, Lucas enlisted Robot Chicken's Seth Green to distill his epic saga into a series of farcical cartoons. Think "stormtroopers complaining about the Death Star's lack of toilets" if you want an idea of the level of humor going on here.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasfilm Animation
Heh?

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

That still too highbrow for you? OK, here's Obi-Wan Kenobi using his Force powers to hit on women.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasfilm Animation
That leads right to the dark side, Obi Wan. Come on, you know this.

The show was meant to have a Seinfeld-like setup, with all the characters hanging out in Dex's Diner, which you might recall as the bizarrely inappropriate '50s-themed restaurant from Attack Of The Clones. Just think that through for a second. Every episode would simultaneously remind the audience of both a better show and possibly the single worst part of the Star Wars universe.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasfilm Animation

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasfilm Animation
"Are you still Sith master of your own domain?" -- a line which was fucking inevitable

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

But Detours was shelved after Disney bought the franchise, despite the fact that they'd already completed 39 episodes. Disney's reasoning was that they wanted new fans exposed to Star Wars through epic space battles of good vs evil, without diluting that experience with a show filled with ironic takes on their franchise's greatest heroes and villains.

Also, they may have been embarrassed by whatever the hell this is:

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverThe Walt Disney Company
None of this is canon at all.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

It's enough to make you wonder why diluting the franchise's value was no problem for Lucas. He was reportedly even pitching cannibalism jokes, and holy shit, we've been saying that about Star Wars for years.

4
Star Wars: Underworld Was Going To Be A Soap Opera About Mobsters

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasFilm

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Announced way back in 2005, Star Wars: Underworld was going to be a live-action series about organized crime set on Coruscant -- which, if you don't remember, is the most populous and urine-soaked of all the Star Wars planets.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasFilm
This was most decidedly not going to be a kid show.

It sounds incredibly ambitious -- something along the lines of The Sopranos, except with a bunch of rubber-masked gleep glorps in place of all the strong character actors. Lucas described the show as a film-noir-inspired "soap opera," and his producer called it The Empire Strikes Back "on steroids." And if that reads as "cliche-ridden," well, it seems they had actual writers on hand to smooth over that. Writers from 24, The Shield, and even Battlestar Galactica's Ronald D. Moore were all involved with the writing, in addition to Lucas himself.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasFilm
The finest writer of all time.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

The show would follow original characters from warring mob families, but more familiar characters would also have cameos, including fairly significant ones. One writer revealed that Palpatine himself was going to show up, but as a more "sympathetic figure" who was "wronged by this fucking heartless woman."

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasFilm
Giving him the same motivation as the protagonist of many country songs.

Despite the fact that the team churned out 50 hours' worth of scripts, the show was eventually put on hold. Why? Well, back when it was his call to make, Lucas told his writers not to worry about budgetary concerns, which inevitably led to the creation of 50 hours of scripts with massive budgetary concerns.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Now the scripts are in Disney's hands, and while they haven't made any announcements on the matter, it seems likely that, given the potential production costs and their other ongoing plans, the backdoor dealings of Coruscant will have to remain confined to your Star Wars Monopoly games for the time being.

3
A FarmVille-Like iPhone Game ... But, You Know, Star Wars

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasArts

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

The idea of a video game that makes you buy imaginary shit with real money sounds like the kind of cash-grabby brilliance George Lucas would have trademarked himself back in the '80s. But it wasn't him! And somehow, to this day, Star Wars still doesn't have a FarmVille knockoff in its roster of merchandise.

But it came close. At one point, LucasArts -- the game development branch of the empire which came packaged with Disney's purchase like those two-pack DVDs -- was developing Star Wars Outpost, a FarmVille-type game which would allow users to live out all their moisture farming fantasies.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasArts
Because that was the part of Luke Skywalker's life that we envied.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Leaked artwork also seemed to indicate you could play on Naboo, with the game presumably calculating land values based on your proximity to outdated racist stereotypes.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasArts
That canal goes through the center of the planet and adds +2 to Trade.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

And of course, the game would also allow you to annoy the fuck out of your social media friends with invites, challenges, and requests.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverLucasArts
And smug Jedi avatars.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

More interestingly, the game would allow players to either support the Empire or the Rebels, and even "betray one another for resources." But before the world could descend into a series of fistfights over stolen moisture vaporators, the game was cancelled. We can't blame Disney this time, though -- LucasArts killed it before the sale, showing an uncharacteristic reluctance to tax the goodwill, joy, and enthusiasm of fans. But it doesn't seem like the kind of thing Disney's likely to revive, if you were holding out hope for the opportunity to send them several dollars an hour, for some reason.

2
The Star Wars Comics Were Really Getting Their Act Together When Disney Cancelled Them

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverDark Horse Comics

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Star Wars has had a checkered relationship with comics ever since some guy at Marvel decided that what the franchise was really missing was a giant green bunny rabbit character.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverDark Horse Comics
And you thought you knew Star Wars.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

That's cherry-picking a bit, though. There have been many Star Wars comics with memorable high points as well. But those are no fun, so let's cherry-pick away. First, let's draw your attention to this the storyline which went way into the future to follow Luke Skywalker's drug-addicted descendant.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverDark Horse Comics
"Deathsticks." Edgy.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Or consider Star Wars Tales, which told non-canonical stories, such as the time Indiana Jones discovered Han Solo's rotting corpse.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverDark Horse Comics
Later, he'd become the biological father of both Jack Ryan and Dr. Richard Kimble.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Then there was the one in which Jar Jar Binks' dad shot himself in the head.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverDark Horse Comics
Can someone please do one non-horrifying things with the Gungans?

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

OK, that's enough low points. In 2013, Dark Horse, the publishers in charge of the Star Wars comic universe, decided to get back to basics with a series focusing on the original characters. Notably, it restored many of them to their original, most compelling characterizations. For example, Han Solo gets turned back into the cold-blooded badass we always wanted him to be. Even Chewie is horrified.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverDark Horse Comics
Unless that's an interrogative "Wharrr." Our Wookie is a little rusty.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

And Darth Vader, whom we last saw cinematically as a whiny 20-something, is back to his evil, heart-stabbing ways.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverDark Horse Comics

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Sadly, as soon as Disney obtained the rights, the series was cancelled and the Star Wars comics were handed back to Marvel. Yeah, the green bunny guys. They're back.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverMarvel Comics
They've already given Han Solo an extra wife.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

1
Up Until Disney Owned Star Wars, Disney Didn't Give A Shit About Ruining Star Wars

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverThe Walt Disney Company

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Probably the starkest illustration of how Disney's purchase will change the Star Wars universe is to look at how they were themselves handling Star Wars before. For example, you probably won't be surprised to learn that Disneyland will soon feature an entire Star Wars-themed section of the park, allowing visitors to enjoy the magic of flying the Millennium Falcon, visiting the Mos Eisley Cantina, or negotiating a trade dispute.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverThe Walt Disney Company
The lines will also stretch to a galaxy far far away.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

But this won't be the first time Star Wars has appeared in their parks. First there was the Star Tours ride, and sure, that wasn't bad. But the same can not be said for Hyperspace Hoopla. Part of the Star Wars Weekends at Disney's Hollywood Studios, Hyperspace Hoopla involved beloved Star Wars characters conducting dance-offs atop a stage built on the graves of all of our childhoods. How else do you explain both Darth Vader and Boba Fett doing Michael Jackson routines?

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverThe Walt Disney Company

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverThe Walt Disney Company
"That's no Moonwalk."

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Despite being an abomination the likes the world had never seen before, the event became insanely popular and soon moved from its first home atop a tiny platform to a stadium-sized arena. It also apparently got way more sexual, as evidenced by this clip featuring Slave Leia dancing provocatively with her scantily-clad mother:

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverThe Walt Disney Company

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

And here she is with -- sigh -- another goddamned Boba Fett.

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverThe Walt Disney Company

Man, this isn't a theme park attraction, it's erotic slash fiction. And speaking of Slash:

5 Horrible Ideas That Almost Killed Star Wars ForeverThe Walt Disney Company
"You're in the forest moon of Endor, baby! You're gonna die!"

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Yup, that's Chewie dressed as Axl Rose and an Ewok dressed as Slash, because our culture can do nothing but regurgitate itself now.

The point here is that once Disney actually owned these characters and had a vested interest in the purity of the franchise, they shut all of this shit down, because it was terrible and stupid. Meaning that when you go to the new Star Wars Land, you won't be able to see Finn and Poe doing the Macarena on the Millennium Falcon.

Also check out 6 Dark Details Of The Star Wars Universe (You Never Noticed) and 7 Insanely Bad Ideas Cut From 'Star Wars' At The Last Second.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel, and check out This One Fan Theory Changes All Of Star Wars Canon Forever and other videos you won't see on the site!

Follow us on Facebook, then go live long and prosper.

To turn on reply notifications, click here

330 Comments

Load Comments

More Articles

The Classic Sitcom That Looks Completely Insane In 2019

Let us pitch you a sitcom ...

317

5 Creepy Moments From History You Never Learned In School

History is full of horribly depressing moments.

83

5 World-Changing Geniuses (Who Got Robbed Of All The Credit)

Behind every great man is a great mind they ripped off.

71

7 New Movies That Sound Totally Bonkers (In A Good Way)

You'll wanna watch 'em!

65