6 Evil Corporations in Movies (With Terrible Business Plans)
The unethical, profit-hungry megacorporation is a pretty standard movie villain; they sacrifice morality for money, giving the hero something to fight against while also demonstrating the evils of capitalism in perhaps the most ham-handed way possible.
But when you think about it, despite all their supposed greed, they're pretty terrible at making money.

The Business Plan:
1. Capture the universe's most dangerous, uncontrollable creature.
2. ???
3. Profit.
What They Did Wrong:
Let's face it, alien xenomorphs are a terrible investment. They don't follow orders, you can't trap or control them and the only way they can breed is by killing every human in the vicinity. Nevertheless, where every sane person sees an unstoppable plague of violent death from beyond the moons, the megacorporation from the Alien series sees only profit.

Cha-ching!
How? Well, that's never quite clear.
As the story progresses over four films, it becomes embarrassingly apparent that Weyland-Yutani, supposedly some kind of space-exploration company, uses all of its mainstream operations as a front for their secret master plan to collect and domesticate aliens--a project that carries a 100 percent failure rate over the two hundred years they've been trying.

"Well gentlemen, the first two centuries didn't pan out but we have big plans for the third."
And although they never see any return on their investment, their methods only become more elaborate and costly. In Aliens, for instance, they waste mind-boggling amounts of money terraforming some shithole moon just because they caught wind that there might be aliens nearby.
You can just imagine the board of directors calculating their profit margin year after year, frowning at the annual 10-billion-dollar hemorrhage that occurs every time they lose a thousand employees and a secure facility to an alien massacre they provoked. And that's before the litigation begins.

Building better worlds by slowly killing off the human race.
Weyland-Yutani is clearly making money doing something, or else they couldn't afford to build all of those ships and complexes the aliens always wind up chasing people around in. Just stick with whatever that is. It's like finding out BP is secretly trying to weaponize sharks at the expense of one exploding oil rig per quarter.
Besides, what's the plan, to sell the aliens to the military as weapons? That's never going to pay off because as scary as they look, they don't make very good soldiers. Really, they're only good at killing unarmed people running scared through dimly lit corridors.

But should humanity ever go to war with milk-filled, effeminate androids,
the profits are going to come rolling in.

The Business Plan:
Sell android "replicants" for slave labor; when they burn out in four years, sell new ones.
What They Did Wrong:
While it may be ethically irresponsible, creating replicants with a four-year lifespan was a stroke of business genius. It's a textbook example of installing built-in obsolescence in a product so you're forced to keep buying. It's the foundation upon which a high-tech economy is built.
Unfortunately for the Tyrell Corporation, that's probably the only good idea they ever had. What's really baffling is why a company that designs robot workers for menial labor would waste millions of dollars making those robots so lifelike that nobody can tell them apart from regular human beings without an insanely sophisticated psychological exam.

These things are built to be soldiers, miners and sex slaves, so giving them anything beyond two arms and a set of genitals is like giving your washer and dryer a set of legs so you have to chase them around the house every time you want to do a load of laundry.

A bottle of Coke does taste better when you have to wrest it away from a resistant, sentient robot.
Indeed, the biggest problem in the Blade Runner universe is that the damn replicants keep escaping, forcing the LAPD to set aside an entire division dedicated to rounding them up all the time. Nobody is going to want a piece of equipment that not only is designed to fall apart after four years, but is also prone to escape the first chance it gets.
Here's an idea - make the replicants look like this:

Why even restrict yourself to the human form when you can design robots for the purpose they are intended? It makes sense for a soldierbot to have machine-gun arms, and people desperate enough to use a sexbot don't really care what it looks like as long as it doesn't insult their masculinity.

"Sh- she can't point and laugh, right?"
And, for the love of god, don't bother programming them to feel pain, oppression and resentment, otherwise your customers have no incentive to purchase your product instead of just rounding up illegal immigrants.
While we're on the subject of robots...

The Business Plan:
Transform dystopian Detroit into the utopian Delta City. The problem is that crime has run amok, so they contract with the city to run the police department and wipe out crime once and for all. With robots.

Peter Wellerobots, to be specific.
What They Did Wrong:
We completely understand that much of RoboCop is satire, mocking corporate greed an America's war on crime.

The rest was explosions.
But what is baffling is how the greedy, money-hungry corporation was so bad at making money.
Seriously, their grand plan was to buy Detroit. Then they were surprised to find there were complications? How long did they expect it to take to convert Detroit from an impoverished, crime-ridden hellhole into this futuristic engine of economic growth? Fifty years? A hundred? The stockholders were OK with that plan?

"Don't you see? We'll simply kill Red Forman. It's foolproof!"
But then, where normal companies solve all their problems using expensive, high-powered lawyers, with Omni you replace the word "lawyers" with "robots." Seriously, they build robots for reasons where building robots doesn't even make sense. Putting aside the obvious issue with their beta testing (which involves live ammunition in the executive boardroom)...

"Shouldn't we at least take the bullets out of it before the demonstration?"
"Screw that, sounds like work."
...let's look at the basic plan of throwing billions into a project to replace the police force with ridiculously huge and overpowered stop-motion robots.
Most cops--even ones in Detroit--will go their whole career without shooting anybody. It's a job that involves dealing with people: investigation, getting stories out of witnesses, getting cooperation from informants and gathering evidence to prosecute bad guys. Omni's first solution for this is a walking tank with four automatic cannons and two rocket launchers. All of that shit is too big to even fit in a car or drive to a crime scene.
We get it, Omni is evil. But ED 209 is not even an effective evil cop--its communication consists of three or four pre-recorded voice clips--it can't extort money from people or make veiled threats or do anything a greedy corporation needs it to do.
And really, even the RoboCop program is a failure. They wound up with one model that works, though all his time is spent trying to defeat all the giant malfunctioning death machines and ninjabots the company keeps releasing into the community without adequate testing.

Really, no amount of testing would ever make this abomination
"adequate" for anything other than being horrifying.
All other attempts are expensive failures. Rather than cancel the program (you'd think the lawsuits would be piling up nicely by that point), they decide to build a robot with a brain from a dead drug-addicted sociopath. Hey, here's an idea: Take the billions you spent on that and hire enough human police to position them every 10 feet throughout the city.
After all, this is a publicly traded company (they mention selling stock more than once). You'd think their wasteful cyborg division would be getting skewered by Jim Cramer on a daily basis.








OCP was meant to be a stab at IBM.
ReplyThey had a monopoly that was legally enforced. Robocop 2 had a good thing, a commercial that showed a ruined young businessmen. His mistake was choosing a cheaper "3rd party" office system. Well, he got locked out and blacklisted from all the other businesses, if their equipment didn't interface with him, they turned around afraid of OCP shutting them down. He shot himself. "OCP It's not a good choice; it's the ONLY choice!"
Likewise, they were "just throwing money at it" to pretend they cared. Problem was, there was one corporate guy who actually paid attention at business school and wanted to rise in ranks without sucking corporate d--- literally or non and going to a "Grove" and sacrificing babies to the devil for 30 years before getting a promotion. So he actually made a device that WORKED and shoved it under the big guy's nose above the head of his superior during a brief "less than expected expansion, the sheep investors need something to chew on" period marred by his boss's system F*cking up... His superior then had him killed...
In the next Robocop movie without the creator's drive, they had two future Robocops that instantly committed suicide 'coz all the scientists could do was imitate his work. At least the CEO was an old school guy... "8 MILLION dollars..."
So it was more of a largely true criticism of corporate America, how big organizations start to become like the worst example of Stalinist Russia due to too much one-way power and being too big for the head to feel the feet.
But, frankly, their business plan wasn't shitty. They had an entrenched monopoly and wasteful mistakes were subsidized or written off taxes. And this is RL. Only now when America is bankrupt is a president even daring to suggest ending "Tax breaks and subsidies" for companies shipping jobs overseas, and that would never have made a profit were it not for such corrupt laws and bought out government.
Weyland-Yutani is a lot like the Unitologists from Dead Space. Release plague is alien scourge on misc. human population, yell at anyone who tries to stop it, wonder why they end up dead by the end of the shenanigans.
ReplyNo, really. Why they thought it was a good idea to let a zombie alien menace loose on a human colony just baffles me. The worst bit is the end of the second game suggests MORE of the same. What the hell kind of beneficial research are they looking into? They sure as s**t don't tell you in the game.
Is it just me or does Weyland-Yutani's bussiness plan sounds like a trollscience process?
ReplyUmbrella didn't make zombies to make zombies, it was part of their "regeneration/look younger" stuff and it backfired very very badly. As far as Weyland-Yutani, it was military applications that they wanted the aliens for, and it was so they just send in a bunch of them to whatever city/country/planet you're at war with and let the aliens do the dirty work soldiers don't... I don't think this article was all that great with those two major points just completely missed.
ReplyI don't think those points were missed, really. The only military application the aliens could have would be to depopulate a planet and make it uninhabitable by any other species. Not a great idea if you want a planet's resources. Can't send in mining operations if all your miners are getting face-raped and chest-busted. Granted, the aliens would die eventually, but then you have a planet full of alien eggs that seem to be able to live indefinately and hatch the moment someone draws near. So, your foreman surveys the wrong place, gets face-raped, and you once again have a planet full of dead workmen. Not good planning.
As for Umbrella, the "look younger" thing was only mentioned in a preview for the first movie, and not mentioned in the movie itself. Besides, look at Umbrella's actions in the third and fourth movies. "Make zombies smarter," and "kidnap humans for Wesker to eat." The point stands: You can't profit from business plans where you kill your potential customers.
Wow, Rohan REALLY lacks an understanding of how BP works. One-time acident does not equal repeated self-sabotaging. Plus it's no mystery how they profit from their business. This is all regardless of how offensive you find their accident to be.
ReplyWow, ShyClown REALLY lacks an understanding of how not to be a massively stupid piece of shit.
Try reading that section again slowly this time and ask yourself if what you irritably responded to might not be what he's talking about.
I live in Detroit... It's much nicer than one would think...
ReplyI was looking at Detroit with GoogleEarth the other day. Whole residential neighbourhoods are now gravel lots with the odd house still standing. It looked like hiroshima.
Have you actually seen Blade Runner? Replicants are not androids or robots. They're clones. Less Terminator, more Universal Soldier. They're essentially an underclass and an ubermensch at the same time. This has an entirely different political dynamic than a humanoid robot.
ReplyWhy the thumbs down? ATZ is effing right.
They're androids, but made mostly from organic material - don't you remember the "I made your eyes" scene?
A military-run corporation would have practically unlimited funds to work with. Also, their ultimate goal would not be so much profit, as the complete enslavement of the human race. Or course, these kinds of principles exist in the real world (which makes an accurate portrayal of such ludicrously soulless actions satirical, as the writer points out). Still, the writer's premise attempts to undermine the virtue of truth in these works (Arnold movies notwithstanding, as those as usually crap), and so this becomes a less than mediocre article, serving to disinformation, rather than enlighten.
ReplyAhh, Umbrella! The reason why a Midwestern city and an African village was destroyed. The latter after creating a dummy company in the same field and finding out one of their creations wanted to go solo made their panties bunch up
ReplyThat's the game. The movie makes less sense.
"GayDominatrix69" is a contradiction in terms.
ReplyHow so? Is not a lesbian a gay person? Could not a lesbian be a dominatrix and enjoy 69? I think you're a contradiction in terms.
Umbrella and Weyland-Yutani seems to be based on "if you through out the reasons companies do things, there is no reason!"
ReplyYeah...just what the hell did Umbrella Corp do to make money? Destroying cities could be helpful as there's a chance you'd be contracted to assist in the rebuild. But if all the people are zombified, I'm pretty sure that won't give a rat's whether the museum is repaired or not.
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesThey make large amounts of pharmaceuticals (like viagra, mostly mentioning it in RE2 video game), some bat s**t crazy genius scientist decided to derive a virus from leeches and convinced the execs to do it for a tremendous new application in revitalizing dead cells/age defying cream (that reverses age). Since said scientist already brought them ridiculously good products, they said "yea, we'll fund your research, since your using your own mansion we don't have to pay for". He failed because he was insane but some execs with deep pockets who work with military applications said: "if we dropped this virus in the outskirts of an enemy town and keep them separated from any spreading (like plague ridden animals in the middle ages) we totally win without firing a shot". BAM!
Same thing with Weyland-Yutani. They are highly successful mega corp in many different areas. They wanted LV-426 as a new planet to sell land on (something they make big money on) so they send workers down. Suddenly they find Ripley who describes a super killing machine and they say "hey, if we take the super killing machine and 1. make it docile or 2. learn from its biological defense mechanisms to at least make super armor, acid, etc. we could OWN the weapons market". Hence why they keep trying to find the thing, in one book they actually domesticate the things and use them as soldiers, in others they derive pharmaceuticals and new armors from it.
I agree with everything but those two, if you read into it beyond a cursory glance on WY or Umbrella you'd get your answer. They both are a money grubbing corp that wants new tech based on biology, just one imploys batshit crazy scientists (another statement on what divides the ambitious scientist from crazies).
and it won't let me add page breaks...
@AlbinoRaven: that's all well and good for the Resi games, the article is talking about the films though (which make far less sense)
"How are you supposed to drum up good press, or even make the world aware of your company's existence, if literally nobody who uses your service remains aware of it?"
ReplyWeren't you JUST saying how possibly illegal it is? I'm pretty sure I wouldn't want to be worldwide if I was doing illegal things. And it doesn't matter if it's negative, if they're desperate enough to considerate, it doesn't matter if it's positive or negative.
I saw RoboCop 2 in theaters when it was originally released. Being eight years old at the time, even I was wondering what the f**k OCP was thinking when they decided to to put the brain of a psychotic, murderous drug kingpin into an even deadlier killing machine.
ReplyWhat they were thinking was FRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLERFRANKMILLER
buy n large?
ReplyIf this was from all media, I suspect Crey Biotech in City of Heroes tops them all. Business plan: Illegally clone dead heroes, illegally gene splice demons with said clones (and have no way to actually -contain- said demon, which trashes the lab), destroy shell companies that are discovered doing illegal things, pay MASSIVE legal fees for the horde of lawsuits, create giant octopus that hangs out by your shipping lanes and eating your employees, experiment on your own scientists; ???; Profit!
ReplyOCP definitely becomes more daft as the moves go on. (Along with everything else.) However, one of the big plot points was the internal politics. E.g. While some executives wanted efficient robotic law enforcement Dick Jones just wanted more power and money 'I had a guaranteed military sale with ED-209. Renovation program. Spare parts for the next decade. Who cares if it worked or not?' After the first film though things get more wasteful for no particularly good reasons.
ReplyThe movies might not make this clear, but zombies aren't the end goal of Umbrella's research. The end goals are cures for degenerative diseases for rich people ($$$$) and near-immortal for the military ($$$$). The zombie virus is an unfinished product.
Reply Hide All See All 5 RepliesAlso iirc, the zombie virus was sold as a form of biological warfare. Ie. you wouldnt give the virus to your own soldiers, you would drop it on an enemy base, or one of their major cities.
The majority of Umbrella's objective with the T-Virus (In both games and film) is a bigger, better biological weapon. The problem is that the number of successful products tends to be hampered with a disturbing number of outbreaks. Of course, admittedly, few of these outbreaks are actually the fault of the guys up top (Ex: Raccoon City technically only went to hell as fast as it did because one grunt screwed up and shot Birkin, Birkin injected himself, G-Birkin hunted HUNK's team down and destroyed most of the samples in the sewer, which rats then transferred throughout the city).
But yes, the zombies are more of an unfortunate accident that tends to happen when it's used in uncontrolled environments. The real goals of the projects were the Tyrants, Hunters, and other more successful BOWs. And then there's Wesker, whose goals seemed to vary from "Destroy and rebuild the world" to "For shits and giggles" depending on how sane he was at the time.
Thing is, they seem to suffer from the same problem as W-U in the Alien franchise. In both the movies and games they're a remarkably wealthy pharmaceuticals company. Highly renowned, facilities worldwide, plenty of successful products (and the profit that comes with them). It makes sense that some of this might have come from their research, but at some point you'd think that they'd stop pursuing the weapon aspect and just go with the freaking medical aspect. Sure, Spencer was a complete nutjob, but IIRC it wasn't a privately-owned corporation. One would expect a few of the higher ups to notice that "successful medical venture" was more profitable than "repeated accidents and failures in weapons development."
The T-Virus was meant as biological warfare? That still doesn't make much sense.
I mean, you're taking a bunch of normal people who don't want to hurt anyone, and turning them into highly-resilient monsters who want to kill and eat everyone they see. How is that a good idea?
You make soldiers out of those that don't want to be soldiers, or don't want to be your soldiers. They are some what easy to stop, but not in the beginning of an infestation, as the hysteria will only aid its spread
In the games at least, the endgame was the "Talos" BOW - which was pretty much a giant, remote-control zombie
did someone miss the part in Eternal Sunshine where Lacuna sends cards to friends telling them not to bring up what you've forgotten? clearly, them observing how little you remember and how happy you are can be a major selling point.
Replyalso, even if you're having your memory of the procedure wiped, that doesn't mean they're removing all memory that the company exists. I would imagine they can still send you a flyer or expose you to advertisements. even within the movie, the receptionist talks with someone that has had the procedure multiple times, and there was a deleted subplot where it's revealed that clem and joel have done this to each other repeatedly.
I didn't miss it, but maybe Lacuna erased their memories of it :P
In Blade Runner, why couldn't the Tyrell corporation just have implanted something that easily and quickly identifies the body its in as a replicant? Then, rifles to take down replicants could scan for that item. Sort of like how Westworld's guns couldn't fire at humans.
ReplyAnd, if we get real fancy, that item could itself be a tracking device or, perhaps, have the ability to kill the replicant upon demand.