5 Retarded Superstitions (With Logical Explanations)
Let's be honest, almost everybody is superstitious about something. Maybe just a "lucky shirt" you wear to job interviews, or maybe you spent all weekend making sure that voodoo doll of your ex looked just right before ramming pins into its crotch.
Where do superstitions come from? And could their origins be more logical than we think? Is it possible that the superstitious old neighbor of yours who runs off black cats and wails over broken mirrors isn't retarded?
Well... sort of.

Recently a whole stadium full of Cub fans held their breath when a cat raced onto the field during the game. They let out a sigh of relief when they realized it wasn't black (and articles the next day were sure to mention its color). After all, every Cub fan knows that a single visit by a black cat cursed the entire 1969 season.
Where the Hell Did This Come From?
So how did something oh-so-cute and fluffy get associated with misfortune, death and witchcraft?
Saints preserve us! It's a basket of Satan!
First of all, cats have always had a few habits that have a tendency freak people right out. They like to seek sources of warmth (sorry, Mister Fluffynuts doesn't like sitting in your lap just because he loves you) and have an odd fascination with examining human faces. Often when a person passed away from fever or a baby died mysteriously in the night, they'd find a cat perched on their chest or in the crib staring into their face, and the logical assumption was made that cats were harbingers of death that could suck the very life from your body.
I can has ur soul plz?
It didn't help that a number of pre-Christian peoples such as the Norse, Celts and Egyptians had cat gods, or at least considered the animal sacred. Once Christianity became the sexy new religion in town, old beliefs were branded witchcraft and cats found themselves guilty by association. Often simply owning a cat was considered proof of witchery. There was even widespread extermination of cats during medieval times, which kind of backfired when they were no longer around to kill plague-infested rats, which in turn wiped out half of Europe. Whoops. But hey, at least they were safe from those goddamn witches.
As for why black cats specifically were feared, well, you don't need us to tell you that black has traditionally been associated with eeeevil. There's a reason Darth Vader didn't spend his time strutting around in a sporty magenta or mint green get-up.


Every year on February 2, people put their faith in the amazing weather predicting abilities of the noble groundhog, hoping he won't see his shadow and doom them to six more weeks of snow, ice and numb testicles. A town in Pennsylvania has become world famous entirely based on this ridiculous ritual. But, hey, why not? Its predictions are probably as likely to be accurate as any weatherman's.
"Now as you see here, my weathercock is just balls deep in Indiana."
Where the Hell Did This Come From?
Folks have always kept their eye out for the reemergence of hibernating animals, logically seeing it as a sign that spring was on the way. February 2 is also the date for Candlemas, a holiday mostly celebrated in Europe--yes, there's another Christian holiday out there that starts with "C" and ends in "mas," please don't tell Hallmark.
Like most Christian holidays, Candlemas is basically an old Pagan tradition with fancy new Jesus decals slapped on. While the holiday is officially devoted to the purification of the Virgin Mary, in practice it's the due date to throw out your Christmas tree and start thinking about Spring while watching furry critters emerge from their holes.

Germans had Candlemas traditions similar to Groundhog Day--except they used hedgehogs--and when they immigrated to America they tossed out all the religious parts of Candlemas, keeping only the fun "waiting around a varmint-hole and drinking" stuff. The groundhog was chosen since it hibernated in the winter, sort of looked like a hedgehog--which aren't native to North America--and presumably because too many people got eaten when they tried it with bears.
But why does the groundhog seeing its shadow and returning to its burrow mean six more weeks of winter? Well there's actually some meteorological truth to it. A winter day sunny enough to allow a rodent to see his shadow is likely to be colder than average since cloud cover actually insulates the earth. In other words, there's nothing mystical going on here, Mr. Groundhog just went back inside because he was freezing his furry little ass off, and if it's still too cold for him there's probably more winter coming.
That, and there's a town in Pennsylvania that really, really needs the tourist dollars.

Break a mirror, get seven years bad luck. It may seem silly, but you probably still take extra care never to drop one, and generally do your best to avoid kung fu battles in the House of Mirrors.

Where the Hell Did This Come From?
Part of this goes back to the stone age, when the first caveman wandered to a lake for a drink and saw his own handsome sloping brow reflected back at him from the water. Having no knowledge of optics--at this point mankind's still struggling with pointed-stick technology--it was a logical leap for him to believe that this reflection was a duplication of himself and shared a part of his soul somehow (though he probably wondered why that lazy fucker in the water never helped out with the fishing).
This way of thinking stubbornly held for millennia, with the belief being that damaging a mirror--and thus your reflection--would damage a part of your soul or cause it to be trapped in the mirror forever, like the supervillain criminals from Superman II.
There's also a more simple explanation. Glass mirrors, as opposed to less breakable ones made of polished metal, weren't really available until the 16th century and were very expensive luxuries reserved for the upper classes. If the servants that cleaned these mirrors were to break one, well, let's just say it was a lot easier to replace a human being back then than a mirror.
Also, if a more middle-class family were to buy one and then break it, it would probably take quite a while to scrounge up the money for a new one--say, around seven years. So the warning to clumsy children wasn't so much about "bad luck" for seven years if they broke the mirror, but rather "continuous beatings."








my grandfather freaked out whenever a bird landed on the house, my mother said it was a warning of death in the household, one day a bird landed on my mom's windowsill when she was little and my grandpa freaked out, sure enough the next day his brother died, freaky s**t for sure
ReplyMy Native American (American Indian? Whatever the hell we're calling ourselves these days) father flat refused to let a cat in the house when my brother was a baby. He used the term "steal his soul" by sitting on him. That sounds stupid unless you think beyond it.
ReplyAnyone who's had a cat will tell you that if you lie down, that thing will be on your chest and in your face. A baby doesn't have the power to push the fuzzball away like an older human with motor skills. Finding a cat on an infant's body, positioned over the child's mouth, would be highly suspect. Adding creepiness to warnings almost always makes it more effective. "Keep the cat away from the kid; he could kill her" isn't quite as scary as "your baby will have lose her soul if the cat is around her while she sleeps."
So I'm gonna be "that guy"... those pictures aren't groundhogs. Those are prairie dogs. Groundhogs look more like little beavers. Come on, doesn't everyone who's ever seen Caddyshack know what a groundhog looks like?
ReplyI find a really uncanny amount of 4-leafed clovers.
ReplyOnce I found 48 in an hour.
But I'm really, and I mean REALLY unlucky.
If only superstitions were true then everyday is an adventure
ReplyDid anyone else notice this article contradicts itself a little? First Christianity made all pagan symbolism evil, then Christianity took all pagan symbolism and adopted it for itself. I think the second is more likely to be true, but they can't both be.
Reply Hide All See All 4 RepliesAs far as cats go, if they ever were exterminated, it probably had more to do with the fact that they too can carry disease or pests, and not with fear of witches. The medievals were not ignorant of their mice-catching abilities, but actually valued them for it, as is clear from the 9th century Irish poem "Pangur-Ban":
I and Pangur Ban my cat,
'Tis a like task we are at:
Hunting mice is his delight,
Hunting words I sit all night.
Of course they can both be true: the fancy Jesus decals purify the evil pagan symbolism. Duh.
Seriously, though, no one said medieval folk were ignorant of cats' mice and rat catching abilities. What they didn't initially know was that mice and rats were connected to the plague. The medieval times were not a culturally monolithic block. Attitudes shift, though Ireland and Britian are generally considerably more cat-friendly than the rest of Europe,
It doesn't really change the attitudes in other places and other times, though. The association of cats and witchcraft is pretty deep. A little Irish poem praising the cat doesn't really compete with the Pope associating cats with devil worship (see "Vox in Rama") a few centuries later. That's what really got the cat=evil ball rolling, and it has rolled pretty far.
They can't really both be true. Not when you say "all" pagan symbols were declared evil, and then say "all" were adopted later. And as Vox In Rama, which you mentioned, suggests, the symbols which came to be seen as evil were not because of pre-Christian use, but because of alleged occult use in already Christian times. And this article did make it sound as if extermination of cats were pretty much universal.
Many Pagan traditions were incorporated into Christianity, in Europe, to make the transition easier. Festival dates, in particular, were continued. People still wanted festivals and liked how they were spread around the year, based on planting, harvesting, season changes, or pretty much any lull before or after a bunch of hard work. Walpurgisnacht and Samhain were sort of mashed together and flipped around to create May Day and Halloween. Yes, Halloween is a Catholic invention.
Direct symbols and objects of Pagan worship were demonized. Aside from whatever loophole Catholics devised to worship Mary and saints, Christianity does not allow worshiping any deity outside The Holy Trinity. All other possible sources of supernatural power must, therefore be considered demonic.
I enjoy pedantic literalism as much anyone. This is a humor site, prone to hyperbole and silliness, not a college textbook. If you can't separate the facts from the jokes, or at least realize that they're mixed together, maybe you should look for a different source of information. You could let this be a springboard to go learn about what really happens when one religion supplants another or just this particular occurrence, but I get the impression that that's not where your interest truly lies.
On the other hand... medieval people had an amazing way of using double-think. They believed that animals were animals and could not think for themselves (which is why they used animals for work and saw them as property), but at the same time, they also put animals on trail for crimes. So... you can't really draw conclusions that medieval people didn't kill cats for fear of witchcraft because they respected cats for catching mice, because medieval people could somehow do both.
Every cat I've ever owned has been black, and will continue to be. They are the least adopted from shelters because of the stupidass superstition nonsense. Stupid damn stupid people. Gah!
ReplyCreepy, a lot of keywords up there insinuate that something is forcing you to keep adopting black cats other than superstition...
Witch! Witch I say! Let her be cast from the rock of Godliness and suffer to burn amongst the kittens of motley colour!
What if you owned a black cat who ate a four leaf clover and savaged a rabbit for its foot then broke a mirror?
ReplyI believed, when I went to read the article, that they'd have one of the 5 retarded superstitions be the bad luck if you walk under a ladder thing. Still loved the article.
Only one outcome is possible in the scenario you devised:
Death by Snoo-Snoo
I heard that if you find a white hair on a black cat it is considered lucky. Also the mirror thing is reflected(heh) in vampire movies, with them being souless and all. As for clovers, I found a six leaf one once. I have a five leaf and several four leaves in my wallet, for extra luck points and some bragging rights.
ReplyAnother strike against kitties which I'm sure didn't help their case is Pregnant women can seriously compromise their pregnancy if they're not careful around stray cats or cat poop. It's a nasty parasite called Toxoplasma gondii which causes Toxoplasmosis. It can cause problems with pregnancy, including abortion. Throw in Bartonellosis AKA "Cat Scratch Fever" (which to be honest is really only dangerous to late stage AIDS patients with lowered immune systems) and cats have a horrible rap among children. Of course with modern medical knowledge it's not much of a big deal, and kitties can haz gud famlies.
ReplyDAMN - I can't believe all the cat superstitious bullshit in the comments... My faith in humanity has dropped yet another notch :(.
ReplyI thought it was because cats are jerks.
Replythere's that too.
Some of the scary superstitions listed such as the black cat and broken mirror want to make me test them out and prove 'em wrong.
ReplyThe rabbit's foot topic did make me laugh a bit. "Fertility was everything..." Lol.
Good article.
The last sentence basically summed up the defining factor behind everything in this article.
ReplyEspecially the misspelled word.
"Druids, basically the hippies of the day..."
Reply Hide All See All 4 RepliesYeah, if hippies were fond of human sacrifice, and their education consisted of composition while balancing a tombstone on their chest, floating in frigid water...
Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the article
If there's no written records, how do you know Druids ever *actually did that*? Seriously, modern-day Druids had to nearly reinvent the whole thing because of the lack of written records. (And no, Christian records don't count, they had a vested interest in lying.)
But we do know they didn't eat potatoes ... so there's that
I'm a hippy fond of human sacrifice. Can I tie a tombstone around your neck and throw you in the water?
Is the reflection/soul thing the reason why vampire lore says they don't appear in mirrors?
Replypretty much. vampires don't have souls, ergo they don't have reflections. i'm convinced i'm a soulless vampire because i can never get automatic soap dispensers, faucets and towel dispensers to work. that has to be why.
But Angel from Buffy the Vampire Slayer can't see himself in a mirror, and he has a soul!
These... are not really what I'd consider "logical."
ReplyΙ τηινκ τηε τερμ 'λογιψαλ ςασ ρεφερρινγ το πεοπλε ςηεν Γοογλε διδν'τ εχιστ.
I think the term 'logical' refers to people back before Google was invented.*
I think in reality SOME people who own cats are a creepy, creepy bunch who do nothing but talk about their little "fluffkins or "cuddlewuddleface." In the dark ages, instead of having the internet where they can post cute pictures of their little darlings doing adorable things and generally leaving real people to go about their day, these primitive people just talked to other people about their cats.
ReplySo the rest of the people decided they needed to get rid of the cats, to save others the needless suffering of hearing yet another brilliant story of Mr. Shitsinthehouse's playful antics with the family rock and grandpa's corpse.
So, easiest way was to kill the cat. How do you kill the cat without pissing the owner off? Easy, kill the owner because f**k Him, I've heard that kitten story one too many times.
You gave yourself a thumbs up then made two other accounts to give that comment two more thumbs up.
Okay, my family has had cats and babies co-existing in the same house. Did they have magical powers to keep the cats away from the babies?! Seriously people. Common sense rules when you have it. Close the frickin' door. Not rocket surgery here. Many many people have had cats and babies in the same house without the cats killing the babies. It's ridiculous to see all these comments where it says "My mom told me cats kill babies for the milk on their breath." First of all, it's not healthy for a baby to have milk in their mouths when they go to sleep anyway, it can ruin the teeth they will have and their gums.
ReplyGood article, nicely written. Good job Nathan!
Reply