5 Ways Your Brain Is Messing With Your Head

By Brian Walton Mar 02, 2009 1,141,160 views
article image

We accept on a regular basis the premise that our minds are being screwed with. Advertisers, politicians, magicians; we accept that they know the tricks to pull the wool over our eyes. But as it turns out, the ways in which your head is being truly and royally messed with the most, are coming from inside.

Please be advised that your brain does not want you reading the following list, and may kill you to protect its secrets. These include...

#5.
Change Blindness

What is it?

It's your inability to notice changes that happen right in front of you, even if they're hugely obvious... as long as you don't see the actual change take place.

Um, What?

Consider Alfonso Ribeiro.

Now, if suddenly that image of Carlton blinked and changed to a different image, you'd notice it. The change would draw your eye. But if you got up and left your computer, then came back and found the image had changed, odds are you almost certainly would not notice, even if you were only gone for seconds. Science has proven it.

In fact, if the entire text of this article--and the whole color and layout of this website--changed while you were gone, you probably wouldn't notice. We could switch it to a wallpaper of dicks. You might not believe it but, as you're about to see below, the experiments they've done on this get truly bizarre.

A scientist named George McConkie started working on this in the 70s. He'd introduce changes in words and text right on the page that someone was reading. By tracking the movement of their eyes, he was able to change the text right in front of their damned faces without people noticing.

Why Does the Brain Lie About it?

Change blindness is usually related to something called inattention blindness. If you tried to process everything in your visual spectrum you would go insane, so your mind picks and chooses what to focus on. If Carlton grows a mustache while your brain isn't paying attention, when you look back at Carlton, your brain tells you he's had the 'stache all along.

It's like your brain is sitting in class, staring out the window at a cloud that sort of looks like a boob. When you call on your brain it does the same thing you do when a teacher calls on you in those circumstances: Start bullshitting. It doesn't really know what Carlton looked like a second ago, but it's not going to tell you that. Since it has no visual memory of the image, it just tells you it's always looked the same. Even when that's a lie.

Where it Really Gets Weird...

What's truly amazing is just how often your brain isn't paying attention. Scientists decided to take the idea to a ridiculous extreme. They ran experiments where they'd have a guy manning the counter at an office serving students, while another guy was hidden below the counter. A student would walk up and request a form, and the guy would say sure and duck down behind the counter to get it.

But then second guy, the one who had been hiding, would pop up and say, "ah, here it is." This second guy would look completely different, and would be wearing completely different colored clothing, and most of the students would not freaking notice it was a different guy than the one they had been talking to five seconds ago.

Here is a video of such an experiment. Far creepier is the bit magician Derren Brown does where he'll approach a stranger on the street, ask for directions, and in mid-sentence have somebody walk past carrying a large object. While the object is disrupting the view for half a second, he'll swap out another guy who looks and sounds nothing like him--and the stranger will carry on the conversation with the second man as if nothing had happened.

This is probably what made the producers of Bewitched think they could just switch out Darrins on us.

#4.
Saccadic Masking

What is it?

It's the 40 or so minutes per day that you're effectively blind.

Um, What?

Quick, look at the wall to your left. When you flicked your eyes over there, for just a moment, you were blind. And you didn't even know it.

Why Does the Brain Lie About it?

Ever watch a movie that gave you motion sickness, due to the camera whipping around too fast? This is what has some people puking during movies that use the "shaky handheld camera" gimmick (see: Cloverfield and The Blair Witch Project). Your brain doesn't like those rapid, blurry changes in vision.


This is either Cloverfield or a picture of John Candy with a Motion Blur filter.

But eye movements are even faster than those shaky camcorders. Flick your eyes over to the wall again. Notice you didn't get that nauseating, blurred image of the room zooming past your eye? That's because of saccadic masking.

In order to bring you this completely awe-inspiring view of what we're guessing is your cubicle wall right now, your brain rapidly moves your eyes without asking, in the neighborhood of three to five times per second. That's in addition to the times you move your eyes consciously, to look at the clock or the wall just now. To prevent your world from looking like the jerky Cloverfield camcorder all day, your brain shuts down your optic nerve while your eye is in motion.

Where it Really Gets Weird...

The spooky part is the way your brain prevents you from noticing the blackness that occurs several times a second, every moment you use your eyes. Estimates vary somewhat, but it's likely that you're spending somewhere around 40 minutes a day with your eyes wide open, and totally blind.


Your brain.

Look at the wall one more time. If you make an effort, you can sometimes see a "flash" of darkness during a particularly long eye movement, one of those periods of blindness your brain insists isn't happening. But for the most part, your brain suppresses these flickers.

And here's where saccadic masking and change blindness team up to have rough sex with your mind. Remember, the first scientist to experiment with change blindness was making changes to the page while people were looking directly at it. He was able to do it by introducing the changes during saccadic movement. If a change occurs during that fraction of a second when the brain is dodging calls like the optic nerve was an ex-girlfriend, you tend not to notice it. Even when it happens right in front of your damned eyes.

#3.
Proprioception

What is it?

It's your brain's map of your body, and it screws up on a regular basis.

Um, What?

Your sense of proprioception is your brain's ability to sense where your limbs are. Nothing strange about that, right? This is how you can put a sandwich in your mouth while your eyes are focused on the TV. Your brain knows where your hand is in relation to your face, thanks to proprioception.

Why Does the Brain Lie About it?

It may not be lying necessarily, just easily confused. You know this if you've ever taken a field sobriety test.

Your proprioception is like your underwear: it's pretty much the first thing to disappear when you're any kind of fucked up. Basically, the cops doing the roadside test are trying to see if your brain knows where your fingers are in relation to your nose.

Even though your brain carries around a detailed awareness of exactly where your body parts are at all times, when it's handed a contradictory stimulus, essentially it says, "Oh, well. Guess I've been wrong about the length of your nose all these years."

It's either that or your brain is a sadistic son-of-a-bitch that likes playing tricks on you.

Where it Really Gets Weird...

The best example we've found so far is "the Pinocchio illusion." Scientists have found they can have the subject touch the tip of their nose with their finger, and have their bicep or triceps electrically stimulated at the same time. Your brain "feels" your arm muscle extending, but also feels that you're maintaining contact with the tip of your nose, and leaps to the immediate, yet fully sober, conclusion that your nose has suddenly grown to be about three feet long.


Science.

Incidentally, we know exactly which illusion you're about to try to induce, figuring all it'll take is a girl, a dark room and the right equipment. Don't do it. It will lead to eventual disappointment.

Show Profanity  
219 Comments


"Incidentally, we know exactly which illusion you're about to try to induce, figuring all it'll take is a girl, a dark room and the right equipment. Don't do it. It will lead to eventual disappointment."

Im doing it. Disappointment be damned.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 8/30/2010 8:28 PM
arrdvark3

That last bit about about the brain deciding what to do seconds before you consciously decide and that someone would be able to tell what you decide by looking at the electrical signals is completely wrong. Read the book. Mind Time by Benjamin Libet. What really happens is that your brain prepares for an action about half a second before you decide to act and that the conscious decision occurs about a seventh of a second before the action is started. Which does suggest that you DO have free will. Also no one has ever been able to connect the electrical signals in your brain to specific thoughts. All they can see is that a part of your brain 'lights up' and that you are thinking about something related to the function of that part of the brain. Get your facts straight before you go publishing something as profound as "there is no free will".

2 Replies | Hide Replies | Reply | Posted on 7/18/2010 11:47 PM
Jan-Hendrik

actually, they don't say anything about them directing your actions, they said they could predict with 100% accuracy what your action would be before you do it. I'm not sure what free will has to do with it, but i suppose it could be like the guys from Dinner for Schmucks, and you could make them believe they have control over your every action. Which if someone can tell you what you'll be doing before you do it, it may be possible for them to convince you that you're doing what you're doing because they willed it and you therefore don't truly have freewill. It's not that you don't have freewill but that you believe you don't have freewill and fall into following the orders of those that know what you're going to do. Sorry if the way i said that is kinda confusing.

Posted on 7/28/2010 4:04 AM
hades252

Also, we can determine now some extremely basic thoughts by watching the electrical signals. They've recently descovered that they can communicate with some people in comas (or "locked-in syndrome") but asking simple questions, and getting them to imagine one thing if the answer is 'yes' and another if the answer is 'no'. They can also pick up on things like the thought/concept "hammer" (as in the tool).

Also, the article didn't say "there is no free will". It simply pointed out that when you consider the implications that these studies raise with regards to free will (and from a philosophical viewpoint at least, yes it does raise questions).

So, how about you get your own facts in order before you complain about someone else, huh?

Posted on 8/31/2010 6:16 AM
Queen_Undine

The ad right beneath was the funniest part. "What's Your Brain Power?"

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 6/1/2010 2:05 PM
BNBazel

I'm pretty sure I notice #4. Occasionally.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 5/30/2010 11:56 AM
ragmaan

wow did anyone noticed that they change the tie on the carlton image?

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 5/2/2010 7:34 PM
i-am-awesome

I need to go kill my brain for ruining my free will now, thanks.

1 Replies | Hide Replies | Reply | Posted on 4/10/2010 11:49 PM
JacksBot

The site lied to you. They have their acts wrong

Posted on 7/18/2010 11:48 PM
Jan-Hendrik

I'm kinda unaffected with #5, as I grew up spotting everything that was s**tty in games.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 4/2/2010 5:55 PM
Dhatz

Oh, maybe he just exhibited cryptomnesia?

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 1/20/2010 7:23 PM
BGH122

Wow, Derren Brown has been taking credit for that 'trick' in #5? I knew he was a hack, but he's also a plagiarist?

He's literally just copied the procedure to the Simons et al (1998) perception experiment in which students on a campus were asked directions and then a door came along and the person asking the directions changed. Half the students failed to notice (or, more correctly, react as if they'd noticed) even when the new questioner was of a different height, build and vocal depth. Derren Brown is such a failmeister.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 1/20/2010 7:12 PM
BGH122

I doubt it. It probably happened to someone else and you only think it happened to you because of cryptomnesia.

1 Replies | Hide Replies | Reply | Posted on 11/29/2009 7:11 PM
Exeres

But that would mean that Deemon_Cat did experience. cryptomnesia

Posted on 8/8/2010 9:24 AM
BNBazel

Cryptomnesia. It's happened to me.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 11/24/2009 4:04 PM
Deemon_Cat

There's a really great book containing real life stories about ways the brain can fuck with you. It's actual case studies of crazy-terrifying neurological conditions. Has a good case of this poor woman's proprioception COMPLETELY crapping out on her. FOREVER. They called her "The Disembodied Lady." The name of the book is "The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat." I highly recommend it.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 11/11/2009 7:23 PM
LizzyStardust

There's a really great book containing real life stories about ways the brain can fuck with you. It's actual case studies of crazy-terrifying neurological conditions. Has a good case of this poor woman's proprioception COMPLETELY crapping out on her. FOREVER. They called her "The Disembodied Lady." The name of the book is "The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat." I highly recommend it.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 11/11/2009 7:22 PM
LizzyStardust

You said they can tell with 100% accuracy. It says right in the article you cite that they could only predict it 70% of the time. That makes me sad.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 8/24/2009 6:49 PM
d_senti

Damn you, brain! All you do is fucking lie!
(Pulls brain out of ear.)
Now who's thekalfs fs,l;f;lsd,fsgddddddddddd.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 8/16/2009 12:18 AM
presidentjlh

I've never suffered from cryptomnesia. I just don't have any qualms about taking other people's ideas and claiming them as my own. :)

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 6/7/2009 7:53 PM
loqutor

I've had Cryptomnesia once myself. I went to hook up a car battery to my balls thinking no one has done this before so it was gonna be new and awesome, but it turns out its been done before. I wish I'd found that out first. (ow)

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 6/7/2009 9:19 AM
benrichardsrm

"That's right: If somebody had electrodes hooked to your brain, they could tell you--with 100% accuracy--what decision you'll make a few seconds from now."
You said that they could detect THAT you were making a decision, not what kind of decision you were making. You're brain is making you lie to us dude.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 5/31/2009 5:45 AM
korilian

I have actually had Cryptomnesia happen. I had this brilliant idea for a comic, then I noticed everything part of the story could be compared to a movie or book I read in the last decade, this came as kinda a shock, I thought I was subconsciously stealing people's work... Glad that's cleared up

1 Replies | Hide Replies | Reply | Posted on 5/18/2009 3:40 AM
1r3gr37n0n

well the problem is, a lot of movies and books are all the same few stories, with only details changed. one good example is "the hero's journey" which is the basic plot in star wars, lord of the rings, harry potter, and many many other books/movies.

Posted on 5/28/2010 1:06 PM
ChipChap

Guitar Hero is a bit of a test in proprioception. At least I seem to have a hard time with it during those alternating blue-yellow, or orange-yellow, or the cascading spectrums all at once. Just try playing GH2's Carry on my Wayward Sun on Hard and you'll see what I mean, and that's not even that hard.

0 Replies | Reply | Posted on 5/2/2009 5:35 AM
l3ailin
Cracked stuff on