Register

The 5 Most Ridiculously Over-Hyped Health Scares of All Time

By Adam Brown March 27, 2008 1,587,527 views
article image
#2.
Asbestos in New York City Public Schools

Few environmental hazards strike more fear in our terrified little hearts than asbestos. Tell someone they have asbestos in their house and you might as well tell them they have a chainsaw wielding serial killer in their house. Actually, given the exorbitant costs involved with removing asbestos from a house, most people would prefer the serial killer.

So when it was revealed in 1993 that an independent contractor hired by the New York City Board of Education to inspect schools for asbestos had failed to perform the inspections properly, nobody was surprised by Mayor David Dinkins decision to not allow kids to return to classes until proper inspections could be performed. Granted, the decision kept over one million kids out of school for two weeks, threw the plans of their working families into chaos, and panicked the shit out of countless parents who thought they had been sending their kids off to get cancer on a daily basis, but it had to be done to keep the kids safe, right?

So what's the problem? For starters, the type of asbestos that was typically found in schools, including those in New York City, was not the monster-under-the-bed type that tends to kill people. No, when you absolutely, positively must kill every motherfucker in the room, crocidolite or amosite is what you need. Chrysotile asbestos, the kind present in the NYC schools, on the other hand, is easily expelled from the lungs and therefore far less dangerous.

The risk of death was in the range of .009 deaths per million. And while you may say that any risk is too much, dammit, you should keep in mind that a child is a thousand times more likely to die playing high school football.

Also, in other schools, botched asbestos removal jobs had actually left the buildings with higher levels of asbestos in the air than if they'd done nothing. But why let that get in the way of a good panic?

In 1993, asbestos in New York schools killed Fewer People Than ...

... were killed in hot air balloon crashes.

Some countries still use DDT. THAT'S how they know mosquitos build up immunity to it. That's also how they're able to test for the dozens and dozens of other fucked up problems it's use causes. I swear some of you believe it's some f*****g miracle product. It's a fucked up chemical that does a lot of damage. So what if it saves people from Malaria? It kills them in other ways. And yes it does kill a lot of animals and causes severe environmental damage as well. Plus it's not like they don't have other chemicals that are JUST as effective and don't have all the band side effects.

10/15/2009 7:05:51 PM
balonius

"Who gives a f**k about the damn birds?"

I DO!!!! They're in my username, dagnabit!

Put otherwise, it was a good article.

10/14/2009 10:39:52 AM
otusasio451

There's the SL-1 reactor in Idaho, 1961. All 3 of the crew died there. (One of which had a control rod shoved through him.) It's biggest asset is probably why it's so unknown: it's remote location.

9/21/2009 6:24:01 PM
Panzerschreck

3 mile island didn't cause any deaths but if the fuel had melted though the containment vessel and into the ground it would have eventually reached the water table and caused a steam explosion. And that would have caused a radioactive cloud and massive contamination.

Evacuating people was not an overreaction. All that may not have happened, but it could have.

9/12/2009 4:01:53 PM
AtomicSkull

"Because it was kind of effective in fighting malaria. When spraying of DDT stopped in Ceylon (present day Sri Lanka), malaria cases rose from 17 in 1963 to 2.5 goddamn million in 1969, an increase of approximately a bajillion fofillion percent. And to this day, the mosquito remains the deadliest killer Mother Nature has to offer, with a confirmed 2 million kills per year."

Ok tree huggers, what exactly about this statement is a lie? How do we know mosquitos here are unaffected by DDT? They stopped using it! TWO million is not a small number of HUMANS... And I doubt they have Bald eagles in Sri Lanka and if they did, aren't human lives more important? I wish all tree huggers would go live in Sri Lanka armed with nothing more than a net.

9/3/2009 7:05:18 AM
commonsense

TMI ACCIDENT WAS INTENTIONALY CAUSED BY AN EX-US NAVY NUKE SUB OPERATOR WHO DIDN'T EVEN HAVE A COLLEGE DEGREE...HE SAW THE CHINA SYNDROME MOVIE AND WAS TRYING TO RE-CREATE IT BY REMOVING ALL THE WATER FROM THE CORE...WANTED TO SEE IT MELT DOWN INTO THE EARTH....AND IT DID...JUST DIDN'T MAKE IT THROUGH THE FLOOR COMPLETELY AND PEOPLE NOTICED IT AND PUT WATER BACK ON THE CORE....CAUSING BIG STEAM & HYDROGEN BUBBLE...WHICH THEY VENTED INTO THE AIR OVER YORK HAVEN...BUT ANYWAY....JUST LIKE 90% OF ALL ARSONS ARE CAUSED BY FIREFIGHTERS...TMI ACCIDENT WAS NOT AN ACCIDENT...IT WAS DONE ON PURPOSE BY A NUTCAKE WHO ALTERED THE LIGHT ON THE VALVE DISPLAY

8/30/2009 7:55:10 PM
TMI_Engineer

the problem with DDT is that it effects the generation after, the eggs were cracking for pecivorous species such as the American Bald Eagle and lowering the birth rates. Yes, let's let the symbol of American life go extinct. Also the US still sells DDT to foreign countries and it pretty much doesn't work for most mosquitoes anymore anyways.

8/30/2009 3:18:44 PM
grizbear98

Why all the profanity? I enjoyed reading the story - but the profanity really puts me off. This language has become every-day for most people, including children. I say - JUST SAY NO to profanity.

8/29/2009 2:45:49 PM
SASSYMISSPEANUT

I'm surprised that there's nothing about Alar here.

8/18/2009 10:59:48 AM
DeeEss

You're right, don't believe everything you read...including all of this article.

7/21/2009 5:00:45 PM
StormandStatic

the percent increase for the malaria is %14705782.35

7/11/2009 7:38:50 PM
metsfan12694

HIPPIES ARE DESTROYING THE WORLD

7/10/2009 6:38:34 PM
alabama2561990

Trains are a good one, when they were first introduced people were scared to ride them as it was believed that going faster than 30 mph could squash your internal organs into nothingness.

7/7/2009 11:00:04 AM
callummcgilvery

Putting DDT on this list is absurd. It wasn't so much banned for its carcinogenic effects as much as for its absolutely devastating ecological impact. And like it or not, the state of the environment DOES affect the state of humanity eventually.

But don't worry, the United States still to this day manufactures and sells DDT to third-world countries (you know, the ones that don't care about human rights, much less human responsibility to the environment).

7/3/2009 10:29:33 AM
slarso

DDT is no longer useful for preventing malaria; most mosquitos are now resistant to it. Still, the hippies should shut up.

4/28/2009 9:08:43 PM
CorruptUser

To all the nuclear power proponents: It really isn't nearly as cheap as you make it out to be. It's just cleaner, which in my view, already recommends it enough.

4/28/2009 8:34:04 PM
iheartjihad

Heh. Haven't heard about DDT since The Machine used it to try and kill Willy in the Free Willy Cartoon. GOOD times...

4/18/2009 9:08:04 PM
BATZARRO

The China Syndrome and Three Mile Island is what caused all nuclear power plant building to come to a screeching halt. Thereafter we have visions of glowing green whenever we we hear the word "nuclear" much less use it. This is still true dispite the many years of safe use by electrical utilities (and military aboard ships and subs.)
Oh yeah, those of that will bring up Chernobyl should note that it envolved a screwball, obsolete reactor design that we don't use and there are modern pebble bed reactor designs that would be as safe as running a microwave.

3/20/2009 10:28:42 AM
thunderguppy

And those environmentalist got the DDT banned once it had removed the malaria from their continents. Once they were safe from it, save the f*****g birds!, who cares of the africans and asians that still die in millions because of no DDT?

2/24/2009 12:32:28 PM
traktor

"No, when you absolutely, positively must kill every m**********r in the room, crocidolite or amosite is what you need."

Substitutes not accepted. That made me laugh a lot.

1/29/2009 5:50:25 PM
rachel_renegade
Cracked stuff on