Yesterday, our wizarding overlords released the final trailer for Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes Of Grindelwald. It's the sequel to Fantastic Beasts And Where to Find Them, the second multi-million-dollar movie based on what is more or less a 128-page knockoff Dungeons & Dragons Monster Manual. In the trailer, Dumbledore is still pawning his most important work off on hapless former students, Johnny Depp still inexplicably has a career, and so forth. But there was one reveal that's pretty major: It turns out Nagini, seen in the original Harry Potter series as Voldemort's beloved pet snake, was originally a human lady.
There's been plenty of discussion about how weird this is in a series full of racial representation problems (Nagini is an Asian woman who has heretofore been portrayed literally as an animal), but there hasn't been as much discussion about how weird this is in terms of character and plot. Humans who can turn into animals are, of course, nothing new in Potterland, but this revelation raises a lot of questions about Nagini, chiefly her relationship with Voldemort, that are frankly better left unasked.
In the main series, Nagini is Voldemort's most treasured companion, the creature to whom he shows by far the most affection and loyalty. His belief that she will always be by his side and that he can always protect her is so great that he makes her one of his horcruxes, embedding a piece of his dang soul in her. It always seemed like an interesting -- and most importantly, intentional -- element of his character. He is so disconnected from humanity that the only creature for whom he can show anything close to love is an animal. His ignorance of the power of human love is the fatal flaw that ultimately brings him down.
So what the hell is going on here? Did Voldemort know she was a human? It's not like he could just pick up an evil snake at PetSmart, so it seems more likely that however they were brought together, he must have known her history. How on Earth did they meet, anyway? It's not clear at what point Nagini transformed permanently, but given that The Crimes Of Grindelwald takes place the year after Voldemort was born and Nagini isn't that old, it's nowhere near impossible that he met her when she was still a sexy snake woman.
Were they *shudder* in love? We've already learned and can never unlearn that Voldemort boinks. Even then, though, the accepted interpretation of the, uh, events that produced a daughter who became the villain of Harry Potter And The Cursed Child is that Voldemort simply sought to reward his most loyal follower in the manner she desired -- i.e. a trip to Pound Town. But the way Voldemort behaves toward Nagini is exactly how one would behave toward an adored life partner. If he knew she was once human -- which, again, seems likely -- the entire message of the original series is negated. Voldemort most assuredly understood the power of the love with which Harry's mother protected him. He had a freaking wife, and well, she was a snake all along.
Is any of this going to be explained? Likely not, if Rowling's history of explaining things with any coherence is anything to go by. What are people gonna do, just not buy everything with her name on it? Don't be ridiculous.
Support your favorite Cracked writers with a visit to our Contribution Page. Please and thank you.
Also, we'd love to know more about you and your interesting lives, dear readers. If you spend your days doing cool stuff, drop us a line at iDoCoolStuff at Cracked dot com, and maybe we can share your story with the entire internet.
Follow us on Facebook. Because why not?
Most actors have rough gigs early in their careers.
What does the person who has everything buy for themselves?
Sometimes the follow-up is worse than original headline-grabbing story.
Some people in entertainment don't even bother trying to come up with fresh ideas.