6 Horrifying Urban Legends That Actually Came True

5 The Tinder Stalker

The Legend:

4 The Killer Clown (With An Even Weirder Twist)

The Legend:

Unless you wisely swore off the internet around three years ago, you've probably heard about the spate of "killer clowns" being spotted around the world. Most of these sightings are nothing but pranks, but is clown murder a real thing? And don't say John Wayne Gacy -- he didn't kill while dressed as a clown, as far as we know. Even he thought that was too creepy.

The Truth:

Well, this series isn't called "Creepy Urban Legends Staged by Guys Hoping to Impress Reddit," so the answer is yes. In the spring of 1990, Floridian Marlene Warren answered her door and found herself face-to-face with a clown sporting the classic orange wig, red nose, painted-on smile, and lingering air of menace. She was holding a bouquet of flowers and two balloons, one of which read "You're the Greatest!" Then, in flagrant disregard for the balloon's message, she pulled out a gun and shot Warren in the face.

Warren's teenage son saw the whole thing, and watched helplessly as the killer strolled away, got into their Chrysler LeBaron, and drove off. The mysterious clown would then avoid justice for 27 years, because sometimes real-life bears a disturbing resemblance to It.

Improvements to DNA technology allowed police to arrest Sheila Keen, who had been having an affair with Warren's husband, Michael. In fact, 12 years after the murder, Michael married Sheila.

3 The Trick-Or-Treat Murder

The Legend:

Halloween is weird. Usually you'd call the cops if folks dressed as monsters, murderers, and mutant turtles kept marching up to your door to demand candy, but for one night a year, it's considered wholesome fun. Well, at least right up until someone shows up in a creepy costume and aspirations of being a real-life Michael Myers. Sure, the vast majority of costumed people you meet don't want to murder you, but you can never be sure, right?

The Truth:

On October 31, 1957, Goldyne Pizer put on gloves, makeup, and a Halloween mask, then walked up to Peter Fabiano's door with her candy bag. It was late, around 11:30, but Fabiano answered the door. Maybe he was hoping to avoid an egging. Instead, Pizer raised her bag, which contained a gun, and shot him dead.

Now here's where it gets strange. Aside from scouting out her target at one of the hair salons he ran, Pizer had never met Fabiano before killing him. So why did she pull the trigger? Well, Fabiano's wife Betty had developed a close relationship with a woman named Joan Rabel. It was so close that it threatened their marriage, so Betty eventually broke it off and returned to Peter. An angry Joan convinced her friend Goldyne to off her rival by convincing her that Peter was a "vile, evil man," and it seems Goldyne was willing to take her word for that.

2 The Avenging Alligator

The Legend:

People loves stories about dumb criminals getting their just desserts. People also love stories about other people getting devoured by animals, because people are terrible. Combine the two and you've got an instant "Only in Florida" saga. A burglar tries to ditch the police by hiding in a swamp, but he isn't alone. There's something else lurking in those dark waters, and it's hungry.

The Truth:

In late 2015, enterprising young Floridian Matthew Riggins and a buddy set off on a trailer park burglary spree. Unfortunately, their criminal scheme unraveled when residents immediately noticed them skulking around. The cops were called and the friend was nabbed, but Riggins decided to try his luck by hiding in nearby Barefoot Bay Lake. Then the screaming started.

Barefoot Bay Lake, despite the pleasant name, is the absolute last place you want to go wading. It's full of alligators, and one of them decided that Riggins looked like dinner. The police couldn't find Riggins during their initial search, but ten days later, his drowned body was recovered. Well, most of it -- he was missing a few chunks, which were later discovered in the stomach of an aggressive alligator. Pro tip for aspiring criminals: Avoid areas where alligators are in charge of the neighborhood watch.

1 The Baby Thief

The Legend:

Pregnancy fears are a common subject of urban legends, because pregnancy can be terrifying. One of the more enduring tales of horror involves a baby-crazy lady attempting to steal another woman's unborn child right out of the womb. The French even made a (completely insane) movie about it. But come on, that's too nuts to happen in reality ... right?

The Truth:

This is the story we warned you about. Last chance to turn back.

Michelle Wilkins didn't notice anything particularly off about Dynel Lane when they met via Craigslist. The two pregnant ladies talked pregnant lady things for a while, then headed down to Lane's basement so Wilkins could look over the spare maternity clothes Lane was giving away. There was only one problem with this friendly scene: Lane wasn't pregnant, just obsessed with the idea. She'd been pretending for over a year, having fashioned a fake stomach, attended a baby shower, and even picked out a name. Lane's boyfriend and family presumably all slept through the "babies come out after nine months" part of health class, but the jig would have to be up soon. Lane needed a baby to continue the ruse and, one way or another, she was going to get one.