Register

Tales To Tell ‘Round Midnight: The Halloween That Was Actually Arbor Day

  • By: Cody
  • October 31st, 2009
  • 14,557 views

Jimothan Taylor reached for the best costume in the store with such haste that you could tell he really wanted it quickly.  Someone, however, clearly wanted it quicker than Jimothan, because not only was there a person hastier in grabbing the best costume in the store, but there was also-No, that’s it, actually.  There was a person hastier in grabbing the best costume in the store.  Jimothan was quite distraught as the hastier person bought the aforementioned hands-down best costume in the store and left.

Jimothan sighed, his arms wafting about as if to say “If only we could sigh, but sadly we are just arms.”  Yes, it was the kind of sigh that a stranger might speak up about, were they so inclined.

“Something the matter, guy?” a nearby stranger felt inclined to say.

“Something the matter, guy?” the nearby stranger asked.

“Oh, no, nothing,” breathed Jimothan.

The nearby stranger had little to think about that day, so he pressed further.

“That sigh certainly wasn’t no nothin’ kinda sigh there, boy,” pressed the nearby stranger.  “What’s the problem-o?”

“I sighed because someone else got the best costume in the store,” Jimothan sighed again.  “I really needed that.”

“Yeah, I’ve been eyeing that costume for months, myself,” said the nearby stranger, standing nearby.  “It certainly was the best costume I ever seen.”

The two stood there a moment, lamenting the fact that neither of them had gotten their hands on the best costume in the store.  Minutes later, the stranger spoke up.

“Why are you so glum, though?” he asked Jimothan.  “You can just get another costume.”

Jimothan scowled. “How am I going to find a costume in time for my party tonight?”

“Why you havin’ a Halloween party on Arbor Day?” the stranger asked.

“What do you mean?” asked a shocked Jimothan, all shocked and stuff.

“It ain’t Halloween, kiddo,” the nearby stranger explained.  “It’s Arbor Day.”

This was too much for Jimothan, who immediately believed the nearby stranger.    It was so too much for Jimothan, in fact, that he screamed quite suddenly and ran out of the store.  The now faraway stranger shook his head and went back to his business, which is of no concern to you, nor is it any of your business.

The parking lot outside of the costume store was full of zombies, which was a mainstay of this particular town’s Arbor Day celebration.  Jimothan was baffled six ways from “I’m baffled,” because  Halloween was a zombie-free holiday in this particular town, and Jimothan could have sworn this was Halloween.  The current zombie frenzy begged to differ, but beggars can’t be choosers and the zombies certainly didn’t choose to be in a frenzy, so maybe we should all just settle down and forget about the zombies for a second.

The particular town Jimothan was in was called New York City, and it was a mere shadow of the New York City you’re probably thinking of (New York City, Ottawa).  This New York City had but one main road with a gas station and a costume shop.  The local school was run by the students, and the local students couldn’t care less about running a school so, no, there was no school to speak of.

New York City didn’t quite care for the theatrics of Halloween, nor was it fond of its ne’er-do-well attitude.  Halloween was tolerated in this particular town, and by God if this didn’t seem like the craziest zombie frenzy this town had ever seen (certainly not the kind of celebration one would see during Halloween).

“What the zombie?” exclaimed Jimothan in the manner one might exclaim “What the hell?”

This certainly was the time for exclamation, but not so much that we need to spend anymore time here.  Jimothan made his way through the zombies and arrived home.

“How is your Arbor Day going, sweetie?” asked Jimothan’s mother, Jimmifer.

“Horrible,” Jimothan muttered.  “I think it’s Halloween for some reason.”

“Well, it’s not Halloween, dear,” Jimmifer explained.  “It’s Arbor Day.”

“If it’s so much Arbor Day, then why aren’t we going to the Frankenstein Feast?  If it were Arbor Day, we’d be enjoying some delicious Frankenstein right now!”

“But, honey,” Jimmifer began to say as she also began to put on her coat.  “We are leaving for the Frankenstein Feast right now.  Put on your coat, or you’ll catch cold.  You don’t want the Ice Pumpkin to come and take your health for the season.”

“Mother,” Jimothan began to say as he also began to put on his coat.  “I’m old enough to not believe in the Ice Pumpkin.  That’s just an Arbor Day myth.”

“Nevertheless,” Jimmifer opened the door.  “We must not rely on the Vampire Campfire for warmth this year.  Rumor has it a lot of the vampires are on strike.”

“Mother, they’re on strike every Arbor Day.”

“Did you see the zombies, dear?”

“Yes, mother.”

“It’s Arbor Day, sweetie.”

“I think it’s Halloween.”

“Nope.  Arbor Day.”

Jimothan looked up and realized that Halloween wasn’t Arbor Day at all.  It was Halloween.  That stranger from earlier was crazy and everything else was a dream or something.

The End

Last 5 posts by Cody

This entry was posted on Saturday, October 31st, 2009 at 11:54 am and is filed under Uncategorized. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Leave a Reply

67 Responses to “Tales To Tell ‘Round Midnight: The Halloween That Was Actually Arbor Day”

  1. Obitron2000 Says:

    Hey Megan, u notice how the thumbs up guy has D.O.B. subliminally slipped in there? I like it!!! d(^O^)b

  2. smac972 Says:

    oops (I meant “good jokes, yo.”)

  3. smac972 Says:

    put your balls in MY MOUTH

  4. Judah Says:

    Random =/= Funny

  5. smac972 Says:

    Ya know,

    I don’t know if you read these comments or if, conversely you don’t read these comments. However, I am sure it is one of those two.

    I get it. You started writing a story and went with it and everytime you noticed a sentence that didn’t make sense you took advantage of it. Maybe you made it a theme.

    Jimothan sighed, his arms wafting about as if to say >>WAIT! That would be his arms talking! Perfect! Comedic gem.

    So, starting with “Jimothan”, a name so remarkably ODD - “Is it JIM, is it Jonathon? No, it’s *DAMNED* clever! What a ‘goofy, wacky’ name”, you kept going looking for forced joke after forced joke, none of which were terribly inspired.

    Now at this point you’re probably thinking I’m just your average bitter παραληρών όρχις but honestly, δεν ήταν αυτό αστείο!

    This is my thing, Cody - (Can I call you Cody?) I like Cracked. I brag to my Russian friends that some of the stuff done on this site are cutting edge comedy. (i.e. SNL can go назад к каменному век)

    And so, I peruse through the stuff that’s submitted and I think, ‘eh - w’eva - amateur’. When I get to the columnists I’m expecting this decade’s version of Groucho Marx and SJ Perelman.

    So, I ask you, with that kind of possible comedic influence, did you *really* *honestly* read this through and wonder if it made you laugh out loud enough? Funny enough? Because it just seemed you banged some nonsense off and noticed a few passable funny bits.

    One last thing (Honestly, I’d be asking, who the 자주색 물고기!! is this guy in your shoes, but hey…)

    Read this - it’s an example of what you were trying to do, written by the greatest Canadian Humourist (not Bucholz, at least yet)

    http://www.online-literature.com/stephen-leacock/nonsense-novels/5/

  6. Megan Says:

    Heh heh…that was pretty awesome. d(^O^)b

  7. meh Says:

    this is just shit.

    Plain and simple

  8. Jimothan Says:

    Have you people seriously not realised that he is writing badly on purpose yet?
    Stop saying “uhhh this is badly written”, that’s the point. It’s satire.

  9. Kefka Says:

    “Something the matter, guy?” a nearby stranger felt inclined to say.

    “Something the matter, guy?” the nearby stranger asked.

    i laughed pretty hard at that, good stuff man.

  10. Michelle Says:

    I’m so confused!!

  11. The Other Sarah Says:

    So . . . I dunno if you actually read the comments or not Mr. Cody, but just in case you do. . . I genuinely like your articles.

  12. Sarah Says:

    “if only we could sigh, but sadly we are just arms”.

    I swear, that’s most likely what anyone’s arms would say, given the person they are attached to would let out a sigh.

    I’m glad they let you write articles for I enjoy reading them.

  13. betamaxrules Says:

    I’m with you, Cody. That was awesome. Keep it up.

  14. Brynjar Says:

    Cool story, bro!

  15. hicher42 Says:

    That was pretty awesome

  16. Shades Magnum Says:

    Yup.

  17. The Killah29 Says:

    Really random, really funny. Keep it up Cody!

  18. discdeath Says:

    I personally thought that this was great. A good deal of wit was displayed, as well of a Milton-Jones-esque turn of phrase of which I am very fond.

  19. King Clown Goomba Says:

    The King Clown Gooma applauds your insanity and is very moved by it. It reminds the King of the good old days when peasants came wrappped in tasty cotton and nobody questions the word of goomba…

  20. kaly76hummer Says:

    Recently, I found an age-gap site called __Agegapmingle.com__ It’s a nice place­ for Younger Women and Older Men, or Older Women and­ Younger Men, to interact with each other. Age gap is­ not problem there. You may check out or tell your­ friends.

  21. Endee Says:

    God frickin’ dammit. It’s gotten so I read the comments section before I plod through the latest installment of Cody’s dreck. Cracked is paying Cody to get us all to sound off with wit and intelligence for free. Good scam, beetches. Good scam.

  22. fully erect Says:

    Take my word, as someone who’s gotten pissed off by something and stopped patronizing it quite a few times, you never announce it. So anyone who comments “I’m done with you” is totally not done with you.

  23. Adam Says:

    Nice job Cody! Very Bizarre. I always enjoy your work!

    http://www.sellbits.com - “The Simple Way To Sell”

  24. Gameclucks Says:

    Kingdomofloathing did that same cross-holiday joke a LOT funnier.
    Just sayin’.

  25. CamboD Says:

    That was amazing.
    Odd.
    But amazing.

  26. FatMartha Says:

    I’m rootin’ for ya, Cody. Don’t listen to these douchebags - they won’t like it if it doesn’t have “The [6/7/8] Most ____iest Things Ever [insert witty afterthought here]” in the title. I used to be a fan of the list articles, but not so much anymore. Your style is a nice change-up. Kudos to you.

  27. ComicBookGuy Says:

    i get it.
    it gave me a tiny chuckle when i realised what you were doing but i didn’t feel like reading any further.

  28. jkl Says:

    what the fuck

  29. Diana Says:

    WTF! That was weird. Not fun weird, or interesting weird, just WTF weird.

  30. Diana Says:

    WTF! That was weird. Not fun weird, just WTF weird.

  31. JesusWasAJew Says:

    Nice shit, Cody. Keep it up.

  32. ApolloSeven Says:

    I really liked this. I agree with Demmagog that it breaks cliches of narration, and that is exactly what needs to be done.

  33. Conor Says:

    much of his writing reminds me of douglas adams, but he does put his own spin on that kind of style. i am still getting used to him

  34. KypPineapple Says:

    Not bad, Cody. Not bad at all.

  35. Demmagog Says:

    I don’t know if I’d say it’s calculated “bad” writing so much as calculated *weird* writing. It breaks the cliches of narration at every turn.

  36. Captain6Tango Says:

    @Ian
    Are you sure that’s what he’s trying to do? I don’t know what angle he is working, I just know that I like most of his stuff.

    Whatever you are going for Cody, keep up the decent to awesome work!

  37. Red Jen Says:

    I kind of get the point, the writing style is almost funny, but it’s just too stilted. It doesn’t flow, it’s a bit difficult to read and you seem to have a big issue with endings.

  38. Chase Stevens Says:

    I love the way you write. It’s hilarious.

  39. Simon Says:

    I got a couple chuckles out of it. I think Cody’s humor is an acquired taste.

    “The now faraway stranger shook his head and went back to his business, which is of no concern to you, nor is it any of your business.”

    I like how the narrator informs the reader that what’s going on in the story isn’t any of their business.

  40. Jared Says:

    “Something the matter, guy?” a nearby stranger felt inclined to say.

    “Something the matter, guy?” the nearby stranger asked.

    Ahaha, I actually laughed out loud.. Just so random XD

  41. Stubby Says:

    Don’t want to be a hater, and I have laughed at some of your stuff, but I just don’t get this one.

  42. Cpt. Awesomeface Says:

    I think I’m starting to understand how you write. I’ve never particularly DISLIKED anything you wrote, I just didn’t fucking understand it. XD It’s definitely starting to make a little more sense now. Just make sure the subject matter stays interesting, I loved this one, the mansion article you did recently written in a similar style dragged on a bit too much for my liking.

    Long as the material stays fresh I don’t think I’m gonna get tired of your stuff. Keep it up.

  43. Ian Says:

    Oh, and I think a lot of the negative comments or the “I could write this” comments stem from the fact that people don’t understand the difference between calculated, hilarious, intentionally bad writing, as this is, and just plain bad writing, which is what they’d do.

  44. Ian Says:

    Every single one of these is awesome. This one is particularly awesome.

  45. Liam Says:

    You know, at first I thought you sucked, dude. Your first stuff made absolutely no sense to me. However, ever since I read the article about the haunted mansion party, I’ve started liking your stuff. This one’s not the best, but I got a couple of chuckles out of it. Keep it up!

  46. Brando Says:

    Very funny. I love your shit, keep it up.

  47. fronswah Says:

    Pardon me, the sentence was “I will not defy readers’ expectations.”

  48. fronswah Says:

    Dude, I’m sorry, I’ve tried to be tolerant and open minded about your work. I know that art takes on many forms and is in the eye of the beholder, blah, blah, blah.

    But man? You fucking suck. Your work is not funny. Some people seem to think it’s funny, but I imagine those are the people who also enjoy things like The Lonely Island and Paris Hilton’s My New Best Friend.

    The only entertainment I’ve gotten (remotely) from you has been in Gladstone’s recent article “The Trials of Gladstone (As Told By Franz Kafka) in which you are strapped to a steel table and have the sentence “I will not disappoint fan’s expectations” carved into your back multiple times by a razor. That little blub made me laugh harder than all your work put together.

  49. DraconianKing Says:

    Jesus, this is bad. It’s like -I- wrote it or something.
    Either fire him or hire me.

  50. Shelly_Lou Says:

    I’m finally starting to see your pattern of humor in your stuff and quite honestly, I am really beginning to enjoy it. Your prose is good. It takes a different kind of talent to be so creatively redundant and yet still be descriptive. I’m looking forward to reading more of your stuff. Great job!

  51. Doimas Says:

    The only good thing I ever saw from you were those game tutorial videos. Everything else sucked.

  52. LexTaliones Says:

    Sorry Cody, this was your last chance. I’m never reading your crap again dude. I don’t know where Cracked found you, or why they kept you … but you haven’t written anything worth a shit since you got here. I’m not sure who the dipshits are that suddenly showed up and started saying you were ok a few installments ago, but I’m not buying it. I’m starting to suspect they’re related to you, or something. That’s the only possible explanation. Your first few articles were unanimously panned and ridiculed, and nothing has changed in your writing, style, subject matter … Nothing, so that must be it. Some day your cousins will get tired of writing kudos for you, and then where will you be? C’mon man, pick a new way to express yourself … stop the pain Cody. Stop the pain.

    Maybe enterperative dance is more your style?

  53. Arucard04 Says:

    You’ve become second only to Seanbaby. Although I don’t see how a normal human could output comedy at the frequency you do, keep it up.

  54. alex Says:

    its actually not that bad. I wont call Cody laugh out loud hilarious, but his articles are interesting to read and subtle. If you actually pay attention and are not just reading for a quick laugh, his articles are pretty good. I’m not calling you a Bucholz or Swaim, but not bad Cody, not bad at all

  55. Jon Says:

    Cody, your stuff is super radacious. Keep it up.

  56. Christine Says:

    That was crazy, I loved it.

  57. thateasilyamusedguy Says:

    you’re turd

    go home

    Call me a troll or whatever, but You’re just not up to standard wiht your writing

  58. MJ Says:

    fuck these guys, that was hilarious. “whats the problem-o” is now my new catch phrase

  59. Emma Says:

    Yeah, Cody, I see where some people may think this would be funny, but it honestly just seemed like you started typing, got bored, and decided to play the lame middle and ending off like it was your “style”. Half-assed job, really.

  60. GHB Says:

    This was possibly the worst writing I’ve seen on cracked, I can’t believe I read it all. You have truly mastered the art of hilariously bad writing, congratulations.

  61. hazardlad Says:

    No. Just no. And yes I realize I have turned into Doctor Chaos, the irony is not lost on me. But, never the less, vast yawning chasms filled with swathes of no.

  62. poopjew Says:

    Jimothan looked up and realized that Halloween wasn’t Arbor Day at all. It was Halloween. That stranger from earlier was crazy and everything else was a dream or something.

    The End……

    hahahaha nice ending

  63. Shad_Phoenix Says:

    Clearly, Jimothan is insane and everyone’s playing along with his delusions. But what he doesn’t realize is that he’s the reincarnation of Jesus and the parties and candy of Halloween are his temptations. The hasty person of course is D.O.B (the Antichrist) and the stranger is Satan, tempting Jesusothan and feeding him lies.

    It was Halloween all along.

  64. Shad_Phoenix Says:

    Clearly, Jimothan is insane and everyone’s playing along with his delusions. But what he doesn’t realize is that he’s the reincarnation of Jesus and the parties and candy of Halloween are his temptations.

  65. Arlo Says:

    Dude, WFT! (Wangtacularly Freakin’ ‘Tardulous)

  66. David Says:

    “What the zombie?”

    Indeed, what the zombie?!

  67. TomJonesRealEstateMan Says:

    Amazing. Bravo, sir.

Leave a Reply

Cracked stuff on