Can we call "Photoshop" on a painting?
Again, Magnani did not have that photo to work from -- that was taken later, probably by somebody trying to find out if he was full of shit. And keep in mind, painting at all was totally out of character for him, given that he had been a cook in Italy and a woodworker when he came to San Francisco. Yet even though he'd never so much as held a brush in his life, he was suddenly overcome with an urge to paint these scenes, with as much detail as his memory provided him. Yes, there are variations in the pics -- for instance when he paints the view from his old bedroom window, he's remembering it being zoomed out a bit:

Via Exploratorium.edu
Photo, again on the left.
What you're seeing is the product of what had become an obsession. According to one of his friends, Magnani was known to leave his favorite bar mid-drink if he got a memory that he wanted to paint. Later, when word of Magnani's story got out, doctors said that what he had was probably "temporal lobe epilepsy," which is known to sometimes create an obsessive personality in sufferers.

Via Francomagnani.com
Photo on left.

Photos.com
Via 
Via 
Via
Via
Via
Via
Via
Via 
Photos.com
Via
Via
Photos.com
Photos.com
Photos.com
Via
Via
Via
Via 
Via
Via
Via
Via 
Via
Via
Via
Via
903 Comments