5 Ways Your Brain Is Messing With Your Head
We accept on a regular basis the premise that our minds are being screwed with. Advertisers, politicians, magicians; we accept that they know the tricks to pull the wool over our eyes. But as it turns out, the ways in which your head is being truly and royally messed with the most, are coming from inside.
Please be advised that your brain does not want you reading the following list, and may kill you to protect its secrets. These include...

What is it?
It's your inability to notice changes that happen right in front of you, even if they're hugely obvious... as long as you don't see the actual change take place.
Um, What?
Consider Alfonso Ribeiro.

Now, if suddenly that image of Carlton blinked and changed to a different image, you'd notice it. The change would draw your eye. But if you got up and left your computer, then came back and found the image had changed, odds are you almost certainly would not notice, even if you were only gone for seconds. Science has proven it.

In fact, if the entire text of this article--and the whole color and layout of this website--changed while you were gone, you probably wouldn't notice. We could switch it to a wallpaper of dicks. You might not believe it but, as you're about to see below, the experiments they've done on this get truly bizarre.

A scientist named George McConkie started working on this in the 70s. He'd introduce changes in words and text right on the page that someone was reading. By tracking the movement of their eyes, he was able to change the text right in front of their damned faces without people noticing.
Why Does the Brain Lie About it?
Change blindness is usually related to something called inattention blindness. If you tried to process everything in your visual spectrum you would go insane, so your mind picks and chooses what to focus on. If Carlton grows a mustache while your brain isn't paying attention, when you look back at Carlton, your brain tells you he's had the 'stache all along.
It's like your brain is sitting in class, staring out the window at a cloud that sort of looks like a boob. When you call on your brain it does the same thing you do when a teacher calls on you in those circumstances: Start bullshitting. It doesn't really know what Carlton looked like a second ago, but it's not going to tell you that. Since it has no visual memory of the image, it just tells you it's always looked the same. Even when that's a lie.

Where it Really Gets Weird...
What's truly amazing is just how often your brain isn't paying attention. Scientists decided to take the idea to a ridiculous extreme. They ran experiments where they'd have a guy manning the counter at an office serving students, while another guy was hidden below the counter. A student would walk up and request a form, and the guy would say sure and duck down behind the counter to get it.
But then second guy, the one who had been hiding, would pop up and say, "ah, here it is." This second guy would look completely different, and would be wearing completely different colored clothing, and most of the students would not freaking notice it was a different guy than the one they had been talking to five seconds ago.
Here is a video of such an experiment. Far creepier is the bit magician Derren Brown does where he'll approach a stranger on the street, ask for directions, and in mid-sentence have somebody walk past carrying a large object. While the object is disrupting the view for half a second, he'll swap out another guy who looks and sounds nothing like him--and the stranger will carry on the conversation with the second man as if nothing had happened.
This is probably what made the producers of Bewitched think they could just switch out Darrins on us.


What is it?
It's the 40 or so minutes per day that you're effectively blind.
Um, What?
Quick, look at the wall to your left. When you flicked your eyes over there, for just a moment, you were blind. And you didn't even know it.
Why Does the Brain Lie About it?
Ever watch a movie that gave you motion sickness, due to the camera whipping around too fast? This is what has some people puking during movies that use the "shaky handheld camera" gimmick (see: Cloverfield and The Blair Witch Project). Your brain doesn't like those rapid, blurry changes in vision.

This is either Cloverfield or a picture of John Candy with a Motion Blur filter.
But eye movements are even faster than those shaky camcorders. Flick your eyes over to the wall again. Notice you didn't get that nauseating, blurred image of the room zooming past your eye? That's because of saccadic masking.
In order to bring you this completely awe-inspiring view of what we're guessing is your cubicle wall right now, your brain rapidly moves your eyes without asking, in the neighborhood of three to five times per second. That's in addition to the times you move your eyes consciously, to look at the clock or the wall just now. To prevent your world from looking like the jerky Cloverfield camcorder all day, your brain shuts down your optic nerve while your eye is in motion.
Where it Really Gets Weird...
The spooky part is the way your brain prevents you from noticing the blackness that occurs several times a second, every moment you use your eyes. Estimates vary somewhat, but it's likely that you're spending somewhere around 40 minutes a day with your eyes wide open, and totally blind.

Your brain.
Look at the wall one more time. If you make an effort, you can sometimes see a "flash" of darkness during a particularly long eye movement, one of those periods of blindness your brain insists isn't happening. But for the most part, your brain suppresses these flickers.
And here's where saccadic masking and change blindness team up to have rough sex with your mind. Remember, the first scientist to experiment with change blindness was making changes to the page while people were looking directly at it. He was able to do it by introducing the changes during saccadic movement. If a change occurs during that fraction of a second when the brain is dodging calls like the optic nerve was an ex-girlfriend, you tend not to notice it. Even when it happens right in front of your damned eyes.

What is it?
It's your brain's map of your body, and it screws up on a regular basis.
Um, What?
Your sense of proprioception is your brain's ability to sense where your limbs are. Nothing strange about that, right? This is how you can put a sandwich in your mouth while your eyes are focused on the TV. Your brain knows where your hand is in relation to your face, thanks to proprioception.

Why Does the Brain Lie About it?
It may not be lying necessarily, just easily confused. You know this if you've ever taken a field sobriety test.
Your proprioception is like your underwear: it's pretty much the first thing to disappear when you're any kind of fucked up. Basically, the cops doing the roadside test are trying to see if your brain knows where your fingers are in relation to your nose.
Even though your brain carries around a detailed awareness of exactly where your body parts are at all times, when it's handed a contradictory stimulus, essentially it says, "Oh, well. Guess I've been wrong about the length of your nose all these years."

It's either that or your brain is a sadistic son-of-a-bitch that likes playing tricks on you.
Where it Really Gets Weird...
The best example we've found so far is "the Pinocchio illusion." Scientists have found they can have the subject touch the tip of their nose with their finger, and have their bicep or triceps electrically stimulated at the same time. Your brain "feels" your arm muscle extending, but also feels that you're maintaining contact with the tip of your nose, and leaps to the immediate, yet fully sober, conclusion that your nose has suddenly grown to be about three feet long.

Science.
Incidentally, we know exactly which illusion you're about to try to induce, figuring all it'll take is a girl, a dark room and the right equipment. Don't do it. It will lead to eventual disappointment.








i have another thing that might be in..
Replyi have several times been looking for an object to finally realize i had it on me all along... ive had it happen with sunglasses, and a backpack... A FREAKINC BACKPACK...
I used a George Carlin joke for years thinking it was mine. When someone somewhere on the internet sourced it to him, I was all offended and thought they were full of shit. So I went to Youtube and looked it up... and immediately remembered the routine where he used the joke from when I had seen it years ago. That fucked with me for weeks, then I found this article. Thanks, Cracked!
ReplyI remember reading the book The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat by Oliver Sacks for my psychology class in high school. There was a story about a person who lost his/her proprioception and had to adjust and figure out how to walk and do day to day things. I just recently learned about cryptomnesia in my other psychology class.
ReplyI'm convinced that there's no such thing as free will, your brain makes the decisions based on past experiences and current hormone levels. Which explains why you will make different decisions when your hormone levels are fucked up by drugs or vitamine insufficiencies or whatever.
ReplyYou're absolutely right. Even if it weren't for our neurotransmitters going haywire at the slightest provocation, it's still logical to assume that everything we are, everything we do, everything we "choose" happens because something else happened first. We have a proximal illusion of free will, but it's only our brains' chemistry and interpretation of our surroundings. Anyone who hypothetically had identical chemistry and surroundings would theoretically make all the same "choices".
I once had a friend when we were younger who thought he had invented masturbation!!
ReplyNow you need to add in an Earthworm Jim picture, and you will have effectively summed up my favorite two cartoons of the 90's in your articles.
ReplyYipes! swiching the images with the crown made me think something whas worng and that i saw the crown on the pic without it i didnt notice i whas scrolling in circles...and when i gone down i nearly got a heart attack when i saw his eyes...then later i checked for illusions or hipnotisam and noticed i fooled myself...seriosly i actualy nearly got a seasore my head hurts...
Lol... A seasore.
is this just taken from the book?
Replyyay for the freakazoid reference/photo!
ReplyMy brain just learned something that it already knew, but didn't want it to know.... *Brain explodes*
ReplyCryptomnesia isn't bullshit. I definitely have experienced that once, memorably, years ago when I was like 7 and I thought I came up with the words "you're just too good to be true, can't take my eyes off of you, you'd be like heaven to touch, I wanna hold you so much." I was trying to convince my BFF at the time that I wrote those lyrics and her mom and her thought I was crazy and joking. I heard the Lauryn Hill song with that chorus on the radio and thought she stole it from me. I didn't realize until a few years later that I subconsciously heard Frankie Valli's version and somehow was convinced at age 7 or so that it was mine.
ReplyAnd it really does sound like a pile of s**t if it never happened to you XD
Does anyone remember what the phenomenon is called where you think something unusual happens to you a lot, when really it happens an average amount but you only remember the times it does happen vs. the times it doesn't? For example, people reporting that they always look at the clock at 11:11 every day because they don't think about it when they don't. I think it was in a Cracked article.
ReplyFrequency Illusion, or the more general Selective Attention. I believe it was in a previous article as well.
It's why people believe in miracles.
Regarding #1, I think it's more like the brain is the "CEO," whereas the inner voice is more of a "spokesperson."
ReplyNumber one is why I hate it when there's a CHANCE at things like school, or work being cancelled for a certain day. Yeah, sure, you think you're doing me a favor by telling me 3 days in advance that I MIGHT not have to come to work on Friday, but don't be surprised if I'm not the most motivated/hospitable employee that day if you DO decide to bring everyone in. I know that no matter how hard I consciously try to convince myself that it's best to assume that there's going to be work, and be pleasantly surprised when there isn't, as soon as I get that call my brain has already jizzed in it's pants over it's unexpected 3 day weekend. I'm sitting there saying "thanks for letting me know" through gritted teeth while my subconscious giddily makes plans to do all sorts of non-work related activities.
ReplySo here's the situation: I have to go to bed early Thursday night knowing full well I MIGHT not have to go to work the next day (even though my brain has come to the conclusion I won't), get up early the next morning, and then have to console my completely devastated subconscious for making it come into work when "we were promised a three day weekend." The worst bit is I usually find out they didn't cancel work when I show up and am expected to get s**t done, all the while my subconscious is pissed at me that we're not sleeping in, or playing Skyrim.
So employers of the world, listen: If you EVER come across a situation where you might not have to bring your people in on any given work day...make up your mind over how that specific day will end up BEFORE having to call people. Or s**t, even better, don't call them at all. Just wait until the morning on to tell people that there's no work that day. I'm sure as s**t more satisfied driving halfway to work to receive a call telling me to drive my ass back home, even though I had to get up early anyway. I'll just pass right back out. I won't even change.
...No, seriously, it's cool to call everyone while they're on their way to work to tell them they have the day off.
I experienc the wierd effects of #1 everyday. I always wake up 3-5 seconds before my alarm goes off, and I always seem to check my phone right before I get a text message. f*****g brain, how you you work?
ReplyFor some reason the only thing that happens to me when I look at the starburst illusion is the "rays" sometimes combine for a split second to look like a lightning bolt shape. Is that what is supposed to happen?
ReplyLook at the red vertical lines again. Are they all parallel?
Spoiler: Yes. Yes they are.
"Free will is an illusion to pander to our dumb vanity"
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesI don't get how your brain 'coming to a decision' before you do is so indicative of a lack of free will. I consider my brain to be ME. Even if I don't consciously recognize the decision until a moment later, as soon as my brain has decided on something, I'VE decided on it. Different people's brains, based on their different experiences and memories, would come to different decisions and then relay that to the more conscious parts of the brain.
I think that in the context of the article the "Free will" statement is referred to someone with the necessary equipment telling you what you will decide before you consciously decide that is not necessarily the truth but the best decision to suit their own means.
It may be splitting hairs, but the idea that your decision is not primarily the result of your conscious reasoning would frighten some people.
Thank you, I finally found someone who's as exasperated as I am every time this article refers to the brain as a different being altogether. WE are our respective brains. And there is such a thing as free will, since we make all the actual important life-changing decisions ourselves whether we realize it or not. Some things depend on the mechanics of the nervous system and are just the way our body functions, but the decisions that matter are our own. Its all a matter of belief, if we believe in free will, it exists. If we dont it doesnt.
So my mind can't make up it's mind, as it changes itself non-stop all the time.
ReplyThe "Free Will" fallacy should definitely have been #1. Godless or Hokey Religion both have the same outcome in terms of free will. It can't exist. It doesn't exist. We are simply a few numbers scratched into the giant equation of existence. Primarily because at no point in our existence did we freely choose the time and place of our birth, our sex, our color, our family or most of the most primary thoughts which formed the foundation for which everything else was constructed upon. Then of course there is DNA and outside influences which we can't control (such as being born in a poor African tribe during a famine/plague/drought) or being born a psychopath. Of course hundreds of millions of people who believe that a pill can help to curb your depression also think they have free will...
Reply Hide All See All 10 RepliesThat's total bunk, what are you basing these theories of yours off of, show me. Not being able to control your genetics and not being able to decide whether or not you want that last slice of pizza or whether or not you decide to save it for later have no correlation at all. What you are suggesting has nothing to do with "free will" or the ability to make said example of choices "while living" birth happens before you exist, and you wouldn't have been born if someone hadn't "decided" to have a child or even "accidentally" did, you're mixing up two completely separate concepts.
You're confusing "free will" which happens very much after you are alive and aware enough to make choices, and "genetics".
"Free will" is the idea that you can decide between something as simple as, do I want to eat that last slice of pizza, or save it. None of the things you stated are even related to having the ability of choice and are entirely related to factors beyond your control, namely genetics and geography, of course you can't "choose" those things, you don't exist when they happen, and last time I checked, science is making some pretty solid leaps and bounds in changing the "genetics" part, there is no such thing as 0% probability or 100% probability, therefore can't and must are not logical terms, ever.
When my brain decides "I'm going to get mad at this person" I am fully capable even after the sub conscious has decided on it to "re-think" the decision before it executes, that is what free will is my friend.
Can everyone do this? Yes. Does everyone take the time to allow themselves? Hell no, people are lazy fucks.
I don't think you can prove that we cannot control our DNA, but Dr. Bruce Lipton in his book, "The Biology of Belief" argues that we can do just that.
In theory, if you make a clone of someone, and put said clone through the exact same life, will the clone make the exact same decisions? If yes, there is an argument we have no free will. And there's no way to test this. We would first need a perfect cloning process (clones are not the exact same as what they are a clone of. Most clones so far generally suffer from some sort of degenerative disease which means they are different on some level.) Even if we perfected cloning, you might argue that it is not enough. Or that differing background radio waves ultimately culminated in some small difference somewhere...
ZhekeCrowley, you seem to be mistaking the statement 'Free will is an illusion' for the statement 'actions have no consequences and all actions are equally valid.' Those are absolutely not the same thing. Some actions are better than others precisely BECAUSE they happen in a predictable universe where cause leads to effect. If we lived in a world where everyone was made up of universe altering free will rays there wouldn't be any point in making good decisions.
Not exactly following what Zheke says, but I'd say lcp1138 has assumed that past events preclude future decisions. It is, theoretically, possible that while you can't determine how your environment operates on you, you do have absolute control of how you operate on your environment, or at least, your intentions when you operate on your environment.
@Squab: Actually it has to do with nature versus nurture, which again has nothing to do with free will. Even if you could make a perfectly identical clone, its not going to go through the same experiences and therefore will not make the same decisions. Zheke is right, you guys keep confusing free will and genetics/environment factors.
Saccadic Masking - so is that why when I'm really tired everything _does_ get blurry whenever I move my eyes - a failure in this mechanism?
ReplyNo. Your eyelids squint, bending the lens and blurring vision.
I've had that Cryptomnesia thing happen to me. I accidentally ripped off an entire dance for my ballet class from Barbie in the Nutcracker in grade school. Luckily my teacher had never seen the movie.
ReplyI had it all the time, when I was younger. For years, the little dimwit me thought he had invented the multiple universe theory, where each universe is the outcome of a chain of possibilities. Blew my mind to think of "Sliders" on day and thought: "Hmm, I liked that series... whait, is that where I got my idea from?"