11 Baseball Legends Who Were Legendary Assholes
Baseball is as synonymous with America as mom, apple pie, and morbid obesity, which probably goes hand in hand with the apple pie. We've all heard the names Ruth, DiMaggio, Aaron, these are the legends of the game who inspire us with awe and wonder.
However, with any group there's sure to be a certain number of assholes, and baseball is no different. Maybe a little worse, in fact.

First known as one of the great power hitters of the 80s and 90s, there are some who now call Jose Canseco the "Woodward and Bernstein" of the Steroids Scandal because of his tell-all book Juiced. While he did shed some light on an important issue, there is one distinct difference: Woody and the B-Dog wrote their book because they wanted to bring a corrupt President to justice because they were great journalists. Canseco wanted to make some money ratting out his old buddies because he's a douche.
If, for even a moment, you held on to a shred of possibility it wasn't all about the money, that was blown out of the water when he decided to write a second book which "had stuff" on the likes of A-Rod and Junior Griffey, two players who have never shown up in any steroids investigation. This means one of two things: Canseco was making shit up because he's a dick, or he willingly held out the most surprising allegations from his first book in favor of turning his best friends in first, which makes him an even bigger dick.
"Raise your hand if you're a dick."
It's hard to believe that this is the same guy who once saved a woman and all her appliances from a burning building. Sure, that was an episode of The Simpsons, but it's about the only good thing Canseco has ever done in his life. Canseco's penchant for douchery extends beyond the realms of using steroids to cheat at baseball, connecting other people to steroids so they too could cheat, then turning them all in for a fat paycheck.

Both of his wives have cited him for domestic violence, and both later divorced him. His second marriage was the classic American love story; boy meets girl working at Hooters, boy marries girl, boy hits girl, boy is arrested and put on probation, girl divorces boy, girl poses in Playboy using his last name. If those kids couldn't make it work, what chance do the rest of us have?
There's more to the story, like when he tried to blackmail Magglio Ordonez into giving him money to keep his name out of his second book. We emailed Bob Woodward to see if he ever tried blackmailing Gerald Ford, but he didn't get back to us. The Canseco saga does have a happy ending though. Jose recently lost a "celebrity" boxing match to former NFL player Vai Sikahema in which Canseco was knocked out in the first round. Now if there was only some way we could make that happen seven or eight hundred more times we'd be good.
"Waaaahhhh."

Comiskey is best known for being the former owner of the Chicago White Sox, and for their field which was named after him, before it was changed to U.S. Cellular Field in honor of Ulysses Stanton Cellular.
However, back in the day, he was best known for being a miserably cheap bastard. It stands to reason that if you own a professional sports team, you have a shitload of money, and if you spend that money to buy a sports team, something that is utterly frivolous, it stands to reason that to cheap out on running that team makes you quite the douchebag. It's just logic.

Charlie Comiskey was one such douchebag, paying his players substandard wages in a time before free agency, when they had no choice but to accept them. He promised one of his pitchers a $10,000 dollar bonus if he won thirty games in a season, but benched him right before he could reach that mark, preferring to save the money at the risk of losing some games. Also he wouldn't pay for his player's laundry. To reiterate, he bought a professional sports team, built them a stadium, then decided he'd rather they look like hobos than pay for laundry.
Of course, his stinginess ended up leading to the Black Sox Scandal, in which his team threw the World Series for cash. Cash, that one can presume went toward not smelling like shit.

John McGraw was a decent player, but as a manager he was a well-known innovator and is credited with inventing the hit and run. He also is credited with being a mean-spirited prick.
Gentlemanly conduct was a foreign concept to McGraw, who as a third baseman was known for his aggressive and undeniably immature ways of stifling opposing runners. Have you ever played with a drunk friend at a softball game who thought it'd be funny to trip people when they were running the bases and tug on people's shirts to keep them from leaving the base? Well that was McGraw, all the time, and there's a very real possibility he wasn't even drunk when he did it.
It's unfortunate that the only available pictures of McGraw show him shaking hands.
As a manager he was just as big of a douche, constantly picking fights with anybody he could, including the fans, who would in turn throw rocks and bottles at the players. The players had to get pelted with dangerous objects just because they played for this guy.
He seemed to embrace being a manager purely because it gave him a chance to wage psychological warfare on the players under him (one coach on the Giants said McGraw "...eats gunpowder every morning for breakfast and washes it down with warm blood.")
See? That doesn't make him look like a dick at all. Clever, McGraw.
McGraw actually held one major league record that stood for 75 years: the most times getting kicked out of a game. Between his time as a player and a manager, an incredible 131 times umpires decided McGraw was just acting like too much of an ass to stay on the field.
John McGraw: great at managing, even better at being a dick.

Remember when Roger Clemens was known for being a great pitcher, perhaps one of the best of all time, and the worst thing anybody had to say against him was that one time he threw a piece of a bat at Mike Piazza? We bet Roger longs for those days.
Some think Clemens' legacy has been tainted by steroids even moreso than Barry Bonds'. First came the adamant denials about steroid use, including such delicious bon mots along the lines of "If I had been using steroids I'd be pulling tractors with my teeth and have a third ear growing out of my forehead" a statement that, while asinine and condescending, also blew our fucking minds with it's utter lack of logic.

Clemens then threw one of his best friends (and steroid supplier) Brian MacNamee under the bus, even taping a conversation with him to save his own ass (it didn't). Oh, also there were all the affairs he's had including one with the wife of professional golfer/beer drinker John Daly and one with country singer Mindy McCready that started when she was fifteen.

We do think Clemens belongs in the Hall of Fame, if there is in fact a Hall of Fame for douchebags somewhere.

Yawkey owned the Boston Red Sox from 1933-1976 and the street which Fenway Park resides on is named in his honor, a tribute to a man of fortitude and conviction. Unfortunately, one of those convictions was blind, fervent racism.
Yawkey has the distinction of being the last owner to integrate his ball club, when he reluctantly let Pumpsie Green put on the Red Sox uniform and stroll out onto the field in 1959, which, to be fair to Yawkey, was a mere 12 years after Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier. That's just a smidge over a decade, right?
"Look, Honey, a Negro. Gross, right?"
That's what earns Yawkey the title of one of the biggest assholes in the Baseball Hall of Fame: determination. Ridiculous, sad, racism-fueled determination. For you see, while other teams were integrating and providing themselves with the best collection of athletes possible, Yawkey stuck with the same old white guys that had worked so well at not winning him a single World Series all those years.
They had been at the very least a contender in the salad days of segregation. Once other teams started to incorporate black players in their line up, the Red Sox started a precipitous fall down the standings board. Lesser racists would have seen the writing on the wall, or perhaps mustered up some simple human decency and accepted the fact that these black players were just as good as their white counterparts.

However, good ol' Tommy rose above all that and proceeded to keep his team the way it was, and the Red Sox proceeded to finish 10+ games out of first place from 1950 until 1966. For sticking to his racist guns at the cost of his team's success, truly Tom Yawkey is worthy of the the title "Douchebaggiest Owner in Baseball History".

Today, mustache aficionado Keith Hernandez is probably best known now as a hair dye spokesperson and for the two-part Seinfeld where he almost banged Elaine. However, before that he was a five time all star, 1979 NL co-MVP, and perhaps the best fielding first basemen of all time. Also he loved him some nose candy.
Yes, Mr. Hernandez was known for his use of the cocaine which led to his involvement in the famed Pittsburgh drug trials. Of course his own substance abuse doesn't make him an asshole, but his destructive influence on young Mets teammates Dwight Gooden and Darryl Strawberry sure does. You may remember Gooden and Strawberry as the talented young stars whose bright careers were derailed by drug and alcohol abuse. You know what probably contributed to that? Hernandez telling Strawberry the best way to break out of a slump is to go out and get shitfaced.

Hernandez didn't stop being a dick when his career ended though. In 2006 he was calling a game between the Mets and Padres when he happened to spy Padres team massage therapist Kelly Calabrese in the dugout. Keith's response? "I won't say women belong in the kitchen, but they don't belong in the dugout." It's true Keith doesn't think women belong in the kitchen. He thinks they belong in his bedroom, feeding him slices of papaya, when not servicing him sexually of course.

Needless to say, Hernandez's comment caused a bit of an uproar, but to be fair he apologized. Apologized by saying "You know I am only teasing. I love you gals out there, always have." You stay classy, Keith.








Reggie Jackson- douche bag supreme. Reggie owned a restaurant in Monterey, CA for a while. I was in there eating and in walks Mr. Jackson. A father and his young son were in the restaurant eating also- the father and his son (who had a Reggie Jackson baseball card in hand) approached Mr. Jackson. The father asked Mr. Jackson if he would sign the card for his son. Reggie replied "You can buy a signed card at the counter" to which the father answered, "Please? It's for my seven year-old son. He's a big fan." Reggie took the card from the kid, signed it then ripped it in half and gave it back to the kid repeating, "You can buy a signed card at the counter.
Replywheres bud selig? the guys THE douche ruining baseball right now.
ReplyThe Bad Mama Talker clearly had 2/10 of a hand.
ReplyLOL!!! Great Article, that exposes how insane America, and the world is, for worshiping the athletic accomplishments of a bunch of douche bag, drug addicted, womanizing, spoiled-rotten racist.
ReplyYou can find just as many popular football players and basketball players that fit into the "Legendary Asshole" category.
Now, with that being said....Go Mavericks.
Rogers Hornsby was hilariously awful. He once was in an argument and out of nowhere, punched his foe in the face. When asked about it, he said flatly "Well, I wasn't getting anywhere talking to the guy"
ReplyYep, that sounds like something Hornsby would do.
Roger Clemens was in that episode of Mythbusters where they tested baseball myths. From reading this, I can see way that episode has never been re-run.
ReplyProbably wish you could take back that bit about A-Rod being clean in the Canseco entry, huh?
ReplyNo John Rocker??
ReplyLMAO... At that Clemens photoshop!!!
Reply@LisaS212: Would it be possible for Kenesaw Mountain Landis to go f uck himself in his grave? Because he really should. You too, on behalf of your family.
ReplyI don't see Joey Belle on here.
Replygo easy on ty, he wasn't as horrible as this blog makes him out
ReplyKenesaw Mountain Landis was my grandfather's great uncle. So, yeah.
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesAnd granted he was definitely a racist douchebag, but there's also the fact that baseball was insanely on the take in the 10's and was on par with the WWE in terms of legitimate sport. Landis brought it back to respectability and out of the hands of bookies. Still a racist douchebag, and you can b***h about the exclusion of black players, but had he not intervened there might not have been a league for them to be excluded from.
Umm, this article is about baseball legends who were also legendary assholes. You just perfectly described why he is a baseball legend....which is a clear prerequisite for inclusion on this list (although Marge Schott's inclusion is questionable at best). Yes, we know he did some legendary things as commish...which is why he is: a baseball legend who also happened to be a legendary asshole.
Not quite right there Lisa. It wasn't so much Landis that brought baseball to its popularity during that time, it was a guy named George Herman Ruth.
Not quite right there Lisa. It wasn't so much Landis that brought baseball to its popularity during that time, it was a guy named George Herman Ruth.
Ty Cobb is a legend.
ReplyAnd so is Dracula.
I came to skim this and make sure Ty Cobb was #1. Good work.
ReplyLet's not forget that Bonds was racist as well.
ReplyI can't testify as to the veracity of this account, but as I understand it, Bonds was approached by a young black boy and a young white boy. After signing a baseball for the black boy, Bonds turned to the white one and said "Fuck off kid, I don't have time to sign your Goddamn baseball."
So...yeah.
because you don't even know it's true, and you're the one presenting the story as evidence of your claim, maybe you shouldn't post it.
how the fock is kevin mitchell not on this list?? yeah cat-decapitating kevin focking mitchell. you all google that crazy mothafocker
Reply"perhaps the most hollowed record in ALL of sports"
ReplyI believe the correct word is 'hallowed' - not 'hollowed'.
Maybe he meant "empty"?
I didn't know that having no hands was to supposed to grant you immunity to physical reprisal. I mean, it's not like the guy was just sitting there, minding his own handless business. He was actively insulting someone. If you can't take the consequences, keep your damn mouth shut. As for Ty Cobb's reaction being racist, the writer of the article failed to mention that the handless dude was being pretty racist as well, unless of course he thought being "half-black" was a compliment. So. . .yeah, Ty Cobb really shouldn't be number 1.
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesThey arent in ascending order in terms of douchbaggery, otherwise Canseco would be alot higher
They left out the fact that Cobb also murdered a guy with his bare hands right outside the stadium one day before a game. Also, it alludes to the fact that he fixed games, but neglects the mention the fact that he avoided a lifetime ban by having a meeting with the commissioner after which the commish mysteriously decided to drop all inquiries. It's rumored that Cobb and fellow game-fixer Tris Speaker threatened his life.
I didn't know that verbal abuse was supposed to warrant physical reprisal.
It's also funny that you try to justify a racist beating up a handicapped man by saying Cobb's victim was racist too. Considering Cobb was a well known racist, it's possible the guy tossed out the "half-black" comment as a troll knowing it would piss him off as nothing else could, too. So, he might not have been racist - although he probably was.
Regardless, being a racist and saying rude things combined are still not enough justification for anyone - let alone a professional athlete - to pound on someone incapable of fighting back.
No Dave Kingman?
Reply