Register

The 5 Lamest Disasters in Disaster Movie History

By Steve Clark August 28, 2008 661,048 views
article image

Hollywood loves a good disaster and, let's face it, the end of the world looks cool as hell on screen. If you show us a bunch of exploding monuments, we'll buy a ticket.

But apparently Hollywood ran out of the really good disasters a long time ago, because sometimes they end up using disasters that appear to be just barely more than mild inconveniences. Such as:

#5.
Volcano

The Disaster:

When the La Brea Tar Pits inexplicably turn into a goddamn volcano, it's up to a plucky geologist (Anne Heche) and a Dedicated Emergency Management director who can't fry up scrambled eggs without injuring himself (Tommy Lee Jones) to save Los Angeles from the river of lava now flowing down Wilshire Boulevard.

Why They Should Calm The Hell Down:

After a character points out early in the film that some volcanoes can erupt with the force of a nuclear blast, we find out that, wait, no, the one under LA is really small. It barely erupts at all, really, just oozes lava down the street.

Here's the interesting thing about lava: It's not very fast. Wait, did we say interesting? We meant boring.


"Hurry, the lava's gaining on us, we only have three minutes. And six hours. And eleven days."

Sure, on a particularly steep slope, a lava flow might get up past 6 miles per hour but on more gentle inclines it tends to top off at about 1/2 a mile per hour, only slightly faster than a turtle can walk. So of course the movie has tons of scenes on steep inclines, so the lava can come rushing down on the characters, right?

Not at all! They even have a scene where a character sets a basketball on the street to figure out which way the ground is sloping, thus establishing firmly that Wilshire Blvd is the safest place on earth to be in the event of a volcano.

That leaves the screenwriters with the uncomfortable task of trying to find ways to make this easygoing safety hazard more exciting. So, in one scene, a palm tree catches fire and falls over, conveniently trapping the heroes between an overturned bus and the creeping tide of molten death. Later, a handful of people on a subway train have to be rescued because not one of them is smart enough to figure out how to use the door on a subway car without outside help.

Finally, the lava breaks several laws of physics to race across town via an underground tunnel and spring out of the middle of the road near Cedar Sinai Hospital, but then it just starts crawling along exactly the way it did on the other side of town.

How They Solve the "Problem":

How do you re-route a lava flow and send it harmlessly into the ocean? Simple: You blow up a huge fucking building! Seriously, to save the city from a threat that can be easily out-walked, they topple a large building, killing two people in the process. If they ever make a sequel, they should save a city from a glacier by burning down an orphanage.


"We'll build a lava blockade using every available fire truck."

Most Laughable Brush With "Danger":

An old lady walks away from the lava that's engulfing her house, but she left her tiny little dog inside! The dog, realizing that he's in no danger whatsoever, runs over to the lava and barks at it.

Then, he scampers out the doggy door to tell all his little doggy friends that lava is a huge pussy.

#4.
Twister

The Disaster:

When a large stormfront threatens to let loose a number of tornadoes in an area commonly known as the "Tornado Belt," it's up to a plucky Storm Chaser (Hellen Hunt) and a guy with the regrettable nickname "The Extreme" (Bill Paxton) to put a bunch of little plastic balls into one of the tornadoes for science.

Why They Should Calm The Hell Down:

We're certainly not going to argue that tornadoes aren't a destructive force of nature. That would be retarded. However, it's important to keep in mind that the average tornado-related event doesn't actually last very long, certainly not long enough to base an entire movie around.

The solution, obviously, was to make a movie about people who are dumb enough to run right up to one tornado after another and try to stick their balls in it.

But, even if you're willing to buy into the idea that the heroes' mission is worth all this ridiculous weather chasing, and some people obviously do, you're still left with the fact that these particular tornadoes are pretty much wimps. Sure, they're ready to tear a house apart or throw around the occasional cow, but time and time again the heroes drive right up to the funnel clouds, as if you actually have to jam your head inside one for it to hurt you.

For the big finale, our protagonists actually pass through into the eye of an F-5 tornado (read: a seriously fucking dangerous tornado) and emerge completely unharmed because they hung on really tight.


"This was such a stupid idea."

Yes, unharmed by the tornado that's full of debris flying around at speeds that can drive a piece of straw through a tree trunk.

How They Solve the "Problem":

Keep in mind that the situation that needs solving isn't the actual tornadoes themselves but rather the problem of getting a bunch of little plastic balls into one of these tornadoes. So, it makes sense that the day would be saved by Pepsi Cola.

See, the balls need to stay up in the air, so the heroes make tiny little propellers out of Pepsi cans. We can only imagine the inevitable, blood-drenched terror when these things finally spin their way down toward some poor farmer and his helpless family.

Most Laughable Brush With "Danger":

In an early scene, the main characters are stuck in a giant ditch with a tornado bearing down on them, and they don't even have time to turn on the machine with all those balls in it! So, they hide under a small wooden bridge. We'll go ahead and assume that it's perfectly normal for somebody to build a bridge over a ditch.

Anyway, the tornado steals their truck, dismantles most of the little bridge, and then just disappears with its tail between its legs, apparently frightened away by Helen Hunt.

#3.
Daylight

The Disaster:

When a gang of astoundingly dimwitted jewel thieves crash their car into a convoy of trucks loaded down with toxic waste and the resulting explosion blocks off a section of the Hudson Tunnel, it's up to a plucky playwright (Amy Brenneman) and a cab driver who used to be the Emergency Medical Services Chief (Sylvester Stallone) to drag the few remaining survivors to safety.

Why They Should Calm The Hell Down:

The explosion must have been caused by some revolutionary new kind of clean-burning toxic waste, because nobody has any trouble breathing in that tunnel. Then again, most of these characters come into direct contact with the flames from that explosion, and none of them appear to have any burns on them, so this might actually be some kind of undercover superhero movie.

Since the smoke doesn't seem to have any effect and even fire can't hurt these people, screenwriter Leslie Bohem tries to come up with a new excuse for excitement every few minutes. At first, it seems like rising water levels will add a sense of danger to the proceedings, but the water is so slow to rise that it acts more as a vague annoyance than an actual crisis.

Then, Stallone takes a shot at livening things up by blowing up a big-ass gas tanker, ostensibly trying to slow down the water even more somehow. It almost seems dangerous because Stallone runs into some unexplained technical difficulties and he can't get quite as far from the explosion as he'd like to, but then he just jumps out of the way (a technique often referred to as a "Stallone" ).

As near as we can tell, his efforts have no noticeable effect on the rising water.

In the rare instances when danger does leap out and grab somebody by the ass, it tends to seem more confusing than anything. At one point a guy apparently falls through the road just because he walked on it and it was wet (how the hell does this only happen once?) and then an old lady sits down and just sort of dies, presumably from boredom.

How They Solve the "Problem":

It all comes down to the brave rescue efforts of a friendly parade of rats.

The rats, who apparently weren't in any particular hurry to leave the ever-so-slowly-crumbling tunnel, eventually swim over to our protagonists and kindly show them the way out, which is something we think they stole from a cartoon.

Most Laughable Brush With "Danger":

As the survivors make their way to safety, having successfully climbed a rickety staircase, they realize that the dog needs help getting up the steps! Bravely, Stallone risks his life to pull a fucking dog up a flight of steps!

And the dog makes it! Stallone, on the other hand, falls back into the water and has to find his own damn way out of the tunnel. We think the dog planned that.

Ugh. I knew there was a Day of the Triffids movie, but I only knew about it in the same way you know that there's a septic treatment plant somewhere near where you live. You're aware of it, and want to never hear or speak of it again. Day of the Triffids was an amazing book, and the author's son made an excellent sequel in Night of the Triffids. This movie seems to have taken novel to video adoptions to a whole new low.

10/26/2009 10:46:25 PM
Tylendal

You missed the lamest plot ever- "Frogs"
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0068615/
The monsters are frogs, turtles, snakes, birds, and all the other little creatures that you might expect to find on an island on a lake. Not big versions of these creatures, or reptiles that have gained mutant powers (although that could have been made to work, considering the plot).

In one scene, a guy gets crushed to death by roughly 50 small frogs jumping on him.

The best part is the end, where the main character finally gets off the island, walks out on the road and hitches a ride with the first car that comes along, despite being barefoot, no shirt, and carrying a shotgun.

10/6/2009 5:28:40 PM
tempestv

that actually happens to ppl. not alot, but some ppl survive tornados

10/6/2009 5:14:35 PM
infinty

Twister was totally unreal! Who the f**k rides through a tornado and emerges alive? I laughed my ass off in the movie during that scene!

Un-f*****g-beleivable!

10/6/2009 1:06:51 PM
jlew911

this is kinda nit-pickish but backfires arn't suppost to steal oxygen they get rid of any possible fuel for the fire making a kind of firebreak

9/25/2009 7:13:04 AM
craftyfirestorm

I hadn't heard there was a Day of the Triffids movie. It looks like a painful desecration of one of my favorite books...

8/21/2009 8:57:00 PM
Daleksammich

"Yes, unharmed by the tornado that's full of debris flying around at speeds that can drive a piece of straw through a tree trunk."

not quite true, but point well taken. The debris is what makes a tornado so dangerous so it is really something that they get to just hang on and watch without taking a fence post to the face.

8/21/2009 7:06:30 AM
Conformist138

Yeah, The Happening should have really been on here. After paying to watch that movie, I felt exactly as if I had been mugged by the makers.

8/12/2009 8:14:16 AM
Colombus

Actually, The Happening was a movie in which... angry plants somehow destroy the human instinct for self-preservation, causing people to commit mass suicide. Yeah, that makes no goddamned sense whatsoever.

7/11/2009 2:40:38 PM
Luigifan

Volcano? Seriously? There are a couple problems with your reasoning.

1. While you can outrun most lava (there are some rare places where lava can move up to 50 mph), I doubt you can get half of Los Angeles evacuated with a less than 30% death rate.

2. Given the lack of volcanic history in Southern California, they really should plan for every possible scenario. Hope for the best, plan for the worst.

3. What laws of physics does a lava tube break? From the little I remember from my geology classes, that is what lava would do in a lava tube, which a subway tunnel would be.

The real problem is that when you breath in ash, it blends with the moisture in your lungs and forms a kind of cement. Tommy Lee Jones would have been dead by the time the cops showed up.

All in all, the geology is pretty sound. The real problem with the movie is that it is poorly explained. If it really happened, the deaths and economic damage would smash all records and hold them until the next world war. Of all the movies mentioned, this is by far the most likely. It's an amazing diaster done really poorly.

4/15/2009 9:13:50 PM
dizzypdx

In the book, didn't the triffids have like, huge, spine ridden club-like tongues that they smacked people around with? It was incredibly wordy, but they were portrayed as more fightenting in the novel than this movie version.

4/2/2009 10:36:19 AM
ROCKET-JOE

The Core didn't make the list because the disaster (getting fried by microwaves) is portrayed as real in the movie. It's stupid, sure, but in that alternate dimension of fucked-up physics, it's very very real. OTOH, the triffids are fvcking lame monsters, the unrealism doesn't begin to matter.

3/10/2009 2:00:21 PM
MissVigilant

What about The Core? For no reason the Earth will stop spinning so they plant nukes in the center of the planet to get it to start spinning again. Ridiculous on a wider scale.

2/21/2009 7:49:25 PM
phoebe

"The Happening" wins this list hands down. It's supposed to be a disaster movie, but there's really no disaster. People just die for no reason. Also, the name is really ironic since nothing actually happens in the movie.

2/19/2009 6:48:56 AM
MikeO

... Oh - I forgot A-Little-Smartass-No-One-Wants-To-Listen-To-Until-It's-Too-Late, a Token Black Guy who meets a tragical fate, some awesome pseudo-scientific bullshit, a Deus-Ex-Machina, and of course the President of the United States of America.

So. You have the recipe for every disaster flick ever made.

2/18/2009 4:49:51 AM
MajorDSaster

I love silly disaster movies. The sillier the better. Especially those that tell you that *every single problem* can be solved with a nuclear bomb (or several nuclear bombs, when the s**t really hits the fan).

Add a few tear-jerking casualties, campy heroics, a lame muscial score, a bad-guy-who-does-not-want-to-believe-a-disaster-is-coming-and-gets-his-comeuppance-in-the-end, a Heroe's Death, a Mother's Love AND someone saving a dog, and the fun is perfect.

2/18/2009 2:46:43 AM
MajorDSaster

Zombieplants = freakin awesome. although 28 weeks later zombieplants = MADNESS!!!

2/15/2009 5:09:23 AM
mindmatter

Triffids sound like zombies. Slow? No danger unless their at arm's length? If the had some sort of ability to horde or the movie was done more like a zombie plant thing...then maybe it would be an OK film I never watched because I'm about 20 years too young.

2/15/2009 3:14:01 AM
Dax

The triffids thing was actually made into a Norwegian radioshow now that I come to think of it. Scared me shitless, but then again I've never really trusted plants.

2/15/2009 2:56:24 AM
Raijn

Have you guys ever heard of a millionaire dating site called ^^^^^^^^millionaireloves.com^^^^^^^^? My friend suggestted me to find a pretty girl there because they have seen some really great girls there. Just wondering if all the girls there are looking for money rather than true love.

2/15/2009 2:10:46 AM
LisaMarie001
Cracked stuff on