8 Classic Movie Robots That Actually Suck at Their Job
Basically, robots can make everything cooler, from wars to weddings. Hollywood knows this and tries, when possible, to give us what we crave in the form of kickass robots with kickass abilities.
Most of the time, though, these robots that look so cool on screen are so incompetent at their jobs, they'd have had better luck just sending a random intern to do it. Such as:
Terminator asks us to believe a computer becomes sentient and begins building an army of machines to wipe out the humans who survive the nuclear holocaust that the computer creates. Machines that look like kickass chrome skeletons with laser Gatling guns and shit, stomping across fields of skulls, grinning like Dick Cheney.
Then the computer, demonstrating child-like frustration at having only murdered about 5.8 billion people, sends a Terminator back in time to take out the most annoying human before he knows how to fight back. At this point a cocker spaniel-haired waitress and then her smart-ass kid, manage to outwit the thing three different times.
That alone should be proof of the laughable incompetence of the grossly misnamed Terminator. But it gets worse.
As witnessed in T3, Arnold Schwarzenegger's Terminator (a T-800) has a little battery thing in his chest that basically acts like a nuclear device when he needs it to. Why didn't the original, whilst crawling through the machines that eventually crushed it, just use that to kill Sarah Connor? We may never know.
You'd be tempted to call the T-800 the lamest possible Terminator, but in the sequel, Skynet sends back a super advanced T-1000. So advanced it has to be within reaching distance to kill someone since it can only stab. Apparently sending the terminators back in time with some kind of pamphlet on how to build an effective bomb was out of the question, as was programming them to not ask the name of their victim then stare at them for an extended period of time before slowly drawing a weapon.
The cruel irony of it all is, with an army of machines that incompetent, it didn't take John Connor to wipe them out. All mankind needed to do was find a hiding place until the machines accidentally killed themselves somehow.
Brainchild of the most sinister man in all of future Detroit, Dick Jones, the ED-209 is the most kick-ass fully-armored chicken ever. Inspired by anime and probably one or two video games, Eddie was a hard ass, even if he didn't work quite right.
So what's the problem? As a law enforcement robot, we're left to wonder, even if it didn't malfunction, what exactly was it planning on doing? It doesn't have hands, or any ability to transport people to jail. It just has giant machine guns. Was there actually a more peaceful way to end this scenario?
If these had been mass produced and set free in town, could they even issue traffic tickets or just blow the shit out of people who double park?
And, no, we can't avoid mentioning that the thing was ultimately defeated because it couldn't walk down a flight of stairs.
Notable for being one of the Transformers in Michael Bay's movie that isn't Bumblebee or Optimus Prime, making him essentially useless, Ratchet developed an extra layer of pointlessness when we found out he was the medical officer.
For a group of robots.
Arguably, any self-aware robot with some spare time and good sense would have skimmed through a few issues of Popular Mechanics or a Reader's Digest DIY home electronics repair book, maybe picked up a cheap set of tools down at Wal-Mart and been pretty much able to handle his own shit from then on.
Thus, in the only scene in which it seems Ratchet has something to do (which is try to figure out why Bumblebee has lost his voice), he shoots Bumblebee in the face with some kind of laser, confirms the other robot can't talk, and that he ain't doing shit to fix it.
Ratchet is the Cybertronian equivalent of man boobs.
Everyone loves good old R2. From the first time some witty scribe made a joke about him looking just like a garbage can back in the '70s, right up to today, he's one of cinema's favorite robots. This is probably due to the fact that, unlike the image C-3PO portrays which is something like a cross between Frasier Crane and a transvestite showgirl, R2 just beeps and tries to fix stuff.
R2 is so impressive that, apparently, no matter what changes were made in robotics technology between Anakin Skywalker's childhood up to his reign as Darth Vader, he didn't become obsolete. In fact, he's apparently better than all the other robots of his design. Not bad.
On the other hand, we're not 100 percent sure what R2-D2 is good at. Admittedly, in a jam, whenever there's a waist-high computer interface handy, R2 can plug in and unlock a door somewhere, but what is it he does out on the X-wing? Beyond idle chit-chat on a head's-up display, can't he only repair damages within about two feet of the hole he's jammed in? What if one of those crafty Imperials shoots a wing off? R2 is about as screwed as Luke at that point, we assume.
Thanks to George Lucas' creative tinkering/dipshittery in the prequels, R2 became retroactively more arbitrary and useless when we learned he could fly, something that could have come in handy many, many times during the original trilogy. You know, had Lucas thought of it back then.
That is of course the real problem with R2: He's just a little rolling Deus Ex Machina device, who can pull out the right tool in any random situation as though he were Inspector Gadget. When the same tool would be handy in dozens of other situations, it's never seen again. So either it's bad writing or R2 is in a union.








Terminators cannot "self-terminate". I'm not entirely sure why Skynet included that in their programming. I mean, aside from removing the most effective way to ensure Sarah Connor's death, was Skynet really that worried its killbots would WANT to kill themselves?
ReplyHmm, I'll probably get torn apart here for defending Transformers, but I think your assessment of Ratchett's usefulness was a bit undeveloped. I mean, yes, any transformer can presumably get a toolkit (or whatever) and learn a bit of engineering maintenance, just as a human can learn first aid and get a first-aid kit. But if you're in a major car crash, chances are you'll still want to see a doctor.
ReplyI agree. And Ratchet can actually fight, can't he? I remember him sawing off a limb or two with a surgical saw.
Actually, the "Arnold" Terminator in Rise of the Machines was built far later than one ones in the first 2. It wasn't a normal model, it was built to look like the T-800 to fool John Connor in the future.
ReplyBasically, he was to real T-800s what an emulator is to the original game system.
What is an emulator?
The Terminators still all had nuclear cores, as we learn from Terminator: Salvation. Besides, whatever powercore it had could still have been powerful enough to at least take out the restaurant where he initially spotted her.
Didn't R2-D2 get his rockets broken off around the beginning of "Revenge of the Sith"? I'm guessing that's why he doesn't fly; it also means nobody was willing to shell out a few credits for replacements. Also the T-1000 DID use guns, and in T3 the self-destructing part was not THAT big of a stretch given the fact that an hour earlier the T-800 was suffering a crisis of programming.
ReplyI'm sure dozens of screaming Star Wars fanboys have beat me to the punch on this, but the purpose of having R2 or any astromech droid in the X-wing or any other hyperdrive-capable starfighter is because job #1 for an astromech is computing pathways through hyperspace. You know how Han Solo says in New Hope, while having the computer on the much bigger Millenium Falcon compute the coordinates, that "travel through hyperspace ain't like dusting crops"? Any starfighter that wasn't exclusively carrier-based (like TIE fighters are based out of Star Destroyers) and was capable of hyperdrive travel needed an astromech droid to compute the path through hyperdrive. Now, you may ask, why couldn't they just fit a hyperdrive computer into the space on the X-Wing occupied by the astromech droid? Well, the answer is f**k you. Also, the astromech droids supposedly could conduct in flight repairs of the starfighters. You know, anything within the 1 foot radius circle of starfighter parts that the astromech droid could actually reach. Why couldn't they just have something built onto the starfighter to do this, instead of needing to be removed or reinstalled all the time? Because f**k you, that's why.
ReplyA hyperspace computer that can't detach and follow you around to hack doors for you when you board an enemy ship is much less useful than a non-stationary one that does. If nothing else, you could use it as a meat shield.
Not a classic movie by any stretch (unless you count being featured in an MST3K episode as classic), but probably the most epic fail I've seen in a robot is the one in Robot Vs. The Aztec Mummy. Lets just say the titular battle doesn't last long, the robot is slow and useless, and it doesn't even have knees! Gotta love those old B-film robots.
ReplyWow! There's someone besides me whose actually saw that piece of shit. Slowest fight EVER.
Box put up a much more competent fight than Dr. Krupp's robot against the Aztec Mummy, if you ask me.
Wasn't Johnny-5 fitted with a laser gun? Why not just manufacture those and sell them to the military?
ReplyThe Terminator Does Not Blow Sarah Conner up in the factory because he would be Knowingly killing himself,... and terminators cannot Terminate themselves as you will see tords the end of the second one,.... and in the 3 one we can assume he was upgraded with the ability to kill himself,.... Leave R2 Alone He Piolets The Ship and In The Prequel it Shows that in flight he can come out of the hole and crawl around the ship,.... Senitals Have Lasers and Bombs,...
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesWhen did they install computers in mental hospitals?
Why is "The Terminator Does Not Blow Sarah Conner" capitalized? Is it a movie? I would see that movie. "Leave R2 Alone He Piolets The Ship and In The Prequel it Shows," not so much...
your spelling is atrocious. I'm with omegacat about the capitalization bit. But your point is correct. Terminators going about terminating themselves would just be emo. R2D2 does the hyperspace computations, carries message cubes, has a little bitty laser, and is programmed for repair. His rockets got destroyed in 3. As Luke says in the beginning of episode 4...Those little droids were in pretty bad shape.
Actually the t1000 does use guns, he just can't turn into one.
ReplySure these have been mentioned already, but the Terminator in T3 was a different model than the one in the first two movies, and in response to "What else does R2D2 do in the X-Wing?"- he's also the navigator.
ReplyI reeeeally didnt like the terminator in the 3rd movie. Because that movie was stupid. first you had a machine wirelessly control cars that require manual manipulation to move (Impossible/Magical). But it got worse, with the nuclear battery scene.
ReplyIt CREATED A SMALL MUSHROOM CLOUD. Theres no such thing! Mushroom clouds arent created because of a fission or fusion blast, they are created by anything blowing up in ridiculous amounts. Clearly, it was not ridiculous power when used in Terminator 3, because youd be torn to shreds if you were that close. Like sarah connors dream.
So how the hell did any of that scene make sense? it DIDNT. At all. it was stupid stupid stupid stupid STUPID. I mean who the hell had this idea, who signed off on it, and how many people worked making the effect itself? Did NONE of them think they should maybe research mushroom clouds first? Or even go to Wikipedia's page on them?
Apparently, No.
The problem here is that you're associating Hollywood with Physics. Reminders of this torrid and ill destined love affair are not welcome, espicially by Physics, as the spousal abuse was horrific.
Actually small mushroom clouds can be made with the right manipulation of combustion and airflow. The mushroom shape is created when air is annihilated and the air around it rushes in to fill the gap, which is then sucked upward usually due to intense heat. All you'd need to do is ensure upward movement after completely destroying the air around the explosive and voila! Mushroom cloud.
Robot apocalypses are a lot like zombie apocalypses in that they're supposed to be metaphors, but yeah, that still doesn't excuse how effective terminator and matrix bots can be in one scene and how incompetent the next.
ReplyI never understood why R2-D2 couldn't talk. You'd think it'd be much more useful if you could actually communicate with your droid without having to learn it's weirdo language. Or was he made for some aliens who communicate by beeping? If so, why couldn't he just be re-programmed to speak English (or... "Human" or whatever they call English in Star Wars)?
ReplyOn the other hand, if it talked, it might be a lot more annoying, actually. At least with George Lucas's writing.
Also... the X-Wing thing is a very good point... wouldn't it make more sense to give the X-Wing a bunch of robotic hands all over and with artificial intelligence so it could fix its own damn self?
I am tired of people asking why the original Terminator didn't use the battery to blow up Sarah in the first movie. You have forgotten that the Terminators can not self-terminate.
Reply Hide All See All 4 RepliesWhich is negated in T-3, where he holds on to T-X and detonates his core. And he can allow events to happen that wil kill him, so...throw the core.
Sligking, in the original Terminator (which Predaprince, and indeed Cracked, were mentioning) it was sent back by Skynet, T-3 it was another re-formatted one sent by the humans, WITHOUT the same programmed rules, i.e. Self-Termination is now possible ^_^
It's true that T3 was sent back by humans reprogrammed - but so was T2! The Connors sent T-800s back in time to protect Connor twice, but only one can self-terminate. So - do they give them that option or take it away? Frankly, it makes more sense that Skynet would permit self-termination, because why would it care? The Terminators still orders, and exploding Terminator is worse news for humans than for robots.
Why would you design a war robot that can't "self-terminate"? This isn't an Asimov story. And don't get me started of the stupidity of the Terminators having to time-travel naked.
In reference to Ratchet, there was a great line in the current Transformers tv show that pretty much sums up what Ratchet does. When asked why cant they just "repair" a robots damaged part, Ratchet responds "can you rebuild your internal organs?"
ReplyNo, but we can get donor organs and the TFs can get parts to replace their damaged ones.
Yes, depending on what it is and the extent of the damage, you can rebuild internal organs (ie bones [yes they are organs], the millions of cells constantly dying making up various parts of your organs and are being replaced, etc...). We can also repair our skin, which is also an organ, and muscle tissue...so...yeah.
And you can fix car parts, so why couldn't one fix a giant robot part?
What no Wall-E?? That robot can't do s**t except stack garbage.
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesStacking garbage is his job...
Please explain to me how being able to stack garbage makes Wall-E bad at his job of stacking garbage.
Agreed w/ThatDaveDude1 except on one count... WALL*E was a garbage compactor and he was great at it. He even excelled at stacking the compacted garbage. Didja even SEE those garbage skyscrapers he built?
Seriousl, Wall-E was -great- at his job It was a s****y job, smashing trash in to cubes, but he did it, and made a whole city out of trash cubes. That's efficiency. A lesser trash compactor robot might have set the cubes where they were formed and boxed himself in in a matter of hours.
I think Ed209 is hot - he would be the perfect boyfriend. *sigh*
ReplyI wouldn't like your odds of surviving your first sexual encounter.
I think we should let the robots have their flaws... you know, for the upcoming robot war...
ReplyThis of corse, is where hollywood shows it's genius.
what i don't get is how a trash-can-robot's interface plugs still fit into the (useless-to-humans) sockets on separatist ships and 20 YEARS LATER on imperial ships, while being designed for naboo ships which probably weren't mil-spec.
ReplyIt's a movie. Just go with it.
it's the standardization wave. It attacked the Empire first and now it's coming for us... that's why most cell phones now have the same plug, and why your PS3 can be used to charge cells. because someday, the Force KNOWS we'll need a standard robotic interlink to save the NEW rebels from evil.
I paid $32.67 for a XBOX 360 and my mom got a 17 inch Toshiba laptop for $94.83 being delivered to our house tomorrow by FedEX. I will never again pay expensive retail prices at stores. I even sold a 46 inch HDTV to my boss for $650 and it only cost me $52.78 to get. Here is the website we using to get all this stuff, FullBids.com
Reply