The 10 Most Insane Medical Practices in History
Cracked.com's new book is now on sale. What follows is one of 22 classic articles that appear in the book, along with 18 new articles that you can't read anywhere else.
Have you ever been left with the impression after a thorough poking, prodding and testicular cupping at the doctor's office that perhaps they don't always know what's best? The thought is usually pushed from your mind, after all these people had to go through years of school and thousands of dollars of their wealthy parents' money to get where they are! If you can't trust them about your health, who can you trust?Here's the thing though, doctors have a long storied background of not knowing what the hell they're doing. History is filled with stories of hilarious medical ineptitude, and in all likeliness, today's medical practices will be similarly snorted at 100 years down the road. In other words, if you're looking to justify your medical phobia so you can rationalize not getting that ever-growing lump on your neck checked out, you're in the right place.

In the 19th century, people were simply too busy churning butter, waxing their moustaches or changing in and out of 15 layers of undergarments every time they went to take a piss to be bothered with disobedient children. To aide the stressed 19th-century mother, a series of "soothing syrups," lozenges and powders were created, all which were carefully formulated to ensure they were safe for use by those most vulnerable members of the family. Oh, no, wait. Actually, they pumped each bottle full of as many narcotics as it could hold.
For instance, each ounce of Mrs. Winslow's Soothing Syrup contained 65 mg of pure morphine.

Based on our experiences teething and experimenting with pure morphine, that seems like a lot. Finally in 1910 the New York Times decided the whole narcotic-babysitter concept was probably bad in the long run, and ran an article pointing out that these soothing syrups contained, "...morphin sulphate, chloroform, morphine hydrochloride, codeine, heroin, powdered opium, cannabis indica," and sometimes several of them in combination.

You can't say the soothing syrups weren't effective, as long as you didn't mind your toddler being strung out on the midnight oil or, you know, dead. That's right, the terrible 2s weren't just a cutesy euphemism back then. Kids were not only at their brattiest but also often died, in many cases after their parents tried to cure the aforementioned brattiness with narcotic concoctions that would give Lindsay Lohan a nose bleed.

That was the thinking for centuries, when Mercury was used to treat pretty much anything and everything. Scraped your knee? Just rub a little mercury on it. Having some problems with regularity? Forget fiber, time to get some mercury up in there! If you lived more than 100 years ago, you simply weren't considered healthy if you weren't leaking silver from at least one orifice.
Mercury, as we now know, is toxic as hell. Symptoms of mercury poisoning include chest pains, heart and lung problems, coughing, tremors, violent muscle spasms, psychotic reactions, delirium, hallucinations, suicidal tendencies, restless spleen syndrome, testicular twisting and anal implosion. OK, we just made the last few up, but they barely looked out of place on that horror show list of symptoms did they?

It's a testament to just how cool a substance Mercury is that people kept trying to cure shit with it for 1,000 years after everybody who ingested it dropped dead. "Yes my Lord, I'm afraid another member of your court has perished. The autopsy showed it was Silver Liver Syndrome. Not even the gallons of wicked-awesome Mercury we fed him could bring him back to health."
There was a silver lining, though, as it helped to fight the spread of STDs. Mercury was used as a cure for syphilis and to its credit, the "cure" usually resulted in one less person with syphilis in the world. It's generally believed Mozart was poisoned by mercury-based syphilis cures, which contradicts the film Amadeus in which he was killed by writing too much music somehow.

Well you probably don't need us to tell you how addictive and destructive a drug heroin really is, but just in case ... Heroin? Might want to avoid that stuff. On the upside, it actually does suppress coughs, so if you do decide to become a junkie at least you'll save on buying Halls.
Heroin, by the way, was originally developed by Bayer. You know, those friendly folks behind harmless old aspirin.
Oh, and while we're taking on the man, we should also mention that Bayer used to be called IG Farben, a pharmaceutical and chemical conglomerate that allegedly sponsored experiments by Nazi torturers. How is this not at the center of every single Tylenol ad campaign: the fast acting pain reliever that has never sponsored Nazi torture camps.

Electrified beds, elaborate cock shocking electric belts and other strange devices were advertised as being able to return "male power" and prowess by making your penis rise to electrified attention like Frankenstein's 6-inch-tall monster.

Photo courtesy of The Museum of Quackery.
What's fascinating is that you can find ads for more than one brand of electric dick-shock belt. That seems to indicate that the dick-shock belt industry somehow survived the negative word of mouth from the first dick-shock belt.


Congratulations hypothetical version of yourself living in the 1940s, you've just been lobotomized! Lobotomies were a popular fad for the first half of the 20th century and were floated as a "cure" for pretty much any mental issue you can name, from conditions as serious as schizophrenia to something as mild as depression or anxiety.

The inventor of the lobotomy was given a Nobel Prize for it in 1949. Doctors claimed the "ice-pick-to-the- freaking-eye" method of lobotomy would be as quick and easy as a trip to the dentist. By 1960, parents were getting them for their moody teenage children.
This practice didn't hang around as long as some on our list, but still some 70,000 people were lobotomized before somebody figured out that driving a spike into the brain probably was not the answer to all of life's problems.








#1: Get a copy of the movie "Hysteria" (starring Maggie Gyllenhaal). Yes, it was popular. And the reason for the hand cramps was that women of that era were wound up so tight that it sometimes took over an hour for them to reach "hysterical paroxysm". The invention of the vibrator was a joyful day, not just for the ladies, but for the exhausted doctors. Gives carpal tunnel a whole new shine, don't it?
ReplyI thought lobotomies were and are useful in some circumstances.
ReplyAren't you mistaking lobotomies with proper surgical methods for reducing intra-cranial pressure?
My psychology professor claims there are a few shrinks tht still practice it but it's by and large considered quackery
Heroin does have medicinal properties when used properly. In fact in Europe it is still used in "pain cocktails" for the control of severe pain. It is more effective but shorter acting than morphine. It would certainly work as a cough suppressant just as codeine does--which by the way is just a less effective form. Heroin, Morphine and codeine are all opiates, from the opium poppy. Here's a little interesting historical note: Heroin was first developed and used as a "safe and non-addictive" cure for Morphine addiction and abuse. Medical science at work.
ReplyI peed on a jellyish sting and it totally felt better, so I'm calling bullshit on that one.
ReplyProbably the only good thing that came of watching Friends.
You're fortunate, as there are certain jellyfish nematocysts that will fire more rapidly in the presence of urine, causing greater irritation. Vinegar is what's actually recommended to deactivate nematocysts.
15 years or so ago, when I was a young kid, I remember me and my friends laugher at this poor kid because he told us his grandmother was sick, and some witch lady she went to told her to drink a family members piss. Never could I imagine there actually is such a thing. And I do hope that kid never had to hear "In the cup sweetie, grandma needs it..."
ReplyI recently did a report on Project 4.1, a test that observed humans reactions to nuclear fallout in the Marshall islands. It would be cool to see that on this list. Does anyone know about any more recent crazy experiments? Ones that happened in modern times?
ReplyI read a magazine, just a couple of years ago, while waiting in a doctor's office (an acute care clinic) that had an article about acupuncture as a treatment for infertility. I showed it to the doctor, and she threw the magazine away, except the cover with the subscription info, and said she would make sure the clinic would unsubscribe (it wasn't a journal; it was Prevention, or the print version of WedMD, or something like that).
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesIf you dig back in history, you can find crazy theories and treatments that have been debunked, or "best efforts," like laudanum for dysentery-- basically, an opiate, the side effect of which was constipation, which kept you from dying of dehydration or electrolyte imbalance cardiopathy while your immune system fought the dysentery.
But people do crazy things now, when they should know better. Homeopathy wasn't completely batshit insane (just slightly wacko) in 1840. It is now, but people still use it.
It we probably "Prevention" magazine which subscribes to non-traditional therapies (as indicated by the article). I'm pleased to see that scientists are at least taking the time to really test many of these folk-remedies and alternative treatments. Just as acupuncture has been proven to be efffective for SOME things (like migraine--but NOT infertility) we shouldn't throw away anything without testing because it might surprise us. Magnetism is another example--they now believe a directed magnetic treatment can cure severe depression. And consider how many folk-remedies have merit. Who knows what we haven't found yet. Still it is disturbing that so many people continue to believe in disproven methods. Mostly because they are convinced that there is a conspiracy between the pharmacuetical companies (and by extension the government) to hide "natural" and alternative cures from the people. Right, like they wouldn't be the first to cash in.
Exactly. Acupuncture works really well for some things. It really helped my husband's chronic myofacial pain. But it's not going to up your guy's sperm count or make you ovulate if you aren't already doing so.
Yep. You never know what will work, or what is really a perfectly good cure under another name. If you said you had a headache, and I told you to drink a tea of willow bark, you might call me an idiot. But willow bark is where aspirin comes from. Those old wives knew a lot of stuff, and not all of it was crap.
1. The electrical dick-shock thing is still used. It's used to stimulate ejaculation in men who have severed spinal cords at a certain level. It allows them to father biological children.
Reply2. The guy who invented lobotomies was killed by one of the guys he lobotomized :)
I'm a female hysteria survivor.
ReplyIf I had a time machine I'd definitely be a Victorian doctor curing female hysteria, hehehehehe.
ReplyEasy to say...you don't get to choose your patients though... eckk.
I guess anything can be too much of a good thing--after all, the doctors wound up inventing the electric dildo!
"No man can stop the world Mulder, I don't care how many holes he has in his head."--Agent Scully, episode Orison, X-Files, greates show EVER!
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesAlso considering how fucked in the head my parents THOUGHT I was growing up, I am so glad I didn't live in the 60s or earlier. Come to find out now that environmental stimuli (Aka NURTURE) most likely led me to devlope the disorders that I had. I am not saying that its all about nurture, yes there are most likely genetics involved too, but consider this. Now that I have cut my parents out of 99% of my life (Only seeing them on holidays) I have been able to successfully go off all the medication they forced on me starting when I was 11. I highly doubt it's that much of a coincidence. In fact I am going off of an anti anxiety med now, after finding out that due to my parents pushing the doctor I was on a ridiculously high dose for WAY too many years, and the withdrawal is debilitating me to the point where I can barely get out of bed. I was on 4 times the average dose for over 7 years, and on the drug period for 15 years. Can you imagine the HELL I am in now that I am being weened off? It's the last medication to go, and besides the physical side effects, my emotional stability has remained constant. Moral of the story? Don't be a f*****g dick to your kids! (I should also mention I have two sisters who were never diagnosed with NEARLY the amount of so called problems I had) so I guess that proves, also, that parents play favorites.
I wonder if the fact that you sound a little bit unstable has anything to do with why you were on meds? Just thought I'd throw that out there. Like the old saying, I probably shouldn't really be throwing stones when I live in a glass house, but ya know.
I never heard of things like ADD, ADHD, bipolar disorder, anorexia nervosa, or most of this crap they diagnose children with, till I moved to America. I wonder if that's due to ignorant doctors, or different methods of parenting, or maybe something I haven't considered?
More like what my dad calls "complejos americanos".
This is cracked and not a medical journal right? I got confused by the ubersmart people catching feelings in the comment section
ReplyRe: Hysteria
Reply Hide All See All 5 RepliesExcept it was basically rape in a lot of cases and scarred many women for life. So, yeah, basically Disneyland.
[citation needed]
If it could be done against a woman's will just because she disagreed with her husband, well it certainly wasn't Disneyland.
But could it be done against her will?
Presuming the doctor didnt actually believed it was the right thing to do.
I've never heard of a rape that made a woman orgasm.
They could lock a woman up in a mental institution with nothing but Hubby Dearest's say-so, so I assume it could be done against her will.
That is a good point that I hadn't considered: Surely at least some of the women were convinced to "take the cure' whether they wanted to or not.
Hey, look at me act smart;
ReplyI don't know what the point of putting heroin (diacetyl morphine, which probably doesn't carry nearly as large an idiotic stigma as 'heroin') into a mixture that's meant to be taken orally, as swallowing heroin would be pointless, and would essentially be like swallowing the exact same amount of straight up morphine.
The only difference between morphine and heroin is those two acetyl groups (thus, *DIacetyl* morphine), and their only real function is to allow one's brain to absorb the chemical easier. As a matter of fact, if I recall correctly as soon as heroin enters your brain the two acetyl groups are detached and the chemical just becomes morphine again.
The problem is that upon swallowing heroin, first pass metabolism (your tummy tum tum) removes those two acetyl groups as well, which means that by the time the chemical got to the person taking the syrup's brain, it would just be morphine again anyways, which is easier and cheaper to make than heroin, so they were wasting time and money.
Maybe it was cause bayer used to claim heroin was supposed to be a less addictive alternative to morphine? Who knows.
Oh those silly old timey folks, with their rudimentary knowledge of metabolism and chemistry. Hah hah hah, ol' chum.
TL:DR; heroin turns into morphine if you swallow it, so putting heroin in cough syrup would be silly. I don't know why it took so many words to say that.
there are still a lot of cough syrups that contain heroin, look up codein and ask your doctor to prescript some
Reply Hide All See All 8 RepliesOk, codeine is in some prescription cough medicines, but is definitely not heroin. If it was, I think there would be a hell of a lot of opiate dependent people who would be getting bad cases of coughing real quickly.
Also, codeine is available over the counter in many places around the world. Unlike dope.
So no, first of all if someone gets codeine, it isn't heroin. Just cause they're both opiates doesn't mean they're the same thing. And second off, don't go asking your doctors for anything of the sort. If someone asks a doctor for any narcotic medicines without a real good reason, or you're not some old lady or something that a doctor would view as "trustworthy" (fucking old ladies), chances are at the very least he won't ever prescribe you anything even vaguely abusable ever again, even if you really need it, and worst case scenario, while I don't know if they're really allowed to do this, they could place it on your record or in some other way let others know that you're a "drug seeker" and that no one should give you drugs, like, ever.
So no, do not do those things. That's a f*****g idiotic thing to tell people to do. And inaccurate at the same time.
lol go uberpengiun. i took a codine based pain killer this morning, it's sold over the counter here in australia. It's definitely not Heroine fool.
Codeine is even weaker than morphine. All 3 are related and derived fr the opium poppy, but they are chemically different.
When it was heroin or nothing, as a cough suppressant, other than whiskey, which wasn't as effective, and the necessary dose (AS A COUGH SUPPRESSANT) gave you a much worse hangover, it's not hard to understand why people used it. This was back when people still got pertussis, and you cough suffocate during a coughing fit. Or end up brain-damaged from lack of oxygen during one of those coughing fits.
Dextromethorphan Hbr is an OTC cough suppressant, and it is also a opium derivative. It can also get you high, if you drink several bottles of it, but most people know better ways to get high, and it takes a teaspoon to stop a really nagging cough, the kind you get with bronchitis that keeps you up all night.
A lot of people who took heroin as a cough suppressant back in the day probably would have been happy to have something with, well, let's say "fewer side effects," and people who bought it over the counter in order to get wasted on it probably didn't sit around waiting until they had a cold, to do so.
In other words, it's not crazy if it's all that you have, and it's better than nothing.
Not, you're both TOTALLY right, it's not possible to get addicted to codeine at all! It's not like it's in the opiate family as well, or anything...
My stomach doesn't like codeine; this was discovered the hard way following my wisdom teeth extraction. Thank goodness the pain was nothing a little Tylenol couldn't take care of instead!
Many people DO abuse cough syrup.. ask Lil Wayne..lol
That DOES happen. Pray you never develop chronic pain. They make you sign away your privacy and dignity in order just to not being in excruciating pain (but you still hurt) every second of every day.
Is there any way to still get some of that soothing syrup? Sounds like it would really live up to it's name, just not for babies.
ReplyFresh urine can used to treat athlete's foot because it contains a small amount of amonia...Amonia is used as a disinfectant in most household cleaners.
Reply Hide All See All 6 Replieswhy don't you just go buy some ammonia?
Ammonia costs money
Look that up on Snopes. Short story: the urea in urine is also an ingredient in antifungal treatments, but in concentrations about 20 times what is found in urine, and that urea is only present in the antifungal creams to help the antifungal get better absorbed. Urine will not cure or prevent athlete's foot.
Pretty sure pure ammonia would do more harm than good.
the Romans used to get people to piss on their clothes because of the chemicals in the piss used to clean the clothes. The Romans were totally gross
I believe you're thinking of the urine used to dye cloth. The Romans didn't invent that. Urine was used in cloth dying for centuries. Sure, it smelled bad, but it did the job and there simply wasn't anything else that would. Nowadays we have analyne dyes, but those are made from petroleum, whose many uses are completely modern and unknown farther back than about 150 years. It's easy to sneer at the past, but please remember that not only did they not have the knowledge we have, in many cases, they didn't have the materials we have, either. They used what they had, and were damn clever about it, too. (Think about it. Would YOU be smart enough to figure out you could dye cloth using plant tinctures and urine?)
The ironic part? Right below the 'Lobotomy' section is an ad for Migraines. I Lol'd.
ReplyI'm sorry to say it, but the bit about lobotomy was quite simplistic.
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesFor instance, the guy who was awarded the Nobel Prize was Moniz and he did *not* invent the lobotomy in the form that was described in the article. What he invented, was the *leucotomy*. The term "lobotomy" was coined by Walter Freeman, who expanded on and modified Moniz's ideas.
Also, it was Freeman who invented the "icepick through the eye" procedure. Originally, lobotomies (and leucotomies) were performed like any other neurosurgeries: by making an opening in the patient's skull. Going through the eye was a later addition. And it did *not* make the patient blind.
Finally, it's worth to look at lobotomies in their historical context. At the moment of their invention, with the neurology not being as advanced as today, they really seemed like a good solution. Only later it was discovered that they were, in fact, a crude procedure that didn't really achieve do what it was supposed to do and had bad side effects...
Sometimes a simplistic view is the best. Do not stick a sharp object into your brain and stir. There's not really a lot to be gained from adding layers of detail to that.
You're still Monday-morning-quarterbacking. What you're proclaiming wasn't known back then. Nobody had ever tried such a thing, so nobody knew it was a bad idea. It's easy to judge AFTER the results are in.
Yeah, but can you imagine being one of the 70,000 test subjects it took to figure out that it wasn't much good?
It's not surprising or "insane" at all that heroin was used as a cough suppressant as other opiate derivatives are still being used for that very purpose (and they work very well!). Lots of modern day medications carry the risk of abuse and dependence and have worse side effects than some schedule 1 narcotics. I'm not advocating the use of heroin at all, I'm just saying, it's not as "insane" as this article makes it out to be. Also, speed is still used for weight loss. The drug Desoxyn (prescription methamphetamine) is used to treat cases of extreme obesity.
Reply Hide All See All 4 RepliesDesoxyn is also used to treat cases of ADD/ADHD in which all other medications have become ineffective over time or the increase in tolerance necessitated a dose that was impractically high. I went from Adderall (started at 20mg, up to 90mg per day), went to Ritalin/Concerta/Focalin (varying doses, Methylphenidate is junk), then to Dexedrine which was superior in effect to Adderall at only half of the dosage, mg-per-mg, as it contains only the Dextro-isomer of amphetamine, while Adderall is racemic and thus contains both Dextro- and Levo-amphetamine. In my case, I went from Adderall to Dexedrine, having gotten back on Adderall after realizing just how bad MPH sucked, and went from a 30mgXR+20mgXR every morning, a 30mgXR early afternoon, and 3x10mgIR, one each morning/noon/mid-afternoon for a total of 110mg of Adderall daily, and it SUCKED. The side-effects were unbearably, and I had a resting Heart Rate of ~85bpm and Blood Pressure was 135/90 (I'm 6'3", 170-175lbs but never over 190lbs, and at the time was running track and cross country, an avid cyclist doing 22-35mile rides 3-5x/week, and a skier who hit the slopes 3x/week every week, and lifted weights 2-4x/week, with a body-fat of 4.5-6.75%, and when I had no medications in me my Resting HR was 55-60bpm with BP 110/75). I was in very good physical health, but the Adderall made me feel on the verge of a panic attack constantly.
Dexedrine removes the L-isomer, which has the most effect on the norepinephrine and the Peripheral Nervous System, causing the increasing HR/BP/shakes/anxiety/etc when taken at a regular dose. This also means that, relatively speaking, Dexedrine is more potent in that I went from 110mg Adderall/day to 50mg Dexedrine/day (2x15mgXR, 2x10mgIR) and I felt not only almost all side effects go away but the drug worked better.
Unfortunately, tolerance meant I got up to around 70-80mg of Dexedrine daily, which was not very comfortable. That was when the physician and I sat down and had a long talk, looked over the available medications as well as what I'd already tried, and decided that Desoxyn would be the best. Desoxyn, which is dextro-methamphetamine made 100% pure in a lab, is different from all other ADD medications. The "Methyl" grouping means that the IR pills, the only ones available, last a solid 8-10 hours (Adderall 4-5, Dexedrine 5-6) as it prevents the breakdown of the drug by Monoamine Oxidase (MAO). It is also significantly more potent than either Adderall or Dexedrine, about 5-6x more than Adderall and 2-3x more than Dexedrine at a given dosage (this is due to both its increased potency as well as how one dosing of Desoxyn = 2 Dex/Add dosing).
The biggest benefit for me personally, considering my coexisting panic disorder/GAD is that its binding affinity is extremely high for Dopamine, high for Serotonin, and miniscule for Norephinephrine (about a 200:110:8, give or take). Racemic amphetamine (adderall) and dextroamphetamine have their highest affinity for dopamine, then norepinephrine, with no distinguishable effect on serotonin. For Adderall, it's about 100:90:0 and for Dexedrine it's 150:80:0, quite different.
I've been on 20mg of Desoxyn (2x5mg 2x/day) for around 5-6 years now, and I've never had to have a dosage change even once. The stuff works incredibly, and also allowed me to cut my anti-anxiety medication down 50% (from 6mg to 3mg of Klonopin/day). It's more of an effect of "allowing me to focus" as opposed to "FORCING me to focus".
As for Heroin being safer than many "legal" drugs, just to put it into perspective, an equivalency chart (Intravenous):
Morphine: 10mg
Heroin: 5.5-6.5mg
Dilaudid: 2mg
Oxycodone: 12-15mg
Oxymorphone:0.7-1.1mg
Fentanyl: 100-150mcg(ug)
Sufentanil: 15-25mcg
Carfentanil:0.25-1.0mcg
We have opiates over 4,500x the strength of morphine that are given to patients routinely, yet a drug that is weaker-per-milligram than Dilaudid or Opana is illegal? Ridiculous.
Wow. Cool story, antiflag.
Yeah, I know what you mean about the adhd meds and having s****y side effects, or maybe just making you feel s****y along with whatever it helps you with (focalin always sucks nuts). I'm on adderall at the moment, and honestly I really don't like it much, but my doctor is just so resistant to everything that I'm afraid to even bring up the subject to try dexedrine at least, since I don't know how anyone uses a drug that boosts norepinephrine and doesn't just get mad anxiety from it.
Unfortunately, despite the fact that desoxyn is really very often far superior to other meds, doctors, such as mine (god I hate psychiatrists sometimes. It seems like they go to school for years, and then are clueless as to what they're actually doing, and I'm definitely not even just talking about this issue. It's like they stopped taking in information of any sort the moment they graduated.), go "Oh my god, it's technically meth, so I can't prescribe it unless I really, really have to!", Which is obviously ridiculous, as any stimulant is abusable. Just because methampetamine so happens to be favored on the streets since it's so easy to make and yet is so potent doesn't then mean that it isn't a great medicine. Generally people who are unfamiliar with psychiatric medicine just don't get that. Also, most doctors I've seen very rarely prescribe benzos (like your K-pins) anymore, but that's also probably safe considering some people don't realize how badly their body can become dependent on it, and it's strange that a doctor would both prescribe a benzodiapine and a stimulant med at the same time (not cause of seizure risk, as I think that's overhyped sometimes, but just because they'd be working at crosspurposes in some ways), but hey, if it's all that works ya gotta go with it I guess.
But with meds like desoxyn, that's what the world's deep, inexplicable paranoia about people getting high does; it just causes problems and hurts people while not really helping or advancing anything whatsoever (other than a number of big industry's interests, cause hell, why get drugs on the street and put money in dealers' pockets? Let psychiatrists and pharmaceutical companies be your dealer and give you their shitty, often times equally or in many cases even more dangerous drugs instead, and put your money in their pockets!)
Though I don't think many people are going to have any idea what you're talking about when you start getting into territory like racemic mixtures and isomers types and whatever else. Most people who aren't involved in drugs or pharmacology, as I said, don't really know or care to know much beyond the basics.
Hi antiflag---your post slightly demonstrates your hyperactivity :) Good information, Thanks. Heroin is still legal to use for pain relief in many countries, unlike here in the U.S. It's ridiculous to ban an effective drug just because some people abuse it.