Marvel Comics vs. Science: 5 of the Most Absurd Superhero Origins
If there's one thing Stan Lee knew, it was how to create cool, interesting characters that would last for decades and become classic superheroes. And that's a relief, since it's arguable this is in fact the only thing Stan Lee knew, judging by the nonsensical origin stories of some of Marvel Comics' most beloved characters. Whether blasting off to Mars, getting bombarded with radiation or simply watching their families die and vowing to fight crime in a leotard afterwards, Marvel superheroes' career-starting legends all share a unifying trait: they don't actually make an ounce of fucking sense.

Origin Story: Hoping to beat the Commies to Mars, '60s super-scientist Reed Richards builds a fab rocket ship and announces his plans to blast off into space. The United States government cautions Reed about getting exposed to potentially lethal cosmic rays, though astoundingly has no objections to a US citizen shooting off homemade rockets into the atmosphere, nor Reed bringing his actress girlfriend Susan Storm, her teenage brother Johnny and a jet pilot named Ben Grimm along with him. (The government's funding for hijinx-related projects, it should be noted, was more robust back then.)

Thanks to Scott Tipton and Comics101.com for the scans!
Comic Book Consequences: Naturally, Reed and his friends are exposed to cosmic rays almost instantly:

The quartet gain fantastic superpowers as a result: Reed can now stretch his body, Susan can turn invisible, Johnny can turn into a human fireball and Ben Grimm is given the unstoppable power of being shit-hideous.
What Would Have Happened in Real Life: After building an unlicensed aircraft in his yard and boasting about shooting his girlfriend and her 17-year-old brother into outer space, Reed Richards is promptly brought up on charges of criminal negligence and child endangerment, his name tarnished in the scientific community. Richards flees the US to avoid prosecution, taking a teaching position at the Universidad de San Carlos in Guatemala. Since Guatemala has the lowest literacy rate in Central America, he spends most of his class time playing cards with his students and cursing his "total bitch" ex-girlfriend, who took advantage of Reed not bombarding her with space radiation by launching a successful acting career.
A Second Possibility: Reed Richards wisely decides to keep quiet about his goal to beat the Communists to Mars after noticing the horrified looks on his colleagues' faces, and so manages to get into outer space without tipping off the authorities. Once there, the four are bombarded with cosmic rays and, as advances in radiation can attest, nothing much happens initially. Since it takes the better part of a year to reach far-off Mars, Reed and co. settle in for the voyage, playing charades and watching Ben Grimm's astonishingly comprehensive collection of amateur pornography.
After a month of lethal radiation, Johnny develops a cataract in his left eye and Ben Grimm becomes sterile. After two months, Susan's hair begins to fall out in clumps and Richards starts pooping blood. By the time they reach Mars, every one of them has cancer. Luckily, due to the heavy nuclei in cosmic radiation all are profoundly brain damaged at this point, and nobody even notices. Now piloting a spacecraft while legally retarded, Reed suggests they abandon their Mars mission and fly off in the direction of a distant galaxy instead, on the grounds that it looks like ice cream. They are never heard from again.








No way the punisher would only kill 6 and wound 14, more like 20 dead with 15 bullets
ReplyOh f**k me. It totally looks like I copy-pasted another commenter's point about the X-men. I didn't, but I feel like an a*****e now. *sighs*
ReplyHad a few funny moments, but on a whole it kinda comes off as...lazy trolling. Lest we forget, many, many superheroes started off as archetypes within social metaphor. X-men is a great example of this, considering it was a giant allegory for the civil rights movement. Y'know, before it became all about Wolverine.
ReplyI object.
Reply"Anyway, yeah: The alpha particles, beta particles and gamma rays in radioactive material destroy living cells by breaking their chemical bonds and disrupting the cell's genetic instructions. Despite what Stan Lee tells you, this is bad. Peter Parker dies."
This is a lie. If Peter Parker was bitten by a radioactivity-poisoned spider, and radiodioactivity kills you, then the spider would be dead. Therefore it wouldn't bite Peter Parker, and he wouldn't die.
wow...
Replyyou really gave up towards the end there, didn't you? :P
Have to object to "economically crippling socialist ideology"... even the profoundly un-Marxist USSR was economically better off than under capitalism. People tend to forget: this was a third world country before 1917, and a third world country after 1991. You dont compare their economy to America, you compare it to Zimbabwe.
ReplyAh, this is not to give any sort of support to the Stalinists. Just sayin; nationalisation and planning works - as long as you also have democracy. A democratically planned economy, where mistakes can be caught and those affected have a voice, would be actual socialism.
the punisher is a elite soldier and a decorayed war veteran, todays us cops would nor could never catch him.
Replyyou english write good
'Us cops'? Really?
Boring article, writer kinda just gave up halfway
Replyalso, I feel that they just kinda gave up on page 6. Still amusing, but there's only about half a page
Replylol. Right below the Captain America one is an ad that says 'shocking muscle pictures' and has a picture of a really buff guy with biceps bigger than his head.
ReplyoNcE YOU'VE READ THE.
Reply Hide All See All 7 RepliesFIRST WORD OF.
THIS YOU CANT GET OUT.
READ ON OR.
DIE TONIGHT AT 10:35...... P.M.9 years ago.
a person named Jerry got.
dared to sleep.
in a house that was belived.
haunted.The... next day his friends.
waited for him out.
side the house...................
They had
to go inside and search for.
him. They
went through every room.
exept the
attic.He wasn't supposed to.
sleep
there. He was supposed to.
sleep in the.
living room they went into.
the attic.
They saw Jerry's corpse and.
they just
left because they were.
scared. But that
night they all died because.
of their
friend. He killed them all.
for making him.
sleep in that house If you.
don't send
this to 11 comments you.
will die tonight.
by Jerry. Example 1: A man.
named
Stewart Read this and.
didn't believe it.
He shut off his computer.
and went
through his day. That night
while he
was in bed he heard.
something outside
of his door. He got up to.
look. And now
he's dead. Example 2: A Girl.
named
Haley Read this in the.
morning and she.
got scared but she didn't.
send it. She
wanted to know if it was.
true. She went
to school (She was only 13.
years old)
and that night she died. If
you don't
post this on 11 comments.
tonight Jerry
will 'visit' you.
I'm still here.
Dammit Jerry again with this? This is the second time tonight... I guess I have to break out the ghost knife again. Bring it on you tubby son of a bitch.
While it would still be so stupid it's laughable, when writing something scary, you may want to try being grammatically correct, or at least watching where you put your damn periods. Nothing ruins. A scary. Story. Then making. It seem. Like. It was written by. A. 2 year-old. Who really liked. The period. Button
who would read that long crap... id rather read thus s****y article again...
I'm too poisonous for ghosts to handle. Bring it on Jerry.
WTF? nicoharr, get a life.
These things area so stupid you have to wonder if even the people who copy-paste it believe it.
the captain america one is rediculous because there chemicals now that cause muscle growth like human groth hormone or hgh which by the way doesnt cause acne and loss of testical size. hgh naturally occurs in our bodies that is why many baseball players take hgh because there is no test to prove you are actually taking them the effects of hgh is bone growth muscle growth tissue growth increased physical abilities ie the exact same thing that happened to captain america
ReplyIs another effect bizarre run-on sentences?
just not with the whole instantaneous muscle/bone/tissue growth like in the comic.
pffft. yeah. he punisher would serve 5 life sentences . . . IF THEY COULD CACTH HIM!!!
ReplyI was cacthed once. Painful.
OMG fiction is fiction. I needed this pointed out to me because I thought I could be a real superhero. Thank you cracked writer, you are the real superhero.
ReplyThe Punisher wouldn't injure 14. Change that to 'Kills 20'
ReplyHeck, killing 20 is a slow day for him. Maybe "kills 39 with 14 bullets"
Dude, what the hell is wrong with this writer?! He should have retitled this as "Five of the most popular super-heroes and how I can act as if they have far worse origin stories than comic super-heroes who actually have really, really bad ones. Mostly because I don't actually read comics". Screw you, writer of this article. Screw you.
ReplyNerd rage o.o
You understand this is cracked right? They kind of make a living from deconstructing pop culture and ruining childhood dreams. It's kind of their 'thing'.
Peter was bitten by a radioactive spider so...young and healthy Peter Parker notices a large lump on his wrist after visiting the lab or whatever and rushes to the emergency room where he is given an anti-venom and possibly some pain medication. After a few weeks of pain from his wrist and sympathy from his family, friends, and possibly a pity smooch from Mary Jane Peter Parker fully recovers and promptly files a lawsuit against Osborne Industries for endangerment. After winning millions in his case Peter Parker pays off his student loans and moves to sunny island in the tropics where winter doesn't exist and the sun is out an average of 345 days a year.
ReplyNo. In the tropics, it RAINS. A lot. This is why we have rainforests and jungles. Because we have rain for about 3-5 months straight every year.
He lives on his island for a happy 14 years before the damage to his system from the radioactivity starts to affect him. It doesn't help that our friend Peter has an irrational fear of sunscreen, and has gotten into the habit of falling asleep in the burning, 345/365 days-present-per-year sun completely nude. After his drawn-out, emotional death Mary Jane, Aunt May and his harem of supermodels contest for his wealth, constituting the largest court cat fight ever.
Never really said what happened to Spiderman tho. My guess is the spider pumped him full of genetically altered super venom. Peter is instantly paralyzed, voids his bowels and collapses to the ground foaming at the mouth. He remains in a paralytic state, the coroner at the hospital mistakes him for being dead and performs an autopsy on a still alive and aware Peter Parker. After his aunt identifies the body and leaves, the coroner turns down the lights and plays some Barry White...
ReplyWhat a sad and pathetic mind you have.
I think you mean sadTASTIC!
The Captain part is awesome, cripple testicles, demanding a protein shake, f*****g hilarious.
ReplyAs a follow-up, you're going to tell us all about how Godzilla (Gojira for the purists) isn't realistic, right?
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesWell, T-Rexes DID have feathers.
Godzilla wasnt a T. rex; he was a symbol of the blind destructive forces unleashed on innocent people by the development of nuclear weapons.
Those don't have feathers.
yeah, they have teeth and claws and other equally horrifying appendages.