The Terrifying Truth About 'Arrested Development'
Let's assume the following logical, reasonable things about Arrested Development:
-- The first half of the first episode is real. Up through the part when the SEC raids the Bluths' boat party and arrests George Sr. All that stuff really happened.
-- The SEC investigates every penny of George Sr.'s business dealings. Admittedly, they're not always perfect when it comes to doing a skilled investigation, but let's say they dig most everything up.
-- Evidence from the SEC's digging helps convict George Sr. of the other crime he's being investigated for: what he calls "light treason" (home building in Saddam Hussein's Iraq, as revealed later in the show).
-- The government calls this crime "treason-treason."
-- George Sr. is sentenced to death (the longstanding punishment for treason).
-- Awaiting execution, George Sr. is held prisoner in the awful conditions afforded to an enemy of the United States. It's very Gitmo. Or if you don't believe the U.S. would put a U.S. citizen through that kind of nightmare, fine, let's say it's very Homan Square.
-- George Sr. is a well-off businessman from a non-Saw background. Thrown into a world of horror he's not ready to cope with, he suffers a mental breakdown.
-- From there, the rest of Arrested Development is a fantasy George Sr. plays out in his mind, full-time, to avoid his pain and guilt and mortality. He's decided his real world is actually a fictional TV show, and he makes up its next developments like they're new episodes. (George also backfills the real events we've seen with details that fit that fantasy.) Remember, our brains invent stuff all the time. Our moods change what we remember. Confirmation bias helps us avoid the truth. It's pretty extreme for those cognitive faults to warp our entire reality, but "Death Row Torture Nightmare" is an extreme situation.
Why even suggest this is the case? Because in that scenario, there are 10 ways Arrested Development makes a lot more sense.
It Explains The Characters' Self-Awareness
How are Arrested Development's cast able to reference the fact that they're characters on a TV show in danger of cancellation? Their self-awareness ranges from the subtle (hinting in this episode of Season 2 about Fox cutting their episode order from 22 to 18) to open begging (in a Season 3 episode, they ask HBO and Showtime to pick them up, throw a stunt-cast "Save Our Bluths" party, and promote an online anti-cancellation fan campaign).
Those behaviors all make sense if this is George Sr.'s fantasy and Arrested Development is a TV show he writes in his head. The cancellation references are how he's digesting his imminent execution, turning his certain death into fun minor entertainment news.
It Explains The Show's Complexity
You've seen network TV sitcoms. They're simple! They're straightforward! They're easy to dive into the middle of! How could that lame profit-driven system generate Arrested Development, a multi-season Rubik's cube of callbacks and references? Such a show could only be the intricate handiwork of a madman. A madman with a death row inmate's free time. Real TV writers have families and orgies to get to. They'd punch the Hollywood clock and write something simpler, like a more normal "kooky rich guy" story, or a cartoon, or a vehicle for a stand-up comedian or whatever.
It Explains Ron Howard Being Front And Center In A Modern TV Show
A man of George Sr.'s generation has seen hundreds of episodes of The Andy Griffith Show and Happy Days. This allowed him to internalize and mentally replicate Howard's voice, using it rather than his own voice to talk himself through the plots he's inventing on the fly. Since George Sr.'s so committed to his fantasy, he never wonders why Arrested Development is Ron Howard's one and only major gig as a TV narrator, or why someone with an unremarkable voice would get so much voiceover work.
It Explains Why The Show's Version Of The U.S. Justice System Is A Joke
In the real America, laws allows the government to do not-a-joke things like torture people at black sites without due process. George Sr. would rather live in a world where the judicial system is easy to game, prisons are easy to escape, and lawyers are the funny guy who played Fonzie. (George loooooooves Happy Days.)
It Explains Why The Family Business Never Goes Bankrupt
The Bluth Company is a real estate development firm. Their lights only stay on if they have the public goodwill to close big complicated deals. They can't just ride out horrible press by selling an irresistible necessity.
$3,000 $4,000 $5,000 suits aren't cheap.
But since this is a fantasy, the Bluths don't just avoid bankruptcy; they maintain lavish day-to-day expenses. Michael's non-stair car is the only major possession they had to sell. G.O.B.'s still got his Segway and two different yachts to live on. Lucille's still at her Balboa Towers apartment, pushing Lupe around. They explain away other family members living in a mansion by calling it a model home, but other than its HomeFill junk and tenant-induced damage, it's fully functional. They still have lawyers and P.I.s on retainer. And they still throw lavish parties and hire a professional caterer / bounty hunter and feast on everything from Skip's Scrambles to poolside lunches, even though real-life cost-cutting means cooking at home more than once and asking family members to stop running up the utility bill.
It Explains Why The Other Bluths Keep Caring About The Company And The Family.
Even though George Sr. has been an awful father and every adult relationship in the family is toxic, every Bluth (in particular Michael) comes together to save the family they hate. That could only happen in the fantasy of that family's patriarch. In reality, the Bluths probably scattered shortly after George's conviction, and gave up their company much sooner than ten years later. The Bluths might stay in touch with each other -- send a postcard from Phoenix and stuff. But George Sr.'s legacy wouldn't mean much to them anymore.
It Explains Everything About Tobias ...
George Sr. never liked Tobias, who's only a part of the family because Lindsay hate-married him. So in George Sr.'s fantasy, Tobias undergoes constant humiliation, has emasculating sexual issues (repressed homosexuality and that clearly made-up "never nude" nonsense), and can't achieve intercourse with George Sr.'s daughter. And as we've said before, Tobias Onyango Funke is a black man. So George's fantasy morphs Tobias into a cartoon white twerp, instead of someone with a sexually superhuman ethnicity (yes, George is a racist!).
... And It Explains Lindsay's Sex Life
Lindsay, George Sr.'s beloved daughter, is a hot flirtatious lady who inexplicably "can't seem to give this away." That's because George Sr. wouldn't want to imagine his own daughter getting intimate with anyone. (Imagining his sons getting intimate is fine, though. Because men are weird.)
It Explains Why A Supposed Mainstream American Sitcom Featured Cousin Incest
George Michael and Maeby are attracted to each other, because this is George Sr.'s fantasy, and he's an old businessman who doesn't know any other kids to pair them up with. That's also why the only other prominent kids on the show are the kind George Sr. grew up with in more old-fashioned time (Ann Veal), stock one-note jocks (Steve Holt), and the sort of third-world adoptees George Sr. remembers hearing about at charity fundraisers (Annyong). George Sr. also finds a convoluted way to make George Michael and Maeby into non-blood relatives once he admits to himself that he's out of story reasons to keep them apart. Then he realizes he can time-jump the whole show forward, making his grandkids now grownups, which are much easier people to invent love stories for.
Related: 4 Sitcoms That Explain the 90s
It Explains "Oscar Bluth"
George's twin brother Oscar appears out of nowhere in "Whistler's Mother," the 20th episode of the series. How did we never hear a word about the family patriarch's twin brother for so long? It's because "Oscar" is an imaginary personification of everything the imprisoned George Sr. wishes he had: freedom, hair, youthfulness, legal and spiritual innocence, an artistic career, a better relationship with Michael, the ability to please his wife (and make love to her on a beach, an obvious sexual fantasy), and the chance to be Buster's "true father" and reverse Lucille's damage. Oscar's also a ridiculous literal "get out of jail free" card, allowing George Sr. to knock him out and steal his identity multiple times. George Sr.'s fantasy even transfers the real pain of the police brutality he's undergone, putting his made-up doppelganger through the Nightstick Mambo instead of himself.
Face it, Arrested fans. You may find all this truth shocking, but it's as Ann as the nose on Plain's face.
Deep inside us all behind our political leanings, our moral codes and our private biases, there is a cause so colossally stupid, we surprise ourselves with how much we care. Whether it's toilet paper position, fedoras on men or Oxford commas, we each harbor a preference so powerful we can't help but proselytize to the world. In this episode of the Cracked podcast, guest host Soren Bowie is joined by Cody Johnston, Michael Swaim and comedian Annie Lederman to discuss the most trivial things we will argue about until the day we die. Get your tickets here!
Return back with us to a time when Michael Cera was essentially Jesse Eisenberg in The 10 Most Bizarrely Interchangeable Celebrities and learn the destructive power of the Avengers in 5 Insane Pop Culture Questions Answered by Super Fans.
Subscribe to our YouTube channel to see how the Starks are just trying to keep the family together in 'Game of Thrones' / 'Arrested Development' Mashup', and watch other videos you won't see on the site!
Also follow us on Facebook or as we like to call it, Mr.F!