Last year we covered in a podcast how truth is stranger and often scarier than fiction, especially when it comes to the history genre. Case in point: the story of Henry Rathbone. You're probably thinking, who's Henry Rathbone? That's kind of the point. Henry Rathbone and his wife Clara were sitting next to Abraham Lincoln the night of the assassination, and despite the decades of conspiracy theories and ghost stories surrounding the Lincoln family, the craziest and bloodiest story of the night belongs to Mr. Rathbone.

See, in the years following Lincoln's assassination, Rathbone's mental state declined as he blamed himself for not being able to prevent the president's death. Soon after that, he started to believe his walls were talking to him. Then he went full Shining and murdered his wife, tried to murder his children, and stabbed himself five times in the chest. He spent the rest of his life in an insane asylum. This is an absolutely bonkers story edited from the margins of history, yet we choose not remember it because it doesn't read like a textbook.

This sort of historical amnesia also applies to how we look at the horror genre. There are countless unsolved murders, disappearances and mass hysterias that we don't know how to classify just because their details are too strange to swallow, the leads go nowhere and eventually we give up.

So in honor of Halloween, Jack O'Brien and Jason Pargin (aka David Wong) share 12 creepy and macabre unsolved mysteries that are just too weird to fit into our cookie-cutter version of the horror genre.

Throw on your headphones and click play above, go here to subscribe on iTunes, or download it here.

More Episodes


How The CIA Quest For Mind Control Drove The World Insane

September 16, 2019

Sidney Gottlieb is a name you do not know. There are a million creepy reasons for that.

 Go Listen

12 Amazing Advances In TV Technology (That Make TV Worse)

September 9, 2019

Streaming services freed us from so many things! Also can we get those things back? Pretty please?

 Go Listen

12 Shockingly Important Near-Misses Of Marvel Movie History

September 2, 2019

Fun fact: Captain America's cinematic civil war almost pitted Tom Cruise against Dane Cook.

 Go Listen

10 Real Science Stories That Should Be A Sci-Fi Movie

August 26, 2019

Get nightmare swarms of yellowjackets' agent on the phone!

 Go Listen

How One True Crime Writer Started Solving Murders

August 19, 2019

You can help catch murderers AND answer decades-old Star Wars questions.

 Go Listen
To turn on reply notifications, click here


Load Comments