The trailer was widely criticized for its brutal violence, a discussion that's only going to pop up more and more as graphics continue to improve to the point where reality itself starts to look bland and low-res. But it's a bad trailer for so many other reasons. There's zero context for the scene, the apparent big bad villain we're being introduced to is immediately killed, and we're told nothing about what to expect in terms of plot or gameplay. The only thing it communicates is tone, and that tone is pointlessly depressing. It's like the developers said, "Hey, remember how the first game's nasty violence was effective because it was spliced into a compelling story of companionship and love? Well, we got rid of most of that." Who is this trailer even for? It's a worrying sign to old fans, and it tells potential new ones to get hyped to buy Generic Apocalypse Scenario 14-B.
The game will probably be fine, or even great, but it says a lot about the industry if they think a marquee product should be marketed with damsel in distress horror cliches. What exactly is being said about horror gaming (that hasn't already been said) by showing a teen having her bones broken in beautiful 4K? One of Sony's big shots, Jim Ryan, defended the trailer by saying, "The Last Of Us obviously is a game made by adults to be played by adults. And there's that market for those people who like that sort of game. Adults who like that sort of game."
Hey, Jim, right now, the most critically acclaimed game made by adults to be played by adults is one in which Mario can run around in boxer shorts, play with a dog, and win prizes by turning into a mustachioed fish. "Adult" doesn't mean an endless parade of gloomy violence -- that's a child's idea of adult. An adult's idea of adult is strong storytelling, gameplay innovation, and characters and situations we care about in a way that feels earned -- none of which are on display in your horror B-movie outtake of a trailer. Yes, the violence is part of the experience too, but it's a piece of the puzzle, not the sole focus which you apparently think we want to masturbate to. For guidance, watch your own damn teaser for your own damn game you released earlier: