The Most Confusing Moment In 'Joker' Has Been Explained

SPOILERS for Joker ... as if you haven't seen it already

Joker has made more than a billion dollars, making it the most successful R-rated movie in history -- that is, until James Cameron decides to pepper his Avatar sequels with intense cat-person dreadlock penetration. You're likely familiar with the big twist that occurs midway through the story: Protagonist Arthur Fleck's neighbor and love interest, Sophie, turns out to be like so many girlfriends up in Canada. Those scenes in which we saw the pair hanging out were all in Arthur's head. He was actually alone, talking to himself!

The Most Confusing Moment In 'Joker' Has Been ExplainedWarner Bros.

Which explains why she'd suffer through an open mic.Warner Bros.Which explains why she'd suffer through an open mic.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

The delusion is shattered when Sophie catches Arthur in her apartment and she's clearly freaked out. Then the movie abruptly cuts away to something else, and we never see her again. This creates the disturbing implication that Arthur hurt or possibly even murdered Sophie. Which is a big deal, because up until this point he's only shot a few violent stockbrokers (which most Gothamites seem pleased as punch about for some reason). Bumping off the single mother from down the hall would catapult him into supervillainy somewhat prematurely. Which is a problem, because that's what a lot of viewers assumed happened.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

Now director Todd Phillips has cleared this all up, insisting that "of course" Arthur didn't kill Sophie. In fact, there was originally a scene at the end in which a not-dead Sophie is seen watching Arthur on TV, but it was ultimately cut. Which seems like a pretty huge omission. Yes, that shot would have diverted from Arthur's POV, but the final version leaves her fate in an ominously ambiguous place, which clearly wasn't the intention. Complicating matters further is the theory that the girlfriend delusion was in fact a delusion within a larger delusion, like a Russian nesting doll of stale plot devices.

Continue Reading Below

Advertisement

You (yes, you) should follow JM on Twitter!

For more, check out 11,000 Scientists: Stop Killing The Planet, You Utter Morons and Trump Will Keep Going To Sporting Events 'Til Someone Cheers.

Also, we'd love to know more about you and your interesting lives, dear readers. If you spend your days doing cool stuff, drop us a line at iDoCoolStuff at Cracked dot com, and maybe we can share your story with the entire internet.

Follow us on Facebook. If you like jokes and stuff.