Why does the Wii even exist?
Or put more generally, why do we have three different, completely incompatible video game consoles on the market right now, instead of multiple companies making video game consoles that play a single format? We have unified formats for CDs, DVDs and bananas, so why not video games?
Here's an article that discusses rumors that Microsoft was considering licensing other manufacturers to make their own versions of the 360 prior to its launch. On the surface this doesn't seem like such a bad idea. It'd remove the responsibility for manufacturing hardware from Microsoft's sloped shoulders and birdlike arms - they've never really proven themselves adapt at the sort of heavy lifting that manufacturing requires. Third party Xbox's could potentially be cheaper, and also, you know, work.
But for now it remains a rumor. Why have console manufacturers resisted licensing the manufacture of their consoles, and in general why haven't we moved towards a single standard, like the DVD? As is generally the nature with rhetorical questions, I've already prepared some answers...
One, the inability to maintain control of the price of the hardware - particularly the ability to sell it at a loss. In the video game industry it's fairly common for a manufacturer to sell their console at a loss for the first few years of production, a sacrifice they're willing to make to build up market share. But there's no way an external, licensed manufacturer would be willing to manufacture Xbox's and price them so low that they'd be losing money. Both the CDi and 3DO were licensed to outside manufacturers, and high prices are one of the reasons they failed (they also weren't much good at playing video games.) I guess this kind of scheme could work, if the licensing involved assorted payoffs and kick-backs from the licensor to the licensee in exchange for the licensor being able to set the price. Seems complicated though.
Two, video game content providers aren't as powerful or concentrated as movie or music content providers. The vast majority of American films are owned by 6 companies. When they throw their support behind a single format, that format becomes the standard - this is exactly how the HD-DVD and Blu-Ray battle was settled. I imagine the same thing happens in the music industry, but with greasier people at the negotiating table. Video game publishing has grown more and more consolidated over the last decade, but it's still nowhere near that level. No single console has been able to gain the overwhelming support of third parties since the NES.
Three, the pace of console development is a huge obstacle for any possible consolidation. The amount of negotiations, arm twisting, and legal kicks to the balls needed for hardware manufacturers to agree to a single standard is considerable, and can take years. For certain formats, that effort might be worth it. CD's have been around and kicking for 25 years or so, and DVD's for a dozen. But new console generations are separated by 5-6 years or so. To have to go through all that hassle every 5 years for the next generation of consoles? It might not be worth it. Now I wouldn't complain if the pace of console replacement slowed down - I don't think it's terribly healthy for the industry. But it will take more than this whiny asshole to stop that particular trend.
I should point out that I'm no economics major (my university career was spent mostly learning then rapidly forgetting computer science) so I may be missing something here. What do the rest of you Monday Morning Console Quarterbacks think?









nintendo's cube 360
ReplyWell, worry no more, because it seems like the future's taking a turn towards the "Digital Media" format, essentially taking out all worth and physical copies from the game market. At least in my eyes it has no worth, after all, if it's not physical and is not backed by any physical value, then what's its really worth? Digital media is easily stolen, and if that's the direction of the market, that's what's going to happen. I don't pay for music or movies unless it's live, so now that this is happening, why pay for games? Definitely a trend we want to stop right now.
ReplySure Guys, a Lot of Big Games are Launched on Multiple Platforms. But you can't PLAY across Platforms.
ReplyIt shouldn't matter if my Friend has an XBOX and I have a PS3, if the Game is the Same, Multiplayer should be Compatible! The Technology should be there...
I completely agree that the "New System Turnaround" should be longer. Make something ACTUALLY WORK before you make a New One. I am mostly just Jealous because I still can't afford a "Next-Gen System" yet. Cross Compatibility is a Moajor Factor in my Hesitation to Decide. I will invariably pick PS3, because I like Sony and it has a Blu-Ray Player. My PS2 and Laptop will just have to do until then...
with the exception of ps3 games that aren't also released for pc you can play any game on your pc whether through actually being released for it or emulation so there you go
ReplyFind me a successful xbox 360 emulator and fully working games for it and ill s**t myself
Yeah except for the games not also released on pc (all consoles have them) and the ones that don't have good emulators, you can totally play all games on PC...you know if yours isn't f**king up already. And if you pay for the upgrades of course.
So...how much was a 360 again?
A standardized format would definitely be great, but then we'd have one less thing to start flame wars over! :P
Reply@Alexander: Well, seeing as CD is an abbreviation it might be appropriate. I've never been sure if that was OK or not.
Then there would just be flame wars over game companies instead! People just need to hate stuff.
Wow, this article is 2 years old and it still gets new comments. It would be cool if the big 3 came together to make one console. The fanboy in me would have the guilty pleasure of playing PS3 and Wii titles.
ReplyPSWii60: the future of gaming?
Yeah if there's one thing that improves quality and price of a product, it's having no competition.
Hey, just today discovered this blog but I have to say that it looks awesome. I totally agree with you. Does someone have some tips on how to repair the casing of my xbox, it has broken.
ReplyFYI on grammar: the apostrophe is used exclusively to indicate contractions and possessions.
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesExamples:
Contraction: You're a giant man eating spider!
Possession: The spider's minions took over the government.
"CD's" could be correct if you were talking about something possessed by a CD, for example: a CD's cover, but you never use an apostrophe to indicate plurality. Never.
CDs (not CD's) have been around and kicking for 25 years.
I know, this is the Internet and nobody gives a shit, but seriously, this is not a youtube comment, it's a widely read blog and presumably you're even receiving money for writing it. Little errors like that really do impact the perceived quality of your writing.
Deos it rely mater?
It does and you're not funny.
Meh, I laughed.
The reason they won't let manufacturers create consoles is because they would lead to security holes in consoles. Unless all were made the EXACT secure way then it would lead to Homebrewing and Linux, which has already happened but still remains secure because it was patched, can never be depatched and required the user to install it.
ReplyIf some versions of the Xbox could be easily exploited like a Windows PC can then hackers might create things like zombie xboxs and unless Kaspersky and Symantec are into making AV for a gaming console there are going to be a few problems.
The PS3/2 on the other hand lets Linux and Homebrew apps run under a "hypervisor" mode, they cannot play games and are limited in other ways. Hackers aren't the smart ones, but apply what the Linux users do for malicious purposes.
Ha!
Reply Hide All See All 3 Repliesi highly doubt seeing the PC gaming market going down the drain anytime soon as PC's pretty much pioneered the game industry and then console adaptions of popular PC games such as half-life and doom where then made. it was these games which really made gaming take off, i mean Doom 1 and quake were pretty much the first true FPS's made and then Age of empires and civilization and empire earth were all the RTS's pioneers.
and there will reach a point in the near future where consoles will pretty much become computers, they share the same CPU's, RAM, GPU's, Hard Drives, PSU's and I/O devices. a console is basically a dumbed down PC, and by dumbed down i mean the software is basically a stripped down Operating system kernel with fancy controllers instead of a keyboard and mouse being connected to a....... thats right folks a USB port. for instance if someone modded their Xbox original so they had admin rights they could install windows 2000 on it or even XP, its only a matter of time before consoles end up with there own operating systems which will basically just be Linux or windows 7 in disguise.
Nobody games on a PC. Nobody. Not even on a Mac.
taco your a moron TONS of people still pc game whether its as simple as playing minesweeper, to playing the newest most visually amazing games made like crysis or bioshock 2 not to mention rts suck camel dick on console. the reason no one games on macs is because macs aren't designed for it in fact there graphics processor and ram are usually extremely subpar for the price you pay to "lease" your self obsessed nazi kgb computer, when compared to the power i can put into a pc with half the price... not to mention fully own.
Successful troll is apparently successful. Nice job showing him Moco, he clearly wasn't just looking for attention and anger. I bet he cried himself to sleep when you totally called his computer a nazi.
We have a standard. It's called Windows. The only benefit of console gaming nowadays is standardized hardware, but if we start having third party licensors for hardware it would defeat the purpose of consoles to begin with.
ReplyI have worked in video game retail for five years. during these years I have watched to pc market dwindle down to almost nothing. people were getting sick of having to upgrade their pc's every time a new game came out,even the die hard pc junkies started buying consoles. not all of them were happy about the prospect, but it was cheaper to get a console than to constantly keep upgrading their old hardware. Plus once you bought a pc game it was yours, for better or worse. No trading in to recoup some expenses plays a role now too.
ReplyThis thing you speak of already exists. I'm using one to say this right now. Many different companies build them, they can be upgraded regularly, and play video games very very well.
ReplyThe question is, why did consoles ever survive the PC age?
Computers even offer emulations of every controller and game you've ever loved.
with advances in hardware at the moment, why dont they just release what is essentially a big ole block of memory, maybe about a trillabite, and allow gamers to choose from a few, much cheaper software upgrades and maybe small hardware plugins, where neccicary. that way theres only one main item of expensive hardware needed, but developers have plenty of possible upgrades to play with
Replythis would also give each indavidual the choice of which company, such as microsoft or sony, they wanted to invest in, and the companys got a estemate of the popularity of there games, depending on how many hardware or software downloads there console plugins have recived. there probably a cubic buttload of reasons this wouldent work, but fuck it, it sounds like it might.
It's actually, like, 10 terabytes. Not to be nitpicky or anything, I just had to say that.
@GetAwesome: "If they could strip all of the other stuff out of a gaming computer that gamers don’t need, make it plug and play (rather than having to navigate to your game through windows, and make a universal controller that doesn’t suck, then manage to get the cost down, then they would have it."
Reply"It" being a console. Consoles have upgrades too. WiiMotion Plus, Project Natal, Eyetoy, racing wheels.
@CS - Exactly right. What is the difference between a universal gaming console and a gaming PC? One is a machine that plays games, and the other does everything else a computer does AND plays games. The only problem is the price. If they could strip all of the other stuff out of a gaming computer that gamers don't need, make it plug and play (rather than having to navigate to your game through windows, and make a universal controller that doesn't suck, then manage to get the cost down, then they would have it. Only problem is, when the games start getting to big for the system, the new systems wouldn't be brand-new shiny things that everyone wants, they would be a-little-at-a-time upgrades like PCs. Which do you think makes more money for the console manufacturers?
ReplyThe console will be gone soon. There will certainly be one more offering from Nintendo, possibly one more Xbox, and never another Playstation.
ReplyAfter-wards, they will have to rely on publishing the game franchises contracted to them, gimmicky wireless controllers, and copyright security (have any of you ever actually really purchased a PC game?).
That being said, Nintendo FTW.
I don't get why people keep suggesting this...
ReplyYou'd basically be turning the console market into a less flexible variation of the PC market.
PC's are generic, and have interchangeable parts.
The downside is anyone making high-performance software (eg. games), has to be able to account for the thousands of variations in hardware and operating software.
A standardised console is a much bigger project than a data storage medium. (notice that both the Wii and 360 use DVD's? - different formatting, sure. But the drive technology is the same, the data capacity is the same too...)
look at mobile phones... Getting any two phones that even work the same way practically doesn't happen.
You want standardised consoles?
Make cheap gaming PC's.
Well, i would say why does the ps3 (aka the motherfucker console of pimos) exists?, Wii can be played by hardcore gamers if they focus on games like no more heroes 2, or super smash brawl (seriosuly, play the story mode on ssb, bet you cant make it on easy without doing a continue on easy) , xbox 360 has halo, and other games like dead rising that calls attentions and are hell good, ps3 has a bonus over all the consoles that its the free internet online gaming yet the wii also has this and it costs less. but well uniting all consoles on one may had pros but may not.
ReplyHell, I want a Wii solely because they're releasing all the old NES games on it. And I don't care what anyone says, Ocarina of Time was weak stuff compared to the awesome difficulty of The Adventures of Link.
Reply