Login or Register

Sign in with Facebook

"You play to win the game!" screamed Herm Edwards at a postgame press conference. Coach Edwards was speaking about the NFL, of course, but in this oft-repeated quote, he could just as easily have been speaking about fantasy sports.

Friendship is great. So is competition. Camaraderie, smack talk, league traditions -- all fun and wonderful. But at the end of it, you play. To win. The game.

But sometimes, in fantasy, it's more important to not lose than to win. Because of all the things that bring leagues together, of all the funniest, most outrageous, most talked about traditions, it's punishments for losing that are the most memorable.

While writing my book Fantasy Life, I heard of every imaginable punishment. I heard of leagues where the loser has to wear nothing but a Speedo, dress up as a woman, dress up as a clown, get waxed, get shaved, and swallow a tablespoon of cinnamon while getting slapped in the face by a fish. You heard me. Slapped in the face by a fish.

And that one didn't even make the list.

The Pasta League

Comstock/Comstock/Getty Images

The DJ and Pasta League out of Brooklyn is a seven-year-old keeper league that harks back to vaudeville for its last-place loser. As "Raffa the Gaffa" explains, "Every year before the draft the last-place team will stand for one minute and all the league members launch tomatoes at him."

More than 200 pounds of tomatoes are thrown at the loser, and incidentally, for you kids out there thinking of doing this, Raffa offers this helpful hint: "Microwave the tomatoes so they soften up a little, bringing the grime level to a 10."

The Public Shaming

Jupiterimages/Photos.com/Getty Images

In their league, Scott LoMurray and his best friend Aaron Doverspike have weekly head-to-head bets where the loser has to do some pretty terrible things, including getting a leg wax and sitting in the back of a pickup truck as it goes through a car wash wearing only a Speedo, a swim cap, and goggles. But my favorite punishment of theirs involves putting on a helmet and Rollerblades and standing on a busy corner with a sign that reads "I Suck at Fantasy Football."

Continue Reading Below

The Grab Bag

Jupiterimages/liquidlibrary/Getty Images

Travis Knoll's BIG League in Bigfork, Montana, wonders why only one guy should have all the fun. They decided it's not just the one in last place who gets punished. It's everyone who didn't win the league.

Travis explains: "Whoever finished in second place gets to choose from the list of punishments, then third place, and so on, until the last-place member is struck with the worst punishment. These included getting slapped on the inner thigh four times, eating worms, eating a small jar of mayonnaise, and finally, standing about 15 yards away from the rest of the league wearing nothing but your underwear and a mask while each owner gets one shot at you with a paintball gun. Needless to say, these punishments cause much bruising, scarring, and vomiting ... as well as plenty of laughter."

The Balls in the Basement


There's no artful way to introduce this one, so I'll just go for it: balls. Huh, easier than I thought, actually.

Christopher M. Curran's Chicago-based Crotch Buffet Fantasy Football League gives out the Balls in the Basement Award to its last-place owner. The "winner" has to "proudly" display it in his house and change all of his social media pictures to include both his face and the trophy. Most important, the trophy features a removable set of realistic-looking balls. When the loser leaves the house, he must remove them from the trophy and carry them with him. If a fellow league member calls him out and he doesn't have the balls on him, he loses one draft spot in the next draft for each infraction.

Continue Reading Below

The Beer Boy

Jupiterimages/Brand X Pictures/Getty Images

No punishment is as stinky as the one for Commish Kevin Leary's Beer Boy League, based in Charlotte, North Carolina. This league has been around for 19 years, and since 2002, the last-place team has had to sign this shirt, retire its team name, and then wear the shirt during the draft. While serving everyone drinks.

It's never been washed. NEVER. 2002. Just saying.

The Grocery Store

Comstock/Comstock/Getty Images

Humiliation is always a constant theme. In Luis' league, the loser has to go to a supermarket on a busy Friday night. And what does the loser have to do there, Luis? "Pick up three items only: a large cucumber, lube, and condoms. And pay for them in the busiest line he can find," Luis explains. "It's the most uncomfortable you can feel."

Continue Reading Below

Taco Night

Jupiterimages/Comstock/Getty Images

Paul Wood Jr.'s Tecmo Bowl Fantasy League based in Bergen County, New Jersey, forces the loser to draft the next year while sitting on the toilet. After the rest of the league has used it. After a large league meal at Taco Bell. Here's last year's loser, Matt "Meats" Lucivero, owner of "Unexplained Mayhem."

Wow, the thumb would not be the finger I would be using there.

The Most Dangerous Game

Digital Vision./Digital Vision/Getty Images

Pat's Boozehound Fantasy Football League is a 14-team PPR from the Bronx with this simple ritual: "The week before the draft, the last-place finisher is taken to a paintball location, where he has to dress as a lion and be hunted by everyone else in the league."

Continue Reading Below

The Panda League

Ablestock.com/AbleStock.com/Getty Images

We come to the Panda League. They are a fantasy football league of 10 high school buddies from the Central Virginia area, and August 23, 2012 was the fifth annual draft for the league. After discussions and votes on rules changes and amendments to their governing document, the "Panda Carta," the guys got down to the last piece of business at hand: voting on this year's punishment for last place.

Now, this is a serious league. In addition to the Panda Carta, they have a roughly 3-foot-tall, 20-plus-pound trophy. They sponsor two underprivileged children to attend the Russell Wilson Passing Academy in Richmond, Virginia. And they have a league where ... the loser had to get his belly button pierced. With ... you guessed it ... a panda.

No words.

For hours, I stared at that picture, trying to top it. I couldn't. No words.

The Tattoo League

Ryan McVay/Photodisc/Getty Images

But the league with the best (erm, worst) punishment has got to be the Tattoo League out of Omaha, Nebraska.

Check it out:

Got a better punishment? Tell me about it in the comments or tweet it to me using #fantasylife.

To turn on reply notifications, click here


Load Comments