Register

Pull It Together, Guillermo

Guillermo, I’ve never questioned you in the past. When you optioned Hellboy, I was like “yeah, duh, he’s the goddamned devil.”

When you and I got sloshed over a pitcher of sangria and you said you just had to make a movie with a guy who had eyes on his hands, I was like “whatever floats your boat, dude.”

But as your friend and paid life coach, I’ve got to tell you, your recent proclamation that extra roles in The Hobbit films will be filled by fans of the movies may be the worst idea anyone’s ever had.

And to prove it to you, I invented time travel, went into the future, and brought back a review of the movie. Yes, that’s what a good fucking friend I am.

Then I destroyed the time travel device. Why? Because it’s function had been served. So take heed, Lermo. THIS is where you’re headed if you don’t wise up.

Del Toro’s The Hobbit Should Have Gone There…And Not Come Back Again

The first of two proposed movies based on Tolkien’s The Hobbit was released this week, and by now it’s a fair assumption that Director Guillermo Del Toro has fled to Spain to escape the bloodthirsty mobs that roam the streets, calling for his blood. All this reviewer can say to those who would kill the man simply for making such an awful movie is: I own a boat.

What makes The Hobbit so uniquely terrible? Perhaps it is that it defames such a beloved work of literature. When a scene as classic as the Elven picnic is interrupted by the background elves continuously jostling one another in order to get close enough to steal pieces of Lembas bread, your movie’s in trouble.

I’d warn of spoilers, but it seems to me that one can’t really spoil a big plate of shit. In Part I of The Hobbit, the “acting” work, almost exclusively in group scenes, contains a number of filmic atrocities the likes of which I’ve never witnessed. Rampant, unjustified departures from the original story included:

  • A goblin warrior referring to his sword as “+1.”
  • A giant spider pausing mid-lunge in order to request an autograph from a captured Dwarf.
  • The complete disregarding of Bilbo’s supposed invisibility by a Lake Town local who proceeds to snap photos of him on an iPhone.
  • A number of goblins marveling aloud at the fact that Gollum is just a tennis ball on a stick.
  • Two trolls agreeing that “this is so awesome” while chasing the dwarven party through the woods.
  • And worst of all, a total breach of character on the part of Bilbo when, instead of eloquently preaching against war to the Five Armies, he simply screams to the attendant multitudes: “Shut up! Just shut up! Will you nerds just please shut the fuck up?!”
  • In the end, Mr. Del Toro appears to have had so little control over his set, one wonders if he’s ever even heard of poisonous gas.

    The Hobbit? More like The Bobbitt. By which I mean this film was so bad that it cut my dick off and flung it into the street.


    In a parallel timestream, Michael is still head writer and co-founder of Those Aren’t Muskets!

    Last 5 posts by Michael Swaim

    This entry was posted on Thursday, July 10th, 2008 at 8:00 am and is filed under Guillermo Del Toro, Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

    Leave a Reply

    49 Responses to “Pull It Together, Guillermo”

    1. candy Says:

      This guy is ugly!! He is dating a famous rich woman on the top sugar dating site ^Black s u g a r m o m m y^co m, and the nice car he drives was a gift from that woman. He can make a perfect sugarbaby!!!!

    2. mshobbo Says:

      What a wonderful article. Maybe we can have further hobbit-related discussions and see pictures of sexy she-hobbits at __hothobbits.com__!.

    3. Nicole Says:

      So true. What the hell is he thinking? I’m hoping that by “extras” he means the people in the movies that you only see for half a second before they are decapitated.

      P.S. Guillermo is a Spanish name and would be pronounced “Geeyairmoe”, so Lermo wouldn’t really work as a nickname…

    4. Panzier-Stier Ross Says:

      At least, that’s what he’d tell you.

    5. ErgonomicVulture Says:

      Vice versa? Fucking syrup whilst covered in trees? Either way, it sounds like something Bear Grylls would do: “This is how to keep warm when you’re lost in the Casnadian wilderness.”

    6. Orchids Says:

      how about fucking trees while covered in syrup? Or vise versa…

    7. J-Pappi Says:

      Is that site for people who like to fuck trees, or syrup? Inquiring minds want to know.

    8. fred Says:

      well……there’s this
      http://www.fakebuddy.com

    9. kingmonkey +1 Says:

      Probably more fun than I had after meeting fun young singles on maplebang.ca.

      Of course, having just read what I wrote, I do believe maplebang is going to become my new catch-phrase.

    10. glendoor42 Says:

      Oh come on Ross, we know that you were out with somebody you met on ___UKbigdate.com___! .

    11. Panzier-Stier Ross Says:

      Yes, Britain, that whole region.

      You think you can trust an Aussie with an obese cat and turn your back to play Vice City and what happens?

      You don’t want to know, let’s just say that.

    12. J-Pappi Says:

      Ok, ok; I suppose I can let it slide this time. What’s this about a time difference? You on the West Coast, Ross? The rest of the world outside Ah-mur-kah don’t count; gotta get the clocks fixed. Though I suppose Britain gets a pass since they invented the whole mean standard time thing in the first place. But you can only use that excuse if you’re going by actual twin authentic naval chronometers. I’ll buy the whole cat, Aussie, Vice City thing though. Fucking Aussies.

    13. vagrant_hippo Says:

      and I was busy making fake spam comments about midgets fucking that prolly looked too much like spam a few comments up

      it took all day to think of it, i swear

    14. hotsexyBBW Says:

      Nice post! I also saw many personal blogs, hot sexy photos&videos @ sexy big people dating club ___UKbigdate.c om___! So many big beautiful women and big handsome men mingle there for fun&love!

    15. Panzier-Stier Ross Says:

      The Australian is having therapy though. And Vice City will never work again.

    16. Panzier-Stier Ross Says:

      He survived. Barely, but he survived.

    17. glendoor42 Says:

      Sorry J-pappi I would have rather been responding to post here because some shark managed to open and drank all the Jack Daniel mini bottles I used for bait. No great loss though, they were filled with cat pee.

    18. kingmonkey +1 Says:

      I hope the cat’s okay.

    19. Panzier-Stier Ross Says:

      Sorry J, combination of time difference and that whole incident involving an obese cat, an Australian and a copy of GTA: Vice City kinda got in the way.

    20. vagrant_hippo Says:

      Hey guys, nice discussion, but i found a great site, midgetsfucking.com, you should all check it out.

    21. Forsooth! Says:

      How long will it be before we get a midget dating site from this spambots?

    22. basil Says:

      I saw many hot video at a black bbw dating site called interracial romancing.com. You can even check out more sexy and beautiful photos, videos and blogs

    23. kingmonkey +1 Says:

      I would have responded, but I was minding my own business, swimming around in my shark cosutme. Some asshole kept throwing a fishing line into the water, though, baited with tiny little Jack Daniels bottles.

    24. J-Pappi Says:

      That’s better. Sort of. And these bots are getting disturbingly more human. If robot technology increases even half that fast we’ll all be the wrong Sarah Connor in the phone book.

    25. alen Says:

      Hi, guys, nice discussion, But it is new year now, would you love to try something new to celebrate these great days? How about interracial hot dating? mixed loving . c o m you will be surprised

    26. glendoor42 Says:

      I’m shark fishing.

    27. Metalbrainsurgery Says:

      J- Pappi, I playing guitar.

    28. J-Pappi Says:

      Where the fuck is everyone? I don’t want to hear that lame-ass “I gotta work tomorrow” or “I’ve got a girlfriend” shit either. I know better.

      BLOG, BITCHES.

    29. J-Pappi Says:

      Marshmaniac, pumpkins aren’t really all that scary when you get to know them. In fact, I know some intimately. Oh, yes. Very intimately.

      Byakuya, it’s probably too late tonight, but yeah in general. And I haven’t seen the first one; this one just looks like it’ll be better. Plus, the Onion A.V. Club said so.

    30. byakuya Says:

      Anybody else looking forward to Hellboy 2 tonight?

    31. marshmaniac Says:

      oh no, a pumpkin

    32. J-Pappi Says:

      Canadian Nazis? “Achtung, Juden! Eh?”

    33. Forsooth! Says:

      For this simply fantasmical blog post, you get many man-hugs Captain Swaim!

    34. glendoor42 Says:

      Yeah, nobody would have looked for you there, that’s for damn sure.

    35. kingmonkey +1 Says:

      Well, how were we supposed to know, Ross? Shit, in hindsight, we really should have just come back to Casnadia.

    36. Panzier-Stier Ross Says:

      Don’t forget those 2 bit thugs from Vegas who’ve never done anything crazy before that night.

    37. J-Pappi Says:

      Fleeing TO Mexico? I thought only train robbers and Nazi’s did that.

    38. Michael Swaim Says:

      He originally fled to Mexico, but they wouldn’t have him. Spain was his backup.

    39. Wiglaf Says:

      “bloodthirsty mobs that roam the streets, calling for his blood”

      Swaim,
      Where’s your editor? Come on! Who’s editing this crap?? Calling for blood is what bloodthirsty mobs do. You should have written: “bloody mobs that roam the streets, calling for his thirst”

      There. That’s better…I think.

      I’d rather have a sword that was “+p”.

    40. fernando Says:

      Del Toro is from Mexico, not Spain.

    41. StiffenLimp Says:

      All I know is that Guillermo better not fuck up the only JRR Tolkien book I actually read. For if he does, it shall be Antzar Eguna for Señor Del Toro.

      P.S. - Swaim, I am truly disappointed that you destroyed that time machine. We could have headed to 2050 to see how that Robot Sex think Bucholz was talking about went…

    42. glendoor42 Says:

      You forgot to mention the one hobbit who managed to get the poster that had the letters
      TAM in almost every scene of Bilbo that was filmed.

    43. Panzier-Stier Ross Says:

      I thought between The Hobbit and The Fellowship would just be endless black space.

      If we’re getting a fantasy epic novel turned movie I want them to finally put that The Name of The Wind film into production.

    44. Res_Ipsa Says:

      Also–I laughed so hard at that PA.

      Isn’t H2 supposed to be released . . . in December of 2012? . . . That’s ominous.

    45. Res_Ipsa Says:

      The idea of making The Hobbit: 2 (yes, I know it won’t technically be a “second” Hobbit) without Christopher Tolkien’s help or approval (as I understand it) scares me to no end.

    46. Levon Swift Says:

      Del Toro’s Dr. Strange would kick ass.

      I’m interested to see what this second film contains, as it is my understanding that it is set between The Hobbit and The LOTR.

      I’m not the only one concerned:

      http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2008/5/28/

    47. kingmonkey +1 Says:

      I’m more anxious to see is Del Toro is actually going to put out a Doctor Strange movie.

    48. Masonic Ski Lodge Says:

      I’d totally sleep with a hobbit.

    49. Robot Jesus Says:

      Which parts would be played by nerds?

    Leave a Reply

    Related Articles

    Cracked stuff on