Five Reasons The Rapture Did Not Occur
The Rapture is a belief among some Christians that they'll be godnapped to Heaven with little to no warning. Preacher Harold Camping predicted an earthquake would commence this prank on May 21, 2011. His ministry has raised millions of dollars by telling people they will soon have no need for millions of dollars.
As this post goes live at 6:00 p.m. local time, I am as-yet undestroyed by the Rapture, and only slowly being destroyed by this fearful series of losses called life. In fact, it's raining from a sunny sky in New York right now, so I presume a rainbow will shortly appear to promise bodily safety and gay rights. Therefore, I am calling shenanigans on Harold Camping, for these five reasons.
The Rapture is derived from a passage about the saved dead rising, with the righteous living later "caught up together with them in the clouds." Not that I object to a zombie apocalypse, but spontaneous discorporation requires an escape-velocity leap of logic. Regardless: no zombies? No Rapture.
Universal
This is what Heaven looks like
Zombies trump earthquakes. Kicking off Armageddon with something that occurs fifty times a day is the kind of quaint opening number that only an 89-year-old man with more money than time finds rah-rah rousing. Does Camping know what a zombie is? To find out, offer him a nickel. If he thinks it will buy him three reels at the pictures plus a malted for his best dame, we know the last time he saw a zombie, it was sleepwalking in the thrall of an effete, ambiguously European man of leisure.
United Artists
What our grandparents called zombies, we call kept woman.
The Bible says more on resurrected dead than it does the Rapture. It also says wild animals will devour the survivors, to which I reply: there's room for interpretation. Camping figures 6.5 billion people will be left behind, so what beast other than a zombie is populous enough to eat us all? Three Luke Wilsons?
Speaking of interpretation, now that we've played golf on the moon, we know Heaven is someplace other than the clouds, possibly in Sofia Vergara's embrace.
ABC
The case can be made.
A literalist's only way out here is to argue "with them in the clouds" is figurative language for the world above this sliver of reality we experience as life, or in my case, alcoholic fugues. But if that's the case, you're not a literalist. You can't be a fundamentalist and still claim poetic license. You don't see lawyers arguing the symbolic imagery in contracts. Unless God's trying to save gas and meet you at the halfway mark in the troposphere, there are only four remaining possibilities:
Every word of the Bible is literally trueResolved- Everything in the Bible is correct, but some of it figuratively so
- Some of the Bible is right, and some of it is wrong
- None of the Bible is true
- It would be better to have a beer than argue over how true the Bible is
We know it's not number four, because the Bible says it's not, and the Bible says the Bible is infallible, so: boom, airtight argument. Nor is it number three, because you know who else is right sometimes and wrong others? TV's Walton Goggins. An actor can't be the Bible! That's blasphemy. Besides, we know they're separate because unlike Goggins, the Bible doesn't improve every film it's in.
Walton Goggins
In his spare time, he is a Star Wars character
Obviously it's not number two because abstract thought is intimidating, and the Bible wasn't written to scare us, except for all the infanticide parts. The fact is God loves you and, being wise, He knows you can't scare someone into loving you back under threat of endless agony. Believe me, I've tried! Granted, it was my agony, not hers, but the court didn't appreciate the difference. Again: lawyers don't understand that 47 pages of poetry like "The sizzling blood which from my wrist doth gush," are just fanciful phrasing for more literal ideas, such as "I'm empty inside," or "I'm going to kidnap you to the clouds."
So plainly, the only answer we can prove is number five, no matter how many beers it takes.
Apart from Thessalonians, the big passage cited as proof of the Rapture is from The Book of Matthew -- "Two men will be in the field; one will be taken and the other left." Plainly the second man sexually assaulted the first and fled the scene, but even apart from that, you don't want to bring this up as proof of Rapturedom, because four verses prior, Jesus says:
But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father.
That's not just the Bible talking. That's the Son of God Himself throwing up His hands and shrugging, "I just work here." Yahweh requires undisturbed secrecy to complete his sinister scheme to lay waste to the Earth, like a supervillain, or most kittens.
Michelangelo made God, and make mine Marvel, but only God can make a kitten.
You can't say there aren't similarities
Since Camping claims to have the inside track not even Jesus has, that's false prophecy, which The Lord does not approve of. These aren't buried nuggets from the book of Ezakazekeliakah; these are direct quotes from Jesus. Camping has built a mountain of success atop a document he's never even read, and only Michele Bachmann should get away with that, because she's the funniest thing on TV right now. It's like he's daring people to stop giving him money, but they keep falling for his bluff. This isn't even his first failed Armageddon. How many times do you have to miscalculate the end of the world before the nation's seniors stop sending you their social security check?
Look, the greatest daily feature of democracy is you can't crucify someone just for disseminating their ideas. The worst features of democracy are hearing Rosie O'Donnell's opinions and watching the cast of The Jersey Shore get rich.
MTV
No way will they enter Heaven. They can barely get into Italy.
Upstanding citizens often confuse decent respect for a belief's existence with respect for its validity. There's a thick line in society blocking polite people from calling most ideas crazy, drawn at the intersection of those ideas' popularity and how big a knob they make you.
Brendan
We found that Pet Rock was considered stupid but not crazy.
As you can see, there's a wide, and long-recognized gap between awaiting the Rapture and trying to raise money from it. But even the former deprives yourself. Most people bang the drum until they can't hear the band change its tune. The notion of being evaporated without notice was a hot idea to people in the 1600s, when the only hobbies were collecting different strains of pox and dancing the hey-nonny in puffy leggings. But you live in the 21st century -- an era of air conditioning, vaccines, and, need I remind you? Sofia Vergara. No matter how bad things get, there's more to discover, experience, and eat (unless your problem is famine). It's a rich world, and you have no reason to want to escape it, unless...oh my God, she's never coming back.
One for the Rapture, please.
Brendan McGinley is past saving.









Hell yeah, Mr. Rodgers!
ReplyI laughed when I saw the kitten for some reason.
ReplyAwesome article and entirely spot-on as well. It's always fun looking at those people who usher in the end-times like it's actually going to happen. Silly Christians!
Replyi wanted you to know that i rated you down because your name implies that you're a hipster... and that you think it's ironic and cool to pretend not to be in the most irritating way possible.... also nasa thinks the world might end in 2012 because of solar flares... soooo SILLY SCIENCE .... though plunging into the dark ages isn't really the same lol
"We know it's not number four, because the Bible says it's not, and the Bible says the Bible is infallible"
ReplyActually the Bible never claims to be infallible. the closest it gets is saying that it is 'God-breathed', but that doesn't necessarily equate with infallibility.
2 and 3 were spot on. The others... not so much. The rapture hasn't happened because it won't happen. Airtight logic there. And on 5, I would point out that the dead rising thing comes after the rapture, which is the start of the whole end of the world process.
ReplyArticles like this annoy me. I love some atheists mind you but some of them ruin it for the rest of us.
ReplySocialism (1920s) - Sane and Accepted
Reply Hide All See All 4 Replieswat
Even John Wayne said he was a socialist back then. It was actually a pretty popular idea among young people.
It still seems to be a popular idea among young people, they just don't want to call it "Socialism"
Yes, it used to be wildly popular among us people.
nazis really killed socialism (by using it in their name) it has gone the way of the hitler mustache and the name adolf (unless your name is hans lundgren)
I object to Objectivism's place below center on the sane-crazy axis. The self-centered ramblings of an entitled b***h who doesn't understand how the world works and is just reacting to trauma in her childhood for FREAKING DECADES is not by any stretch 'sane'.
ReplyI don't like the direction Scientology seems to be heading here.
ReplyWhoa, a 3D graph! Crazy.
ReplyOk........ I am lost. Why was blaming the victim acceptable in the 1950s.
ReplySame reason it is acceptable today?
An example that seemed to have been considered acceptable in the 1950s: Well, I'm sorry the black guy got lynched, but he shouldn't have been winking at the white women.
An example that seems to be considered acceptable today: Well, I'm sorry the woman got raped, but she shouldn't have been wearing that shirt.
I just saw this; why are most of these articles not even listed on the main page? When did this guy become a columnist? WHY was he made a columnist? Mysteries abound.
ReplyReligion, like politics, is just a tool used by the moronic to gain a foothold in society. G.W. Bush... For example.
Reply Hide All See All 3 Replieszing! take THAT, all 5 billion of you morons.
@JesseClark, the majority isn't always right.
ok did you just compare george bush to
Jesus, Buddha, Zeus, Odin, Allah and all those indian gods?
ummm wow
I paid $32.67 for a XBOX 360 and my mom got a 17 inch Toshiba laptop for $94.83 being delivered to our house tomorrow by FedEX. I will never again pay expensive retail prices at stores. I even sold a 46 inch HDTV to my boss for $650 and it only cost me $52.78 to get. Here is the website we using to get all this stuff, FullBids.com
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesJesus tells me you should give all your money to me.
Right now.
Why do spambots still exist on this site? All anyone ever does is make fun of them.
So you ripped your boss off.......... seems legit.
I think that a religion, whose only hard and fast rule is "Believe this and nothing else, otherwise you are going to Hell!" is a pretty bleak religion. I'd rather not have all of that BS dogma in my life, thanks.
ReplyYou just reminded me of a book of quotes I have. In it there's a quote by someone called Annie Dillard which says "I read about an Eskimo hunter who asked the local missionary priest, 'If I did not know about God and sin, would I go to hell?' 'No' Replies the priest 'Not if you did not know.' 'Then why,' asked the Eskimo, 'did you tell me?'"
Very well written article, I agree. But your Sofia Vergara is another person's soap opera. What will all the hill billies do without Touched by an Angel? (Or whatever soap opera was cancelled recently). I would think someone who actually believes the rapture is coming whenever some preacher says it will the most fun they have is shooting beer cans and catching possums. Guess they just have to wait another 6 months.
ReplySofia Vergara FTW. You're a breath of fresh air McGinley. I was sick and tired of hearing about how fat, female and Asian Christina H is, and how many cats she has.
ReplyGreat article i really loved the idea of heaven being in Sofia's embrace.
ReplyDancing hey-nonny, in puffy leggings is not a hobby, it is an ART!!! I say 'Good day' to you, Sir! >:{[-
ReplyStupid graph :(
ReplyBrilliant comment.