Why We Should All Be Scared Now That Facebook Has Gaydar
Students at MIT have devised a way to identify people who are gay by analyzing their Facebook profiles. The method works by examining who a person is friends with, and drawing conclusions based on the characteristics of those friends. Based on the principle that birds of a feather flock together, the technique assumes that if a person is friends with a high percentage of people who are themselves identified as gay, that person is guaranteed to be super-gay.
The linked article goes off into a discussion of online privacy in the face of ever improving technology and changing social norms, but once it started using complicated words like homophily and principle I kind of lost interest. Anyone trying to make a point without first breaking it down into a list of the 10 Most Hilarious Episodes of The Gummi Bears isn't going to get a lot of traction with me.
No, instead of caring about the actually-interesting privacy issues, my first though upon reading this was one of concern. You see, I havent been particularly discriminatory when adding friends on Facebook. As a ruggedly handsome Internet humor-smith, a significant number of people have realized their lives would be meaningless without adding me as a friend. And, perhaps due to childhood memories of loneliness and having to ride the teeter-toter with the school janitor, I havent rejected a single friend yet. As a consequence, my Friends list is now inflated with a significant percentage of people Ive never met at all.
So my worry, given the probable-depraved nature of anyone who would find me amusing, is what would someone running a similar algorithm on me find? Based on the company I supposedly keep, would a researcher conclude that Im a fan of mustache-rodeos? I had to find out.
So, using the computer knowledge that all white guys with glasses possess, I fired up my laptop, and during a techno laden montage of progress bars and really fast typing, hacked in to an MIT mainframe and stole a copy of the code used by the researchers. After reviewing it, I saw numerous opportunities to expand upon the students work, and over the next four minutes made several improvements to the original algorithm. Most notably, I implemented several heuristic generalizations into the code and gave it the ability to pivot on all possible classification criteria, not just homosexuality. Once activated the software would comb my list of friends, their lists of friends and so on, computing a list of attributes that all my accidental acquaintances possessed. If I had a significant number of friends with a given attribute, the algorithm's output would then indicate that I myself share the same attribute.
It was clear that activating such a wide-ranging piece of software would potentially be a violation of Facebooks terms and conditions, set me up for felony charges and usher in a dystopic world where privacy was nonexistent, and government boots were constantly pressed to our necks. So I had a nice stiff drink first. The programs output and my accompanying notes are recorded below.
__
YOU ARE: Straight
Whew. I cant say Im that surprised, but I guess Dad will be happy.
YOU ARE: White
Nothing to disagree with here either, although I think for a later version of the software it would be amusing to quantify just how white I am. (Correct Answer: 786.2 Greg Bradys on the Stanford-Brady Complexion Gradient Scale [revised] [1994])
YOU ARE: An alcoholic
Well thats wrong. And no, Im not just saying its wrong because I CAN QUIT ANY TIME (smashes a glass on the wall). Although I like beer, and drink beer, and have good times with beer, we also know we don't have to spend every waking second with each other. The time apart makes our relationship all that much stronger. However it looks like a lot of my friends don't feel the same way. Im guessing the software observed that many of them have pictures of themselves doing keg hoists or shooter blasters or whiskey felchers or whatever it is the kids do now a days.
YOU ARE: A fan fiction author
So it seems a lot of my friends like losing themselves in their own worlds full of popular, copyrighted characters. Nothing wrong with that I guess, but I don't think it applies to me. Some of you may recall the early months of this column, when I used to write highly sexual tales featuring Lieutenant Worf and Count Chocula, but those were actually sonnets and not fan-fiction, if you look carefully.
YOU ARE: Chinese
This one confused me, because earlier it said I was white. Then I wondered if it thought I was Chinese as in nationality-wise. A review of the data revealed that a big chunk of my friends are Chinese spambots. Surprisingly this subset included two of my ex-girlfriends, which upon further reflection probably explains why they kept selling me all those region-free DVDs.
YOU ARE: A communist
At first I assumed this was caused by those Chinese spambots again, and thought the irony of being tagged a communist by associating with spambots (the armpit of capitalism) was pretty rich. But further review revealed that a sizable number of my friends have been chattering about health care reform, and my apparently staunchly-conservative computer has rather editorialized their views rather harshly. That may be a bug.
YOU ARE: An arsonist
Err. I may be splitting hairs here, but Ive always considered an arsonist someone who burns things because they like watching them burn. I only burn things because its funny. Im going to give my friends who enjoy flame-based comedy the same benefit of the doubt.
YOU ARE: On an FBI watchlist
I think this is actually pretty standard for anyone whos friends with Cracked Columnist Dan OBrien.
YOU ARE: A hermaphrodite
You see? This is what I was worried about. Apparently 43 of my friends are part of some group called the Chicks With Dicks Alliance.
YOU ARE: Capable of fellating yourself
Hang on. Nope, not even close. Although I guess congratulations to my statistically significant number of friends who can.
YOU ARE: Interested in knowing what Bert and Ernie are like, off-camera
This is completely true.
YOU ARE: Being stalked by eight people
Evidently eight of my friends are also stalking me, operating in shifts. Theyre organized, well equipped and have a particular interest in ass-shots. Hey team.
YOU ARE: In terrible danger
The software seems to think that one of my admirers has been reading up on African tribal rituals, and is now convinced that by consuming my blood they will gain my powers. The algorithm is only supposed to pick up on statistically significant groups of people though, so this is probably a bug too.
YOU ARE: Theyre in the house. Fly you fool!
Evidently the program has taken up my sense for melodrama, and also my deep passion for plagiarizing Tolkien. These bugs are starting to annoy me. As soon as I get back from investigating that noise in the cellar Ill take care of them.
___
Follow Cracked on Facebook and you'll be the first to know about all the ways you're being spied upon. Well, the first to know besides whoever is spying on you.









I was particularly impressed by the effort apparent in making the Stanford-Brady Complexion Gradient Scale so formal-founding...
ReplyLOL Based on my friends, it would probably say I'm a bi, heavily tattooed/pierced, Chinese Indonesian (possibly from Brunei/Malaysia) with a criminal record and a history of picking loser boyfriends. Oh, and that I'm in a screamo band and love photography. I don't know why or how these people became the majority of my FB friends, but there ya go.
ReplyReality:
White-ish straight girl with one tattoo, no criminal record and a love of languages living in the US who doesn't understand the appeal of screamo and prefers obsessing over Korean boy bands and watching J/K/T dramas.
the second i read you loved korean boybands i knew why your friends were indonesian.
NOT THE CELLAR! Dammit, Chris, run!
ReplyGuess mine would say I was from ZombieLand.
ReplyThis was awesome
ReplyThat was utterly hilarious. I was laughing so hard, I almost inhaled the rotten cafeteria pizza I was eating.
ReplyWOW, people, start thinking a little. This was a comedy article. Bucholz did not actually run a program that told him that he was both white and chinese, or an alcoholic. It's all a joke, so stop whining about how "it's a big step backwards in facebook's social system."
ReplyAre you calling Bucholz a liar? He is white, has glasses, and is also apparently Chinese. Of course he can re-program something in four minutes.
"As a ruggedly handsome Internet humor-smith, a significant number of people have realized their lives would be meaningless without adding me as a friend."
ReplyThat's a dangling participle, unless the "significant number of people" "are [sic] a [sic] [...] humor-smith [...]." Also, I like Dairy Queen.
You'll quiet down unless you want me to kick YOU in the dangling participle!
According to that algorithm, I'd probably be:
ReplyWhite
A Hipster
Originally from Nigeria and/or India (contradicts the first one, though)
A Lesbian
A Fan of Dashing Fellows
Podophile (Foot Fetishist)
And other things. I haven't looked through my friend list in a while.
[...] markers, a la the “gay face” (and speaking of search engines, it may be possible to program computers with gaydar) — not that I’m suggesting in any way that these people are gay (I’m assuming [...]
ReplyI do agree activities on social networking sites as facebook might leak some personal information. And the experiment Gadar even proved that "people may reveal information about themselves in another way, and without knowing they are making it public. ” But is it necessary to keep everything private online? What is facebook for?
ReplyMaybe some of us would like a more natural or subconscious way to make ourselves known. For example, a guy might "come out " by just revealing his friend list. Isn't it a glad thing for him for it saved all the concerns or hesitations? So I think it's too early to worry about privacy because of Gaydar. Besides, the so called "accuracy" is not that accurate. Look at the above"YOU ARE:White"and "YOU ARE: Chinese"
nice trolling LOL
A more serious note is that it promotes homophobia. Now people will avoid gay and bi friends so that they won't be labeled as such themselves. This is really a stupid system, as straight people who can accept their gay friends are probably more secure in the sexual orientation then there homophobic counter parts.
ReplyAlso what ever happened to not randomly judging people without knowing them? Oh, here's a picture of you with a beer, you're an alcoholic! Sorry if I'm ranting, but this really bothers me, it's a huge step backward in Facebook's social system.
Um...
ReplyThis is my rifle!
there are many others like it!
This one is mine!
Without me, my rifle is useless!
Without my rifle, I am useless!
Good job Mr. Marine, now f**k off before the navy kicks your teeth in.
I bet it ended with, "YOU ARE: A VERY Dangerous Man to Fuck With," which leads me to feeling sorry for those people in your house
ReplyThe Gummi Bears bit and your computer saying you're a hermaphrodite really got me! Great article.
ReplyYou okay there, Gabriel?
ReplyYou made some good points there ;)
ReplyI don't see how this could work all the time. There has got to be a huge margin of error....... As somebody who was in performing arts for over 10 years I have many gay friends, but I myself am not gay. I don't see how this could be accurate. It makes assumptions based on assumpions. The software has to assume that everything in a persons profile is correct, and that is where the problem is.
ReplyI want to make sweet love to your rigomortissed body then I want to use your cold blood to jerk off and then ill smear your poop from your split open colon all over my face and then write I love you in your own shit.
Reply Hide All See All 4 RepliesJust kidding., Your my hero and im only 14 years old :)
Ho.Ly. Shit.
What the f**k did I just read?
You should write for Cannibal Corpse.
I bet you would be the type to type that freaky fanfiction s**t where some innocent child character fucks their sister. Or the type that goes to the library every morning and during lunch in high school to actually read. I only say that because you want to slap your dick with a dead man's fluids.
Technically we're only interested in facepainting each other with your blood, so you don't really have to die (unless you resist).
Reply