5 Feel-Good Movie Lessons Undone By Their Own Plots

It's no secret that Cracked loves to bag on Hollywood. And let's face it: They kind of deserve it. Every movie, no matter how dark or light-hearted, attempts to teach us some sort of moral lesson in the end. It's just that Hollywood is about the least reliable source of moral values on the planet. When they try, they come across like one of those people who claims to have taught their dog to talk. "Wait, you don't hear it? He's saying the 'I Have A Dream' speech!" Nope. All I hear is a howling, whining dog.

Feel-good movies are the biggest culprits. Their entire story hinges around a good, solid moral. But when you combine that with standard Hollywood dipshit writing, it just goes to hell. In fact, in the following examples, the moral isn't just bad ... it actually undoes the entire point of the movie. For instance ...

#5. Finding Nemo: Never Let Your Kids Out Of Your Sight

Pixar

The Intended Moral:

The whole point in Finding Nemo is that Marlin, Nemo's overbearing father, needs to relax -- learn to let go and allow his son to grow up in his own time, in his own way (because that always works with kids).

Pixar
Finding Emo

When he takes Nemo to school for the first time and learns that the teacher is taking them to the drop-off, Marlin freaks the hell out and races after them. He tells Nemo's teacher that his son could easily sneak off and get hurt, that he's not ready for school yet, and a bunch of other crap that makes us roll our eyes at how demanding a father he is and how unfortunate Nemo is to have such a hardass dad. We've all seen those overprotective parents, and we always want to tell them, "Holy shit, dude, you have to settle down. Your kid will be fine."

But Marlin is absolutely right, because everything that happens during the film should convince him that instead of letting go, the exact opposite is true.

The Actual Moral:

From the moment the film begins, Marlin has to deal with so much shit it's a miracle he doesn't strap Nemo to the anemone and keep watch 24/7. Let's have a recap:

1) His wife and 99 percent of his children are eaten alive by a barracuda. 2) His son, on his first day of school, ventures away from the class and is kidnapped by an Australian dentist (Parents: Beware). 3) He is pressed into joining a "Fish Are Friends" AA-style club run by sharks, who are not sticking to the program. 4) Said club's leader, Bruce, tries to eat him. 5) He is almost blown up by underwater mines. 6) He is eaten, but not digested, by an angler fish. 7) He is shocked unconscious by jellyfish. 8) Again he is eaten, but not digested, this time by a whale. 9) He survives a spinning "vortex of terror." 10) Once more, he is eaten, but not digested, by a pelican (for a change).

Pixar
He's been in and out of more mouths than Ron Jeremy.

The idea that Marlin should just chill out like a stoner turtle, or let go like an amnesiac tang fish, and let Nemo find his own way in a world that is systematically trying to kill them, is just plain dumb.

Plus, the two characters who give him this advice are easily the least trustworthy of the lot. Dory can barely remember her own name, but Marlin is supposed to believe that she knows when is the right time to "let go." Is she even a parent? She tells him this after they've been eaten by a whale.

Pixar
And this dingus is getting her own goddamn movie.

As for Dude Crush (the stoner turtle), he's just lucky his kid, Squirt, isn't eaten by a passing shark or knocked unconscious when spinning out of the East Australian Current. And yet Marlin is supposed to take that as a good example of parenting?

Oh, and remember at the start when Marlin loses his shit when he learns his kid is going to the drop-off, worrying that Nemo would get away from the rest of the class and something bad would happen? That part when we all rolled our eyes? Yeah, that's exactly what happens.

Pixar
Assholes.

The real lesson of Finding Nemo for parents is: Don't let your children go outside or leave your sight for a single moment, ever, because they will likely die.

#4. Mrs. Doubtfire: Your Parents Are Divorced Because Of You

20th Century Fox

The Intended Moral:

In Mrs. Doubtfire, Daniel Hillard quits his well-paying voiceover job (on moral grounds, admittedly) which ends his career and leaves him working in a warehouse. After his marriage disintegrates, he decides that pretending to be a woman in order to babysit his children for the next few months will not only help him pay the bills but also let him see more of his kids. A win-win situation, right?

Well, no. Not only does Daniel lose his wife (to James Bond!), he almost loses access to his kids for good. But it's OK, because in the end he gets to visit them regularly and they all live (kinda) happily ever after.

20th Century Fox
Though the annual Christmas photos got a little weird after that.

Mrs. Doubtfire was a huge deal in my life growing up, as it was the one movie I had ever seen where we not only got to see a broken family, we watched them breaking up. Like for many in my generation, my parents hit Splitsville when I was young, and it was a weird and difficult time, filling my head with basic questions such as, "Why can't mom and dad be in the same room at the same time (is it a Clark Kent/Superman situation)?"

DC Comics
Not all of us were fortunate enough to have Barry Allen as a parent.

The moral is delivered right at the end. When we see Daniel driving off with his kids, we hear his character on TV answer a child of divorcees, reassuring them that, "Just because your parents don't love each other anymore, it doesn't mean that they don't love you."

Which, I'm here to tell you, was something I really needed to hear way back when.

The Actual Moral:

The problem is, and I hate to do this to my 8-year-old self, that's not the real moral of the story.

That comes during the trial at the end, after Daniel's plan has come undone in a drunken fuck-up. After it all unravels, the judge passes "that despicable order" (in Daniel's words), telling him that his behavior was potentially harmful to his children and not only is he denying him access to them, he suggests Daniel seek professional help.

20th Century Fox
Does this look like the face of a crazy person to you?

Which is completely rational from a legal standpoint.

Mrs. Doubtfire seeks to assure kids that even if their parents are separated, they still love them. No one would argue against this in Daniel Hillard's case, but this love manifests itself in very harmful ways: It pushes his wife away and almost turns his son catatonic when he discovers that the babysitter has a pee-pee.

In defense of his actions, Daniel says, "As for my behavior, I can only plead insanity. From the moment I held them I was crazy about them. I was hooked. I'm addicted to my children."

His children are his drug, and his inability to find a middle ground where he helps his wife look after them in a mature way costs him his marriage (and, very almost, access to his kids).

20th Century Fox
Of course, the drugs Daniel actually needs are antipsychotics.

So the real message of the film is: The reason your parents are no longer together is because they love you so much. That love is a mental illness. It will make you uncontrollably obsessive, to the point that you lose your ability to think and behave rationally.

I'm sure that's a great comfort.

#3. Forrest Gump: Do What You're Told, Idiot

Paramount Pictures

The Intended Moral:

Stepping to the side of the Jenny abuses Forrest debate, this Oscar-winning epic of a mentally deficient boy going on to deeply influence popular culture and succeed in everything he does seems, on the face of it, to have a very positive message (again, apart from the Jenny-abuses-Forrest thing): Mentally challenged individuals can exceed expectations and inspire others.

Forrest comes from humble beginnings, so humble in fact that he is almost denied a basic education but manages to go on to graduate college, become a war hero, invent Elvis' dance moves, and earn a shit-ton of money. And if that ain't the American Dream, then I don't know what is.

Paramount Pictures
Dude even puts a positive spin on stepping in dog poop.

Take another look at Forrest Gump, however, and you find a very different lesson.

The Actual Moral:

Everything Forrest does or achieves is either a result of luck (investing in Apple, surviving the storm to create the Bubba Gump Shrimp empire, cleaning his face on a T-shirt and inadvertently creating the smiley) or, most importantly, by doing what he is told to do.

Forrest's mom tells him, "Stupid is as stupid does." Well, she may be right, but blindly following everything you are told until you're informed otherwise isn't stupid: It's brainless.

Paramount Pictures
"If you ever catch a feather, always start telling total strangers your entire life story."
"Yes, mama."

Someone must have attempted to sit down with Forrest and explain the rules of football to him, but because he was told to run (most notably by Jenny when he was younger), he does just that until screamed at by half the stadium to stop. His C.O. tells him he's a "goddamn genius" because he does exactly what he's told, to the letter, with no thought about what he wants, thinks, or needs. The perfect soldier, in other words.

Paramount Pictures
With the attention span of a moth, but still.

His ability to focus on one task at a time (be it running, assembling rifles, or keeping his eye on the ping-pong ball) leads him to the top of each field. Forrest becomes a Vietnam War hero, an Olympic champion, and a Forbes 100 CEO, and all because he never asks any questions (such as, "Why am I running from coast to coast?" Or, "Do I think the war in Vietnam is just?"). Instead, he mindlessly sticks to everything he does because he's told to.

That's one helluva criticism of society in general, and a total slap in the face to anyone who suffers from a disability: Do exactly what you are told and don't ask any questions and you'll do just fine, because "Life is like a box of chocolates; you don't buy those for yourself -- someone hands it to you as a gift."

Paramount Pictures
Just gonna leave this here ...

Recommended For Your Pleasure

Matt Cowan

  • Rss

More by Matt Cowan:

See More
To turn on reply notifications, click here

358 Comments

The Cracked Podcast

Choosing to "Like" Cracked has no side effects, so what's the worst that could happen?

The Weekly Hit List

Sit back... Relax... We'll do all the work.
Get a weekly update on the best at Cracked. Subscribe now!