Television and Film Industry: I Dislike You and Your Opinions, and etc.
If you check out the CRACKED forums, you’ll notice a lot of heated debate about “Sin,” the proprietor of the defunct tv-links domain, having his site shut down and being sued for copyright infringement. In case you hadn’t guessed or are pretending not to be an accomplice, tv-links used to post links to thousands of hours of up-to-date TV shows and movies, all for your viewing pleasure (and a tidy advertising profit).
First of all, if you don’t want to look suspicious, don’t name yourself Sin. It can only refer to a base act of human corruption or the world-devouring monster from Final Fantasy X, and neither association is going to help your public image much.
Secondly, as that forums thread proves, there is a lot of controversy among Internet citizens about the ethics of the case, all of it centered around complex metaphors that don’t hold much water. The debate goes something like this:
From these arguments, only two reasonable conclusions can be drawn:
1. The new season of Heroes is as addictive as crack cocaine.
2. Gang members are missing out on the huge profit-making potential of “guy you pay to tell you where to find a drug dealer.”
As neither are very helpful, I’m going to try my best to put this whole thing in perspective. Shocking revelation after the jump.
Yes, what tv-links did is wrong.
Maybe or maybe not technically illegal, but “wrong” in the sense that you felt the little thrill of piracy every time you loaded up that episode of The Office you missed last night, or that episode of Weeds, even though you don’t have Shotime.
And yes, the outcome of this lawsuit will set important precedents about cases like this; cases where, it’s true, the culprit did little more than give directions to a place where one may commit a crime. As one Forums poster named Rambo put it: “This is like arresting the guy at the gas station who gave directions to a bank robber.” And in some sense that’s true, although I’m not sure I should trust the opinion of a man who kills people with a bow and arrow.
But the key point here that the RIAA and those who make TV should be gathering is that Sin ran a successful site off of linked television shows. He made money off it. For a long time. Because he provided something people want. Fighting trends like that is what’s killing the music industry, and you’ll fare no better. It’s time to shift some paradigms, folks. Either that, or start suing Youtube and Google video, who essentially do the exact same thing, just with a more circuitous user interface.
I, the lone anonymous consumer, want to be able to watch South Park on my computer, and you, the massive multinational corporation, want me to not be able to do that. I hate to break it to you, but for once, I am going to get what I want one way or another. You’d just better make sure that “or another” involves a modest subscription fee or some Google Ads on NBC.com.
As both a public service and an illustration of my point, here is a link to the Digg comments about all this, which contain literally tens of links to still operating tv-links-esque compiler sites. So metaphorically I’m giving you directions to a store that sells maps to places where you can find people who will tell you where to get drugs. If CRACKED gets raided tomorrow, you’ll know why.
Rabid debate to follow below.
October 25th, 2007 at 5:23 pm
That blog post was terrible. It was even worse than something Michael Swaim might write.
October 25th, 2007 at 5:51 pm
Okay, maybe rabid, off-topic, one sided debate, but debate nonetheless.
October 25th, 2007 at 6:48 pm
You know who was funny? Jay Pinkerton. You know who else? David Wong. You know what isn’t? Heroes. Even when referenced with crack (hilarious!).
October 25th, 2007 at 7:10 pm
What’s this WAS shit? Did Jay and David die? Or are you saying they’re not funny anymore, because if you are, then I demand satisfaction sir! Flame war at dawn!
October 26th, 2007 at 1:07 am
Well I enjoyed that heroes line. Don’t listen to the naysayers Swaimish! It’s people like them that make communism fail!
October 26th, 2007 at 4:39 am
I thought this was jaypinkerton.com
October 26th, 2007 at 6:42 am
Dude, dont’ have a flame war with someone called Creamofsumyunguy! They’ll be nothing left of you! You’ll say something sarcastic and he’ll be all “do you have prince albert in the can,” and then you’ll try to rally and he’ll drop a Polish light bulb joke on you and you’ll just never recover. Stay safe, Michael.
October 27th, 2007 at 1:15 am
“Heroes” is addictive this season? I guess there’s just something compelling about a Nawlins wannabe-Peter Petrelli learning to double dutch.
October 27th, 2007 at 7:59 pm
Well I thought the article was funny as hell.
October 28th, 2007 at 3:21 am
I just want to say for all topics such as these (and when I say “topics such as these” I mean topics concerning morality, the legal system, and life) I turn to the one true source of all wisdom: Futurama.
“You can’t shut us down! The Internet is about the free exchange and sale of other people’s ideas!”