The 7 Most Offensive Adaptations of Classic Comic Books
Since its earliest days, Hollywood has known that comic books are a fertile source to steal ideas from, since everyone knows the characters but nobody actually reads the stories (right?).
But Hollywood hasn't always treated the source material with the same respect and reverence that it gave characters like Iron Man, Scott Pilgrim or even Howard the Duck. For example ...

Yes. Yes, you can go wrong with a bunch of well-known superheroes. Horribly, horribly wrong.
Legends of the Superheroes was the name of two one-hour specials inspired by The SuperFriends, the cartoon loosely based on the Justice League comics. And it was a variety show. With a laugh track.

The cast included Batman, Robin, Captain Marvel, Green Lantern (the better-known one this time), Hawkman and The Flash. The only reason Superman and Wonder Woman didn't show up is that they had a movie and a series in production. Adam West and Burt Ward reprised their roles as Batman and Robin -- except that this was in 1979, more than 10 years after their show went off the air, which means that Batman is now over 50 and the "Boy Wonder" is in his mid-30s. The unintentional result was a Dynamic Duo that looked like it had fallen on some hard times.

"One more crack about the new Batmobile and you're walking home."
The first episode features the heroes trying to discover the location of a doomsday device, but then the second one was, inexplicably, a celebrity roast of the superheroes hosted by Ed McMahon.

But it gets worse: At one point, McMahon tells the audience that there are other less well-known superheroes, "especially in the minority area." From that point the show spirals into a politically incorrect nightmare:

That's right, the only black superhero in the entire show had to be called Ghetto Man and come from the projects. After he's done performing his sassy stand-up act ("I'm sorry, but we don't feel the Green Lantern qualifies as 'colored people' "), he flies away by opening his arms and legs and shouting "KAREEEEEEEEM!"

We'd say that 1979 was a different time, but we're pretty sure that episode qualified as a hate crime even then.

Most of the (puzzlingly enduring) charm of Archie Comics lies in their complete inability to change with the times, retaining the same innocent view of teenagers since the 1940's. That's also what makes Archie: Return to Riverdale, a TV movie that aired in 1990, so amazing: It takes a massive turn to the dark side by featuring Archie and the gang decades later, as a group of badly adjusted adults dealing with their depressing lives.

Wait until the first kid from Boy Meets World turns 50.
The story shows the characters reuniting for the 15th anniversary of their graduation from Riverdale High -- because if there's one thing more depressing than high school itself, it's high school reunions. All their lives have taken turns for the worse: Betty is a small-time schoolteacher trapped in an abusive relationship; Veronica is a four-time divorcee with an implied sex addiction problem; and the once fun-lovin' Jughead had his soul crushed by his ex-wife and now struggles to connect with his son.

It's all downhill from here, guys.
Archie himself was doing fine, with a hot fiance and a promising career as a lawyer in the big city, until he came back to Riverdale and saw this:

Like an addict falling off the wagon (and being run over by it, then defecated on by the horse it's tied to), Archie finds that his feelings for both Betty and Veronica resurface, putting in jeopardy the only healthy relationship he's ever had. It doesn't help that the home-wreckers don't give a crap about ruining his life and openly pursue Archie despite being fully aware of the existence of his fiance.

Veronica, propositioning Archie for illicit hotel sex.

Betty, kicking things up a notch.
Archie ends up being dumped and throwing his career away to move back to Riverdale, which is the most depressing outcome we could think of. But there are also some light hearted moments, like this scene where Jughead and his son finally bond over a 90s hip-hop remix of The Archies' "Sugar Sugar" ...
... but, of course, that only serves to highlight the song's inappropriate sexual overtones, with lines like "You laid your ever-lovin' stuff on me" and "I'm gonna rock your world complete." Yeah, we're thinking the people who made this thing freaking hated the Archie comics.
They apparently hoped it would spin off into a series, which thankfully never happened. If it did, we're pretty sure Jughead would have hanged himself by the fifth episode, and the season finale would have involved Veronica being convicted for gutting a hobo.

Archie ends up in prison after a botched convenience store robbery costs 14 people their lives.

After the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles utterly dominated the 80s, getting their likenesses plastered on lunch boxes, pajamas, sleeping bags, action figures and basically everything else outside of feminine hygiene products, their makers were almost out of ways to really run the franchise into the ground.

"OK, so how about we reboot the whole series and give every character fetal alcohol syndrome?"
Thus in 1990, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles released their first and only pop-rock/rap album, kicking off a nationwide tour that must have been attended primarily by curious people wondering how the fuck that was possible.
It was the worst possible answer:

The show featured actors dressed in turtle suits, like the ones from the movies, except cheaper-looking and now featuring denim jackets. They were lip-syncing to 90s pop-rock while pretending to play instruments like guitars, bass, drums and, as if this whole thing wasn't horrible enough already, keytars. During other songs they simply forgot about the instruments and performed elaborate choreographed dances, like in a Madonna concert.

Except with more natural-looking skin.
The venerable Master Splinter makes an appearance to tell his pupils that they "can do more good with music than with any pair of nunchuks" -- because apparently real ninjas are less about violence and more about ripping off the New Kids on the Block. Later, the Shredder crashes the concert to tell everyone how much he hates music, which he does by performing a song called "I Hate Music."

"Wait ... shit."
The Turtles even appeared on Regis and Kathie Lee to promote the show, in what must be the lowest point in two separate franchises.
The whole concert was released on VHS, but even stranger was the "making of" documentary included. What could have been an interesting look at the behind-the-scenes stuff (because, seriously, how the fuck does this happen) turned out to be a bizarre Spinal Tap-style mockumentary that pretends the Turtles are an actual rock band. While this could have been clever idea for a five-minute sketch, unfortunately it goes on for 30 minutes. It includes interviews with real-life managers and producers who somehow had nothing better to do, plus a scene with the Turtles in the studio laying down a track for their album.

The ambiance was tense because Michelangelo showed up with a hangover again.
The recording engineers even go out of their way to explain how the turtles can play instruments with only three fingers. Donatello, we learn, has extra-thick keys on his keytar, while Leonardo plays a one-string bass.

It's the same one the guy from Radiohead uses.
Because if there's anything fans of the Ninja Turtles crave, it's logic. Sure, a quartet of turtles exposed to ambiguous radioactive goop can be trained as ninjas and speak like California surfers, but if those same turtles also learned how to play musical instruments? Well, that's a little far-fetched.

Like most entries on this list, this low-budget movie was produced in the hopes of creating a live-action series. Unlike the other entries, this one was considered so bad that it has never aired in the U.S. But that's why the Internet exists. So we can watch awful things.

Awful, awful things.
Justice League of America (1997) shortens the teams' all-star roster by getting rid of dead weight like Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman, and keeping guys like The Atom (whose power is making himself little), Green Lantern (not even the most famous one) and the Martian Manhunter. The Flash is also on the team, but he looks like this:

"Ah-durrrrrrrrrrr"
The movie features costumes that look like they were designed by nerds to wear at Comic-Con and sewn together by their mothers.

The main character is Tori, a meteorologist who gains superpowers by being the worst lab assistant ever and spilling water on an experimental device, electrocuting herself. She's abducted by the Justice League and soon given a membership on the team. Yes, all it takes to get an invitation to join the mighty Justice League of America is proving that Darwin was wrong.

The poor guy just can't catch a break.
It's an odd mixture of superhero story and sitcom, and the script awkwardly tries to balance drama with comedy by showing the characters' dull normal lives side by side with their dull superhero exploits. One reviewer called it "Friends with superpowers," but that's giving it too much credit. It's more like "Perfect Strangers with superpowers," and with every character played by Bronson Pinchot.
The whole thing is intercut with interviews with the characters, implying that this is a documentary and that these guys are incredibly bad at keeping their secret identities.

"So I put on my costume an- hey, this isn't, like, going on TV, right?"
The secret underwater headquarters of the Justice League is accessible only through an elevator located under a bridge, where no one could ever notice a group of brightly costumed individuals walking together and disappearing.

"Aaaagggh, they pissed on the handle again, Aaaaagggghhhhh"
Once they're down there, they meet the Martian Manhunter, who is pretty much a full-bodied version of Zordon from the Power Rangers here. Despite having telepathic powers, the Manhunter summons the members of the Justice League only through beepers, a technology that was already outdated by the time this movie came out.

"Listen. You guys. Beepers are coming back. I'm telling you."
The villain is a guy called "Weather Man." Out of the 500 villains the Justice League has fought in the comics, they had to choose the one who sounds about as menacing as Al Roker. We'd like to think that if they didn't use better characters it's only because they weren't available, because otherwise the choices that led to this thing are pretty puzzling. We've seen plenty of examples of adaptations where for some reason they leave a lot of important characters out of the movie, but you couldn't possibly go wrong if you had a bunch of well-known superheroes, right?








I think #7 was supposed to be after #4.
ReplyNo love for Roger Corman's Fantastic 4
ReplyThis was a really well done article! Not only were the selections you chose to talk about funny on their own but your jokes throughout and the captions you wrote under the images were also hilarious! I haven't laughed that hard in a while, this was a cracked article of the highest quality for sure!
ReplyWow. Y'know, I knew Generation X was going to be on the list, because it really was an awful movie, but the analysis by the author of this article is just... ignorant.
ReplyIt's a huge deal for me b/c I was, in fact, a big fan of the Generation X comic at the time, so I was really excited about seeing the movie, which was made b/c Generation X was actually a really popular comic at the time, and stayed pretty popular until the two original creators, Scott Lobdell and Chris Bachalo, left. After that it was pretty much downhill, but up until that point, it really was one of the best-written and uniquely drawn comics in the Marvel comics stable.
As far as the point of there not being any popular characters and/or characters featured in the other movies, that's patently false; Emma Frost was a popular character, primarily as a villain for most of the previous 20 years, give or take. She also made appearances in both X-men Origins: Wolverine and X-Men: First Class. Banshee was a character who first appeared as a villain sometime during the Stan Lee days of the X-men in the 60's, and was later tapped as a team member by Chris Claremont in Giant Size X-men. I wouldn't say he was ever REALLY popular, but he was also, of course, a character in X-men: First Class. Jubilee was a fairly popular character at the time, having spent a lot of time basically as Wolverine's side kick, and she also made a cameo or two in the first two X-men movies.
The rest of the Gen X crew were so new to comics they had had exactly zero time to actually appear in anything else, and by the time the other X-men movies had come out, they were all pretty much dead.
The big letdown (for me) was the fact that two of the most popular Generation X characters, Chamber and Husk, didn't appear in the show (probably for special effects reasons) and were replaced by a douchebag with X-ray vision and some chick with lots of muscles.
The author obviously has never read a Gen X comic (or possibly even an X-men comic, since Emma Frost has been one of the most important, popular, and central characters of the mainstream X-men series for years now; Generation X was actually really important for introducing her as a hero, rather than a villain) and clearly didn't bother to do even the most cursory of research (I mean, seriously, at least take a glance at the Wikipedia article), but that's ok... the people who wrote the script to the Generation X movie probably didn't, either.
Here here! I fuckin' loved the Generation X comics. Not to mention the fact that they were SUPPOSED to be mostly all relatively unknown. They were new mutants being taught, except New Mutants was already a thing. :P
Hey. NOBODY knocks Emma Frost. Boink her, well, that's a different story.
ReplyI had totally repressed that Archie thing until I played that clip. Now its all back in my head, you ba$$$ds.
ReplyNo mention of the Captain America movies where he steals cars, has a female sidekick, and gives the President a big ole thumbs-up? Even the newest Cap movie acknowledges its existence!
ReplyBut they star Reb Brown! That makes them good.
"Airing in 1996, Generation X was an X-Men adaptation that featured none of the popular X-Men"
ReplyUm.....it was an adaptation of Generation X. And Emma Frost is actually very popular. sooooo....yeah.
And didn't I just read a Cracked article about how wonderfully progressive Archie comics are by featuring a gay character and promoting the nu gay agenda and this one points out how un-progressive Archie comics are? Way to get on the same page fellas.
Or perhaps you don't know what you're talking about, and are too busy worrying about the 'nu gay agenda' to actually pay attention to what you're saying. And I'm hoping that misspelling of 'new' was intentional, but it honestly wouldn't surprise me if it wasn't considering your post.
They both say literally the exact same thing about the comics; that they're time capsules of innocence from the 1940s that appear to be mainly walled off from all real world problems and have barely changed since they were created.
In the other article that leads into mckinney talking about why that innocence then just proves exactly how innocent the idea of gay marriage has become that even archie comics are willing to tackle the issue, and he uses that point to demonstrate why the 'one million moms' group consists of a bunch of douches who have opinions that are way off in left field. Maybe in your head that translates into him saying the entire comic is 'wonderfully progressive', but it's no one else's fault that you're delusional.
Of course, neither actually comments on how progressive or non-progressive their attitudes are on social issues. The whole point of what they're saying is that they don't even acknowledge the existence of issues like that for the most part; that would be where that whole innocence that both articles comment on comes from, which leads to their points.
Though I'm assuming the whole issue is that you didn't actually read mckinney's article, you just saw that he was supporting a comic that included gay marriage and condemning those against it and decided, like the little b***h you are, to just skip the actual reading part, make up the details, and then go complain about it. Or maybe you're just getting this whole 'reading' thing down?
I get that you're a miserable, insignificant little f**k and don't realize just how embarrassingly stupid you are, but I'm forced to ask on behalf of society at large that you please remain in your cave where you belong and don't come out and pretend like you belong among normal, mentally fit individuals. See, then you could spend your time plotting how to fight back against the 'nu gay agenda' rather than spending it reminding all of us exactly why it would be nice if only those with IQs above that of common pocket lint were allowed on the internet.
LOL. You are what is commonly referred to as an "Internet Tough Guy" (see also: Keyboard Commando). Someone doesn't see the world through your narrow paradigm so you choose to attempt to insult me, which is the same as a five year old throwing a temper tantrum when they don't get what they want. *yawn*. Okay, I'm done with you now.
WE SAID LOOK AT IT.
ReplyAt least Peter Parker is hot. Unlike that ridiculous, high-pitched Tobey Maguire.
ReplyI got Generation X confused with Mutant X
Replyok, I could laugh with you about all the other superhero flicks. But Generation X was based off of a hugely popular comic series called... and stay with me here "Generation X" It is an entire series about the CHILDREN Mutants born during what we call generation X. It was supposed to appeal to the same group of people that the comic book series appealed to... The teenage memebers of Generation X. It wasn't a ripoff of Xmen. It was a spin-off series of comics from x-men. Which they thought might make a good series... For teens.
ReplyGenertaion X 'hugely popular'? Really???
Yes actually, it was quite popular amongst Marvel comics readers who are also mutant fans when the books came out. God forbid anything that you don't like being considered popular, eh?
As the Giant Robot Spiderman thing makes me go hmmm I wonder if that classifies as a Super Sentai.
ReplyNot only does it qualify, I believe that it's considered the very first Super Sentai series. It also wasn't a "rip-off" as it was fully licensed from Marvel (they had intentions to possibly do other characters as well). It's considered a classic in Japan.
OMG. I had forgotten, I was actually hyped about the Turtles band when I was a kid though.
ReplyNow in #7, if "Ghetto Man" was intended to be as offensive as possible (the same way Laugh In would do sketches that were purposely offensive to poke fun at the people that would do something like this semi-seriously), then it sounds potentially hilarious! Perfect example of a sketch SO intentionally offensive it's funny: Sammy Davis Jr. pushes his way through a line of Klansmen and says "I bet you're wondering why I asked you all here."
ReplyMatt Frewer's poor performance in Generation X seems like a poor attempt at mimicking Jim Carrey's poor performance as the Riddler in Batman Forever.
ReplyPoor performance? Jim Carrey was pretty much the only reason to watch Batman Forever. Otherwise, the series might have bombed a movie early.
Why is Guy Gardner wearing blue?
ReplyAnd if you want to see depressing Archie comics, read "Archie Marries..." They all graduate high school and realize just how terrible their lives are. IN STEREO!
It's not Guy Gardner. It's Kyle Rayner, the even lamer lantern.
Actually, they called him "Guy Gardner", but the character they wrote was Hal Jordan.
Same thing that happened with the new GL movie. They wrote Kyle Rayner, but called him Hal Jordan.
I loved Generation X. Yes i know it was terrible, but.... I don't know I still love it :)
ReplyI am the only one who thinks that April O'neal looks suspiciously like Sigourny Weaver?
ReplyYou know, a new version of the Archie one might actually be pretty cool if it had little things like good acting, writing and production value behind it.
ReplyBut no rapping Jughead please, because f**k that.