5 Reasons Immortality Would be Worse than Death
If you're reading this, congratulations on having achieved the primary goal with which we begin each day: You have avoided death.
We're big on this idea of not dying. We love stories of immortal vampires and invincible superheroes, each of us wishing on some level that was us. If we didn't have to worry about death, we could finally get shit done.
But could we? If you take a moment to think about it, you realize immortality is grossly overrated.

Contrary to what many people believe, humans are still evolving. That's not a big deal if you have the kind of immortality that only lasts 1,000 or 2,000 years, but of course real immortality means you'll still be walking the earth, in your current body, a million years from now.
Science has no idea where future mutations might lead us by that point, so it's anyone's guess what your neighbors will look like in the future. You, on the other hand, will be walking around as the future equivalent of this:

Their bodies and brains are going to continue to adapt to an ever-changing world. Yours won't. Will your digestive system be able to handle the same food they eat? Will your brain enjoy the same entertainment? Will your non-evolved tongue even be able to speak the languages they speak in the year one million AD? Would an unfrozen caveman be able to do all of that now?

One thing we do know: You won't be getting any lovin'. It turns out that mother nature hates inter-species breeding, and is such a big cockblocker that science had to come up with a name to describe it: Reproductive Isolation. It's the reason there aren't packs of ligers or centaurs roaming around.

Basically, it's nature's complicated "the triangle doesn't go in the square hole" law, with a bunch of subset rules that will kill off your children if you decide to take a hammer to the triangle. Meaning that as that species further evolves, there is no possible chance for you to create a new species closer to your own that you could stand to look at for five minutes.
Of course, that's assuming that you're even safe walking around among the members of this new freak species. Will they treat you like a novelty and cast you in hilarious insurance commercials, like the Geico cavemen? Or will they do to you what current humans would do if they finally caught Sasquatch roaming around through the forests (that is, stick you in a zoo)? Though whatever the freak-species decides to do with you won't be as bad as no sex for the rest of your life. Who knows, maybe someone will decide to make you the donkey in their next show.
And it's probably irrelevant, since your inability to make friends with mortals will go out the window long before then...

Let's say some kid goes rummaging around in your basement, finds that witch's old portrait of you and discovers that you are immortal. Word spreads and suddenly you're famous the world over. Sure, a lot of people might not buy the story at first, but folks have become famous for much less.

Sounds pretty sweet, right? Probably get a reality show out of it. But that's just scratching the surface. You're not just going to be famous; you're going to be a god. You have eternal life, which means you must know the secret to eternal life, which means you will immediately be the center of the world's newest and most popular religion. You'll be like a guy revealing himself to be Jesus, and proving it. Why would anyone continue to worship an invisible deity when they have a god walking around amongst them? Each morning your yard will be packed full of several thousand terminally ill people, or parents with their sick kids, asking you to grant them the same immortality you have.

That, of course, is assuming a government or crime syndicate doesn't get to you first. Literally every powerful and wealthy person on Earth will decide that in your veins pumps the one thing they can't buy: freedom from death. They're not going to stop until they've spent every penny they can spare to see if they can turn your blood and organs into unending life for themselves. Think about the wars that are being fought over oil. The secret to eternal life would be worth far, far more.
So we're not talking about the occasional blood test and urine sample here and there while they let you stay in some five-star facility. It's more like you getting kidnapped and kept in some damp underground shack away from any civilization while they go balls out on your organs E.T.-style.

"Just contact our concierge if you need anything."
Get comfortable, because since nobody will know where you are, they can keep you there for as long as they want.
But let's say you give them the slip, and successfully keep your secret under wraps with a series of new identities. It's going to get awfully hard to keep track of all of them, because...

We're not saying that if you were to be magically granted immortality, you'd eventually get Alzheimer's anyway--we assume that the Elixir of Life you sipped will keep your brain physically young just like the rest of you. We're saying it won't matter.
Imagine if your cell phone number changed every week, and every week you were forced to memorize the new one. It gets exponentially harder because all of those old numbers are still in your memory, clogging up the works. Then imagine someone asked you to instantly recall the number you had five numbers ago.

"Wait! It had a six in it."
That's one reason your memory degrades as you get older. Your brain and its ability to store and recall memories is limited, but the amount of stuff you're asking it to remember keeps piling up over the decades.
That's a problem because your brain relies on not just storing information, but being able to rapidly recall it at a moment's notice. As time goes on, more and more memories pile up, along with names and dates and birthdays and anniversaries. Your brain can keep all that stuff organized for a while (say, the span of most of a normal human lifetime) but it's not like you can go into your brain and just delete files like cleaning up a hard drive. So useless stuff starts accumulating, clogging up the works and slowing everything down, like all those toolbars on your mom's Internet browser.

"Thanks, Yahoo!"
Your immortal life and experiences may be infinite, but your brain's ability to store and recall them is not. It wouldn't be very long before your brain is piled up with junk like one of the houses on Hoarders. Your body will be young, but you'll still be forgetting people's names and telling the same jokes to the same person twice in one day. Though you'll still be perfectly capable of giving a grumpy speech on where you were when the World Trade Center was destroyed and how kids in the future have it so easy.
And, even if you find a way around this, you still have to deal with the fact that...








Even still, I'm down with some immortality. The pure fascination of it all is enough.
ReplyI agree completely with the last point. I've just been forced to watch Sex in the City 2 and I can say from personal experience that eternity is a bad, bad thing.
ReplyExcept as one of you point out YOUR A FRICKEN GOD. Not in 1000 years when people will have slightly evolved but right now. So how did this future society come into existance with you being at the centre of all religion from now till then. Plus You can walk around being a non-suicide bomber, literal go hell no detonate bomb walk away (through the cloud of flesh droplets that used to be the CIA operatives wanting to study you.
ReplyDo some un armed fighting courses and You could walk up to the president and kill him with you bare hands all while they pump a million rounds at your immortal ass and do nothing. At some point while once youve taken off the presidnts head like a twist top and they emptyed a couple a mags your still laughing they are going to Sh!t themselves and worship you as a god. Or Die. If I had Immortality I'd be the Ultimate dictator after a hundred years there would be no rebels I'd be undisputed God King so All those Future Gov't stuff is Crap because Step one (once Immortality is accquired) wipe out all other forms of Authority. Step 2 GOD KING
...Or realize that immortal does not = unlimited superstrength, when those badasses you attack forgo shooting at you and instead simply grab you, tie you up, encase you in steel chains and cement, stick you 100 feet in the ground, then build a giant monument on top of you with a plaque proclaiming your supreme idiocy.
All of these complaints are for storybook or movie immortality, not the kind of immortality which is ACTUALLY going to be developed in the real world. In reality, the methods that will grant immortality in real life won't be "true" immortality. People will still die of non-aging related things. Still, 800 years is far better than 100.
ReplyIt's funny how people say that "nature wont allow this and that", like if the nature is a inteligent being that knows what is better for itself ( and looks like this inteligence appeared from nowhere, of course), just like religious people do when talking about their god. Oh yeaaaah. You all can thumbs down me now. X-D
ReplyIt was a writing tool. It's based on evolution in that if nature let itself mate with eachother it would only have one big superbeast manbearpig plus every animal on noahs ark. Each species is all about its own survival, it wants to keep itself pure.
Wait if our perception of time slows down and time seems to go by faster won't watching intelligent life evolve would be like watching a3 hour movie
ReplyI don't care I still want to be immortal. f**k death.
ReplyI read this article a while ago, posted a comment and had good discussions on the topic. Now I'm back, read it again, and saw all the comments were identical to the ones before. If I'm bored now, I could only imagine what it would be like to do this and endless amount of times. At least Dr. Manhattan had the ability to leave Earth to start his own form of life once he realized he was doomed to eternal boredom.
Reply Hide All See All 3 RepliesTry finding something else to do then, instead of coming back to the same thing over and over again.
There is nearly an infintate amount of things to find simply on the internet alone, let alone all there is to experience out in the big wide world.
...And new things are being added and created every second, so it would be pretty much impossible to experience it all, no matter how long you lived.
...You're just not trying very hard.
umm but immortality brings new games liek sky diving no parachute, Great white shark wrestling and all sorts of Wild Sh!t to make the X-games look like lawn bowls
your assuming that you would feel no pain, you can go insane from extreme amounts of pain, also there would be no out for you anywhere want to end it? jump into the sun burn till the end of time :(
What about the fact that if you are the ONLY immortal person on the planet, you will basically stay the same age while watching your friends & family age, deteriorate, and eventually die. Any relationship you form will only end in pain & loss as you watch countless generations pass away while there is nothing you can do.
ReplyBeing immortal would mean this would only suck for the first 60 years or so. After that, in the grand scheme of things (like a million years) you wouldn't care nor would you remember them.
If you had read the article properly you'll see that you would even remember any relationships you had
In the movie I AM Legend, Will smith is battling vampires... Not zombie
Reply Hide All See All 3 Repliesno hes battling the newly evolved form of the human race, read the book
If you read the book you would know that *they* are battling *him*
I think its more than safe to say that the book makes the movie look s**t in the same way star wars makes its animated series completely retarded and lacking any sense of how it actually connects with the movies
Hmmm...it didn't seem to take my comment. So, I will try again, sorry if this is a repeat. Immortals would not be able to reproduce. Nature would weed this ability out as a non essential. The whole purpose of reproduction is survival of the species, and allow for change. By definition, an immortal will survive, and cannot genetically change. Barring that argument, nature would realize a species that never dies would be a destructive force. Immortals would reproduce, eventually non immortals would die out completely, leaving only a species that cannot die. Within a few generations, the worlds population would exceed the planets ability to sustain it. Not just a little bit, but completely. There would not be enough cattle, corn, or even insects to feed the exponentially growing immortal population. The result, eternal starvation and thirst.
ReplyCannibalism? Perhaps. Romans became cannibalistic when they were besieged and became hungry enough.
But here's the flaw with that, if the immortals were also invulnerable, you wouldn't be able to just lop off an arm and have the human equivalent to chicken wings. If they were not invulnerable, they would be subject to disease. Disease brought on by billions of tons of excrement. Disease spreads, the immortals become sick, forever. Quite possibly to the point of either a) immobility or b) zombie like status.
less words please i can't focus
I don't believe immortals would be able to reproduce. Nature would probably not allow it. In a world where nobody dies, but people are born, it would not take long for the population explosion to surpass the ability to maintain it. Food and water sources would soon be depleted, not to mention all the other natural resources a given planet provides. Eventually, this would lead to eternal starvation and thirst. The whole purpose of reproduction is to allow for survival of the species. By the very nature of immortality, survival is a non issue. Wether one enjoys surviving or not is not natures problem.
ReplyCrocodiles can live indefinitely if nothing kills them and they can reproduces
Crocodiles cannot live indefinitely, that's ridiculous
#1 is the really bad part. The story "I have no mouth yet I must scream" does a nice description of torturous immortality.
ReplyThat's why I'd just like to live a really long time.
Same. Hearing about the people of the Old Testament living to be 500 or 900 always enticed me as a kid, even if it wasn't true. "I Have No Mouth!"
lol "even if"!
Intresting... however, I think there are a few flaws in your theories. For example:
Reply1. of course you will be able to speak the languages of the future, seeing as how you live every day until then, learning them (if needed). If you go to another country, in a few years of living there, you will be able to speak the language quite well, so why not any future language? also, the part about the frozen caveman is very weak. You don't just teleport into the future, you don't just come into contact with the new food, technology, people, languages, at a given time in the future, you live up to that point, gaining knowledge about that stuff. also, your brain and body, even if they won't evolve, will adapt to certain things.
2. you may or may not get older mentally... being immortal, your organs probably regenerate when damaged, so why not the brain? it will probably adapt and begin to recycle and delete information that you haven't used in a thousand years, the irrelevant and trivial information, in any case
3. again, the brain will probably find a way to compensate for the long period of time you live, so time won't seem to be speeding up. seeing how everything in nature adapts to their environment, so would an immortal body and mind. your flaw in logic is that you view it from the perpective of a normal human. if an immortal would be born, I'm pretty sure that, even if he would look like us, he will have a series of different traits that will help him survive with his/her "condition". and this because that's how nature works... it doesn't just make you immortal in body and give you a mind that breaks down after a few centuries, just to f**k with you.
4. however, even if you are right, you didn't take into consideration the techological advances... they are building spear organs that work better than the originals, so it's only a matter of time before they can build a brain better than our faulty human brains. you can get ahold of one, adjust the settings and would be good to go for ever and ever and ever... also, thanks to the same technological advances, you will probably have a personal spaceship in maximum 300 years... wich is not that long, considering you are immortal. so, if they tell you that a meteor is on an iminent colision course with earth, you just get the f**k off the planet and cruise around the milky way for a while, in search of a new planet. also, you can do this when you are tired of living on earth and decide it's about time you find those aliens that anal probed your neighbour.
1. It didnt say you couldnt speak the language cus u cudnt learn it. Its because the human race may evolve a new tongue or form of communication (like farts teehee)
4. What happens when that space cruiser runs out of whatevers powering it and you cant control it (which will happen) and you crash into a planet- back to square one.
wait, if your body was completly destroyed, like deca[itated, then burned to ashes, but you are immortal, what happens? do you still live on in some way?
Replyyou'd probably be a disembodied consciousness, which just sounded weird when i said it out loud.
Maybe Sasquatch is an immortal :O
ReplyThe phone number analogy is really weak. I remember the first phone number my family had, before cell phones. I have my current number memorized and never need to know the others, and can't recall them. Other than that, i have few numbers memorized. As time goes on, items that are reinforced would be remembered, things not reinforced would not be remembered. Why would you ever need to? Also, the article forgets about technology advance, new construction techniques etc. The trapped argument could be a fallacy. Time perception would not be a factor if you always kept doing new things.
ReplyThere's a finite number of things you can do, it is PROVEN that time actually appears faster for old people, and I don't think you grasp the concept of infinity. Given infinite time; everything possible would eventually happen. You would have an interspecies orgy in zero gravity, and considering that the chance of getting trapped for ages is a lot higher than that, you would either get trapped for a very long time (7000000 years perhaps) and go insane, or get trapped until the planet, or our universe, expires.
Monkeys and Shakespear you know
You may have a point about the phone number thing. Sometimes I often have to stop and think to remember my own current cell number, but I remember the number my grandmother had 20 years ago.
This article views immortality from the perspective of Darkseid from DC comics. The assumption being made here is that immortality = indestructable and never ages. What about an immortality that is just no physical aging or illnesses, but without the invulnerability? That would mean you could stay young and fit forever, but if something catastrophic happened where you would WANT to die, you could just jump in front of a bus or shoot yourself and end your immortality.
Replywell in that case odds are you'l be dead in 100 or so years anyway, unless u live in a bubble
With proper training #2 & #3 shouldn't be that big of a problem. Yes time speeds up has you get older, but that has just as much to do with your daily habits as it does your age. People who trap themselves in monotony, doing the same thing every day for years and decades will feel time go much faster than those who try to do make a point to do or experience something different each day.
ReplyIts the same principal wherein if you travel a lot, the miles begin to feel like feet instead of te miles they are.
every day was quick until i smashed my bits...those few minutes were a lot of hours metrically speaking
If you live forever, it's certain you will eventually
Reply*Kill someone accidentally
*Be imprisoned for a crime you didn't commit
*Commit a major crime
*Become paralyzed
*Suffer 100% third degree burns
*Be victim of a major crime
*Experience any other major unpleasantness you can think of.
Kinda depends on why/how you are immortal, and how well you are able to use that to your advantage.
For instance, you wouldn't have to worry much about burns and physical harm if you are invulnerable/indestructable.
...And if you were smart or lucky enough, you could presumably, over enough time put yourself in a place of power where you "could" be somewhat above the law..... or not... really I don't even bother to think or wish for "true eternal" forever life. ...I prefer to ponder what it might be like to live for maybe a few thousand years or so.
They forgot that there wouldn't be a point in anything you do,
Become an emperor you empire will die soon enough
Become a corporate mogul it can and fall apart