Cracked's RomCom Encyclopedia
The Good News: Your winning combination of a sharp sense of humor and passable hygiene has landed you a girlfriend and/or wife. The Bad News: Valentine's Day is fast approaching, and odds are she's going to want you to spend some time watching romantic comedies. Here's how to avoid the worst.
The Classics

Rob Reiner directing and the sharpest script of Nora Ephron's career add up to a lightning-in-a-bottle combination that set the standard for every romantic comedy that followed and gave goofy misanthropes everywhere hope that they too could score with a perky blonde.
Verdict: Countless imitations have made most of the jokes tired clichés by now, but with Meg Ryan at her most adorable and Billy Crystal delivering lines that almost make you want to forgive him for his 1985 single "You Look Marvelous," this genre-defining classic is the Star Wars of romantic comedies. Except with fewer space battles and a significantly less coked-up Carrie Fisher.
Cracked Fact: Sally's famous fake orgasm was actually Ryan's idea, the nearby diner's equally famous punchline was suggested by Crystal. And every time that scene's parodied somewhere, they both die a little inside.

When the first five minutes of a movie feature a six year-old saying "I used to be a heroin addict; now I'm a methadone addict," there's a good chance it won't be going down as the most romantic flick ever made. Then again, one should never underestimate the strange allure of a young, borderline suicidal Christopher Walken.
Verdict: Not only do Allen's one-liners provide more laughs than Diane Keaton's outfits, but two hours of the most dismal relationship failures ever filmed will make your romantic flaws look a lot more forgivable-especially if you've never ditched your girlfriend for her adopted Vietnamese daughter.
Cracked Fact: A scene where Allen sneezes while holding a snuffbox full of cocaine was an accident, but got so many laughs it was left in the final cut.

With a satire that takes on two genres at once and ends up being one of the funniest and most quotable movies of the past five years, Simon Pegg and Edgar Wright fused quirky romance with George Romero to bring us the world's first "RomZomCom."
Verdict: A slacker getting his life together and reclaiming the love of his life is boring, but a slacker getting his life together and reclaiming his lost love while under constant threat of being devoured by the shambling hordes of the walking dead? That's genius.
Cracked Fact: Ask any married woman: There's nothing more romantic than shooting your own zombified mother in the head with a rifle.
ALSO CLASSICS: Notting Hill, The 40 Year-Old Virgin








I'm kind of surprised The Wedding Singer didn't make this list, given you wrote about liking it in your Adam Sandler movie review.
ReplyWhile I totally agree that Sleepless in Seattle is horrible, you can't say that the reason why it's crap is "Cute quirky girl meets cute quirky guy and, despite various factors keeping them apart, they fall in love, ditch their respective mates and end up together in just under two hours." While you admit that is the plot of every romcom in the 90's, you also have to remember that it's the plot of every romcom EVER! Even the good ones.
ReplyEven the oldest romantic comedy I've seen, It Happened One Night, follows that plot exactly, and it's hailed as an American classic. As are The Philadelphia Story, Bringing Up Baby, etc. etc. etc., and they all follow that same plot.
My Best Friend's Wedding is the only movie I like on this list. It really drives home how everyone is terrible, and nothing ever works out the way it seems to in other romantic comedies. Everyone gets what they deserve! Hooray!
ReplyHumm... where are the other commenters? Am I really the second one, or is it a glitch in my browser or something? Weird. Now, to the actual comment.
ReplyI, for one, think that every romantic comedy should be categorized as "atrocity against humanity". Really, I think I'm still single today mostly because romcoms exist.
By the way, I didn't know "Shawn of the Dead" was a romantic comedy. I thought it was just "unwatchable pile of pseudo-comedy crap", not "unwatchable pile of pseudo-romantic-comedy crap". It was pretty s**tty anyway.
The hell? Shaun of the Dead was awesome.
You are the saddest person ever and the level to which you've lost touch with what makes you human makes me scared for your future. Good luck, you sad, pathetic little man.
FURST!
Reply