Welcome, PWoT fans! David Wong and PWoT have merged operations with Cracked.com, so you need to update your bookmarks or else you're going to see this damned banner every time:

Register

The 5 Most Ridiculous Lies You Were Taught In History Class

By S Peter Davis April 2, 2008 1,813,143 views
article image

High school was hard enough, what with all the video games and boobies to distract us from our homework. What makes it even harder is having to unlearn all of the stuff they taught us in elementary school that turned out to be utter bullshit.

To this day you can even hear some adults repeating these "amazing" historical tales that, years ago, somebody just pulled out of their ass:

#5.
Columbus Discovered the Earth is Round

The story we heard:
In 1492, a Spanish ponce by the name of Christopher Columbus won his long-standing feud with the monarchy and the Catholic church to get funding for a voyage to East Asia. They were afraid that he would fail spectacularly, because everybody knew that the Earth was a flat disc, and the direction Columbus was sailing in would cause him to fall off the edge and into the mouth of the giant turtle that supported it.

Columbus, as we were told, did fail to reach his destination, but not because the world was flat--it was because he crashed into the future greatest nation on Earth, baby! Thus, Columbus proved the world was round, discovered America, and a national holiday was born.

The truth:
In the 1400s, the flat-earth theory was taken about as seriously as the Time Cube theory is today, if not less so. The shape of the world has been pretty much settled since the orb theory was first proposed by the ancient Greek philosopher Pythagoras, around 2,000 years before the existence of Spain.

In fact, the navigational techniques of Columbus' time were actually based on the fact that the Earth was a sphere. Trying to navigate the globe as if it was a flat plane would have fucked up the trip even more than it was.


Artists' representation

The Spanish government's reluctance to pay for Columbus' expeditions didn't have anything to do with their misconceptions about the shape of the world. Ironically, it was because Columbus himself severely underestimated the size of the Earth and everybody knew it. The distance he planned to travel wouldn't have taken him anywhere near Asia. Nevertheless, he eventually scraped together enough funds to embark on his ridiculous adventure, and the clusterfuck that was the Columbus voyage has been celebrated annually in the Americas and in Spain ever since.

So where did the myth come from? It began with author and historical charlatan Washington Irving, who wrote a novel about Columbus in 1838. The novel was fiction, but some elements managed to creep into our history textbooks anyway, probably by some editors who wanted to spice it up a bit. Who's going to read a history book that's just filled with a bunch of boring shit anyway?

#4.
Einstein Flunked Math

The story we heard:
Motivational speakers love to tell this tale, inspiring underachievers with the story of this German kid who was just like you! Despite his sincerest efforts he could never manage to do well in his math exams, and struggled desperately with physics while working as a lowly patent clerk.

That muddled kid grew up to be Albert Fucking Einstein! And if he can do it, then so can you!

The truth:
Well, no you can't. As it turns out, Einstein was a mathematical prodigy, and before he was 12, he was already better at arithmetic and calculus than you are now. Einstein was in fact so fucking smart that he believed school was holding him back, and his parents purchased advanced textbooks for him to study from. Not only did he pass math with flying colors, it's entirely possible that he was actually teaching the class by the end of semester.

The idea that Einstein did badly at school is thought to have originated with a a 1935 Ripley's Believe it or Not! trivia column.


Not the actual column

There's actually a good reason why it's a bad idea to include Robert Ripley among the references in your advanced university thesis. The famous bizarre trivia "expert" never cited his sources, and the various "facts" he presented throughout his career were an amalgamation of things he thought he read somewhere, heard from somebody, or pulled out of his ass. The feature's title probably should have been: Believe it or Not! I Get Paid Either Way, Assholes.

When he was first shown this supposed expose of his early life, Einstein allegedly just laughed, and probably went on to solve another 12 mysteries of quantum physics before dinner. By the time he finally kicked the bucket in 1955, it's entirely possible that "failure" was the one concept that Albert Einstein had never managed to master.

Of course, this just reaffirms what we have always suspected, deep down: success really is decided at birth, and your life will never be better than it is right now. Sorry about that.

#3.
Newton and the Apple

The story we heard:
You've probably heard of Isaac Newton. He's pretty much the Jesus of physics. In the late 17th century, Newton practically fucking invented science. The discoveries we can thank him for include the laws of motion, the visible spectrum, the speed of sound, the law of cooling, and calculus. Yes, all of goddamn calculus. One wonders if anybody in history ever had a thought before Newton.

Probably his most famous discovery, however, is the law of gravity. The story goes that Newton, a modest mathematician and professor of physics, was sitting under the shade of an apple tree one sunny day, when an apple dropped from a branch and bopped him right on the head.

While most people would merely think "Ouch! Son of a bitch!" and stare warily upward for 10 minutes, Newton's first instinct was to formulate the entire set of universal laws governing the motion of gravitating bodies, a theory so sound that it went unchallenged and unmodified for over 200 years.

The truth:
Newton never mentioned the thing with the apple, and in fact it was another guy named John Conduitt who first told the story some 60 years after it supposedly happened. Even then, he was decisively vague about whether Newton actually saw an apple, or whether the apple is a metaphor that he used to illustrate the idea of gravity for people less intelligent than he was (read: everybody):

"Whilst he was musing in a garden it came into his thought that the power of gravity (which brought an apple from the tree to the ground) was not limited to a certain distance from the earth but that this power must extend much further."

You'll notice that even then we don't get the thing with the apple actually hitting Newton in the head, it got added somewhere along the line to add the element of cartoonish slapstick to his genius life.


Future versions will say that Newton then vomited in agony.

We like to think complex discoveries happen this way, with a sudden light bulb popping on over our head. Kind of makes it seem like it could happen to us one day, the next great idea will just occur to us while we're wasting the afternoon on a park bench. In reality, Newton spent the best part of his life formulating and perfecting his theories.

When we have kids, we're going to tell them the truth, dammit. Just Newton, hunched over his piles of papers covered with clouds of tiny numbers. Just months and years of tedious, grinding, silent, lonely work, until he had a nervous breakdown and finally died years later, insane from Mercury poisoning. Welcome to the real world, Timmy.

Um, Gottfried Leibniz had quite a bit to do with the creation of calculus, too.

11/18/2009 10:17:30 AM
rowrohoh

The timecube link just made my head explode! i mean come on! We've got rambling:"Educators are KILLING US!", rascism:"White Americans deserve to be hacked to death
by the Black Race - for they are dumb, educated
ONEness stupid and worship EVIL ONEness
WHICH EQUATES DEATH of OPPOSITES. ", and whatever the heck this is:"Creation is the Harmonics of Opposites -
Opposites are the Harmonics of Creation.
God entity is q***r sex, or no opposite sex.
God Oners must ban all sex with Opposites.
Trinity of males degrade female opposites.
Sex okay for atheist, but not God Oneists.
Opposite hemispheres equate planets to a
Giant Brain, that has 4 faces, but no limbs.
Adults create baby, baby evolves to adult.
No 1 God can create a planet of opposites,
which equate to a zero value existence, and
cancels to nothing as an entity in death. " seriously Dr.Gene Ray? Seriously?

11/17/2009 5:13:29 PM
saint7

ADDENDUM: circumference, not diameter. Why did I write diameter?

11/13/2009 8:48:39 AM
Alceister

You know, there is a reason why a) the original native Carib people are more or less extinct and b) Columbus was fired from his post as governor of the Caribbean. To get to the bottom of this, let's go back to the beginning.

Columbus was basically an Italian with sketchy origins who one day, went to the King and Queen of Spain and asked them to fund a westward expedition to Asia with three barely sea-worthy vessels. His voyage was entirely based on his assumption that the Earth was about six thousand miles in diameter and that China was about half-way across the world.

In modern day terms, it would be like L. Ron Hubbard proposing to the Senate that NASA fund an expedition to Jupiter, based on his calculations that the core of the planet houses a hyperspace gate. The difference in Columbus' case was that he was talking to the King and Queen of Spain, who could basically do whatever the f**k they wanted. So they eventually gave him his three ships.

Columbus also made a number of other outrageous demands: in return for claiming any lands he may discover in the name of the Spanish crown, he would become governor of those territories, given the rank of "Admiral of the Seas", as well as a twenty foot long gold chain with his name and title made out in encrusted rubies. Admittedly the last part was a lie, but it would've made more sense than any other demands he made.

So when he set off to go find China, everyone else thought that either he was simply going to wind up in the middle of a massive expanse of ocean and starve to death, or that the crew would decide to throw him overboard and return back to Spain. Much to everyone's surprise, he managed to find land. He thought it was India; we know it now as the Caribbean.

As promised, he became governor of the new land and quickly put the natives to work. Unfortunately, due the harsh European labour laws of the time, as well as filthy European diseases, the natives quickly died off and nearly became extinct. Columbus was later fired from his post, and died in poverty. Meanwhile, the native Caribs were replaced by hardier African slaves, but that's another story.

So in conclusion Columbus was pretty much an incompetent, arrogant, and incredibly lucky bastard who somehow managed to get the King and Queen of Spain to fund an expedition to what most people thought was nowhere, and was even fortunate in actually reaching any land at all.

Besides the explanation in the article, the only other reason why Columbus is so famous is well, because Western historians have traditionally taken a European stance. Not entirely their fault really, because back then, the Internet had yet to be invented and so only had access to what resources available to their country.

Holy f**k, I could've written an entire article with that.

11/10/2009 1:53:31 PM
Alceister

@jdbaldwin

"Actually, Einstein never really accepted quantum theory."

If he accepted quantum theory, he wouldn't have been very interested in "solving its mysteries" now would he?

11/4/2009 11:36:14 AM
doubty

It's been said, it's worth saying again: Columbus was from Genoa (Italy). He was therefore Genovese. Not quite Italian, since Italy itself didn't exist before 1861.

Cool article anyway.

11/4/2009 3:38:19 AM
Jesiel

Although an apple most definitely did not fall on Newton's head, he did use the story to explain the theory. Newton created the story.
And, seriously you thought Columbus was Spanish?
where are your citations?

10/29/2009 10:17:34 PM
glad

@obxsurferbabe Columbus didn't really kill the natives. That was Cortes, Pizarro, and subsequent conquistadors, mainly from the region of Extremadura, Spain.

"...he crashed into the future greatest nation on Earth, baby!" What, Cuba?

10/21/2009 10:13:47 AM
meltingpine

Sweet Christ...the writing....it's beautiful........

10/3/2009 9:54:55 PM
Mr.Entropy

WOW, that TIMECUBE link blew Me away, thats some crazy ass s**t! I dont get it but whoever wrote that s**t was a crazy f****n wack job!!

9/7/2009 9:46:05 PM
FRANKENSLUT

#4.Einstein Flunked Math

Wooo!!! Carlisle reference~! ...Ben Nevis reference?! Even bigger Wooo!!!

Okay, I'm finished XD

9/5/2009 7:43:31 PM
Azrael_Alaric

funny I always thought Columbus was from Columbia, but I guess you learn something new everyday

9/5/2009 12:13:59 AM
bestcomeback

Uh, both Wikipedia and Newton say that there is some truth to the apple thing.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaac_Newton#Newton.27s_apple

Fail.

9/4/2009 2:19:23 AM
CaptainADD

christopher colombus was genovese you fuckheads not spanish not portuguese damnn read a f*****g book

9/3/2009 3:57:05 PM
fedemonsalve

v you are an idiot, fivepoundnote.

9/3/2009 2:08:46 PM
Silly Billy

Another lie still being taught in school is the notion that Western women were (and still are) somehow oppressed.

9/2/2009 3:18:45 PM
FivePoundNote

Someone might have already made this point (apologies if so): Columbus was Genoa, an Italian city-state. His exploration was funded by Ferdinand and Isabella of Spain, which sometimes leads to confusion.

B

9/2/2009 12:41:06 PM
BacchicDance

Leif Eriksson is presumed to be the first one to discover America, or "Vinland" as they called it back then.

He and his men got their asses whooped by indian rage, and went home to the safe fjords of Norway.

8/28/2009 12:55:03 PM
Schmondr

Or, let's not forget how he savagely killed the so called "Indians" and made them mine for gold...yeah, let's celebrate a guy who murdered hundreds of Native Americans and give him his own f****n holiday. Also, Columbus did in fact get funding from Spain, Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand. He originally went to whoever was the Ruler of Italy and asked him to fund the voyage and well we all know how that turned out...anyway, good article...I'm so fed up with the lies they teach in school.

8/26/2009 1:21:04 PM
obxsurferbabe

This article is just missing one point with Columbus. The biggest lie probably isn't that people in his time didn't think the world was flat. The much bigger lie is that Columbus discovered America. Before him there was at least an anonymous Asian guy who came across the sea and then started what's now referred to as First Nations. Then there were some norsemen who came to North America. It was some 500 years after that Columbus finally got to America.

The fact that there is so little attention for the First Nations in history books, is a very significant form of americentrism/eurocentrism. The non-white are constantly being degraded to a much less important position in history.

8/17/2009 12:49:26 PM
Smilingdude
Cracked stuff on